IWIW RWBY

Sometimes the resistance against government oppression is actually just a crazy guy who needs to touch grass. Sadly, Mantle and Atlas have ice.
Even if he's right, would you trust his take out of hand given how he acts about it? It's evidence, but he is questionable.
Also, little detail, I'm convinced Watts was from Mantle originally. The way he talks about the people in charge up in Atlas never paying attention to Mantle sounds like its from personal experience.
He got up there from his own ability, but if there was someone more capable he might see them getting more as being about his origins, and he grew to resent both?
 
Most of all, for me at least, this was the point I became convinced that Watts was the best minion Salem could have gotten. More than Cinder, more than Hazel, more than even Tyrian. He designed the security for Mantle, and at this point, I became convinced he was actually rather high ranking in Atlas's R&D arm. The reason Salem's been able to predict Ironwood so well she's been playing him like a kazoo, and built her plan around the actions she knew he'd take? This bastard right here. He put together a profile of James Ironwood that found every structural weakness. Not even Lionheart had enough regular contact for that.

Also, little detail, I'm convinced Watts was from Mantle originally. The way he talks about the people in charge up in Atlas never paying attention to Mantle sounds like its from personal experience.
I'm not so sure about that, but my evidence is in later episodes, so I'll wait till then
 
Honestly there's a rather more fundamental issue to resorting to the military in the way that Ironwood wants to that someone in the room probably should have started thinking of a way to bring up; Ironwood's plan assumes that Salem can be killed.

Now there's an argument to be made against just blurting that out, probably better to try and a way to word it that doesn't make him just give up on the idea of being able to oppose her at all when he's leader of the only army non-Grimm army in the world, but it is an issue that'll render the entire plan pointless if it's not changed to address that.
 
And threatens the mooks. Come on Winter, you can be better than that. You don't NEED to threaten them, for that matter.
To be fair, how would you feel if you saw these two jackboots somewhere under your command not questioning the ill-founded arrest of your sister.

While cutting allies in Vale, Mistral and Vacuo out of the loop. Remember, he abandoned Lionheart at the start of V5. Yes, WE know Lionheart was a traitor, but Ironwood had no evidence of it. So it feels less like he wanted people he could trust... and more people that answered to him in the know. Especially when you remember how he ran to the vale council in V2 and backstabbed Oz then to take control of security for the festival.
On the one hand, some problems could have been avoided if a couple of Lionheart's subrodinates had been read in. On the other hand, it's been left to Lionheart/Ironwood to read them in.

He thinks EVERYTHING needs a military solution. Best intentions, road to hell and all that...
I'd go with he has a hammer and sees nails, myself.

To quote a line from the Amity Arena game, about an in-universe source claiming Ironwood would be the one to save all the kingdoms.

"Menagerie? What about it?"
Watch me forget about Menagerie :/

Yup, truly, Atlas is above and beyond all the other Academies in every way. Or just advertises itself as such.
Truly Atlas is above and beyond all other Kingdoms, too. In multiple senses.

How pathetically evil do you have to be to cause potentially fatal traffic accidents because you couldn't be bothered waiting to cross, or looking both ways before crossing the street, but fuck with traffic systems to protect you instead?
This pathetically evil! I'm a perennial pedestrian - I don't even drive - and I'm still frustrated by the ego on this guy.

Honestly there's a rather more fundamental issue to resorting to the military in the way that Ironwood wants to that someone in the room probably should have started thinking of a way to bring up; Ironwood's plan assumes that Salem can be killed.

Now there's an argument to be made against just blurting that out, probably better to try and a way to word it that doesn't make him just give up on the idea of being able to oppose her at all when he's leader of the only army non-Grimm army in the world, but it is an issue that'll render the entire plan pointless if it's not changed to address that.
While Ironwood led with the assumption that Salem could be destroyed, the plan - to the extent we heard it - doesn't get as far as needing to use that assumption. It's really kind of 'tell everybody about Salem, ???, profit'. The destruction presumably comes later.
 
V07C03 Ace Operatives

V07C03 Ace Operatives


The last character to have their third appearance named after them was Ruby.

Ironwood's command centre is in fact the Atlas Academy headmaster's office.

First, a montage:
  • Three aircraft fly towards ...somewhere as somebody narrates the start of a mission briefing.
  • One of the Ace Ops, presumably their leader, is briefing. Qrow, Ruby, and Jaune are in attendance as he tells them about this abandoned Dust mine where they'll be clearing out the Grimm to set up the Amity launch site. The Dust still on-site will help with that.
  • Pietro takes Teams RWBY and ALN (that's JNR) to get their upgraded weapons. We don't see any of the weapons yet.
  • Ace Ops guy continues that the tundra around the mine is clear (the three aircraft overfly it), but an old and smart Geist - remember those !!fun!! things? - has rooted into the mine and needs special attention, which they will be providing.
  • Teams RWBY and ALN unbox their upgraded weapons. We still don't see the weapons, but the wielders look impressed.
  • Briefing: The mine is a real maze, so they'll have to split up to deny the Geist escape options. What could go wrong?
  • Jaune sadly considers where he's going to fit the fragment of red sash he still carries with him to his loadout.
  • As narrating Ace Ops guy closes the briefing by saying he's trusting them, Team RWBY lock and load. Oscar appears at the door and asks for Ruby.
Now here's Team RWBY, with new outfits, ready to airdrop.

And here come the lyrics!

Team RWBY all show off on the way down. So do two of the Ace Ops, so I can't blame them too much.

On a second aircraft, two more Ace Ops airdrop, followed by Team ALN who also have new outfits. Who did Jaune's hairstyling, and have they been fired? (In-universe, I mean.) They are a little insulted by one of their handlers saying that maybe they won't get themselves killed. Also, lookit that, Jaune finally has a landing strategy, courtesy of hardlight extensions to his shield.

Ace Ops Leader, having presumably dropped from the third aircraft along with Qrow, reports that everything's clear right now. Blake stows her fancy new scroll (which they all have), then realises Yang's staring at her new haircut. They flirt awkwardly. "I did not sign up to be a babysitter," complains one of their handlers. Mood.

Ruby thinks it's freezing, giving Weiss (who isn't bothered) an excuse to exposit on how cold it gets. Apparently Ruby didn't think about that beforehand, because Ruby and Yang's new outfits (but particularly Ruby's) are more suited for less arctic temperatures and neither of them thought to wear a coat or anything. Blake has seriously a lot of zippers, allowing her to adjust her outfit's coverage depending on temperature, and Weiss made nearly-as-smart choices and grew up here. Oscar is not joining this mission because he has neither new outfit nor weapon upgrades.

Speaking of Oscar, as the two Ace Ops range out ahead of Team RWBY, Yang brings up how they haven't told Ironwood about why Ozpin actually hid (or Ozma's history), they're not planning to, and she doesn't feel great about that. Ruby says they'll tell Ironwood later, once they've recovered from the shock of their entry to Atlas. Blake agrees: "The general's heart seems to be in the right place, but that doesn't mean we should trust him yet." I get it, I really do, but this still feels like exactly how they got to Ozpin hiding but from the other side. Weiss signs off on waiting as well, so Yang folds, but not without asking what Oscar's opinion was.

Flashback to Ruby giving Ozpin Knowledge for safekeeping, where Oscar raises the same point as I've been.



We're not yet going to find out what Oscar's opinion was, apparently. Here's Qrow and handler walking down a small mine tunnel. Perhaps that's what was in the titles, rather than a subway? Anyway, Qrow says it's been a while since he worked non-solo in the field, and longer since he had a team. "I think that's a shame," says his handler, to which Qrow trips over and has to be caught lest he slide down the inclined tunnel face-first.

Team ALN and their handlers are walking along the "ice tunnels". Nora compliments Ren's new outfit, and is very insulted when he says they should focus on the mission. Jaune tries to salve it but he never had a hope.

Team RWBY and their handlers, going via the main entrance, have discovered that it's caved in. Like, all the way in. To make matters worse, Blake has just realised she's in a Dust mine that was shuttered because of a massive safety failure. I can't rule out that this is precisely where, when, and how Ilia's parents died. One of their handlers (faunus himself, I'm pretty sure) comes to make the conversation between Blake and Weiss about it a bit more fraught, then painfully segues into how they've found a way past that they need Blake to squeeze through to scope out the other side.

It looks like one of the professionals could have fit, but perhaps we're not seeing the narrowest part. Anyway, Blake confirms that there's no exposed Dust near the other side. They call her back so they can start blasting through. She can't return because the Geist has just dropped on her. They blast through immediately. The Geist decides it has better places to be and leaves. Yang encourages pursuit, but is stymied by a new and interesting Grimm type emerging from the ground. She punches it. It calls its friends in.

Fight scene! The first interesting thing to happen is Ruby ramming one with her Semblance on. The second is Yang showing off a new weapon feature: she can now choose to fire sticky micro-grenades to detonate later.

One of RWBY's handlers (the known faunus) wields a carbine that turns into a boomerang. What appears to be his Semblance is he can point at something and tell it to stay, and for the duration, it does. I might scream if he's a dog faunus. His partner for the mission arrives and punches the stayed Grimm right out before calling in that they found the Geist. Earlier, before the fight with these "Centinels", would have been a good time for that call.

Team ALN's handlers get that call and rush towards the scene, followed by Team ALN. This seems a poor idea when more Centinels might appear from anywhere. More Centinels do appear, but only from the rock that the ice tunnel transitions into, which suggests that they won't burrow through ice and therefore the idea wasn't as bad as it looked. Anyway, Jaune's shield has gravity pulses to knock things away, and Ren's pistols can now launch their sharpened bits on cables. No word on Nora's weapon upgrades yet, if any. Their handlers, who stopped themselves on the ice rather than rushing into a fight, seem a bit unimpressed by Team ALN rushing into a fight.

Ruby doesn't seem too sad about having the last kill stolen by one of her handlers, having found a kindred spirit of speed Semblance. They might have gotten into an argument about who's faster if not for leadership calling in that they've met the Geist. Qrow shoots at the thing, as his handler orders everyone to converge, then tries to hook it with his weapon - a fishing rod, seriously? This doesn't work, because the fleeing Geist goes incorporeal at the very ends of its tendrils to let the hook pass through, then possesses a really big ice crystal (or icy rock or something) and pulls all the like crystals embedded in the walls to make a fight of it.

Qrow's handler rushes in with his telescoping fishing rod, fulfilling Einstein's reputed definition of insanity. Qrow calls him back just in time to avoid the collapse of a roof frame - an icy rock was stuck under one of its supports. This throws up a dust cloud, which the now-embodied Geist uses to escape. ...Okay, that's left a big hole in the floor that goes down a long way. I thought this guy was a professional.

This is the context in which they have a talk about Qrow's Semblance. Qrow is absolutely floored to hear that this guy's is good luck.

Anyway, the Geist is heading for "the heart of the mine", a massive (in all three dimensions) open chamber with Dust crystals all over its walls. I'm pretty sure that's not how mines work, especially those powered by indentured labour instead of big machines. I think it isn't helping Nora's mood that she has hammer envy of one of Team ALN's handlers.

Team RWBY arrive at the same place, and one of their handlers instructs everybody to be careful, because there's a lot of Dust in here that wants to be free, violently. Setting it off could ruin the launch site. And kill them all, adds an irritated co-worker.

"I thought the target was supposed to be in here," says Nora. It is only when the target makes noise in response to this that folks look up and finds it. Nobody ever looks up.

Now things are gonna get real fun, because, as Ruby says, "It added Dust to its body? How are we supposed to-". The Ace Ops engage.

The Ace Ops are taking turns calling each other's names so we know them. With Team ALN were Vine (Semblance: extending arms, Elastigirl-style) and Elm (pinning her feet in place?). With Team RWBY were Marrow (he is a dog faunus, contemplates screaming, the names) and Harriet (sprinting good, with the aid of electricity or something). They, and their late-arriving leader, proceed to utterly dismantle the Geist without letting any of the Dust chunks it loses hit the floor and blow them all to Brothers come. Shoutout to said leader for managing to hook the Geist's mask and pull the thing right out of its summoned body, allowing Harriet to come and uppercut it to death.

Ruby then beats Harriet to catching the last Dust chunk. Harriet reckons Ruby's Semblance isn't a pure speed Semblance, based on her (Harriet's) experience with those. Team WBY have a little in-joke about Ruby's eyes.

The Ace Ops leader, finally named on screen as Clover (the naaaaames), reckons the chunk he caught was talent rather than Semblance. Regardless, he declares mission complete.



Mr Tinfoil is dropped off nowhere-in-particular in Mantle. He enters an alley near where the police van left him. Unfortunately for him (and everybody, but particularly him), this alley contains Tyrian.



Next time: Missions!
 
Missed this one in the last chapter

An utterly dark shape dramatically rises into the view of another camera. Presumably we'll find out about that later.

That's blood sweeping across the pavement. Tyrian is doing his second favorite thing in the world! (Top favorite is receiving praise from Salem)

Who did Jaune's hairstyling, and have they been fired?

The banana hair has been considerably mocked in FNDM since first appearing.

Team RWBY all show off on the way down.

Also, take note of the repair to Blakes weapon. The writers and animators made reference to Kintsugi, a japanese art of repairing damaged objects with gold or similar metals. *Looks at Yang* They're not bothering with being subtle anymore.

then realises Yang's staring at her new haircut. They flirt awkwardly.

SEE?!

I get it, I really do, but this still feels like exactly how they got to Ozpin hiding but from the other side.

And so you see how Oz feel into the trap of not trusting anyone over time.

Nora compliments Ren's new outfit, and is very insulted when he says they should focus on the mission.
Yeah, Ren is not in the mood for banter at this point.

I can't rule out that this is precisely where, when, and how Ilia's parents died.

Never confirmed or denied either way, but even in Atlas, there can only be so many mines so lax on safety standards they had to be shut down.

The second is Yang showing off a new weapon feature: she can now choose to fire sticky micro-grenades to detonate later.

Because sometimes, she needs to stick as many bomblets as possible onto one thing to blow it all up at once!

I might scream if he's a dog faunus.

*Covers ears in preparation*

Semblances are an expression of the soul. What does that say about the shit Marrow's seen in his life?

a fishing rod, seriously?

Seriously. It doesn't even have a gun or a blade. Clovers entire fighting style is to incapacitate something, and have the big guns hit it.

Qrow is absolutely floored to hear that this guy's is good luck.

Here's an interesting thought. Qrow is a poor kid from a bandit tribe, who was treated as the guy to blame for things going wrong long before he went to Beacon. Clover is from the shining city in the sky, celebrated for things going right around him.

Are their semblances specifically good and bad luck, or is that a matter of perspective? After all, bad luck happening to Qrows opponents is good luck for him, and if Clover accidentally gave his enemy good luck in a fight...

I think it isn't helping Nora's mood that she has hammer envy of one of Team ALN's handlers.

This is Clovers Big Gun.

(Semblance: extending arms, Elastigirl-style

I go with 'Wacky arm flailing inflatable tube man!' personally.

(pinning her feet in place?)

When she has a strong footing, she is utterly immovable.

reckons the chunk he caught was talent rather than Semblance

I'll... leave my opinion on that one until later...

What I will say is that personally, this fight established that the Ace Ops aren't as far beyond our heroes in terms of capabilities as one might have expected. Yes, they took down a geist. RNJR did that in V4, and Jaune wasn't even armed. More than that, their maneuvers... Clover shouts out a name, and one of them leaps in to show off. Impressive looking, but not really anything we haven't seen before. Hell, RWBY did that with team combos in V2 that had them combining attacks.

Mr Tinfoil is dropped off nowhere-in-particular in Mantle. He enters an alley near where the police van left him. Unfortunately for him (and everybody, but particularly him), this alley contains Tyrian.

Time for more of Tyrians second favorite thing!
 
Last edited:
Who did Jaune's hairstyling, and have they been fired? (In-universe, I mean.)
The banana hair has been considerably mocked in FNDM since first appearing.

Fully my own opinion here, but what I personally hate the most is how it adjusts Jaune's look just enough that he ends up reminding me of Cardin whenever I see him. And while I won't deny having issues with Jaune's role in the past, come on, the boy doesn't deserve That.

I might scream if he's a dog faunus.

Someone, I have no idea who in universe, decided to name his weapon Fetch too.
 
That's blood sweeping across the pavement.
(starts humming V3 theme, quickly reconsiders)

Seriously. It doesn't even have a gun or a blade. Clovers entire fighting style is to incapacitate something, and have the big guns hit it.
...does it... does it at least glow funny colours?

Here's an interesting thought. Qrow is a poor kid from a bandit tribe, who was treated as the guy to blame for things going wrong long before he went to Beacon. Clover is from the shining city in the sky, celebrated for things going right around him.

Are their semblances specifically good and bad luck, or is that a matter of perspective? After all, bad luck happening to Qrows opponents is good luck for him, and if Clover accidentally gave his enemy good luck in a fight...
See, this is the kind of insight I would never have had and I think I'm better off for hearing someone else have. Here we have two mirror-image characters in every respect: Qrow is (was?) a Chaotic Good solo covert operative who thinks he brings bad luck to others, Clover is the Lawful (TBD) leader of an oversized overt ops team who thinks he brings good luck to himself.

What I will say is that personally, this fight established that the Ace Ops aren't as far beyond our heroes in terms of capabilities as one might have expected. Yes, they took down a geist. RNJR did that in V4, and Jaune wasn't even armed. More than that, their maneuvers... Clover shouts out a name, and one of them leaps in to show off. Impressive looking, but not really anything we haven't seen before. Hell, RWBY did that with team combos in V2 that had them combining attacks.
On the one hand, all of that. On the other hand, Team RNJR made missteps like lighting its tree arm on fire, and didn't have to play the-floor-is-lava with its debris. The Ace Ops have a similar execution score, but I'd raise the degree-of-difficulty for that context (and then lower it a bit for being oversized, but still).

Fully my own opinion here, but what I personally hate the most is how it adjusts Jaune's look just enough that he ends up reminding me of Cardin whenever I see him. And while I won't deny having issues with Jaune's role in the past, come on, the boy doesn't deserve That.
I'd say he now looks concerningly like Taiyang.

Someone, I have no idea who in universe, decided to name his weapon Fetch too.
...I'll trade Jaune's hairstylist back for whoever's idea that was.
 
V07C04 Pomp and Circumstance

V07C04 Pomp and Circumstance


Now that I know what to look for, Jaune's hardlight shield is shown off in the titles, as his team and the Ace Ops fight exactly that Geist. Also Weiss and Blake were definitely fighting Centinels in a mine tunnel rather than any sort of subway.

Some trucks drive out to somewhere in the middle of the tundra. I think it's the mine, because Amity Colosseum is following them. A couple of random folks with binoculars are taken aback as Amity's huge shadow passes over them.

It is the mine. As the trucks arrive, the Ace Ops and Qrow emerge from the mine. I'm not sure when Teams RWBY or ALN got out of the mine, but they're starstruck, probably by Amity.

Okay, maybe Jaune is starstruck by the Ace Ops. I think he's embarrassing himself in their professional context.

Okay, maybe it's not exactly the professional context I thought it was. ...Or maybe Marrow is just at the bottom of the social pecking order. I shouldn't jump straight to assuming racism, I really shouldn't. (Fun fact: Totem poles actually had the most important totems at the bottom.)

Nora now sees Elm, the Ace Op with the hammer, as awesome. Nora. Nora no. (Nora yes...)

And here we see a fundamental difference in outlook between Team RWBY and the Ace Ops. The former see intra-team friendships as the foundation of the team. The latter see the team as a purely professional entity, no friendships required or allowed. Given all of the show's messaging so far, I can confidently say that the former have the right of it.

Then Team WBY aren't at all interested in exploring Atlas like Ruby is. Oh Ruby.

Qrow manages to give Ruby and Jaune about two seconds of warning before Ironwood (who arrived on a truck, I presume) calls for the three of them. Ironwood's voice here sounds exceptionally like it was recorded indoors, which is a somewhat unavoidable reality of production, but this particular clip moreso, so it jars exceptionally terribly with the animated snowy tundra.

Ironwood instructs Clover, for presumably his next mission, to "be subtle... and don't take Marrow". Must not assume racism... Anyway, with Clover joining the Ace Ops on their flight out, Ironwood turns to Qrow's question and explains that Mr Tinfoil (real name Forest) is just the latest of the public opposition to Ironwood who's now been found dead. Jaune recognises the guy. (Ruby is saddened to think she was listening to a man who was about to die.) Ironwood is pretty sure he's being framed - successfully, given tensions in Mantle. Jaune points out Ironwood started the pattern by embargoing Dust exports. Ironwood is naturally slightly irritated, but concedes the point.

Ironwood's speech about his belief in the usefulness (maybe even better natures) of Teams RWBY and ALPN is somewhat interrupted by the arrival of everybody's least favourite father by personal air transport. Jacques, being Jacques, is real mad about the expropriation of the private property that he didn't care about yesterday or for years before that. Ironwood informs him that contrary to his (Jacques') assumptions, the Atlas Council already knows, and furthermore no Council vote occurred because it's a "classified military operation". Welcome back, my conflicted feelings about these two guys, accompanied by my fresh new negative feelings about the governance of Atlas.

Jacques is apparently a candidate in upcoming elections to the Atlas Council, which is its own burning bad thing for everyone else. Even if somebody there needs to push back a bit on Ironwood and I trust Jacques to do that, I don't trust Jacques to do anything else associated with the position, on top of my usual antipathy to the worst of big business seizing the means of government.

Ironwood tells Jacques he shouldn't expect to be able to land here again. Jacques fumes about his soon-to-be-ended lack of hard political power before cutting himself off when he sees Weiss. (dons fireproof suit)

Suffice to say that Jacques continues to Jacques - at first ramping up towards physically abusive, then when he remembers Ironwood's there, ramps down to merely emotionally abusive. H*ck off, we just got rid of Adam.

Jacques isn't actually 100% mad about the private property he just remembered, he just reckons Ironwood has "personally hand[ed] me the noose to hang you", which I both hope and don't is an electoral metaphor. He then manages to restrain himself from flipping his lid again when Weiss calls Team RWBY her "family". Go Weiss!

Jacques leaves to do whatever slimy things he does when we're not watching him. His shuttle is replaced by a truck containing Winter, who disputes that she "missed" Jacques, before Team RWBY are blown off their feet by the sudden arrival of Penny. "(banner reading "CONGRATULATIONS!") Surprise! ... ...uh, did we not start yet?" They did not.



They start, which involves the eleven of them in the center of Amity's arena as Ironwood gives a speech about everything Teams RWBY and ALN have already done. It's kind of a lot.

Penny, who has been struggling to contain her excitement the entire time, is eventually cued to walk in front of the line of former Beacon students and mark an electronic clipboard entry for each of them. Each, in turn, pulls their Scroll to see their Hunter license has been amended from student to full. As far as Ironwood (an Academy headmaster in addition to everything else) was concerned, this mission was their final exam, and they passed.

Ironwood is not great at ending speeches, and apparently he used to be worse. Relatable. (I vaguely remember his very deflating speech in V03C10.)

Yang had forgotten that graduation was even her goal. Oof. Blake had merely given up hope of it. Apropos of having made it there somehow, some music (a full hour of it):


Ironwood mentioned cake, and later there actually is cake. Penny slices it with her weapons. Then Yang does the old detaching-arm prank on her - Penny may herself be mechanical, but she knows that biologicals aren't normally capable of that.

Away from the festivities, Ruby and Qrow talk about her doubts. (Really? Go eat some cake, you two!) Ruby is particularly doubtful about whether she's turning out like Ozpin with regard to secret-keeping. Qrow says she's not, she's just verifying before she trusts. Next doubt is whether she's learned much since Beacon; Qrow's wisdom is that that doubt sticks around. He says Summer (by name) would be proud of her, leading Ruby to ask if Summer's last mission - that she never came back from - was also an Ozpin secret. Qrow is pretty sure not - Ozpin seemed to know as little as they did. Of course, that's not a guarantee.
"What do you think she would have done if she learned the truth about Salem, that she can't be destroyed?"

"Pressed on, I think. Like you. She was always the best of us."

Yang calls Ruby over to check out a mission board. "It's an app now?!" Mood, Ruby. Ruby Rubies all over the prospect of unrestricted missions (V02C08 flashbacks intensify). This, and her inadvertently shaking Penny about (as Elm [I think] did to Ruby - circle of life), are interrupted only by the arrival of Elm, Vine, and Marrow, the latter of whom pronounces the new graduates to be "fresh meat", a joke that Vine and Ren completely miss. (Wait, when did they get back?)

The newly arrived Ace Ops are disappointed that the new graduates are already looking for missions elsewhere, Vine saying that the real mission here is the Amity launch. Ren has to remind him that they can continue to train and improve their skills in the meantime.

Marrow points out a high-priority mission. Everybody puts their hand up. Marrow explains the mission as escorting some kids in Mantle to preschool - no danger, but fretting parents attract Grimm. Jaune is the last to put his hand down and gets stuck with it. Marrow doesn't remember Jaune's name.

Elm, being Elm, shoves Marrow out of the way and reads off the next high-priority mission, dramatically. It's considerably more dangerous, and therefore attractive. Everybody laughs at Jaune when he protests. Being Jaune is suffering, just like old times.



Jacques lurks in his main study, drinking in self-isolation. He's not happy when Whitley tells him he has a visitor, but it wasn't Whitley's fault - Watts, being Watts, just went ahead and let himself in. Watts proceeds to creep about the study. Only on Jacques' direct order does Whitley leave and shut the door.

Watts, says Jacques, is supposed to be dead. "That is what I wanted people to think," Watts replies, before offering Jacques a yet-unspecified way to win election to the Council without having to keep Mantle on side. Probably election interference. (sighs)



Next time: Tension.
 
Or maybe Marrow is just at the bottom of the social pecking order.

He's the new guy. It came up last ep, if I remember right. Ah, military hazing...

And here we see a fundamental difference in outlook between Team RWBY and the Ace Ops. The former see intra-team friendships as the foundation of the team. The latter see the team as a purely professional entity, no friendships required or allowed. Given all of the show's messaging so far, I can confidently say that the former have the right of it.

Ah military squad design... This ties back to a thought I originally had in V2, when Ironwood was showing off his latest generation of mecha mooks (proudly built by the SDC!) in that James, and the Atlas military in particular, would become not an outright enemy (THANKS CORDOVIN), but a rival in terms of ideals. Mass produced drones, expendable but individually weak robots, and a very uniform style. This shows up again here with the Ace Ops, with the way all their outfits are slightly customized uniforms, the way they have a 'strictly professional working relationship' (that has already displayed some toxic elements with the Marrow hazing), and so on. It never comes up directly in the show itself, only in behind the scenes material, but even their weapons show this, bearing the logo of atlas armory, being all made in-house as opposed to the huntsman making them themselves, although at least they still have considerable customisation to take advantage of their skills and sembelence.

Must not assume racism...

New guy syndrome again. And well, look at him in the background talking to a guard. Not the most subtle boy, our Marrow. Mind you, that could be applied to a number of the Ace Ops. Very much a team designed to be noticed.

Ironwood is pretty sure he's being framed - successfully, given tensions in Mantle

Lets be fair, Tyrian and Watts are just throwing matches at the pile of logs James has been pouring petrol on.

Jaune points out Ironwood started the pattern by embargoing Dust exports. Ironwood is naturally slightly irritated, but concedes the point.

And there's the petrol :)

Ironwood informs him that contrary to his (Jacques') assumptions, the Atlas Council already knows, and furthermore no Council vote occurred because it's a "classified military operation". Welcome back, my conflicted feelings about these two guys, accompanied by my fresh new negative feelings about the governance of Atlas.

Those two council seats are REALLY useful to James. Common theory is that's the meeting he was complaining about attending in ep 2, and that there was no vote because the Headmaster and General of the Military both agreed it was a classified military operation. Wait, that's the same person? Oh dear...

Seriously, I don't know who it was who put James in both positions, be it Oz using connections (The previous headmaster reccomending James perhaps?) or the Atlas Council itself, but that's the sort of shit you don't do. EVER. It makes problems like this...

Suffice to say that Jacques continues to Jacques - at first ramping up towards physically abusive, then when he remembers Ironwood's there, ramps down to merely emotionally abusive.

Asshole gotta be a Jacqueass.

Team RWBY are blown off their feet by the sudden arrival of Penny. "(banner reading "CONGRATULATIONS!") Surprise! ... ...uh, did we not start yet?" They did not.

Also, we now know Penny has holographic projectors.

For added laughs, pause during impact and check out the flailing bodies. The animators had FUN.

Penny, who has been struggling to contain her excitement the entire time,

*bounce bounce Bounce BOUNCE BOUNCE*

Also, something you'll see whenever Penny and Winter are on screen together. Winter letting her guard down the way she does for Weiss sometimes.

Ironwood is not great at ending speeches, and apparently he used to be worse. Relatable

I love how AWKWARD James gets in quiet moments like this. Reminds me, oddly enough, of Optimus Prime in transformers cyberverse.

Yang had forgotten that graduation was even her goal. Oof. Blake had merely given up hope of it.

Let's face it, they've had a lot happen since the last time they were in a classroom.

Ironwood mentioned cake, and later there actually is cake.

Also, Yang and Blake posing together for a photo. That shot ended up being one of the better memes from this volume.

Next doubt is whether she's learned much since Beacon; Qrow's wisdom is that that doubt sticks around.

The people who stop asking themselves questions like that are the ones you should worry about.

The newly arrived Ace Ops are disappointed that the new graduates are already looking for missions elsewhere, Vine saying that the real mission here is the Amity launch.

Frankly Ace Ops, it seems they have a better work ethic than you. And unless RWBY suddenly became engineers, probably best to leave the launch to the people that can do it and direct their skills where they'll be useful

escorting some kids in Mantle to preschool - no danger, but fretting parents attract Grimm.

Given how we've already seen grimm breach the walls in mantle, that fretting is kind of valid, and also ensures Huntsmen are in the right spot when shit goes wrong. But also, yes, feel free to laugh at Jaune. This is far less painful than some of his suffering.

He's not happy when Whitley tells him he has a visitor,

Note Whitleys voice and body language here. I don't think our boy is enjoying being Jacqueass heir as much as he hoped. And why is he showing the visitor in, don't you have people for that?

Watts, being Watts, just went ahead and let himself in.

And so, for all the 'improvements' to security, Salems people were able to make it onto the flying island. *slow clap* well done Atlas military, good fucking job.

Watts, says Jacques, is supposed to be dead.

You just let a dead man walk around your city without trouble!

Also, here we see further proof Watts was high up in Atlas society.
 
Last edited:
Something I've heard to justify Atlas's flaws is that society itself in Remnant is surprisingly young, by that given the old system of Monarchy were overthrown less than a century ago that means many cracks in present in the system exist that if pressure if applied to could seriously damage a kingdom.

Could be a case of Atlas's military or headmaster always had bigger say than the rest of council but during the early post great war years viewed as a best a minor issue. However given the rise of the white fang for example gave a excuse to both get more authority but far more importantly act on it.
 
Something I've heard to justify Atlas's flaws is that society itself in Remnant is surprisingly young, by that given the old system of Monarchy were overthrown less than a century ago that means many cracks in present in the system exist that if pressure if applied to could seriously damage a kingdom.

Could be a case of Atlas's military or headmaster always had bigger say than the rest of council but during the early post great war years viewed as a best a minor issue. However given the rise of the white fang for example gave a excuse to both get more authority but far more importantly act on it.
Democracy being weak is an explanation for why things fall apart and slide into dictatorship, not a justification.
 
Oz, in his earlier life, set up the CCTSs failure point to encourage cooperation between the kingdoms.
I maintain that this is a misconception. The actual way he narrates that World of Remnant episode, it seems more like a legitimate technological limitation that he's finding a poetic silver lining in.
Like, the man is not omnipotent. If there was some kind of intentional failure point coded in, surely one of the hundreds of CCT technicians over the past decades would have noticed it, gone "what the hell, get rid of that", and done so? Heck, is there even textual support Oz was involved with the creation of the system in any way beyond the greater causal relation of ending the Great War?

Democracy being weak is an explanation for why things fall apart and slide into dictatorship, not a justification.
It is a justification for writing things that way though, which might be partly responsible for the vocabulary confusion.
 
Ah military squad design... This ties back to a thought I originally had in V2, when Ironwood was showing off his latest generation of mecha mooks (proudly built by the SDC!) in that James, and the Atlas military in particular, would become not an outright enemy (THANKS CORDOVIN), but a rival in terms of ideals. Mass produced drones, expendable but individually weak robots, and a very uniform style. This shows up again here with the Ace Ops, with the way all their outfits are slightly customized uniforms, the way they have a 'strictly professional working relationship' (that has already displayed some toxic elements with the Marrow hazing), and so on. It never comes up directly in the show itself, only in behind the scenes material, but even their weapons show this, bearing the logo of atlas armory, being all made in-house as opposed to the huntsman making them themselves, although at least they still have considerable customisation to take advantage of their skills and sembelence.
As Clover mirrors Qrow, so the Ace Ops as a whole mirror Team RWBY+Q as a whole.

For added laughs, pause during impact and check out the flailing bodies. The animators had FUN.
(checks) Yes, yes they did.

Note Whitleys voice and body language here. I don't think our boy is enjoying being Jacqueass heir as much as he hoped. And why is he showing the visitor in, don't you have people for that?
To be fair, would anybody enjoy the visitor insisting that you in particular show them in?

And so, for all the 'improvements' to security, Salems people were able to make it onto the flying island. *slow clap* well done Atlas military, good fucking job.
The attacker can pick a location to attack where they can bring the most advantages to bear. The defender must defend everywhere, lest their inattention anywhere become an advantage for the attacker. It would only take one customs officer half-asleep on the job for ten seconds.

Something I've heard to justify Atlas's flaws is that society itself in Remnant is surprisingly young, by that given the old system of Monarchy were overthrown less than a century ago that means many cracks in present in the system exist that if pressure if applied to could seriously damage a kingdom.

Could be a case of Atlas's military or headmaster always had bigger say than the rest of council but during the early post great war years viewed as a best a minor issue. However given the rise of the white fang for example gave a excuse to both get more authority but far more importantly act on it.
Democracy being weak is an explanation for why things fall apart and slide into dictatorship, not a justification.
On the other hand, a particular implementation of democracy having exploitable flaws, especially when nobody in the world had much experience at democracy when it was designed, and nobody's been bothered to patch it for a while...
 
Back
Top