To be honest I don't like it at all.
by all indications Fu Xiang, the instigator gets off scott free?
YrsillarToday at 3:43 AM
He's not getting a reccomendation from Cai, but she's not going to go further than that, be a bit hypocritical otherwise
and if asked her professional opinion, she will tell the truth
Honestly that seems more hypocritical if anything. Ling Qi gets what is in practice a significant fine and Fu Xiang doesn't get a recommendation? He should at least get a similar quiet conversation where he agrees to "discreetly" donate something (a month or two of his potential inner sect salary entitlement?).I would agree with you that there is less tension this way, but that Confession plotline was one of the FoD plots that really got missed.
Bonus | General | Bond 0 | Bond 3 | Bond 4 | Bond 5-6 | Paired |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Speed | 15 | 25 | 25 | 35 | 25-35 | |
Initiative | 15 | 25 | 25 | 35 | 25-35 | |
Health | 10 | |||||
Resist | 20 | 30 | 20-30 | |||
C.Perception | 10 | |||||
P.Avoid | 15 | 20 | 25 | 30 | 25-30 | |
P.Armor | 15 (SNR) | 15 (SNR) | 15 (SNR) | 15 (SNR) | 15 (SNR) | 15 (SNR) |
S.Avoid | 10 | 15/40 | 25/55 | 15-25/40-55 | ||
S.Armor | 15 (SNR) | 15 (SNR) +10/40 | 15 (SNR)/35 | 15 (SNR)/40 | 15 (SNR)/45 | 15 (SNR)/40-45 |
Qi regen (Lost Child's Elegy) | E | D | C | D-C | ||
Poise (with MSS) | 15 (MSS) | 15 (MSS) | 15 (MSS) | 15 (MSS) | 15 (MSS) | 15 (MSS) |
Resolve | +1 Rank | |||||
Composure | +1 Rank | |||||
Immunity to compulsion/illusion which would cause action against Bond 3+ allies (2+ for B5-6) | Effect < C | Effect < B | Effect < A | Effect < S | Effect < A-S | |
Immunity to effects which reduce speed, initiative, or avoid | Effect < C | Effect < B | Effect < C-B | |||
Immunity to Effects which induce Immobility or Helplessness | Effect < U | |||||
Immunity to effects which would isolate or remove an ally from the Mist or its beneficial effects | Effect < A |
In the RRL version, it was stated that CRX didnt do anything special regarding the matter due to Ling Qi not being her subordinate at that time.Honestly that seems more hypocritical if anything. Ling Qi gets what is in practice a significant fine and Fu Xiang doesn't get a recommendation?
Honestly that seems more hypocritical if anything. Ling Qi gets what is in practice a significant fine and Fu Xiang doesn't get a recommendation? He should at least get a similar quiet conversation where he agrees to "discreetly" donate something (a month or two of his potential inner sect salary entitlement?).
I agree it's a plot that sort of fell by the wayside, but this ending feels cheap. It changes a significant area of weakness for Renxiang into a strength just to try and get rid of a single neglected minor plot thread. As I said if the ambiguity of the situation was going out the window anyway I'd have actually preferred Ling Qi fess up herself, since there really is no reason not to now.
Ling Qi hummed noncommittally, she could see the use for being able to talk over distances, what she could find on the subject indicated that the qi costs involved increased massively and exponentially with time and distance though. "You going to sign up with Lady Cai when your done here then? Be her coordinator?"
"Heavens no," Fu Xiang replied, looking at her as if she had suggested her go streak through the market. "I intend to use my eventual place in the inner sect to receive a recommendation into a junior position at the Ministry of Communication. I am a son of the capital, I shall leave the barbarians to you border landers."
I dare say it probably hurt him a lot more than not getting a gift she wasn't expecting to get hurt Ling Qi.I dont know if he means the Imperial or the Emerald Seas capital, but either way a recommendation by CRX could have helped him a lot to get his dreamjob and with how generous she has been about rewarding loyalty in her student council and given that we know from the tournament arc at the end of FoD that she did write recommendations for other disciples (i think we delivered some of those to the Bao representative), he likely would have gotten one from her. So I would say that this is not such a trivial setback for Fu Xiang
The thing is more that we won't really follow up on that plot line...pretty much ever? Might as well close the dangling plot thread if we never intend to tell Renxiang.
For all that he's had time to prepare, Rong doesn't have confidence in his counterplay. He *expects* to get his ass kicked. Unless he's completely reversed his position dramatically in the past month, I don't expect him to pull a rabbit out of his hat. he doesn't even have a hat to pull from.All the good words. But it's Ji Rong we are talking about. Remember his dragon Relong. He was Yellow 1 four months ago, Green 1 last month. And I bet he is Green 2 now. Every time you think that Ji Rong is just talented boy he is doing something absurd and getting absurd bonuses. He is TOD's own shounen protagonist after all. ......
I prefer Ling Qi not being the kind of character that's easily duped into "compromising her own sense of what's right" purely because "Oh I need to repay this person". Like what? You want her to be the kind of person who'd do stuff she hates or morally opposes (for instance potentially help a cruel and abusive brothel owner escape legal punishment just because he saved Biyu from a mugging) simply because "I need to repay this debt to someone who helped me"?For me it felt like the business with Fu Xiang said something important about Linq Qi's character. She felt an obligation to pay her debts, even it was something she really didn't want to do and even if it meant compromising her own sense of what was right. Linq Qi didn't confess to Renxiang, not so much because she feared punishment, as because that would be screwing him over.
I've often thought about Fu Xiang when the thread has voted on several recent occasions, "sure we'll incur a debt to X over this". Mostly it's been to people who seem much nicer than Fu Xiang and probably won't ask Ling Qi to do something she really doesn't want to do... but if they did, she'd do it. For me that was the important thing about Fu Xiang, not some unresolved business with Renxiang.
Nothing much ever came of that vote anyway and nothing would likely ever come of it later because people chickened out on the plot hook of confessing and resolved to make sure it didn't come to light so we wouldn't get punished.For me the price the story will pay later is not worth getting this ending to the plot line. Quest!Ling Qi resolved to never do something like that again without any pressure from her superiors&peers, entirely on her own. RR!Ling Qi gets a clear warning to never do it again from her direct superior. Where's the character development?
Nothing much ever came of that vote anyway and nothing would likely ever come of it later because people chickened out on the plot hook of confessing and resolved to make sure it didn't come to light so we wouldn't get punished.
I prefer Ling Qi not being the kind of character that's easily duped into "compromising her own sense of what's right" purely because "Oh I need to repay this person". Like what? You want her to be the kind of person who'd do stuff she hates or morally opposes (for instance potentially help a cruel and abusive brothel owner escape legal punishment just because he saved Biyu from a mugging) simply because "I need to repay this debt to someone who helped me"?
I don't see how that's much different than the annoying anime protagonist who lets the abusive tsundere "love interest" make him her "slave" and boss him around when he can just stand up for himself and tell her off instead of accepting it because he's so kind and forgiving.
.... Ok, yeah, wow.It was to Ji Rong's credit that he hadn't needed intervention. He knelt there, blackened skin cracking under the returned heat. His qi was gone, but he was still conscious.
Ling has *convinced* Rong of the virtues of connection.Oh man what a fight!!
Loved how it played out and the ending of the Bond being reset to 0 felt really freaking good, wow
Great update~