Green Flame Rising (Exalted vs Dresden Files)

Just out of curiosity, if we get a duration shorter than permanent can we specifically summon the same devil again for the next try?

Since the fluff from the chapter mentions them gaining names, and we might either want to retain a character or avoid letting a devil who's had access to our stuff stay in the wild.

Yes, you can also keep the charm on anyone that is still there.

Most Spirits aren't in the same plane of existence as a Yama King, under their direct rule, with self serving minds.

This is like the difference between having a friend who lives in town, and having a friend who is a deep cover spy against literal Hell.

The spirit on your phone no matter its nature could be tortured into spilling your secrets if someone got their hands on your phone.
 
Charms and Intellectus exists, I wouldnt be surprised at some point.

It has to be smart enough if we employ it, if it werent, it wouldnt be useful enough for us to make use of.

It may only be fully sapient while possessing an item, just like the spirits awakened by the original version of the charm wouldn't normally be sentient and only are when awakened.
 
Thinking about bleach baths, I wonder if throwing a few bags of ice in the bath wouod get us those extra dice for a cold environmental hazard
Ice would probably work really well with the ultra salt bath, as evidenced by the number of morons who recently filmed themselves using both to deliberately injure their hands for the purpose of getting 1 second of internet fame.
 
That's true even if we dont awaken its spirit.

Someone else could awaken it themselves and make it cough up the info.

Do many other Dresdenverse magic users have the ability to awaken object spirits though?

If there are Hungry Dead Thrashing Dragons out there they probably do, but apart from that?
 
Charms and Intellectus exists, I wouldnt be surprised at some point.

It has to be smart enough if we employ it, if it werent, it wouldnt be useful enough for us to make use of.

The Yama King of the Wicked City has dominion over the darker side of tech, he has corrupted countless city spirits commands hacker Akuma and legions of once human cyborgs. He would have better ways to spy on you with tech than using intelectus to repeatedly ask 'Has Molly Carpenter's phone blown up yet?' Especially as his attention is limited and every time he asks that question he isn't doing something else. Now could be specifically blow up something of yours than grab the devil as it slides back whence it came? Yeah, but if he is in a position to blow it up he is probably in a position to steal it or spirit trap it and no matter what kind of tech spirit it is he can use that.
 
Do many other Dresdenverse magic users have the ability to awaken object spirits though?

If there are Hungry Dead Thrashing Dragons out there they probably do, but apart from that?
There aren't any Yama Kings either in Dresden, so I am assuming at least some other spirits are able, as a staple of both WoD and Exalted to have least spirits.

Otherwise, I don't think Dresden is animistic.
 
Doesn't the charm we just took do away with the need for a node/dragon nest?
No it charges our essences that is all. You still need a node for most things, especial crafting magical stuff, you can't just half ass it and let the excellency drop part way thou crafting. And taking penalties for working underwater in deadly liquids certainly won't help.
That's true even if we dont awaken its spirit.

Someone else could awaken it themselves and make it cough up the info.
The problem is now anybody with even a spark of magical abilities can just extract the demons name, banish then and re-summon them loyal to them for a no cost way to compromising everything. This makes the charm basically useless for its intended purpose of set and forget spy networks. We can't just take over the cites camera network as anybody could notice and flip it upon us at will.
 
I feel at least some yama-kings or equivalents will be other cultures than just asian or well have different facets that aren't the asian stuff. something something faces changes. Its even kinda dresden compliant since God probably presents itself in multiple forms and definitely isn't merely a European centric thing.
There aren't any Yama Kings either in Dresden, so I am assuming at least some other spirits are able, as a staple of both WoD and Exalted to have least spirits.

Otherwise, I don't think Dresden is animistic.
I mean some of the yama kings are well gods in myths which I assume can and do exist to some extent in dresden if very limited in actions.
 
No it charges our essences that is all. You still need a node for most things, especial crafting magical stuff, you can't just half ass it and let the excellency drop part way thou crafting. And taking penalties for working underwater in deadly liquids certainly won't help.

The problem is now anybody with even a spark of magical abilities can just extract the demons name, banish then and re-summon them loyal to them for a no cost way to compromising everything. This makes the charm basically useless for its intended purpose of set and forget spy networks. We can't just take over the cites camera network as anybody could notice and flip it upon us at will.
okay easy is an overestimation of other peoples skills extracting shit from demons or even fae for their true names can be hard its not an easy thing. Its not impossible mind you its not most sane peoples go to though.
 
I feel many modern garou are less assholes and just picking up the pieces of their fucked up ancestors and dealing with their problems. Unsure how many modern Garou are really aware how fucked up their ancestors were and justify the stupid stupid genocides of other shifters.
It is and it isn't. Especially before chronicles of darkness lots of werewolves still practice some amazingly reprehensible traditions.

Like Red Talons eating human their human babies, because they are insane.

Charity: *Meaningful look about the feasibility of this argument*
This made me laugh.

The Yama King of the Wicked City has dominion over the darker side of tech, he has corrupted countless city spirits commands hacker Akuma and legions of once human cyborgs. He would have better ways to spy on you with tech than using intelectus to repeatedly ask 'Has Molly Carpenter's phone blown up yet?' Especially as his attention is limited and every time he asks that question he isn't doing something else. Now could be specifically blow up something of yours than grab the devil as it slides back whence it came? Yeah, but if he is in a position to blow it up he is probably in a position to steal it or spirit trap it and no matter what kind of tech spirit it is he can use that.
If anything we would pick up this charm as a defense against that. A phone thats possessed and under our control would be marginally harder to turn against us than one out in the wild.
 
The problem is now anybody with even a spark of magical abilities can just extract the demons name, banish then and re-summon them loyal to them for a no cost way to compromising everything. This makes the charm basically useless for its intended purpose of set and forget spy networks. We can't just take over the cites camera network as anybody could notice and flip it upon us at will.

OK... why can't they do it to Jim the New-made Phone spirit? I mean if something is network hopping no matter its origin it could be trapped. If your problem is 'demons can be subverted by a sorcerer who knows enough about magic' the same is true of all spirits
 
It is and it isn't. Especially before chronicles of darkness lots of werewolves still practice some amazingly reprehensible traditions.

Like Red Talons eating human their human babies, because they are insane.


This made me laugh.


If anything we would pick up this charm as a defense against that. A phone thats possessed and under our control would be marginally harder to turn against us than one out in the wild.
are red talons not wyrm infected?
 
No it charges our essences that is all. You still need a node for most things, especial crafting magical stuff, you can't just half ass it and let the excellency drop part way thou crafting. And taking penalties for working underwater in deadly liquids certainly won't help.

We just need the Shintai feature that can give telekinesis...

Although I'd fluff it as Diablo angels style prehensile energy wings made of green fire, that may just be me.

are red talons not wyrm infected?

Nope, very Wyld, because White Wolf.
 
Last edited:
OK... why can't they do it to Jim the New-made Phone spirit? I mean if something is network hopping no matter its origin it could be trapped. If your problem is 'demons can be subverted by a sorcerer who knows enough about magic' the same is true of all spirits
Except they can't as without the charm empowering the objects spirit, they lose their intelligence, and go back to being regular objects. You could awaken them later but they would not recall anything not on a hard drive. They don't have minds to remember things, without the charm giving them true intelligence. If they are captured and tortured to betray us the charm ends, and information security is maintained.

The demons do have minds and can recall information without the charm empowering them.
 
DF locals wouldn't even look lol.
Not for a few decades.

Its well known tech is fiddly with spooky stuff
except those with some form of intellectus that would inform them its fair to assume even those with intellectus wouldn't know in this case. Maybe mother winter does shes kind of a non factor on mortal level though.
 
Back
Top