Counter-argument:*Edit: Also! Completely forgot, in setting example: Unison and Hybrid Devices. If merging with the mage didnt have some advantage, why do these super high end devices do it? Im just saying we do it permanently instead of having it turn into a plushy.
I don't see how embedding PS in Taylor's body will boost her combat abilities in any way, and, anyway, we were too outclassed to actually change the outcome.To be fair, your assuming the fight would have played out the same way. If her device was embedded in her body she may have avoided getting shanked. If nothing else devices seem to take damage (even direct hits) alot better than a human body. So it may well have turned the blow if they tried to stab her directly in the shiny chestplate.
Alternatively, they may have seen her without a staff and stopped to question why this person doesnt have the template's standard issue weapon and not Surprise!shanked her at all.
All of your other "points" are debatable (though I think I would win) but this seems to be an axiomatic disagreement between us. Paragraph, but particularly the highlighted line.The nature of nanotech is that the benefits scale up and compound, what nanotubes can do to flesh is nothing compared to what they can do to a tungsten plate. While your trying to justify a nanoware transhuman... Ive built their replacements. This applies even to Tinkers and magictech. If they can do something amazing at the nano scale... they can use that same technique to do something even better at the macro scale. Nothing that can ever be injected into a person, to change them from within, will ever be as good as something crafted to purpose without wasting time and effort trying to emulate (or even interact with) silly biological processes. As if those were something sacred and not part of the problem.
She's probably not even going to look as conspicuous as the resident GaoGaiGal Subaru. And as far as I'm aware, she only looks conspicuous when her prosthesics are in use.Voting for the Heavy combat arm wont automagically turn Vista into an inhuman killbot.
Upgrades will still need to be built/voted on, and Nanoha cybernetics are very discrete.
Just look at the Numbers, combat cyborgs that don't look even slightly mechanical.
[] Social (Vista & Shipwright)
"Anyway, that's that. Then there's option 3." This diagram is the most detailed of them all, looking almost like an arm off a twenty-fifth century knight. "Full armor plating, fingertip to shoulder. Increased strength, energy weapons, mechashift, some weird combination of the above? You want it, you got it, whatever and wherever. Now comes the bad news. This is the heaviest arm, and then if you add enhanced strength, it would definitely rip itself off your body if you weren't careful. That means the most surgical revision."
We're looking to recruit Vista, the pro-transhuman vote just pushes her further into our camp. A camp which already has Alexandria in all but name.Are people trying to make Vista leave the Wards or something? Pretty sure a heavy arm is just asking for a bunch of uneccessary drama to occur on that front.
This seems like a leap in logic to me. IIRC, Tim is all/mostly human still, we're human. I do not see how foisting a "the human body sucks, make me a machine" mindset onto Vista pushes her further into our camp.the pro-transhuman vote just pushes her further into our camp.
We'd be the only group that both accepts her desire to modify herself, and provides her with the technology for said modification at the low, low cost of FREEEEEEEEEEE!This seems like a leap in logic to me. IIRC, Tim is all/mostly human still, we're human. I do not see how foisting a "the human body sucks, make me a machine" mindset onto Vista pushes her further into our camp.
Don't forget the hidden cost of "dependent on Tim for the upkeep/maintenance of her cybernetic 'enhancements'". That's not free.
That was subtle in comparison to grafting cybernetics onto one's person.That, and given Taylor got a bit of a body mod herself from when she first got Storm, she's understand the desire to improve one's self-image 'physically'.
Wasn't it stated that Tim's magic-tech can be maintained by normal people as long as they have the skills? Or am I mistaking it with some another Wormfic?Don't forget the hidden cost of "dependent on Tim for the upkeep/maintenance of her cybernetic 'enhancements'". That's not free.
Yep, any normal person with a degree in magical engineering and necessary tools can maintain and replicate Tim's tech.Wasn't it stated that Tim's magic-tech can be maintained by normal people as long as they have the skills? Or am I mistaking it with some another Wormfic?
So, unlike Tinkertech it can be taught. And Vista is that kinda person who would jump on it and, even if she's not academically strong enough to learn it fully, she'd probably learn enough to not depend on Tim entirely.Yep, any normal person with a degree in magical engineering and necessary tools can maintain and replicate Tim's tech.
But Tim is the only such a person on Earth-Bet.
Also, no. That "wooden sword" can have an edge at a nanometer, or even one atom with a diamond support lattice. It'll carve through any mechanically made steel sword.I'm not sure you would win even those points, to be honest. To use a shitty comparison, a solid steel sword is better than a wooden sword covered in steel in every single way, including cost.