IWIW RWBY

Also people had picked up the fairy tale connections at this point (I mean, from the trailers). "We got Weiss, who's Snow White with some shades of the Snow Queen, we got Red Riding Hood, Goldilocks.... gee, who could the girl with 'Belle' in her last name be?".

So she's obviously beauty and the beast. Which doesn't necessarily mean she's a faunas but everyone was thinking it.
 
V01E16 Black and White

V01E16 Black and White


I have only just now noticed that Blake mysteriously disappears during her brief first appearance in the title sequence.

"Nearly two days and you've given me nothing but small talk and weird looks," says Sun (aka That Faunus™) to Blake on their tea date. (Blake gives him a weird look.) "Like that." When prompted about the White Fang, he impolitely explains his very low opinion of them, then just about chokes on his tea when Blake reveals she used to be one.

Oh, a history lesson, my favourite thing. /s The White Fang were founded as the guardians of a promised equality between humans and Faunus after the war, which was (shockingly) an empty promise so immediately they had to be a voice for that equality. Five years ago, new leadership changed their methodology from peaceful to violent, which appeared to be working in the short term, but Blake had enough of that so she left and went to Beacon. She doesn't mention Adam was why.

Sun, after recovering from either listening mode or speechlessness (his facial expression looks closer to speechless, but I'm not the best at reading facial expressions even when they're well-animated, so it could go either way), asks if she's perhaps mentioned any of this to her friends. Fade to her friends, who are searching for her in about the most useless way you could search a major city for someone whom you think doesn't want you to find them. Not that the obvious alternative of 'report missing person to police' would work much better, but it would be more likely to get any result at all than wandering along at ground level shouting their name.

Weiss told them all so™ and it's really getting on my nerves.

Suddenly, Penny! I was expecting her to give a literal answer when asked where she came from.

Apparently Team RWY are literally the last people to realise that Blake was hiding her cat ears under her bow. There is a literal tumbleweed tumbling by as it sinks in. Before anybody brings up Penny's bow, she's wearing it much further back on her head - it couldn't possibly hide any cat ears.

"...she does like tuna a lot." Oh Ruby, I'm really not sure whether that's racist.

Penny promises to help find Blake. Ruby tries to decline, looking to Weiss and Yang to back her up, but Ruby looked away from them while talking to Penny, which gave them a license to disappear. I am going to laugh out loud if we get a Queen of the Castle reprise. The next best thing happens: the tumbleweed blows back the way it came.

"It sure is windy today." Penny, you're better comedic relief than Jaune ever was.

Cut back to Blake and Sun, who have finished their tea and gone for a walk. Blake refuses to believe that the White Fang were responsible for the Dust robberies. We can be fairly sure they are, based on Torchwick's scene at the end of V01C08. Dramatic irony! Sun stumbles his way through the (correct) logic that the only way to prove they're not is to prove who is. Fortunately, he has a lead on a shipment that will very likely be hit. I feel like these two are about to do something ill-advised.

Meanwhile, Yang accuses Weiss of not caring whether they find Blake. Weiss counters that she's just "afraid of what she'll say when we find her. The innocent never run, Yang." (shakes head sadly) Such a privileged thing to say.

Ruby and Penny have a friendship moment as the former tries to explain the context of the situation.
Penny: "I don't have a lot of friends, but if I did, I would want them to talk to me about things."

Ruby: "...me too."
On second thought, I'm not sure if Ruby is just wishing Blake talked to them instead of fleeing, or if she's also filing herself under "don't have a lot of friends". My feels.



Later that night, Blake is staking out the docks where the shipment has been unloaded. Sun returns with two, or possibly three, apples.
"I stole you some food!"

"Do you always break the law without a second thought?"

"Hey, weren't you in a cult or something?"

(weird look)

"Okay, too soon!"
Any further conversation is forestalled by the deafening arrival of a tiltjet in full landing lights: you couldn't miss it if you tried. White Fang minions (I typed "grunts" in the first draft, but that seemed racist) pile out to start securing the Dust-filled shipping containers with towing cables. To Blake's credit, she admits she was mostly in denial about whether her old organisation was responsible. Any further conversation is forestalled by Roman Torchwick making himself known and (racistly) demanding they get a move on, seeing as their arrival was absolutely unmissable. Blake sees red in a less literal sense than Torchwick's hair and goes to confront them. Yep, there's the ill-advised.

"No, you idiot, this isn't a leash," says Torchwick to a White Fang minion holding a towing cable. Any further conversation is forestalled by Blake holding a blade to Torchwick's throat. He actually manages to say "Oh, for f-" before Blake demands nobody move. This is followed by a mini-montage of minions moving to bring weapons to bear. Blake may have been counting on this attentive audience; her next move is to discard her bow into the wind and ask them why they're working with him. They seem conflicted.

Torchwick explains they're cooperating. Blake tries a little amateur interrogation. Right on cue, two more tiltjets show up, and Torchwick exploits Blake's momentary distraction to fire at the ground at their feet and knock her away.

Ruby and Penny, nearby, hear the explosion and see a smoke column. "Oh no," says Ruby, which sounds about the right reaction.

Torchwick harries Blake away with a series of follow-up shots. Where does that cane hide the magazine it clearly has to be able to fire that many times? He is then attacked by Sun, who is in turn attacked by the White Fang reinforcements leaping down from those newly arrived tiltjets (not sure how Ruby and Penny didn't see those). In full accordance with conservation of ninjutsu, Sun and his collapsible staff have no problem dealing with them.

Torchwick tries shooting at Sun, but Blake drops in to block it and engages him in melee combat. She appears to leave ephemeral shadow-clones behind herself as she goes, which seems like it would be pretty confusing to try to fight against. Just as Torchwick gets the upper hand on Blake, Sun tags back in. You will be utterly shocked to learn that the collapsible staff is also a gun.

Torchwick would have been in a great deal of trouble here if his opponents hadn't ended up standing under a shipping container suspended from a crane; shooting at it drops it and forces them to dodge and lose track of each other. Sun recovers to discover Torchwick aiming at his head. Fortunately, this is when Ruby discovers them both.

Torchwick is quite unimpressed to see "Red" again. For some reason she's not expecting him to shoot at her. Ruby, what have they been teaching you at combat school these past months to make you fight worse?

Unfortunately for Torchwick, shooting at and knocking down Ruby has made Penny angry. He won't like Penny when she's angry. A compartment in her back (literally) Her adorable little backpack opens itself up and a folded-in-half sword floats out and unfolds. Then the other h*cking nine detach from it. This is sufficient weapon for Penny to enter the fray. Ruby is very surprised by all of this.

Penny proceeds to monopolise all the ninjutsu in the area, effortlessly taking down every single White Fang minion. Sun takes the opportunity to leave.

Three more tiltjets appear and fire chin-mounted machine guns. Penny effortlessly deflects the gunfire, then deploys two more swords - these ones connected to her by cables - embeds them in a building some distance away, and uses the cables to yank herself out of the firing line. The original array of swords then becomes the focus for a ridiculous beam attack that bisects two of the reinforcing tiltjets. The third wisely decides to flee for its life.

One of the tiltjets still present attempts to abscond with a shipping container. Penny sticks swords in its hull to cable it to herself, then whips the cables around to slam it into a grounded pile of containers, to its doom and Ruby's awe.

"These kids just keep getting weirder!" mutters Torchwick as he boards one of the two remaining tiltjets, which both flee for their lives. Penny is moments too late to stop either of them.



It now appears to be daytime, and the docks are crawling with police. Ruby, Penny, Blake (replacement bow firmly attached), and Sun have been corralled to some wooden crates (serving as seats). It is to this scene that Weiss and Yang arrive. Okay, it's not daytime, the police just brought lots of lights or something.

Weiss, having had twelve hours to reflect on the matter, chooses not to care about Blake's former affiliation[s] in favour of insisting that Blake talk to her team next time a problem comes up. I feel like Weiss's reflection would have been better depicted in a short montage or something instead of just told to us.

Weiss even manages to restrain herself from saying whatever derogatory thing she was about to say about Sun. There may be hope yet.

"Wait, where's Penny?" Unseen by them, Penny is being taken away in a car.
(off-camera): "You should know better than to go running around in a strange city."

Penny: "I know, sir."

(off-camera): "Penny, your time will come."
And just like that, my unease returns.

Fade to somebody watching Ruby on a live feed. They receive a message from "Qrow" (Ruby's uncle?) that "QUEEN HAS PAWNS". They are Ozpin. He says "hmmm" but otherwise doesn't react. He doesn't react to much, does he.



The credits have started with still three minutes to go. Clearly these will be long credits.

The voice cast seem to be listed in order of appearance (to be specific, the first time the character speaks). The first narrator of the history lesson is still only credited as "Mysterious Narrator", but the second is very clearly Professor Ozpin. Roman's goons from Chapter 1 are actually named as "Goons". {{Cyril Ian is a name I've literally never seen, and I've seen most of them somewhere or other out there.}} And the list ends with "Cinder", who hasn't been introduced?

The music is a bit of a sad mood.

I could probably make a whole game out of 'how many hats is this crew member wearing'.

I think each of them got up to three slots in "Special Thanks" and one in "Security" to name family, pets, and suchlike.

Surprise post-credits scene! Oh, that's Cinder. Y'know, Volcanic Pilot. Accompanied by her two Shadows, who now step out of the shadows.

The long credits had no character silhouette background, so it's slotted in here at the very end: Cinder and the No-Longer-Shadows.



Next time: (in the voice of Crocodile Dundee) "That's not a food fight..."
 
Last edited:
Where does that cane hide the magazine it clearly has to be able to fire that many times?
I think that his cane has a trick that lets it fire from a magazine in the barrel, similar to some kinds of fire works.
You will be utterly shocked to learn that the collapsible staff is also a gun.
No, it's four guns that are also nunchucks.
A compartment in her back (literally)
It's a backpack, just not a very big one.
 
I think that his cane has a trick that lets it fire from a magazine in the barrel, similar to some kinds of fire works.
The shots look a lot like fireworks, so that would make sense.

No, it's four guns that are also nunchucks.
At least they don't glow funny colours too. ...right?

It's a backpack, just not a very big one.
Huh, so it is. I shall have to edit that.
 
V02C01 Best Day Ever

V02C01 Best Day Ever


That transport jet is not passing the camera at the moment, so its engine noise shouldn't be subject to the Doppler effect at all; and if it should be Dopplering, it's not going nearly fast enough to Doppler anywhere near that much. I also worry about its lack of engine efficiency if it's making that much noise to go that slowly. Methinks someone on SFX crew was told to go get a stock jetplane noise wthout any understanding of why that noise sounds like it does.

The Dust shop from Volume 1 Chapter 1 is "Newly Re-Opened!". As the shopkeeper descends a stepladder from hanging that banner, someone wearing very few clothes bumps him off the ladder as a pretext to get directions. I'm even less sympathetic to this someone because I recognise her as one of Cinder's Shadows.

Directions obtained, Nearly-Naked Shadow meets back up with her co-shadow Mercury, who is also fairly unsympathetic, but he's an antagonist so he's probably just a jerk.

I find this bribery/theft joke funny. "That's not [even] your money." "But it could be yours...!" Unfortunately for NNS, Mercury won't be bribed to shut up.

The casual sexual harrassment means that my prejudice ("probably just a jerk") is now just judice.

Holy cow, background extras who aren't black silhouettes! How am I meant to know who's important?!

Mercury and the now-named Emerald walk into a bookshop. It's dim and musty. It's probably pretty easy to find people who think that "musty" is the ideal state of a bookshop; I'm less sure about the dimness. Bookshop guy - maybe the eponymous Tukson - is momentarily taken aback by Emerald for some reason. If I had to guess why, I'd guess Emerald's (lack of) outfit.

What is it with all the books in this setting making really loud noises when they shut? ...are they also guns.

Evidently Mercury isn't much of a reader, nor does he have much respect for books (sounds like a good way to get accidentally shot by a book that is also a gun, but whatever).

Apparently "Third Crusade" is some kind of awkward book title. Not that it wouldn't be IRL unless you were in a university history library or something, but bookshop guy is quite taken aback before admitting they don't have it. (Oh, he is Tukson.) Emerald asks what we were thinking: if this place has "every book under the sun", why not that one? I worry about Emerald's motivation, though.

Emerald advises him not to make false promises (like the catchphrase), and then non-segues into "I hear you're planning on leaving" as Mercury turns off all the lights. Yep, I'm scared now.

They're here on behalf of "[his] brothers in the White Fang". Anybody who thought I was already scared (including me) was wrong, because now I really am. Tukson was initially taken aback because he recognised them as enforcers and knew why they showed up, which answers one of my questions.

Tukson, with no better options, attempts to fight back with concealed claws (literally). He's not expecting Mercury for some reason. White screen with gunshot noise. Fade to the two enforcers exiting the shop; Mercury has grabbed a comic on his way out. I'm scared of the implications. Also, even the comic makes significant noise when closed, and there's no way you could possibly hide a gun in that.



Meanwhile at Beacon Academy's dining hall, Teams WBY and JNPR (and a heaping helping of non-silhouette extras) are multitasking. I don't believe Blake (bow firmly attached) when she says she's "just going over notes from last semester", because nobody who's actually doing that prefixes that explanation with "Nothing!". Nora is throwing bits of food into Yang's mouth - y'know, Yang and Nora things. They are all interrupted by Ruby arriving with a comically massive binder folder labelled
Vytal Festival Activities
Property of
Weiss Schnee

BEST DAY EVER
ACTIVITIES!
which sounds like something my mother would think of as fun for the whole family, and I would very much not.

"Sisters! Friends! Weiss," says Ruby. ("Hey!") "Four score and seven minutes ago, I had a dream," etc. Excuse me while I explain to a medical professional how I just got diabetes: They seem to have used the volume hiatus to animate everyone better, and Ruby here was already weapons-grade adorable.

Weiss has just realised that her binder has been stolen repurposed.

{{Ah, the Yang pun in its natural habitat.}} Yang is so busy being proud of her pun she doesn't notice Nora's next projectile and takes it to the face.

Ruby's plan is to pack maximum fun into the one remaining day before the new semester starts. Weiss "[isn't] sure whether to be proud or scared" of it, which is about what I expected. Yang throws something back; the noise of dismay is not Nora's.

Blake says she might sit out. Mood, Blake. Weiss says they should either sit out or not as a team, which is pretty much just pressuring Blake to not sit out. Weiss attempts to continue into a speech, but barely starts before being interrupted by the arrival from across the table of a pie to the face. Nora frantically but silently tries to deflect blame as the rest of her team silently manifest horror in their own ways.

Outside, Sun is telling someone with blue hair - maybe one of his teammates - about the events of last episode, and thoughtlessly blurts out that Blake is a Faunus (fortunately without Blake's name attached). He then doesn't do a great job of communicating the importance of secrecy. But to be fair, communication is a two-player game, and this other guy doesn't sound like a secret-keeper either.

Sun then tries to impress on his probably-teammate to "be cool" meeting his new friends. I doubt there will be much coolness given that, by this point, coloured things (and Jaune) are splatting on the windows they've walking past.
"You're gonna be cool, right?"

"Dude." (establishing shot of just how cool this guy's natural state is)

"Good point."
They enter the dining hall just as most of the extras are fleeing past them. Oh, here's our Queen of the Castle reprise. The castle in question is constructed from a large number of cateteria tables and is an affront to the very concept of order (the music agrees with me). Somehow, the rest of Team JNPR have gone along with this insanity.

At the other end of the cavernous space, Team RWBY are setting up a siege position.
Ruby: "Justice will be swift! Justice will be painful! Justice will be delicious!"
Given that Weiss got pied in the face earlier, I'm actually not surprised she's going along with this insanity.

The ensuing food fight cannot be explained, only experienced.

Sun and his probably-teammate have been standing in front of the doors through which they entered the whole time. "I love these guys," says Sun, somehow unscathed. His probably-teammate is thoroughly scathed and less impressed. Both are startled by Professor Glynda Goodwitch kicking open the doors behind them. You'll be shocked to learn that she is about as unhappy as anyone has ever been. In case you weren't already convinced of her telekinetic prowess, she proceeds to reassemble the entire dining hall in ten seconds flat before delivering her Bond one-liner:
"Children, please. Do not play with your food."
Yang then falls from the ceiling where she was evidently plastered at some point - which is seriously impressive given the height of that ceiling. I think her impact destroyed one of the tables. Goodwitch reaches hitherto unheard-of levels of unhappiness.

Professor Ozpin, being Ozpin, is completely unflapped by anything that just happened, and manages to take the edge off Goodwitch's apocalyptic rage by pointing out that these children aren't the defenders of the world yet and they won't be kids forever, so they shouldn't be begrudged a little more time to be kids. I would have thought that 'kids being kids' goes out the window sometime before structural damage to solid stone walls, but I'm not Ozpin so what do I know (shrugs).



(Haha, Emerald's [excuse for a] top has a drawing of an emerald on the back.)

Later, at the local White Fang base, Emerald and Mercury visit Torchwick.
Torchwick: "Oh look, she sent the kids again! This is turning out just like the divorce..."

Emerald: "Spare us the thought of you procreating."

Torchwick: "That was a joke, and this just might tell me where you two have been all day."
Emerald checks her pockets and thereby confirms that Torchwick did, in fact, pickpocket the piece of paper with the address of Tukson's shop. Clearly the student has yet to surpass the master.

Torchwick disagrees with their tactics to handle the Tukson problem which he had "under control", which spirals into an argument that is only forestalled by the arrival of Cinder.

I'd like to take a moment here to rant about one of my dialogue pet peeves which just came up: neat interruptions. People don't just neatly cut themselves off when someone is about to interrupt them by surprise - there is always overlapping speech. Writers are just not good at writing that happening. They're not good at it in written media, presumably because it's a hassle to convey in writing (it definitely is a hassle); and they're not good at it in audiovisual media, where the actors and/or sound editors can actually do it, presumably because it has to be written out in a script first.

Cinder isn't happy with Torchwick for sleeping on Tukson's imminent flight (as in fleeing, and possibly also flying), and she also isn't happy with Emerald and Mercury for possibly blowing their clean identities. Also Tukson is definitely dead. I'm not scared anymore, but the replacement dark feeling is worse.

Torchwick, for his part, has been quite busy doing the rest of what Cinder ordered: stealing all the Dust, driving up prices and drumming up unrest. Cinder still refuses to tell him any more of the plan. Also, she's altering the plan. No more Dust thefts; they have enough now. Instead, prepare to lift-and-shift the whole base. As they leave, an incredulous Torchwick goes for a stress-relieving smoke, only to discover that Emerald felt petty and pickpocketed his lighter. Emerald sticks her tongue out at him. Excuse me while I wash my brain out with soap again.



Roll titles. The soundtrack is another banger, although goodness me is it a more ominous one.
  • Establishing shot of Beacon and its huge architecture budget.
  • Team RWBY stands in a line as the surrounding Beacon appears to be on fire (uh oh).
  • Ruby is doing an orbital drop?
  • Ozpin has a serious gears motif.
  • Last volume, Pyrrha was reassuring Jaune. Now it's the other way around.
  • I'm gonna need the frame-by-frame controls for these teams we barely saw frames of. Wait, this isn't YouTube, I don't know the frame-by-frame controls! I think I saw Cinder and her Shadows, and the Beacon staff, in there.
  • The lyric "our enemies" plays over Cinder and her Shadows; with Junior, and his enforcer twins Melanie and Miltia. I'd nearly forgotten about them.
  • Many Grimm in a forest, and a passing bit of colour that could be a human amongst them?
  • Now the entire student body is doing the orbital drop! They all land on a road and make craters.
  • Pyrrha fights many opponents in an arena.
  • Prominent depiction of Cinder, not in shadow this time.
  • Duels! Yang v Mercury, Weiss v Emerald, Blake v Torchwick, Ruby v Cinder.
  • The title gets its own screen now, uncluttered by such things as a moon background or Ruby in silhouette.

Okay, I found the titles on YouTube where I know the frame-by-frame controls.

The teams we barely see are:
  • Team CRDL, unfortunately;
  • Sun and three others, among them his blue-haired probably-teammate;
  • Miss Rabbit and three others;
  • Penny and many others;
  • The Beacon staff: Goodwitch, Ozpin, Oobleck, and Port.
I'm guessing we'll meet most of these folks at some point. No Cinder here, she gets to be in the next shot.

The splashes of colour amongst the Grimm in the forest turn out to just be Death Stalker stingers.

I think I recognise some of Pyrrha's many opponents:
  • Looks like Jaune, but with a more substantial sword and no shield;
  • I've only seen that mohawk on one of Team CRDL;
  • Don't know, but context suggests this is another of CRDL;
  • Cardin himself.
...that's all of them? I could have sworn there were more. My new theory is that the first one is the other member of CRDL, and this is Pyrrha making a mockery of them all at once. Go Pyrrha!



Next time: Beware of the visitors.
 
Last edited:
I think I recognise some of Pyrrha's many opponents:
  • Looks like Jaune, but with a more substantial sword and no shield;
  • I've only seen that mohawk on one of Team CRDL;
  • Don't know, but context suggests this is another of CRDL;
  • Cardin himself.
...that's all of them? I could have sworn there were more. My new theory is that the first one is the other member of CRDL, and this is Pyrrha making a mockery of them all at once. Go Pyrrha!


Yep this is just flat-out Pyrrha vs Team CRDL, an entire team of her peers!

Word of creator is the Jaune-looking one, Dove, is the most skilled of the lot. Mohawk is Russel Thrush, and the last guy is Sky Lark.
 
I would have thought that 'kids being kids' goes out the window sometime before structural damage to solid stone walls, but I'm not Ozpin so what do I know (shrugs).
I imagine having Goodwitch on staff does wonders for keeping the repair budget far lower than would otherwise be expected. She does in about fifteen seconds what would probably take a crew of cleaners and heavy lifters at least half an hour.
 
Oh yea, fun fact on the food fight scene- you know how at one point Ruby is carrying Weiss's body?

In the season trailers they cut out all the food and silliness so it looked like something super dramatic was happening!
 
V02C02 Welcome to Beacon
Minor edit to last post: I thought of a better "Next time:" quip.



V02C02 Welcome to Beacon


I wasn't expecting the full titles again...

The hidden note from the animation factory reads 'look, even the Beacon architecture budget now has an animation budget'. Not to mention the new and exotic VTOL jets, and even some jetfighters that might not VTOL.

I see Professor Goodwitch is holding the angry ball this season.

Ozpin concedes that the decently-sized air force outside his window is "a bit of an eyesore".

Enter the commander-in-chief of that air force, General James Ironwood. Ozpin gets on well with him. Goodwitch, not so much. "Well she hasn't changed a bit," says Ironwood while they all darn well know she's still just behind him. Very rude. He follows up by fortifying his tea from a concealed flask (?!).

Why is this office full of gears?!

This isn't just a friendly chat: Qrow's message that "QUEEN HAS PAWNS" has gotten them both concerned, but they have different opinions on how to direct that concern. Ozpin, merely an academy headmaster, continues to train Hunt[smen/resses], whom I shall collectively refer to as Hunters. Ironwood, a headmaster but also C-in-C of a military, prefers military solutions.

Ironwood: "Do you honestly believe your children can win a war?"

(extended meaningful silence)

Ozpin: "I hope they never have to."

It sounds like Ironwood has been captured by one of his jobs and should maybe rebalance his responsibilities.



Meanwhile, deep in a gigantic library, Team RWBY are playing a board game. I think. It looks like one of those board games that writers 'invent' when they need to have the characters play a board game, which is to say it's pretty poor from an out-of-universe - oh they did NOT just do the Yu-Gi-Oh meme!

(They did.)

Yang slams her fist down on the board, displacing half the pieces. This is bad board game etiquette.

Weiss just sits there and looks unimpressed by the Ruby-Yang interplay. She might not actually be that unimpressed, though, because that's close to her usual facial expression and I'm not the greatest at facial expressions.

One table over, Team JNPR are occasionally menaced by a flying board game piece. Ren is studying. Nora is asleep (dreaming of pancakes), despite all the noise Ruby and Yang are making. Jaune is reading a comic which I think I recognise as another Rooster Teeth property (checks yep). Pyrrha confiscates the comic (and starts reading it herself), forcing Jaune to pick up a textbook. He then gets beaned by a particularly large gamepiece. Being Jaune is suffering.

As Ruby sobs over her failed strategem, it is Weiss's turn. "I have... absolutely no idea what's going on." Mood, Weiss. Yang leans over to give her tips, incidentally leaning all the way into the intentionally cartoony animation choices (it was really very mundane-made-awesome to motion-blur her arm while she was going through Weiss's cards-in-hand).

Oh no, Weiss is monologuing. It's like a cartoon villain monologue except cartoon villains have to imply their mass-child-kidnapping intentions. I've changed my mind: I am now okay with Yang having trap cards. ...Look, when Weiss starts monologuing it's time for desperate measures. I'm maybe even okay with inflicting Ruby-like emotional devastation on her if it gets her to stop. Maybe.

Weiss: (in poorly-animated floods of tears) "I hate this game of emotions we play!"

Ruby: (appears, latches on, also in floods of tears) "Be strong Weiss, we'll make it through this together!"

Weiss: (clutches Ruby, still in floods of tears) "Shut up, don't touch me!"
I've changed my mind: I'm not okay with this emotional devastation. Somebody burst Yang's bubble.

Blake has not been paying attention to anything at all. Mood, Blake. (This also burst Team RW's bubble of sadness - they recovered offscreen.)

At this point Jaune teleports over to see if he can escape his studies by joining the game. Unfortunately for him, it is a four-player game and Team RWBY are all there. Weiss also tries to get in a putdown, which Yang mercilessly points back at her.

Weiss doesn't trust Jaune with her game state. Jaune protests that he's been trusted with more than that, and promptly gets to the "faun-" in "Blake is secretly a faunus" before Pyrrha can dash over and stop him. (Oh hey look, they can write a naturally messy dialogue interruption.) Blake is not amused.

Cue Sun and the other guy from the other direction. Other guy promptly punctures his own air of coolness by wondering what they're doing using a library for activities other than reading. "Thank you!" shouts Ren from the other table. This may be the loudest thing he's ever said, which leads me to believe he's a bit exasperated at all the disruption they're causing. It also awakens Nora. "Pancakes!" she says, because of course she does.

Oh, I see, "intellectual" is much cooler than "nerd", noted.

Apparently his name is Neptune, and Jaune's seriously envious of his ability to converse with Weiss without inviting hostilities.

Blake is done with all these shenanigans and wanders off. "Women," says Nora dismissively, which I find to be a very autological remark in this instance.



Wandering off might not have been Blake's best decision - now she is alone with her thoughts in the RWBY dorm, having a flashback to Ozpin hauling her into a meeting after the events of V01C16.

Blake makes more clear that she had a difficult and violent life pre-Beacon.

Ozpin: "And I am proud to run a school that accepts students from all walks of life. Rich, poor; human," (sips tea) "...faunus."
I bring this up because the video went cactus just after he said "human". This is the second time it's happened, and both were as Blake's faunus nature was about to be pointed out. My video player might be racist?

Ozpin tries to gently persuade Blake to stop hiding her faunus feature by appealing to recent strides in racial integration. Blake's response is to drop the "with all due respect" bomb. For those few who might not have heard it yet, the Ashley Williams (RIP, statistically) quote:
Why is it that whenever someone says "with all due respect" they really mean "kiss my ass"?

Blake asserts to Ozpin that she didn't know the White Fang would turn up at the docks. This is correct - she and Sun only had Sun's hunch that the then-unknown Dust thieves would turn up - and even more correct given that I think Ozpin is trying to wheedle any residual White Fang sympathies out of her. Not that I can blame him; he has a duty of care to everyone.

Ozpin's mug of tea is still quite full, and perilously close to his edge of the table. I hope Aura can protect against scalding liquids...

Fortunately, Ozpin's tea stays unspilled. He leaves, but not before encouraging Blake to talk to him again if necessary but in more and clunkier words. Here's a free tip: Use positive words when giving instructions, especially to young people. (Contrast "Don't use negative words [...]". Negative words like "don't" suck attention away from the rest of the sentence, can leave ambiguity as to what you'd prefer done instead, and thereby open you up to more loophole-lawyering.)



Team RWY re-enter the dorm - apparently they let Sun sub in for Blake and he absolutely cooked their bacon. Blake, jolted from her flashback, attempts to leave for quieter pastures - but Weiss notices and stops her on the way out, accusing her of being "quiet, antisocial, and moody" ("Uh, have you met Blake?" "[...]more than usual") and bringing up her promise to tell them about problems in future.

Uh oh, Weiss has a full animated background. The last time that happened to someone we got Queen of the Castle.

The next best thing happens: Weiss somehow ends up precisely balanced standing on a tilting chair. Not quite a Nora-grade castle, but quite impressive in its own way.

Weiss realises her position, sheepishly blurs the chair back to the desk, then blurs back to an unimpressed pose on the bit of floor it just occupied. Yes, I'm certain this time that she's unimpressed.

Blake's problem is that, being much less comfortable with authority than her teammates, she's not confident at all in authority's ability to handle the White Fang (and Torchwick too)'s recent escalations. Worse, she's herded herself into a main-character mindset and is spending all her free time trying to solve it alone.

Weiss, self-declared voice of reason, senses Ruby and Yang about to jump on board. Dramatic irony drips off her pronouncement that "We're students! We're not ready to handle this sort of situation." It's dramatic irony because of the title song. Blake's response could have been ripped right out of said song.

Ruby calls a vote. Yang is enthusiastically on board. Weiss has somehow been convinced (you suppose it could be fun? Who are you and what did you do with the real Weiss?). Ruby is just disappointed none of them said "aye" like she told them to. (Oh Ruby.) Then she remembers she left the board game in the library. Weiss flips right back to "We're doomed.". Ruby, already out the door, shouts that she'll be right back before bouncing off the camera onto her still-cooked bacon.

Uh oh, it wasn't the camera, it was Emerald, accompanied by Mercury. I have a bad feeling.

Oh no, I was right: Cinder is behind them, oozing malice as usual.

Mercury makes the least convincing excuse ever for why they're not in the exchange student dorm. Even if the excuse was better, I doubt his ability to deliver it.

Ruby finally gets to drop the episode title. Cinder doesn't notice - she's too busy advancing towards the camera. Maliciously.

Roll credits. What kind of concept-art abomination is this? I cannot explain to you how wrong all the faces look. And why do the lyrics sound like they could just as easily apply to Transformers?

...oh dear, it's fanart. It seems I owe a fan an apology.



Next time: How to become an isekai protagonist.
 
(Two synonyms for red? How obvious can you get? ...Weiss and Blake sound awfully close to 'white' and 'black'. I'm willing to bet that 'Yang' translates to 'yellow' somehow.)
Weiss and Blake don't just sound like White and Black, they mean white and black, just in case no one else pointed it out.
Also, Schnee means Snow. So she's White White-Thing. Same as Ruby Rose is Red Red-Thing.

Something in Pyrrha's colours takes Jaune off to stage left at speed; the sound effects imply it pins him to the far wall. Somebody apologises for something, but I've no idea who (or what).
Huh, you really might be a little voiceblind. I had no trouble telling that was Pyrrha when I watched it.
This sequence makes the classic "Superman catches Lois Lane just above the ground" error. As the saying goes, it's not the fall that kills you {{(sweats)}}, it's the sudden stop at the end. The stop here is just as sudden as if Jaune had hit the ground. Assuming he's suspended from a spear stuck in a tree, the sudden stop is less likely to break his legs, but more likely to break his neck: generally less survivable at the best of times, which this isn't.
Ah, the old Gwen Stacy.
 
Last edited:
I'm very monolingual and German(?) doesn't often trigger my research impulse, so that one slipped by.
Yep, German.

On Nora: I can see the comparison to Pinkie, but she's actually fairly different in personality. Pinkie is a compulsive people pleaser, obsessed with trying to make everyone else happy. Nora isn't that, for all that she's also a cheery cloud-cuckoo-lander.
 
Last edited:
V02C03 A Minor Hiccup

V02C03 A Minor Hiccup


Apparently we just don't get short titles this Volume. Also, did you know that "Time To Say Goodbye" is a really common song name?

Weiss is clock-watching in Professor Port's lecture theatre, which is understandable given that Port is storytelling. She redoubles her focus when Jaune tries to ask her out.

Finally, class is over. As Weiss leaves, she reveals that she was apparently paying enough attention to agree with the part where Jaune trailed off into saying that she was much smarter than him. Yang, walking past him slightly later with the rest of her team, delivers an en passant headpat and remark of "One day.", which really isn't responsible or helpful of her.

Rare side-on shot of the "bunk beds" as Ruby proclaims the beginning of Team RWBY's investigation into the White Fang and Torchwick and everything. Weiss has to dodge fast as Ruby leaps off her bunk in her excitement.

Everyone knows their roles: Ruby and Weiss will abuse the latter's family connections, Blake will abuse her heritage, and Yang will abuse her underworld connections (by which she probably means Junior). The Unspoken Plan Guarantee™'s inverse means that it won't work out that way.

I wasn't expecting it to go off the rails before they even left the room, but here's Sun anyway.

Also he brought Neptune. This is getting out of hand, now there are two of them. He's not quite as comfortable with heights as Sun.

Sun and Neptune are paired with Blake and Yang respectively. Weiss protests - Weiss is acting distinctly un-Weiss-like with regard to Neptune - but Ruby drags her out the door.

I have just noticed that Team RWBY are all wearing new outfits. Look, costume animation budget!



It is now time for michaelb958's Tangentially Related Storytime.

In the grim darkness of history, there was mostly war. This was not for no reason. We live in a time of unprecedented technological advancement: Most of history was pretty technologically boring across the span of a human lifetime. There were rarely any great advancements in productivity, and when there were, deploying them was beyond the means of many states. Furthermore, nigh-all production came from agriculture, which is basically proportional to land. If a state wanted more stuff, the most efficient option by far was to take more land from other states.

In the 1800s, industrialisation had a twofold game-changing effect. Firstly, building machines and factories and stuff could dramatically increase the productivity of the land a state already had. Secondly, this also increased the ruin of war, so taking land from a peer power (which, eventually, most of them were) would destroy the machines etc. already deployed there, rendering the land a bit useless relative to the new normal.

Suddenly, trade was more productive than war, and war was more destructive than ever. The First World War ended up being what was always going to happen when states, constructs designed to support wars to take land, tried to war under this new paradigm: 'horrifyingly inefficient in money and lives' is the most charitable interpretation possible. And so, when the dust settled, the surviving states of Europe looked at each other across the oceans of rubble and said "Let's not do this again. H*cking dismantle the worst aggressor as an abject lesson to anyone else who wants to try."

As you know, that didn't work so well: About twenty years later we got the Second World War, which was even more lethal, destructive, and generally wasteful of lives and assets, not to mention it took half again as long to resolve. And afterwards, the surviving states of Europe looked at each other across the even bigger oceans of rubble, and one of them was the first to say "We can't go on like this." The new plan: entangle all of themselves in so very much international trade that none would dare start a destructive, wasteful war because even the obvious immediate costs would be too much to bear. The instrument of that plan was the European Coal and Steel Community, which became the ancestor of the European Union and the eurozone and all those other nice things. There wasn't another war in Europe for more than seventy-five years, and they all got fabulously rich.

(Most of that was basically just me reading off the notes of an actual historian. Check them out.)

So while one's first reaction to Weiss saying 'the Kingdom of Atlas graciously gifted everybody the Cross-Continental Transmit System after the Great War' is probably 'in what utopia', on sober second thought it makes a great deal of sense as a forward-thinking mechanism to support economic entanglement and thereby discourage future wars. Better communication links can only help the eternal defense against the Grimm, and encouraging trade also helps with the cost-benefit analysis for such a megaproject. Truly, Remnant is fortunate to only have needed one Great War to realise they should be making trade not war. (I wouldn't swap, though - they have Grimm.)

Ruby, being Ruby, insisted they visit the gargantuan CCTS Tower (it deserves the capital letters) itself to check out the cool technology. When she tries to take a picture, she butterfingers her Scroll all the way over there to Penny's feet. When Ruby asks where she's been, Penny just accuses her of being confused and flees. Well, she's definitely confused now.

Ruby pursues. Penny doesn't want to say anything, but under a two-pronged attack of 'the people from the docks are up to something and we're investigating' and "as your friend!", eventually admits "It's not safe to talk here."

Meanwhile, Weiss walks into the megastructure. You'd think she would have noticed it visually before kinetically. That's only three-quarters a terrible joke: She's inside, walking directly towards the camera, and directly behind her is a solid pillar between the two sets of main doors - the visual implication is she phased through the pillar.

The immediate lobby of the CCTS Tower is very old-style fancy, but it rapidly transitions to a more cyber-fancy style.

When Weiss presents her Scroll to the cyber-fancy lift as an access card, it thanks her by name. I've never had a lift address me by name and I don't want to. I'm also a bit irked by having a voice operator when a button would do, and curious as to what destinations a random walk-in might want that aren't "the communications room" (as if this megastructure only has one).

The communications room's receptionist is a hologram. Telepresence, or AI?

The SDC receptionist confirms that Weiss has a living father and sister. Blake, the only possible-orphan of Team RWBY, is now the only possible-only-child as well.

"I've compiled a short list," says Weiss, transmitting from her Scroll what the sound effects imply is an unshort list.

Weiss is evidently not very attached to her father. But oh, how refreshing, nepotism leveraged for a good cause. I read some piece of media criticism once that asked, essentially, why is it that only the bad guys ever benefit from corruption? Why don't the protagonists occasionally get to come out ahead by bribing the right guy? It stuck with me.

That conversation would probably have gone worse if Ruby was there, wouldn't it.



Meanwhile, Penny is standing in front of a cafe that looks like the same one patronised by Blake and Sun, if possibly a little less colourful. Right on cue, here's Ruby, hoping it's safe to talk here. It sort of is - the conversation waits until they're walking along some random footpath.

Ruby and Penny commiserate over their fathers being a little overly-protective of them. Ruby then makes progress on who asked Penny not to even say anything to her (or the rest of her team), but they walk around a corner into a press-conference-slash-live-demonstration of the latest in Atlas military hardware. Not only do they have new and improved human-scale robot mechs, they also have giant human-piloted mechs! Ruby is naturally captivated, but Penny is extremely uneasy, and then flees as two soldiers break off from the demonstration and run in their direction. Free tip: Police running at you are scary, and soldiers doubly so, but fleeing is a pretty suspicious-looking reaction. (I'm not quite saying this from my ivory tower. Ask me about the time I got pulled over by an undercover cop car for Walking While Hoodied.)

Ruby pursues. In turn, the soldiers pursue her. All four of them fail to look both ways before crossing a minor road. Most are lucky, but one of the soldiers is collected by a car that can't quite stop in time. The other soldier ditches their partner to continue the pursuit. There are so many things wrong with that decision.

The next alleyway they all run down has a somewhat rickety-looking wooden structure with a bunch of crates on top of it. A slash from Crescent Rose brings it down behind Ruby, delaying the soldier. Ruby then parkours her way to catching up with Penny and carries her off down a connecting alley in a burst of rose petals. I question why she didn't go to petals a lot sooner - superspeed is pretty handy if you want to catch up to someone. Maybe she's worried it would make her too identifiable if the soldiers saw?

Anyway, Ruby stacks the landing (maybe that's why), leaving Penny flat on her face at the alley mouth as she (Ruby) bounces and rolls into the middle of a road. I don't like where this is going.

Suddenly, truck! I knew I didn't like where this was going.

Suddenly, Penny! She shoves Ruby out of the way and braces herself to be hit palms-first. Against all reasonable expectations, Penny is not isekaied; instead, the road she's standing on is.

It's the same shopkeeper driving the truck. Sometimes I just can't even.

Penny, still visibly distressed, considers her hands for a few moments before resuming her panicked flight. Ruby pursues again. The soldiers finally catch up, but are kept busy policing what is now the scene of a weird traffic accident. I wonder how the first soldier, who got collected by a car, got here in the same amount of time as their partner who left them behind (again, so many things wrong with that). Perhaps they went back after being blocked by the cratefall.

Ruby catches up with Penny and just wants to know what the h*ck is going on. Penny, fists firmly clenched, gets an attack of the hiccups in between deflections that are more like outright conversational blocks. (Is that what the episode title is about?)

Sufficient silver-eyed pleading, and assurances of friendship, finally gets Penny to open up, somewhat literally as well as figuratively, revealing a deep metaphysical inferiority complex in addition to the metal beneath the damaged skin of her palms. "Oh," says Ruby, as the writers leave us on a cliff.

Today's credits fanart is of Penny, and today's credits music is actually going to make me cry if it goes on a second longer.



Next time: Car Crash TV.
 
inally, class is over. As Weiss leaves, she reveals that she was apparently paying enough attention to agree with the part where Jaune trailed off into saying that she was much smarter than him. Yang, walking past him slightly later with the rest of her team, delivers an en passant headpat and remark of "One day.", which really isn't responsible or helpful of her.
Now there are people who say Jaundice is when they started disliking Jaune, but for me, it was here. If someone kept asking me for something I had already told them no on over and over again, I'd start out annoyed and end up pissed and if they still kept going at some point they'd find they'd made an enemy for life. Yang is definitely making a bad play here, though I'm hoping she's just being unclear and means "someday, a girl will agree to go out with you" not "someday Weiss will suddenly change her mind if you keep bothering her." I don't want to hate you Jaune, so please learn to respect people's boundaries.

Seeing more Penny is always great, though, especially interacting with Ruby.
 
Last edited:
The communications room's receptionist is a hologram. Telepresence, or AI?
According to the episode's voice acting credits, it's the latter:
V02C03 Credits said:
CCT AI - Megan Castro


I question why she didn't go to petals a lot sooner - superspeed is pretty handy if you want to catch up to someone. Maybe she's worried it would make her too identifiable if the soldiers saw?

Anyway, Ruby stacks the landing (maybe that's why)
Ruby seems to have trouble even jumping off the wall into superspeed right after she grabs Penny, gritting her teeth. Seconds later mid-flight, her face goes slack and she hangs her head right before she drops Penny and starts tumbling. I think the implication is that trying to bring a passenger made using her speed a lot more strenuous and she hit her limit at the worst time.
 
Penny! :D

According to the episode's voice acting credits, it's the latter:




Ruby seems to have trouble even jumping off the wall into superspeed right after she grabs Penny, gritting her teeth. Seconds later mid-flight, her face goes slack and she hangs her head right before she drops Penny and starts tumbling. I think the implication is that trying to bring a passenger made using her speed a lot more strenuous and she hit her limit at the worst time.
Also seemed to me like Penny was heavier than she expected too.

I've seen people get it mixed up but the CCT is also located inside the main Beacon tower alongside Oz's office and the clock.
 
Back
Top