I feel differently. What can't be done is changing the selection criteria. That's by design. What can be done is manipulating the candidate pool in order to maximize the chances of a specific viable candidate receiving the exaltation. This here is where I believe both the disagreement and misunderstanding of what I am proposing are coming from. I am not proposing we try to alter the exaltation, or mess with it. What I am proposing is that we study it (via the crown and other means) and arrange the situation so a person we approve of is the best possible candidate.1) assuming the charm effects persist and that they're interested in paying attention.
2) Nobody has managed to reliably game this algorithm if it's anything so simple as that. Literally the guy who made it couldn't pick who got them once they were loose by design.
This is one of those functionally impossible things that can't be forced with any degree of certainty unless you remake the exaltations entirely. Which has only been done with the aid of the creators of the universe.
If we take a throwaway passage in the Fair Folk book as gospel, something like this has been done to the very first Chosen:
At first, the raksha did not know why the gods of Creation
did this. They watched as scores of the most powerful gods
and elemental beings selected and separated out a fraction of
humanity based on bizarre criteria. More raksha gathered as
those gods pulled off one piece of each human's soul, changed
it intrinsically in some unfathomable way and put it back in
place. The gods gave their chosen and altered humans gifts
that interacted with Creation's Essence flows. They trained
their chosen in how to utilize those gifts, always preparing
for… some momentous event that the raksha could not
guess at. The watchers wondered for years what that event
might be before the answer came. For no reason the raksha
could name, every member of the Primordial Host (save two)
poured suddenly into their Creation. When the Primordials
arrived, the humans whom the gods had altered made war
against them.
If you want to go that way, in Graceful Wicked Masques - The Fair Folk book, the length of Creation's border is described as "an infinitely long fiber of solid reality", so there's an argument that Creation was initially infinite (a subset of the infinity that is the Wyld, which makes sense). Also, there's this part of description from the same book:Yes but i am comparing their biggest act, creation of Creation, to the mages universe. Narratively it is exactly right for its story.
It was also impossible to physically travel from Creation to the Wyld before Three Spheres Cataclysm, which implies spatial looping, or infinite size or some other manner of prevention:The raksha
watched, rapt, as more Primordials fell and others were
enslaved. They cheered again as one of the most fanatical
Primordials sacrificed a portion of itself in an attempt to
destroy Creation rather than cede it to humanity and the
gods. The chancre contracted to a size many thousands of
times smaller than its original as concepts and constructs
were eradicated, and the raksha dragged the Wyld back
into the emptiness left in its wake. When the fighting was
over, Creation was much diminished, and all but a mere
handful of the Primordials were either dead or sealed away
in a place the raksha did not know. And none of it would
have been possible without the strange, compelling power
conferred upon humanity.
We also know that Autchtonia by itself is vastly larger than modern Creation (Exalted 2E - Compass of Celestial Directions Vol. 6 -Autochthonia):Those raksha with longer attention spans stayed close
around Creation, studying the new form it had taken. They
found its center to be denser and more structurally stable,
but many of the protective layers that had once confounded
raksha intrusion had been stripped away or changed such
that they now served different purposes. Taking hold of the
shinma Nirvikalpa, which defines the principle of commu-
nication, the raksha could now attract the attention of the
human beings within Creation and lure them out toward
the fringes. So much had Creation changed that humans
who were brave or determined enough could now walk out
of Creation altogether and enter the Wyld. Their passage
carried them outward through Nirakara and undermined
the stability of their forms, which revealed to the astonished
raksha the glorious beauty of the essential nature and will
of humanity.
It stands to reason that original Creation was vaster than what Autochton made of himself and by himself.The inhabitants of the Great Maker's body call their
world Autochthonia, and themselves Autochthonians.
Autochthonia is a rough spheroid of unknown dimen-
sions; no Autochthonian has ever pierced the outer shell
of their world to attempt to measure it. The Machine
God's interior is much larger than his armored hull, in
any case; his anatomy incorporates space-folding magic
beyond the ken of any but the most erudite First Age
savants. It's enough to say that Autochthonia is vast be-
yond imagining, that entire Directions of Creation could
disappear into it without difficulty.
I am not seeing the description of the War in Dreams of the First Age or Compass of Celestial Directions Vol. 5 - Malfeas. Dreams of the First Age starts at the end of the War, and Malfeas book has this to say about it:Its scattered bits Things like dreams of the first Age and thr malfeas book.
After the gods tired of their enslavement and cre-
ated the Exalted to battle their Primordial masters, a
war unlike any other began. Countless mortals died,
and the race of the Dragon Kings was all but wiped
out. The King of the Primordials led his kind against
the gods' Chosen in battles that shook Heaven and
Earth. In the end, several Primordials lay dead. The
Black Boar That Twists the Skies—Isidoros, who had
never known defeat—now lay half dead, his blood
drowning the armies of his conquerors. Oramus,
indefinable and terrible, now was held fast, bound
in his own wings. The fetich souls of Adrián and
the Primordials' king were killed in battle or soon
after, thus changing their very natures. The other
surviving Primordials looked at their devastated
armies and the terrible wounds they had been dealt
and surrendered. Along with the Primordials, vari-
ous behemoths and those things that would become
demons were rounded up. Many were slaughtered by
the Exalted, but others were kept prisoner—their final
fate to be decided when the gods passed judgment
on their masters. And so, with the curses of the slain
Primordials still echoing in their ears, the Chosen
ended the war victorious.