IWIW RWBY

Was a real shame when this was, seemingly, the end of RWBY. It's a distinct cliffhanger for the next arc, for all that the cast progressed emotionally and in character growth. Hopefully we get season ten in the next few years from the franchise's new owners.
Could have been worse.

Could have been one Volume earlier.

Really, the Cat was doomed the moment it was knocked out of Neo. Now it's just a big monster. They take out a dozen of those before breakfast.
And in Neo's case, as breakfa(is shot)

Also fun, no one's gonna be telling Cinder Neo stayed behind in the Ever After. When she learns RWBY made it back, her paranoia will be legendary.
Personally, I'm 100% okay with Cinder being paranoid about Neo forever.

Also implies that the Brothers themselves have no understanding of balance, which might come back into play if they ever show up again...
Frankly the entire "There must be a balance" thing just seems to be a rule they agreed on rather than something cosmologically necessary.
Or they heard the Tree or Blacksmith talking about balance but didn't get it, so made up rules to try to follow to see if that was balance.
...wait, holy crap. Ozma. The gods decided that Salem needed to be "balanced", so they went and applied Ozma to the problem because they don't really know what balance is! It all makes sense now!

I take it as a bit of an apology from the ever after for the whole clock fruit mess that got him aged in the first place, but also that, from a narrative point of view, he wouldn't really be able to continue as a main character with that legacy visible, alongside RWBY and ORNE. He gets the lessons, and then he gets to be who he needs to be.
There's a reason for this, the writers wanted V9 to be a turning of the tide, triumphant and joyful thing. Jaune being kept as having squandered decades of his life, left in a still rather ruinous head-space even if he was sort of functional in that moment and otherwise still being stuck so deeply wounded from his time in the Ever After and now set to likely die well before all his loved one's and remain forever awkwardly disconnected would not do that. It would be interesting to explore, but it wouldn't match the tone the writers were going for.
I agree with the tone thing, mainly because I really want to have a better tone for this ending than the scarcely-mitigated-in-retrospect clusterf*ck that was the previous one.

and that takes us into the ending of the Volume, and technically the end of RWBY so far (Beyond is partly set after this, and the second Justice League movie takes place after this point, but that's a sorta-loose canon). With a soft version of the volume 1 theme playing, the team look out over Vacuo, defended by ships from multiple nations, Amity floating above it. Times have been tough. There was deaths and defeats. But there is still hope.
yeeeeeeees
(I have done too much thinking about this one particular point: the closer Salem pushes humanity for extinction, the less room there is for disunity, simply because there aren't as many humans to be disunited.)

(I missed that it was a This Will Be The Day reprise. That's cool too.)

Low key surprised this one didn't leave you more flabbergasted, this one left the FNDM in hysterics and led to the spread of amazing Rosebird meme XD
Pick your favourite explanation of "flat surprise", "{{forgot to pretend to be surprised}}", or "missed it entirely".

In all fairness, the Cat is also rapidly approaching Ruby's body, this is less the Blacksmith pressuring Ruby because she wants to (The Herbalist was there for like 30 hours) and more a case of, "I need you to make a decision now or the decision you would have made won't matter cos you'll be super dead."
I know. It isn't real life, there are scriptwriters. Also I work for a bank and my conscience yelled at me about working a scamwatch message in as soon as it realised the opportunity.

I legit cried at this line.
So did, at minimum, Ruby. So it's understandable.
 
Personally, I'm 100% okay with Cinder being paranoid about Neo forever.
Mood XD
...wait, holy crap. Ozma. The gods decided that Salem needed to be "balanced", so they went and applied Ozma to the problem because they don't really know what balance is! It all makes sense now!
Admittedly I am unsure Light was trying to help Salem so much as add another elaborate layer to her punishment, or just screwing around with his experiment and not really thinking about her.
I agree with the tone thing, mainly because I really want to have a better tone for this ending than the scarcely-mitigated-in-retrospect clusterf*ck that was the previous one.
Volume 8 was brutal, very much the darkest moment.
Pick your favourite explanation of "flat surprise", "{{forgot to pretend to be surprised}}", or "missed it entirely".
Fair XD
Also o the memes front, I have some:

I know. It isn't real life, there are scriptwriters. Also I work for a bank and my conscience yelled at me about working a scamwatch message in as soon as it realised the opportunity.
Fair, fair.
So did, at minimum, Ruby. So it's understandable.
Appreciated.
 
V09C11 Bonus Ending Animatic

V09C11 Bonus Ending Animatic


A couple of the writers turn up in live-action to tell us that this was planned to be Chapter 12 (of 12), before 8-11 got crunched into 8-10 and this one got more-or-less dropped and its content moved (not quite intact) to Volume 10. But we are blessed with its storyboard-with-audio form anyway. Context, Chapter 10 nee 11 was meant to end with Team RWBY+J finding their own cenotaphs and somebody (cliffhanger on who) finding them there...



Black screen. "We buried our friends today," says Nora (I have had a sudden attack of not-voice-blind-ness).

You can tell this is raw form because the visuals we are now getting still have scene and shot numbers on them, and assorted other technical marks that would have been fed into the animation pipeline. This is going to make it difficult for me to visually identify anything. Like, I'm pretty sure the funeral crowd we're panning past includes Emerald, but don't quote me on that, I don't really know. Taking another look (as Nora tries her best to give a eulogy, it's heartbreaking), there's Fiona's uncle, I think those might be some of the Mantle crowd, cut to Willow, Whitley, Emerald, Fiona, Joanna, May, h*ck me they have no idea Robyn survived the Fall of Atlas.

It's one big cenotaph. A front row of four characters are seen from the back looking at it. I guess this is Team, uh, {{OLVE sounds good}}. ...Here's Nora's long-delayed total emotional breakdown. Oh gods Nora. And the rest of them too, but Nora's the one I'm hearing bawling right now, so sue me. ...No, this can't be all of Team OLVE because Emerald's still a row behind. I don't know who the fourth one was, then.

Okay, this explains a little bit, this is Nora narrating superimposed on the scene. She says Ren had the idea of putting the cenotaph at the portal site. Vacuo proper is easily visible from there on a clear day. Thanks, sandstorm!

"I think everyone lost something that day," narrates Nora. Sandstorm-wipe-transition to that day, and Winter trying to remain functional and keep the Grimm off everyone while also having an emotional breakdown. (Remember also the folks whom Cinder blew off the platforms in the Central Location.) I don't have to try to find Nora in this shot because there's a big working note of "Nora in foreground". Now here's Emerald, Oscar, Ren, and Nora in that order trying to hold the flanks. Now here's some of Vacuo's !!fun!! new Grimm to make them work for it.

Nora heads for the Grimm wave, and almost gets there before it's gunned down. I do believe that this is Team CFVY reappearing after a casual six Volumes out of the spotlight. And I think this is Sun and Neptune right behind them. Narrating Nora says, in time with it being shown, that as Winter cleared the sandstorm it became clear that they were right near Vacuo proper.

And then the !!fun!! really started for Vacuo. What do you get when you take a Kingdom in constant low-to-mid-level hardship and add a refugee camp half of whose population thought that 'hardship' is something that might abduct them to Menagerie for mob justice if they didn't eat their greens? That's right, Grimm attacks for days. Literally. Also holy cow that's a scary sandworm.

The Grimm attacks were soon replaced by constant national tensions, as you might expect in this kind of situation. Here's Neon Katt trying to keep a proto-mob off a kid who absolutely does not deserve to be lynched. Nora arrives for backup. "What's wrong with orphans?" she asks the instigators. They might or might not know she is one, but the hammer makes her stance and intent clear. They slink off. Nora immediately pivots to reassuring the kid. Go Nora! The kid isn't going to recover immediately. :(

Now Neon gets to see some of Nora's scarring, and Nora takes her shock just as badly, as Narrating Nora wonders if they're all just not going to recover before the end of the world. Or, as she puts it, "too... scarred". The writers must think they're hilarious. Also, :(



Oscar is out at the cenotaph, wishing to have Ruby's certainty. Cue portal? No, just sunrise? Not sure, but it's about the only coloured thing so far.

Neither Oscar nor Ozpin have been able to dig up anything resembling an idea of what might have happened to Team RWBY+J. Vacuo's history of being repeatedly burned and looted by invading powers does not help. Also the Grimm attacks are back on and it's not great.



I see different characters are taking turns talking to the big cenotaph. Now it's Ren's turn. He has no clue how exactly Jaune got forged into a leader by the events of Volumes 3-7, rather than just broken. The real question is whether Jaune even had/has any clue.

I've been trying to resist calling any group of protagonists "the gang" except when trying to evoke It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia episode titles for comedy which I think I did once or twice. Ren now unironically drops the G-word in dialogue.

Nora and Velvet decline Ren's offer of dinner because they're going on a supply delivery mission. Ren says that's cool. I think he's actually not. He worries that Nora's "putting the world on her shoulders" (I am uncomfortably reminded of Ruby's journey). Also Oscar seems to be increasingly merging with Ozpin despite their best efforts.

Yatsuhashi calls Ren to report trouble. A group of ne'er-do-wells have been kicking doors in and leaving graffiti. Also Tyrian. Remember Tyrian? Like we needed him here.

Ren is worried that Salem can replenish her ranks better than the side of good can. Also his Semblance-vision works on entire cities, which would be very cool out of context.



Now it is Winter's turn. Behind her are several teams, labelled:
  • "CFVY" and "SSSN", obvious enough.
  • "QRFJM", which would be the Happy Huntresses plus Qrow. Oh excellent, Qrow and Robyn made it.
  • "EONR", which took a bit of thinking before it hit me that it's Emerald, Oscar, Nora, and Ren, whom I and many others previously called OLVE.
  • "MEH". This cannot possibly be the meme name for Mercury, Emerald, and Hazel, but I can't think who it would be. Maybe it's a note that these are random extras? But then why are they here? ...I'm an idiot, it's the surviving Ace Ops: Marrow, Elm, and Harriet. Not a very flattering team name for them.
Anyway, Winter has now run through all the stages of grief w.r.t. Weiss. (Cut to Willow and Whitley who have also had to go through that process.) Winter, narrating, has a bad case of survivor's guilt crossed with plain old guilt at having propped up Ironwood and not having accomplished all of the gang's objectives in the Central Location.

Cut to more xenophobic-nationalist graffiti. This is swiftly replaced in importance by an aircraft arriving. It bears Professors Port and Oobleck. They report that Salem has stopped by Vale and given it the Atlas treatment, which. Okay. Things are clearly not going well at all. Professor Goodwitch is elsewhere "trying to find help". I think it's being implied that Mistral is in no state to receive this refugee column either, so it might be anywhere from 'as dysfunctional as we left it' to 'Salem's next known target'.

(Fun fact which I learned recently [possibly not for the first time]: The English word "vale" can mean a valley, or it can mean a farewell with heavy connotations of postmortem. I'm certain the writers planned that all along.)

Cut to Qrow and Willow - an unlikely alliance on any subject other than alcohol - helping distribute rations, as Winter narrates that Weiss was the optimistic one of the two of them (Winter and Weiss). Some are still not inclined to take charity from anyone named Schnee. Others decide that they ought to go somewhere other than the refugee camp; I admire their optimism in thinking there's anywhere else to go.

Winter thinks that Team RWBY+J would be disappointed in them. I think instead that she's having a bit of depression, and understandably so.

Klein arrives in an aircraft for some reason?

Somebody has defaced the cenotaph with "DON'T COME BACK". This could have any number of fascinating implications which I am in no mood to explore.



Qrow is apparently the optimistic one right now. Weird. His view is essentially that the better side of the human condition now has the opportunity to shine brighter than ever.

Desert oasis symbolism. The writers must think they're hilarious.

Anyway, Qrow has been summoned by Robyn to come see something. The something is a much less nationalistic mural on a wall. Much of the population of Remnant, faced with the where-were-you-when moment of Ruby's broadcast from Atlas, has evidently attempted to come to grips with it through humanity's oldest mechanism for finding meaning: religion. Congratulations Ruby, you're a martyr-prophet.

Qrow regrets only that Ruby won't see the good things she started rolling. Somebody please tell him.

Later, Qrow broods outside what I assume to be Shade Academy. Suddenly, portal! The colour scheme (unusual for anything here to be coloured) makes me think of Raven's portal, but this is unquestionably Team RWBY+J who emerge from it. Don't ask me which of them is in the foreground of this side-on shot, though - I don't recognise them at all. ...Wait, that must be Raven, who portaled them the rest of the way up here. What was Raven even doing anywhere near here? Good question.

(The most likely answer is that Raven was nowhere near here, noticed via her Semblance that Yang died, then noticed that Yang undied and wondered what the h*ck that was about.)

Qrow breaks it to Ruby that the world heard her.

The music here is the same piece that would ultimately cap off Volume 9.

"Hey Qrow, are you coming to the meeting, or-(gasp)" NORA YES. And the rest of Team OLVE too, but Nora's the one talking right now, so sue me. (Yes, that's definitely Raven next to Qrow there.) I'm not crying. Get the keyboard away from me I'm not crying!



Credits. Some of the assets that would have been used in the animation stage made it as far as concept art, so here it is.

Yep, Ruby has a religion now. "Remember heR / message" says the text on the mural; the capitalisation is no doubt intended to evoke Ruby's initials.


Next time: (TBA)
 
Yatsuhashi calls Ren to report trouble. A group of ne'er-do-wells have been kicking doors in and leaving graffiti. Also Tyrian. Remember Tyrian? Like we needed him here.

This is suspected to be related to the ultranationalist group the Crown, the villains of the two Vacuo books.

...Wait, that must be Raven, who portaled them the rest of the way up here. What was Raven even doing anywhere near here? Good question.

(The most likely answer is that Raven was nowhere near here, noticed via her Semblance that Yang died, then noticed that Yang undied and wondered what the h*ck that was about.)

Also note that in the animation, while it's rough, she genuinely smiles at Qrow. I suspect they might have had words in the time skip...
 
Huh, that's interesting, I genuinely didn't know we had any content for season ten yet. Even if it's moreso cut stuff from season nine. Wasn't expecting Ruby to be a religious figure either.
 

V09C11 Bonus Ending Animatic

Gods I would kill for more RWBY right now.
Now Neon gets to see some of Nora's scarring,
Fun fact this led to shipping art of them :3
wishing to have Ruby's certainty.
Stuff like this is why I say Oscar's as much of a pressure applier as the rest were, just differently.
Also gosh he was struggling in tat scene :(
Ren now unironically drops the G-word in dialogue.
I love it, also wait they have intentionally referenced It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia?
LOL
I'm certain the writers planned that all along.
Given V9 was planned around V1 it would not shock me.
Goh I remember some Ironwood fans thought that was a statue of hi built in Vacuo for some reason and got inordinately offended that "CRWBY had a soldiers war memorial defaced!"
religion. Congratulations Ruby, you're a martyr-prophet.
Give that girl a cult!
Qrow breaks it to Ruby that the world heard her.
Gods I adored that moment so much!!!!!
 
Was a real shame when this was, seemingly, the end of RWBY. It's a distinct cliffhanger for the next arc, for all that the cast progressed emotionally and in character growth. Hopefully we get season ten in the next few years from the franchise's new owners.

As inadvertent endings go, it's far from the worst out there, with at least an emotional climax, but it'll be so good to get more.
 
This is suspected to be related to the ultranationalist group the Crown, the villains of the two Vacuo books.
Well, that's going to be Fun™.

Also note that in the animation, while it's rough, she genuinely smiles at Qrow. I suspect they might have had words in the time skip...
Raven be a better person challenge (impossible what!)

Huh, that's interesting, I genuinely didn't know we had any content for season ten yet. Even if it's moreso cut stuff from season nine.
Conditional on there being a V10 eventually, I think it's better to put the break before all this. It makes the separation between the Ever After (V9) and Vacuo (V10-) a lot cleaner.

Wasn't expecting Ruby to be a religious figure either.
To be fair, who was?

Fun fact this led to shipping art of them :3
I am completely and totally unsurprised.

I love it, also wait they have intentionally referenced It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia?
Probably not intentionally, it's just wormed its way into the popular subconscious.

Goh I remember some Ironwood fans thought that was a statue of hi built in Vacuo for some reason and got inordinately offended that "CRWBY had a soldiers war memorial defaced!"
Well, they're not entirely wrong, it is defacing a memorial to combatants in a war...

(I am informed on the other forum that Winter did it. What?! What in the flaming Solitas h*ck is going on in her head to make her do that?! It's going to be an Interesting™ reunion at some point, I see.)
 
(I am informed on the other forum that Winter did it. What?! What in the flaming Solitas h*ck is going on in her head to make her do that?! It's going to be an Interesting™ reunion at some point, I see.)

She MIGHT have done it. People say the writers said that, but I've never actually seen that confirmation.
 
Last edited:
I am completely and totally unsurprised.
We are a predictable lot XD
Probably not intentionally, it's just wormed its way into the popular subconscious.
Ah fair.
Well, they're not entirely wrong, it is defacing a memorial to combatants in a war...

(I am informed on the other forum that Winter did it. What?! What in the flaming Solitas h*ck is going on in her head to make her do that?! It's going to be an Interesting™ reunion at some point, I see.)
True, just not a soldier of the state or the one they thought it was, so like, 30% correct I guess? XD

I believe the logic was that she feels they failed Weiss and she doesn't want Weiss to have to see that all her efforts and faith were miss-spent.
 
Last edited:
Winter Schnee and the Marked Memorial
She MIGHT have done it. People say the writers said that, but I've never actually seen that confirmation.
Okay, so I've gone to have another look.
  • 10:46 I think this is the memorial service crowd dispersing. Winter starts her little depression monologue (in narration, I think), standing a bit back from the cenotaph.
  • 10:50 Now Winter has a hand on the cenotaph (seen only from behind it).
  • 11:00 Willow and Whitley trade lines. I think Willow is trying to avoid Whitley getting sunburnt but Whitley has taken it as symbolic.
  • 11:07 Klein arrives by aircraft. We get a reaction shot of Willow and Whitley, and over their shoulder we can see Winter, still with her hand on the cenotaph.
  • 11:09 Same shot, Winter now applying a light blue glow which the wiki transcript says is magic (I believe it).
  • 11:11 The focus goes back to Klein for a bit.
  • 11:17 Willow looks back over her shoulder at Winter, who has finished with the magic.
  • 11:21 Winter leaves the cenotaph, exposing "DON'T COME BACK".
The lack of detail makes it difficult to be sure, but we never saw the written area before 11:21 except from very wide shots - either the camera was behind it or Winter was in the way. It's possible that Winter was just trying to block the writing from their view, but then what was the magic for if not to remove it? I think they want us to think Winter wrote it. Maybe they're setting up to pull a fast one on us later, or maybe they're not.
 
Volume 9 Checkpoint
No slide this time. (The source post ran out.) Here's a YouTube video entitled "RWBY Volume 9 out of context" instead:

I've also seen an equivalent for V1, from which I have learned two things:
  1. The difference in animation quality is incredibly stark over this extended timeframe.
  2. Here I was thinking that Grimm Eclipse only drew its OST from the series soundtrack, but apparently every single other piece of music in Grimm Eclipse had appeared at some point prior in the series score. I mean, it does make sense, they had no budget for the flagship web series, they had about negative budget for the spinoff video game.



I'm apparently really good at forgetting the music I planned to mix in. Here's a track I was going to slot into V8 somewhere, guess why:


And here's one that should have gone into a scene at Salem's castle sometime (V4-6):




I swear this post is just the 'I forgot to sprinkle this in' tour. Next up, the phrase "vote early and vote often". Volume 7 gives us a tour of what happens when these two suggestions of electoral meddling conflict; turns out "vote often" wins.

And while I'm on the topic of Volume 7, a reminder of timeframes. Chapter 6 occurs on Atlas Council election day, which for the benefit of the Americans in the audience I'll call Tuesday. Chapter 7 plausibly occurs in a single day after that (Wednesday). I'll be generous and say that there was 24 hours' notice of the "party" at the Schnee live-in trophy cabinet (starting in Chapter 8), which puts it on Thursday night. The rest of V7 spans from there to sunrise Friday. Volume 8 runs over about 24 hours after that, concluding an hour or two into daylight on Saturday. Volume 9 is difficult to judge due to the timey-wimey nature of the Ever After, but if one discounts the darkness in the Herbalist's Acre as a local effect rather than the day-night cycle, the first six Chapters occur on the same day, and the last four early in the next day, so it's some point on Sunday when everybody pops in to see the Blacksmith. The portal then proceeds to dump them out in Vacuo much later than that by anyone else's calendar, but in the subjective experience of Team RWBY (obviously not Jaune), it has been five days since their biggest problem was convincing General Ironwood not to freeze out presumed-Councillor-elect Robyn Hill. FIVE DAYS.



During the animatic in Chapter 10, there is a brief view of a map-diagram of the Ever After. It's not a board game, but it looks just like the board for one, and honestly, I want that board game. Players compete to amass memory tokens to Ascend with in order to stack bonuses to, uh, that's where my theorycrafting runs out, I'm not a board game designer. But I can see the game's tagline already. "Live. Learn. Repeat."



It has been noted that Ruby and Jaune's self-destructive attitudes that came out to play in Chapter 7 were inadvertently seeded way back by Ozpin's leadership advice to Ruby in V01C10:
"Being a team leader isn't just a title you carry into battle, but a badge you wear constantly. If you're not always performing at your absolute best, then what reason do you give others to follow you?"
which Ruby then mangled, internalised, and passed on to Jaune in V01C13:
"You're a leader now, Jaune. You're not allowed to be a failure. [...] We have to put our teammates first, and ourselves second."

I put it to you that in between those things there was even worse foreshadowing. Here's Jaune in V01C12:
"Pyrrha, I know I'm going through a hard time right now, but I'm not that depressed."



One more video! If, like me, you're in dire need of some happier Pyrrha memories to displace her V9 appearances, I found some while reading an old fic thread. Some of you may remember how Rules of Nature, from the Metal Gear Rising Revengeance OST, goes with everything. Well, here's another data point: it goes great with the V2 food fight.

Fun fact: I actually had not previously watched the food fight - it was too much for my very low cringe threshold. Now I've at least seen the visuals.
 
No slide this time. (The source post ran out.) Here's a YouTube video entitled "RWBY Volume 9 out of context" instead:
Gods that was entertaining, thanks for sharing and also yeah HUGE glow up to say the least.
Schnee live-in trophy cabinet (
Brilliant phraseology, I love it.
Holy crap, yeah no wonder Ruby got pushed to the breaking point, like it didn't shock me at all in canon anyway but still this really drives home how staggeringly crunched they were.
During the animatic in Chapter 10, there is a brief view of a map-diagram of the Ever After. It's not a board game, but it looks just like the board for one, and honestly, I want that board game. Players compete to amass memory tokens to Ascend with in order to stack bonuses to, uh, that's where my theorycrafting runs out, I'm not a board game designer. But I can see the game's tagline already. "Live. Learn. Repeat."
OK this is a genius idea, seriously I love this and while also not a game board designer I low key want to try toying wit this concept more.
It has been noted that Ruby and Jaune's self-destructive attitudes that came out to play in Chapter 7 were inadvertently seeded way back by Ozpin's leadership advice to Ruby in V01C10:
Yuuup, like they already had issues, but Ozpin's advice and their roles as leaders/Hunters kind of served as an anchoring point to keep them on these paths even when they were growing or changing, or had other avenues. Jaune may have started outgrowing his toxic ideas, but he was still being a Huntsmen, still trying to save people and when that blew up on his face he regressed. Ruby already had issues with living in her mothers shadow and repression, but her obligations as team leader meant she steadily got worse and worse on these fronts as expectations mounted.
Fun fact: I actually had not previously watched the food fight - it was too much for my very low cringe threshold. Now I've at least seen the visuals.
Wait what? How did you skip it? XD Like in the sense of reacting to things I mean. I still need to go through the backlog ><
 
Brilliant phraseology, I love it.
Thanks, I stole it:
Really, Schnee Manor, especially in this shot, but elsewhere as well, does very well at illustrating that it's not a place intended for living in, it's for Jacqueass to show off his trophies.

Wait what? How did you skip it? XD Like in the sense of reacting to things I mean. I still need to go through the backlog ><
Very easily. Anyone who's seen it can tell from my descriptions of the aftermath that I missed the context.
 
Volume 9 Beyond
Volume 9 Beyond is a series of four short animatics covering events occurring, well, guess when. Apparently more than four were planned, but plans got cut down real quick when Rooster Teeth realised it was closing down. Also, in this case 'animatic' once again means something that went through an animation pipeline, as opposed to the storyboard-with-audio of the Bonus Ending Animatic.



Volume 9 Beyond E1: Jr. Detectives


Sun narrates like he's in a noir film. Neptune, as usual, plays the straight man.

Oh, the "and Jaune too" jokes. Given three years in the fandom subconsciousness, they were bound to creep in.

Sun's being incredibly cringeworthy and I don't know whether to cringe, or be thankful that he's been having less trauma.

I just... this will be a short one, even moreso than suggested by its runtime of barely 3.5 minutes, because I'm busy half-cringing at Sun. Apparently the comedic tone of this piece isn't working well for me.

Yes, shocking, the two surviving Academy headmasters (if we can apply that word to Oscar) are meeting with the two known Maidens, who could have foreseen this. (Apart from the obvious 'what? Raven here? what?'. So much for my theory that she sat up and took notice when Yang reappeared - at this point Yang's only apparently died.) And possibly a third, heretofore unknown Maiden.

The two Junior Detectives turn chibi when Qrow picks them up by the scruff of the neck. One of these days I'll watch Chibi and be able to get all those jokes. Maybe. The latter does not necessarily follow from the former, because this is me we're talking about.

"And I hope they haven't given up either." Well, it was looking dicey for a while...

Most of the 'concept art' in the credits did not need further work before it was used as backgrounds in the animatic.



Volume 9 Beyond E2: A Knight's Journal


Somebody - probably Jaune, my voice-blindness has returned - is narrating a journal entry (the first one).

Yep, it is Jaune. Having had a lot more life than most people who haven't physically reached twenty (...this time), he's trying to keep things in perspective, and someone told him that a journal would help.

Team ALN is back together, about as much as it can be with Jaune now being as mentally old as the balance of the roster combined. Nora, being Nora, likes to tell everyone she meets that Jaune's the Rusted Knight. Jaune would rather leave that behind.

The journal advice was apparently given to him by Oscar (now increasingly merged with Ozma), the one person best equipped to sympathise with a drastic reversal in age, along with advice to put more emphasis on the positives of his time in the Ever After to try to remember what it was for rather than depressively spiral.

First on that list, the early travels with Alyx and Lewis (I just checked, I apparently did guess the right spelling). Apparently they compared notes on Remnant; they learned that Jaune was from the future relative to them, and he learned that they were from (old) Vacuo. Old enough not to have invented days of the week, apparently.

The Ever After continues to be the Ever After: a farmers' market is where you rent farmers to grow stuff for you.

And around campfires Lewis would take copious notes on what would one day become the fairy tale, and Jaune would tell parts of his life. Imagine the increased timey-wimey shenanigans if any of that got into Lewis' notes.

Alyx and Lewis as replacement Nora and Ren. This is now made explicit. Also imaginary Pyrrha turns up as well. :(

Speaking of campfires, Vacuo is full of them right now. What are the people around them thinking? What kind of hope are they finding? Jaune doesn't know.

Jaune: "...Do you think we're gonna make it?"

Oscar: "Around that campfire, did it matter?"

Jaune: "... ...No. No, I guess it didn't."
The lesson here, I think, is that life can still be taken one day at a time. I've heard much worse lessons.



Volume 9 Beyond E3: The Adventures of Somewhat


I think Ruby is narrating here. Yep, Somewhat's voice is noticeably different to the narration.

Drinking game suggestion: Take a shot every time Ruby says "somewhat". If you hate your liver. The writers must think they're hilarious.

Anyway, Somewhat's new purpose is to "find what feels wrong" in the Ever After. This reminds me of the Curious Cat's old purpose. I guess it still needs to be done, and with the Cat's well-overdue demise they can't do it anymore.

Somewhat's first stop is the Genial Gems, who are busy rebuilding their own infrastructure in preparation to help others later. They have not seen anything that needs to be brought to Somewhat's attention - they haven't seen much at all yet, because they've been busy.

At the marketplace from Chapter 5, Somewhat is informed that something bad did happen here, but they've rebuilt and recovered, stronger than ever.

The reborn Herbalist, on the other hand, has a quest to give to Somewhat. Not a vision-smoke quest, an actual quest that matches Somewhat's purpose.

Somewhat arrives at the Crimson Castle Keep. (I really should have seen this coming.) It is almost entirely empty. After a meticulous search they finally find the Red Prince, who has dismissed His entire retinue in a fit of imposter syndrome. They find each other to be somewhat passingly familiar, which Somewhat, being Somewhat, interprets to mean that they might have been friends.

It remains the Red Prince's purpose to win games. Somewhat accepts the challenge. Over the game, they attempt to convince Him that they can find a new purpose, with or without Ascending. Somewhat wins the game so easily I'm half-wondering whether the Prince lost deliberately.

The Red Prince does not throw a tantrum of any kind or scale. Look, they can change!

Job done for the moment, Somewhat heads off into a dark Acre, only to be surprised to meet a portal. We do not see who emerges from it, only that Somewhat's reaction is "You're back!", which probably narrows it down a bit but we'd still be engaging in wild mass guessing.

(The drinking game counter stands at 8. Probably survivable.)



Volume 9 Beyond E4: Boba


For those wondering what the h*ck is going on, "boba" usually refers to tapioca pearls, aka balls, probably encountered as a component of bubble tea, aka boba tea, invented in the 1980s in Taiwan and since popularised by various East Asian diasporas, most notably in California because of American cultural hegemony. Chemically, it is a suspension - solids mixed into a liquid. What does this have to do with the world of RWBY? Let's find out, I guess.

The same shot of Vacuo proper that we've been seeing this entire series fades to a view of Ruby and Yang walking down a street somewhere therein. Yang apparently has a surprise prepared, but only a moderate one.

Ruby: "...why are you being weird?"

Yang: "I'm not weird! You're the weird one!"
That's hitting like Cars 3 right now. It shouldn't - it really shouldn't - but it is. (Brutal political satire in advance returns after an extended hiatus.)

Ruby goes chibi while emphasising how weird Yang's being. She's knocked out of chibi by a well-placed sisterly fist.

Uh oh, I think Ruby's about to meet her religion. Has such a thing ever gone well? Literally ever in the history of anything?

...It seems to have gone mostly okay. Yang takes the opportunity to call back to that "normal knees" line that was, out-of-universe, more than ten years ago. Have a seat and think about that.

The religion was not the planned surprise. The planned surprise was a bubble tea shop. Ruby disagrees with Yang's assessment that this is only a moderate surprise: she seems more excited than she was about the impromptu Beacon weapons gallery shortly after "normal knees", complete with what I'd swear are about the same chibi styles of excitement. (checks) Yep. Bubble tea: best thing since bread slicers, apparently.



This shop apparently migrated from Patch sometime around when Salem happened to Vale, having previously been a fixture of Ruby and Yang's childhoods. This unfortunately brings the conversation crashing onto what Taiyang Xiao Long may or may not be doing, and where he might be doing it if not here. Ruby reckons they probably don't have enough information to know.

Yang decides that this is the opportune time to clear the air a bit about the mess otherwise known as the back half of the Ever After; she tells Ruby that she (Ruby) doesn't owe her an explanation, apologises for the part she played in Ruby feeling like she had to bottle up her problems, and asks her to remember that she isn't alone.
"We're not going back-"
This episode can fit so much satire-in-advance in it. ...Anyway.
"We're not going back to the version of Team RWBY where you put everything on your shoulders. ...Where we put everything on your shoulders. From now on, we do it together."
Look, they're healing. Isn't it precious.

Ruby thinks that the hardest part of leadership is asking for help. Maybe that was on Beacon's second-year curriculum. Yang proposes a codeword. I'm certain that the codeword will be "boba". ...Someone better answer that Scroll, because I called it.

(Most bubble tea uses milk tea as its dispersion medium. Milk tea is largely a solution of tea and milk, exactly as it sounds. It's only taken more than ten years, but finally, Ruby drinks milk! Good thing she had friends.)
 
So, in the grand scheme, the four Beyond clips we got before RT's shutdown are character pieces at most, with little in the way of ongoing plotline details, and really depended on what CRWBY had access to. The VAs were all more or less working at RT at the time of the shutdown for example. But it sets up a side angle of something I wouldn't mind seeing more of when Viz starts up production again. Little shorts, even semi-animated like they were here, giving the little character moments they can't afford to squeeze into the show proper.
 
Most of the 'concept art' in the credits did not need further work before it was used as backgrounds in the animatic.
The concept art is amazing, I also love how technology is weaved into the classical architecture, also agree the comedic tone did not vibe with me. Qrow saying ACAB did however XD and the encouragement to not give up hope resonates still.

The lesson here, I think, is that life can still be taken one day at a time. I've heard much worse lessons.
This one was much more my speed, loved the imagery, themes and message.
The reborn Herbalist, on the other hand, has a quest to give to Somewhat. Not a vision-smoke quest, an actual quest that matches Somewhat's purpose.
I love the Somewhat story so much, legit could make a great children's book series or cute casual adventure life game thing. Also pretty sure I saw a Neo-Cat with the Herbalist.
I am so intrigued!!!!
Maybe that was on Beacon's second-year curriculum.
From what I know of the novels it was not.

Also adored this episode, and loved the code word, and general look into their head-spaces as well as Ruby's new cult.

Thanks for covering these, oh and as an aside, I'd been suspicious sine the epilogue that Raven had been 'around' since Yang fell into the Ever After or at least not long after that. She likely sensed her 'die' and it caused a crisis, hence Qrow being so unsurprised with her arrival.
Little shorts, even semi-animated like they were here, giving the little character moments they can't afford to squeeze into the show proper.
Gosh this, I'd love this so much.
 
Be funny if this shop was what she was talking about with that line.
Probably retroactively true.

the encouragement to not give up hope resonates still.
This is about the most thematic possible thing in the face of the indefinite hiatus before an uncertain V10.

Also pretty sure I saw a Neo-Cat with the Herbalist.
I don't recall that, got a pic?
This cat off to the left of the center has a sort of Neo like color scheme, but that could be me making connections where there aren't any.
H*ck if I know. I can't even tell that they're a cat!
 
It's been a fun ride, with the ups & downs, and I hope that things will continue once things get settled with Viz. I'm hopeful that the series can reach a high point again.
 
Fic Recs: Instant Sunshine, Just Add Sunshine
So what have I been doing? Well, I have been starting to watch RWBY Chibi like I promised. I have also fallen down a rabbit hole of Miraculous Ladybug fixfics. What even is my life right now. Going by prior history, there's a small-but-not-zero chance that in a few years' time I'll be back in a Let's Watch thread trying to pretend I don't know three-quarters of the plot twists over there.

But anyway, RWBY fic.
  • The Gang Kidnaps A Child (Kablob, mylordshesacactus): A rec I pass on from the SV thread. This time it's the entirety of Team STRQ who find and object to Cinder's backstory.
  • nose kisses and soft paws (paponela): One of those short fluffy modern AUs. In which Blake doesn't have a weapon, she has a cat, to whom Yang needed to pay more attention.
  • this will be (ProfessorSpork): Describes itself as "the Wedding DJ Yang + Seamonkeys Bridesmaid Blake meet cute AU the world has clearly been clamoring for". It's a very handy palate-cleanser.
  • Red Sky At Night (GreatBlueHeron50): In which Penny was hacked by Watts a long time ago, which sucks. Until it really doesn't.
  • Broadcasting Live from Amity Arena... (chaoticevilspacewitch): It would be remiss of me not to mention how I found out about the plug being pulled on Rooster Teeth.
  • The Face of the Enemy (BryonNightshade): "Spiritual successor" to The Salvation of James Ironwood, which I have recommended before. The story of a new trainee class at Atlas Academy going on a field trip to that spot Atlas has bombed every two hours for decades (and probably always will), because sometimes you really do have to see the thing in order to understand it.
  • Familiar (Deferonz): Team RWBY were bogged down in the early Ever After a lot longer, and long story short the Rusted Knight went and Ascended during that time. So now his spitting image with antlers is following them around...
So yeah, that was the animated Tier 1 canon. Soon, chibi.
 
Back
Top