Again few positive feelings and a genuine contentment in our current list of PCs. Why are you so interested in her anyway? She's proven herself competent but competent isn't a good enough reason. Explain your reasoning because all I see is a way for us to either be backstabbed or kill her slower
My reasoning is that I don't think it's a sure thing, but I don't think she's so bitter an enemy, that it's not worth it to do some divination, to see if she can be turned to our side, if the answer is no, we kill her or don't revive her, depending on if we took her dead or alive, but if divination actually indicates she can be turned I want to do so.
I'm not particularly committed to turning her in particular, what I'm committed to, is opposing the beginning tendency to use snap judgements, I see this as a symptom of.
I don't like the tendency, the thread has to call for the dead or worse, of mostly good people we haven't even tried alternatives with.
1) This isn't permadeath, this is aging her to death. It's just a more secure execution where she can't come back to life. Her soul is untouched and free to roam the afterlife.
2) I have no interest in her being under our rule, I just want her dead. There. That's my reason. I have no obligation to provide further reasoning.
Are she really worth a sacrifice to Yss to keep dead? I doubt that curse comes cheap, and aging to death in an instant sounds rather painful, can't we just kill her normally?
And I have to ask, in character, what crimes have she committed that allows us to lawfully execute her? She's an enemy combatant so killing her in battle is certainly an option, but I don't think she has committed any crimes, that our laws actually punish with execution, so what's your in character reason for executing her?
