sainen
Elder Lich
hardly, and nothing says that the other walkers would be evil.
-
Going forward, links to content from Twitter (now X) will no longer be embedded. Pre-existing links should not be affected.
Ignition (MTG/Multicross, Planeswalker PC)
- Thread starter Alivaril
- Start date
-
- Tags
- fairy tail magi: the labyrinth of magic magic the gathering magical girl lyrical nanoha (magical girl) puella magi madoka magica rwby alternate universe spoilers unreliable narrator earned your happy middle feedback appreciated life slowly gets better metaknowledge is overrated never too much fire setting knowledge not required this can only end well what could possibly go wrong?
Akasha
The Only Truth
- Location
- 「̛̛́́ ͏̨҉̕͏ ͏̶̴」
sainen
Elder Lich
yes, but that just means that some of them will be hostile, with the number of potential sparks in PMMM it's hardly likely that they all would be.
Akasha
The Only Truth
- Location
- 「̛̛́́ ͏̨҉̕͏ ͏̶̴」
"Yes, but that means that only SOME Planeswalkers will be hostile, not ALL of them."
Talk about casual playthrough.
chocolote12
A Penguin Flailing Against The Keyboard Of Life.
He can see mages, not planeswalkers. Whole different kind of fish.
Kyuubey doesn't know that.
[X] Don't have the possibility of other 'walkers turning up.
--[X] But have stories / rumours / myths of them be something that can be encountered
I don't want to deal with other 'walkers. We have MTG card game for that
But I do feel like stories / rumours / myths would be interesting, and allows for the GM to also handwave in changes to universes (although already being in the past / future already allows some), although uh that WOULD make Jade feel less special about her 'walking skills.
--[X] But have stories / rumours / myths of them be something that can be encountered
I don't want to deal with other 'walkers. We have MTG card game for that
But I do feel like stories / rumours / myths would be interesting, and allows for the GM to also handwave in changes to universes (although already being in the past / future already allows some), although uh that WOULD make Jade feel less special about her 'walking skills.
sainen
Elder Lich
I would not put it passed the little Blue-Black abomination to start making Magical Boys if it meant more free energy from MtG magic.Kyuubey doesn't know that.
Worth noting that Kyubey did in fact detect our Spark igniting:
Furthermore he is actually trying to recreate that effect:
He just hasn't succeeded. The bit about Subject #1781 is more a side success in that he succeeded in replicating the 'empty' spaces in Jade's soul, making 1781 a Black mage, but not the secondary overlay, IE: spark.
notanautomaton
I've got 99 quests, I've finished one
[x] Go with the MTG statistics. Allow the existence of 'walkers other thanJade, with one out of every trillion people becoming one.
chocolote12
A Penguin Flailing Against The Keyboard Of Life.
No, he activated the empty spaces, not created them.
Adamantium9001
Sworn enemy of the dragon-tyrant
- Location
- Inside my own head
[X] Don't have the possibility of other 'walkers turning up.
--[X] But have stories / rumours / myths of them be something that can be encountered
--[X] But have stories / rumours / myths of them be something that can be encountered
- Location
- Betwixt every moment and its next
[x] Go with the MTG statistics. Allow the existence of 'walkers other than Jade, with one out of every trillion people becoming one.
First of all, just because they spark doesn't mean we will run into them for a while. Infinite universe and all that.
Second of all, the best way to nullify an enemy Planeswalker is to rip out their spark. We might as well shove that into our friends so they can travel with us.
Third of all. Just because others can Planeswalk doesn't make us less unique. We are a Super-Red-Mage-Space-Princess whereas others will simply be MGs who can planeswalk. Sure they might get access to Mana but I don't think they will develop the same way we did. If any are activated somewhere they are not familiar with and then walk away then they won't even have reliable access to Mana.
Fourth of all. It would make things more interesting. At the moment we can just walk away from places and everything pretty much resets. With enemies who can planeswalk we can have cold wars and such that span multiple planes.
Fifth of all. Planeswalker duels are fun.
First of all, just because they spark doesn't mean we will run into them for a while. Infinite universe and all that.
Second of all, the best way to nullify an enemy Planeswalker is to rip out their spark. We might as well shove that into our friends so they can travel with us.
Third of all. Just because others can Planeswalk doesn't make us less unique. We are a Super-Red-Mage-Space-Princess whereas others will simply be MGs who can planeswalk. Sure they might get access to Mana but I don't think they will develop the same way we did. If any are activated somewhere they are not familiar with and then walk away then they won't even have reliable access to Mana.
Fourth of all. It would make things more interesting. At the moment we can just walk away from places and everything pretty much resets. With enemies who can planeswalk we can have cold wars and such that span multiple planes.
Fifth of all. Planeswalker duels are fun.
[X] Don't have the possibility of other 'walkers turning up.
Hestia&theCourt
Turns out we're plural too.
- Location
- In transition
- Pronouns
- She/Her
[x] Go with the MTG statistics. Allow the existence of 'walkers other than Jade, with one out of every trillion people becoming one.
- Location
- Betwixt every moment and its next
So were the three extra counted in
Or should the count be upped to 24?
banjo2E
Has left the planet
- Location
- Mafia Town
[X] Don't have the possibility of other 'walkers turning up.
--[X] But have stories / rumours / myths of them be something that can be encountered
Let's not make the quest even more complicated than it already is. We can always add planeswalkers in later once we've actually finished the tutorial.
That said, I kinda like the idea of a scavenger hunt to find out what happened to these ancient figures with powers similar to our own.
--[X] But have stories / rumours / myths of them be something that can be encountered
Let's not make the quest even more complicated than it already is. We can always add planeswalkers in later once we've actually finished the tutorial.
That said, I kinda like the idea of a scavenger hunt to find out what happened to these ancient figures with powers similar to our own.
- Location
- Betwixt every moment and its next
Just because there can be Planesalkers doesn't mean that they are going to be thrown at us right away. We're voting for if they ever show up. Not for if they show up now.
Your Watsonian is a good argument from a statistical point of view but from an MtG point of view Planeswalkers seem randomly bump into each other far more than they statistically should.
As for your Doyalist, just because we are fine for now I like to leave the option open for more interesting adversaries in the future. Unless we come across something plane spanning I see us running out of interesting things to do.
Alivaril
On a magically-deficient journey of self-discovery
- Location
- A single human dimension
- Pronouns
- She/Her
Sorry, missed this 'til just now: Yes. When magic was revealed, that attack was pointed to as what happens when a Witch kills enough magical girls and becomes absurdly strong. Its shape, theme, and familiars were altered after the attack. The next time Jade returns, if it's within the next few months, its new appearance will be shown on most news stations and/or an easy Internet search away.
On that note, since a bunch of people are voting for "don't have them", but are fine with them cropping up later: It won't really be relevant for at least several in-game months, possibly years or decades. The other Incubators can't start experimenting until after the complete information from Kyubey reaches them. Not to mention most of the new planeswalkers are just going to get nom'd by Eldrazi.
Last edited:
TBF we're voting for 'don't show them in quest' but 'hear they exist from past events in the universe'.
Like A:TLA would have rumors of a 'walker helping one of the earlier Avatars, with the title 'Spirit Walker' or something.
If they're coming from the PMMM verse, I'd rather that no planewalkers ever show up.
What this guy said.
Most, if not all, MtG planes, from what I remember, are planet-sized at most. We are dealing with interstellar civilizations in several of the settings. I doubt we are in risk of becoming overpowered any time soon.