- Pronouns
- He/Him
So - remember when Bongo corrupted our shield from the inside because of that nat1, and the shield started projecting corruption tentacles?I really don't think the warp tech path is all that stand-out valuable for Chaos to abuse. Useful? Maybe. Certainly some use specifically for traitors on Denva. But so's all the other tech they've got and all the other tech we can give them. A cultist with OMC implants could, surely, channel daemons straight into whatever machines they're operating. Universal factories are obviously useful for any kind of insurgents. Don't even want to think about what they can find in Drugs. Other than a handful of specifically anti-chaos techs practically any technology can be used to corrupt ends. It's all a security problem, but it's already all a security problem.
A mechanical way to phone daemons (which, yeah, is exactly what Yelling Into The Warp sounds like, isn't it) seems more redundant than anything considering any hardcore cultist already knows a more organic way to phone daemons.
(Warp Abacus they probably can't use against us here, but it's funny to imagine some Dark Mech handing it to people in Imperium space to start turmoil with the Navigator Houses.)
...Ubiquitous psy shielding is a pretty sweet offering though. I do like what that does to a world.
That was Bongo's magnum opus, basically, and we killed everyone he could have told it to, assuming that was even one of the things he spoke about to the Echo. But Alternate shield meanings would essentially allow a cultist to configure a shield they have access to in order to do that with much, much more modest means.
As for a mechanical way to phone demons... it's not redundant. It's not redundant at all when the normal way to phone demons is mass human sacrifice. In the current environment where getting those sacrifices is hard and traceable, and where the rituals themselves can be directly detected by warp sensors, said mechanical alternative lets an operator make deals from relative stealth.
The way psy shield tech tends to just... auto apply to all shields with a software update works against us here. Remote OMC for comparison, that can be black boxed, and every terminal strictly traced and tracked. Drugs? We track and control those in real life.
It's less about what you can do with it - and more how hard it is to rule out that bad things are being done using it, how hard it is to keep it out of bad hands. Single purpose tech and drugs can be strictly controlled and tracked.
Psy shielding? Psy shielding we want absolutely everywhere. Once the software to make it a transmitter leaks, then it's leaked, and then anywhere with a psy shield is anywhere that could turn into a corruption bomb or a mechanical demon summoning.
The foundation of security is to understand what is possible, and use your tools to rule out things that are adverse to what you are protecting. New technologies make new things possible, and while you can use that for protection, sometimes they make it far easier for an attacker, and the warp comms techs are prime examples. Even the above nightmare scenarios are controllable, but we do not want to be working out the kinks to that when we have an active cultist problem.
It is honestly, genuinely better if alternate shield meanings requires a hardware difference - this becomes a million times easier if you can't just get the ability to turn your household chaos defense into a corruption projector or a demon phone off of The Pirate Bay.
But so far we've had exactly one psy shield upgrade that you couldn't apply via software, and that was high density shielding. So until we learn otherwise about alternate meanings - I'm fairly opposed to distributing that until the cultist problem is further reduced.
Last edited: