Green Flame Rising (Exalted vs Dresden Files)

... Can she protect herself from being possessed? I mean, she's mortal. No magic gift. Epic willpower, yes, but no inherent magic, and no "not involved" protection. No inherent defenses against memetic hazards.
And how would say Nemisis learning that she knows about it be a problem in that case. If it takes over Mom we have much bigger problems.
 
Can Charity protect herself from being possessed in general? Yes, she has her will and her faith. Can she protect herself from being possessed by Nemesis? Molly had no idea, she barely understands how this thing works and most of what she does know is about how it thinks not how its magic works.
 
Can Charity protect herself from being possessed in general? Yes, she has her will and her faith. Can she protect herself from being possessed by Nemesis? Molly had no idea, she barely understands how this thing works and most of what she does know is about how it thinks not how its magic works.
I doubt it is something to really worry about even if dad didn't get a mission to help Molly can sense possessions and manage exorcisms Mom is about the worst possession target.
 
Can Charity protect herself from being possessed in general? Yes, she has her will and her faith. Can she protect herself from being possessed by Nemesis? Molly had no idea, she barely understands how this thing works and most of what she does know is about how it thinks not how its magic works.
What about mind reading? Is Charity likely to notice or be able to repel someone sneaking into her mind for her secrets?
 
What about mind reading? Is Charity likely to notice or be able to repel someone sneaking into her mind for her secrets?

More than most people less than a trained mind mage, but it should be kept in mind that it;s not easy to just read someone's deep thoughts and that attempting to do so with anything but the utmost skill leaves marks. There is a reason that as many mind focused warlocks as show up most of them are caught when they break the minds of their victims. The prospect of someone walking up to even a mortal, picking an old memory out of their head and just going off is, if not impossible then at least very unlikely. The best way to get someone to spill their secrets magically is compulsion, or alternatively getting them to think of the subject and reading their surface thoughts . Charity is unlikely to think about Nemesis that often and she would be hard to prompt. All that said there are plenty of supernatural beings which can controll one with a look/ a song etc.. is pretty high and as an adult and a warrior in her own right Charity does not get the same protections as say Leech. So really it depends on how you guys asses the pros and cons.

On the pros side since I have not seen this one considered, if you tell her about Nemesis odds are good she will start to get why an angel was so invested in the glowy green sun power. It is one thing to hear that Molly killed a weird sort of vampire from some weird hell and quite another to hear Michael confirm that she has the solution to a major infiltration problem.
 
More than most people less than a trained mind mage, but it should be kept in mind that it;s not easy to just read someone's deep thoughts and that attempting to do so with anything but the utmost skill leaves marks. There is a reason that as many mind focused warlocks as show up most of them are caught when they break the minds of their victims. The prospect of someone walking up to even a mortal, picking an old memory out of their head and just going off is, if not impossible then at least very unlikely. The best way to get someone to spill their secrets magically is compulsion, or alternatively getting them to think of the subject and reading their surface thoughts . Charity is unlikely to think about Nemesis that often and she would be hard to prompt. All that said there are plenty of supernatural beings which can controll one with a look/ a song etc.. is pretty high and as an adult and a warrior in her own right Charity does not get the same protections as say Leech. So really it depends on how you guys asses the pros and cons.

On the pros side since I have not seen this one considered, if you tell her about Nemesis odds are good she will start to get why an angel was so invested in the glowy green sun power. It is one thing to hear that Molly killed a weird sort of vampire from some weird hell and quite another to hear Michael confirm that she has the solution to a major infiltration problem.
I know the white councils mind defenses are on average all bad since they can't really practice the better applications. Also you know magic usually being individualized for people. So it'd be really really rare right to find good mind mages? Not to even mention becoming an expert means your gonna be hunted by wizards if they know.
 
I know the white councils mind defenses are on average all bad since they can't really practice the better applications. Also you know magic usually being individualized for people. So it'd be really really rare right to find good mind mages? Not to even mention becoming an expert means your gonna be hunted by wizards if they know.

Pretty damn rare, Corpsetaker was exceptionally good. The greatest dangers mind wise are the non-humans and again, making thralls not reading minds. It would be especially hard to enthrall Charity, given her history
 
Pretty damn rare, Corpsetaker was exceptionally good. The greatest dangers mind wise are the non-humans and again, making thralls not reading minds. It would be especially hard to enthrall Charity, given her history
yeah that makes sense also you know you probably have mind magic based supernatural out there somewhere in your notes. Thanks for the answers I appreciate it. There's no real 1 for 1 conversion with exalted, to world of darkness, to dresden files, to quest format.
 
tangentally are oneiromancers a thing here? they'd be the best for interacting with others minds without violating them.
 
Adhoc vote count started by Goldfish on Jun 6, 2023 at 6:08 PM, finished with 97 posts and 6 votes.

  • [X][All Three] Apparently the bitch Sandra Marling set me up to fall afoul of the Laws.
    -[X] Winter has rendered all my past transgressions void and now owes me two favors.
    [X] [LYDIA] That would include much of what your father did not wish to talk about to you. If you still want to know, I'll tell you though.
    -[X] If she wants to know: Exorcised Nemesis out of the Winter Lady, witnessed Nemesis Greatest Shame. (With NWS explanation)
    -[X] If she doesn't: Exorcised the Winter Lady of a possessing entity.
    [X] [MICHAEL] Exorcised Nemesis out of the Winter Lady, witnessed Nemesis Greatest Shame. Likely set some others possessed by it up to be killed by Mab. Since she didn't ask for two more exorcising. (With NWS explanation)
    [X] [CHARITY] Exorcised the Winter Lady of a possessing entity.
    [X][All]: Everything
    [X]STUNT: You sink into a cushioned chair beside Lydia with a sigh of relief and kick off your shoes, before beginning to massage speak. "Okay I have good news and unsettling news. Met Mab, met her daughter, resolved our....current dispute." You make a face, then take a pull from your soda can. "Even came out ahead a little." You meet your mother's eyes " Some of this will be public gossip by morning in Faerie, the rest will still be secret. But first, I need to give some background about what Winter does. You see, they are ...."
    [X][All Three] Apparently the bitch Sandra Marling set me up to fall afoul of the Laws.
    [X] [LYDIA] My meeting went fairly well. I no longer have any enmity from winter and the she is actually in my debt. Also had a great victory against the things beyond the outer gates. These two things might be related.
 
Though I expect the more invasive methods the white council still considers law breaking. Given the laws are not perfect and an exact science butchers as much said there are degrees but the council sure as hell isn't measuring them and looking to be lenient right? Oh also one of the fundamentals of magic is still using magic to do something still requires belief to a degree and to do something repeatedly means that you think it is a right thing to do which affects the minds of casters still right?
 
Mind magic seems like a red herring here for Charity.

As pointed out, just taking memories is actually hard to do. If a hostile actor is willing to pull the trigger on something like that why would they stop there? In terms of leverage she's worth a lot if they can get into a position to take her, and incidentally an excellent divination focus if someone wanted to play that game for information.

Her value as a target is already so high I don't think these sorts of secrets really make a difference.


On the topic of what Molly's hell is supposed to be, it's worth considering the charm description:

the King and the Kingdom: the
thousand and First hell (•••••)
The Infernal shapes her heart, soul, and Essence into the shape of a realm of her devising, featuring what- ever oddities of geography or natural law suit her nature.
System: The Infernal crafts a new Hell-realm with- in her own Exaltation. By meditating in specific cir- cumstances selected while learning this Charm (such as in perfect darkness, while covered in blood, or to the sound of screams) and making a Wits + Occult roll against a difficulty of her own Willpower (which acts as the effective Gauntlet rating for this internal
200

realm), she may disappear into her Kingdom for up to five days, making it impossible to find her. She can linger no longer, however, and must spend at least that much time in reality before visiting again. Spending five full days within the Kingdom resets the difficulty and cost of her Shintai transformation.
By paying 2 Essence while crossing over into her inner landscape, the Infernal may also bring up to a score of willing, restrained, or unconscious individuals along with her. Visitors to the Kingdom may stay for as long as they wish (indeed, they may even become permanent residents), and are free to depart whenever they desire – so long as they are able to walk to the border of the realm. While the Kingdom must be com- posed of geography which makes this possible, noth- ing stops the Infernal from importing soldiers to man guard posts, or adorning the realm with prisons, natu- ral hazards, and the like.
While within her personal Hell, the duration of the Infernal's Shintai form becomes indefinite rather than scene-length: she may wear it until she chooses to dismiss it, or until it is destroyed.
Upon learning the King and the Kingdom, any Charm the Infernal knows which consigns a being to a particular Hell may instead be used to entrap them in the Infernal's Kingdom.
The Infernal must have an Essence rating of at least 3 to purchase this Charm. Rules for creating the Kingdom can be found beginning on page 192.
Signature Effect: When the Infernal dons her Shintai form, and while that form persists, the world around her within (Essence x 500) yards warps and twists, gaining many of the features of her Kingdom. Any time the Infernal uses a stunt incorporating the features of her Kingdom, she reduces the difficulty of that action by one.
Building the Kingdom
Infernals who purchase The King and the King- dom develop a new Hell-Realm within their own Es- sence. The rules found below can be used to design the Exalt's new Hell.
The Infernal has 5 points with which to construct her Kingdom. Some options may give her more points to work with, but most will consume them. In some categories, it's possible to select multiple options so long as they're not mutually contradictory.

The hell is patterned after Yami Wan's bullshit, but it's formed of the substance of the infernal's own soul and exaltation in concert. It's located within them in the sense that it's grown into their spiritual existence.

My read is that this is supposed to be a true self willed miracle of dark creation; a mirror of the Yama Kings, but also of the primordials drawing themselves out of chaos by their own self contained power.

It looks like a horizon realm, but that's just fancy cosplay because the exaltation likes the look.

[X] Uju32
 
[X] Uju32

Bearing your heart openly gives you a shield firmer than steel.
 
Last edited:
[X] Uju32

I don't think telling Charity everything here is a problem.
It might make her a little bit more of a target for Nemesis, but that one will attack us through our family anyway if it can.
And other people learning about Nemesis is not such a problem, since even people who would generally be willing to summon Outsiders would propably hesitate to invite a mind-controling virus into themselves.

This is an entirely different case from when we didn't tell her about the situation with Eiko, because in that case another person's life depended on Charity's ability to keep secrets from Wan Kuei and Devils, while in this case we are the main-party involved.
 
Okay, trying to make a bestiary for DF-Creatures that we can fill up with information from story and QM-confirmations.

Creature: White Court Vampire

Soak:
-Bashing:
Full Stamina
-Lethal: Full Stamina? Half Stamina?
-Aggravated: Only through Disciplines or equipment/magic?

Specialities on Soak: Bullets deal full lethal damage?

Weaknesses: Conceptual counter love/hope/courage deals unsoakable damage?, can Frenzy from Hunger, True Faith?

Fuel/Powersource: Bloodpool-Equivalent?
Refill-Method: Draining Emotions, deals WP-damage, followed by Permanent WP-loss or lethal damage?

Supernatural Powers:
-Vampiric Disciplines
-Bloodheal-equivalent
-Passive Healing?
-Bloodbuff?
-Supernatural attractiveness (expressed only as Presence or other effects like stat-increase or lower difficulties in social?

Creature: Red Court Vampire

Soak:
-Bashing:
Full Stamina, halved past soak?
-Lethal: Full Stamina
-Aggravated: Only through Disciplines or equipment/magic?

Specialities on Soak: Bullets deal full lethal damage?, Aimed attacks on the stomach are more effective/less soakable/also drain bloodpool?

Weaknesses: Sunlight (while not in skinsuit), can Frenzy from Hunger, True Faith?

Fuel/Powersource: Bloopool
Refill-Method: Draining blood

Supernatural Powers:
-Vampiric Disciplines
-Bloodheal-equivalent
-Passive Healing?
-Bloodbuff?
-Skinsuit/True Form switch?
-Narcotic Saliva (Combat use and enthrallment)


Creature: Black Court Vampire

Soak:
-Bashing:
Full Stamina, halved past soak?
-Lethal: Full Stamina
-Aggravated: Only through Disciplines or equipment/magic?

Specialities on Soak: Bullets deal bashing damage unless aimed at the head?

Weaknesses: Sunlight (Elders seem resistant?), can Frenzy from Hunger, True Faith?

Fuel/Powersource: Bloopool
Refill-Method: Draining blood

Supernatural Powers:
-Vampiric Disciplines
-Bloodheal-equivalent
-Bloodbuff?
-Enthrallment very mentally damaging to the target, maybe independant power from normal Dominate Discipline?

Creature: Jade Court Vampire

Soak:
-Bashing:
Full Stamina, halved past soak?
-Lethal: Full Stamina
-Aggravated: Only through Disciplines or equipment/magic

Specialities on Soak: Bullets deal bashing damage unless aimed at the head? (I actually can't find that one in the book, but by default I'm assumin it works for them like for WoD-Vampires?)

Weaknesses: Sunlight, can Frenzy from Hunger/Fear/Demon Arts, True Faith

Fuel/Powersource: Chi-Pool
Refill-Method: Draining Chi, usually from people, Elders from Environment

Supernatural Powers:
-Wan Kuei Disciplines
-Yang-based healing
-Chi-Buff
-Innate Chi-Sight



Creature: Fey

Soak:
-Bashing:
Full Stamina
-Lethal: Full Stamina, Half Stamina?
-Aggravated: Only equipment/magic?

Specialities on Soak:

Weaknesses:
Cold Iron deals Aggravated Damage, variety of minor weaknesses of mostly social nature

Fuel/Powersource: ???
Refill-Method: Time/Rest?

Supernatural Powers:
-System unknow, can manifest as weather-control, direct damage, environmental control and more
-Vaguely comparable to the broad Sphere-effects of Mage, or more specific Charms/Gifts?

Creature: Wizards

Soak:
-Bashing:
Full Stamina
-Lethal: Only equipment/Magic?
-Aggravated: Only equipment/magic?

Specialities on Soak:

Weaknesses:
Nothing particular, water makes it harder to cast?

Fuel/Powersource: No particular powersource needed, though if Quintessence exists that would boost the magic, Soulfire and Hellfire for equivalent?, Willpower is important for casting?
Refill-Method: Time and Rest

Supernatural Powers:
-Sphere Magic from Mage
-Death Curse for more powerful magic than usual
-Path Magic from Sorcerer (or is that unavailable rather than just uneconomic for real Wizards?)
-Reliable Healing (not necessarily much faster than regular humans, but almost everything heals eventually
 
Last edited:
This is probably too broad a category to track this way beyond the superficial cold iron grade stuff.

Proper war trolls are basically Winter space marines, for example, they probably have dramatically different soak profiles than a Sidhe or Fetch.

Their esoteric powers can get weird too. Some are simple and bullshit like the way red caps can grow stronger by dipping their hats in the blood of their victims, some are just neat little tools they're built around, but almost every fey has something like that going for them that makes the sub groups very different in a fight.
 
This is probably too broad a category to track this way beyond the superficial cold iron grade stuff.

Proper war trolls are basically Winter space marines, for example, they probably have dramatically different soak profiles than a Sidhe or Fetch.

Their esoteric powers can get weird too. Some are simple and bullshit like the way red caps can grow stronger by dipping their hats in the blood of their victims, some are just neat little tools they're built around, but almost every fey has something like that going for them that makes the sub groups very different in a fight.
I'll split it up once we have either IC-knowledge or DP hands down some info.
 
So a pissed off Mab with an hour to prepare rolls 23 dice at difficulty 5 when attacking and gets an extra attack at the end of the round.

How much dodge/soak would we need to deal with that? Or would we have to spam perfect defenses?
 
Local Supernatural Mechanics
Okay, trying to make a bestiary for DF-Creatures that we can fill up with information from story and QM-confirmations.

This is what I have for the vampires and wizards, the fey I'll have to think about how to break it up

Creature: White Court Vampire

Soak:
-Bashing:
Full Stamina
-Lethal: Half Stamina
-Aggravated: Only through Disciplines or equipment/magic

Specialities on Soak: Bullets deal full lethal damage

Weaknesses: Conceptual counter love/hope/courage deals aggravated damage can Frenzy from Hunger

Fuel/Powersource: Lifeforce/Chi Equivalent
Refill-Method: Draining Emotions, deals WP-damage, followed by Permanent WP-loss or lethal damage, vampire's choice (if they take more physical or mental power)

Supernatural Powers:
-Vampiric Disciplines
-Bloodheal-equivalent
-Heal Bashing at Exalted levels
-Can spend lifeforce like the Kindred spend blood
-Supernatural attractiveness, expressed as breaking the cap on apparence through merits and discipline

Creature: Red Court Vampire

Soak:
-Bashing:
Full Stamina, halved past soak
-Lethal: Full Stamina
-Aggravated: Only through Disciplines or equipment/magic

Specialities on Soak: Bullets deal half lethal damage, Aimed attacks on the stomach do lethal and also drain bloodpool

Weaknesses: Sunlight (Elders with specialized Discipline can hide in the shadow of their Flesh-mask), can Frenzy from Hunger, True Faith

Fuel/Powersource: Bloopool
Refill-Method: Draining blood

Supernatural Powers:
-Vampiric Disciplines
-Bloodheal-equivalent
-No Passive Healing, they have to use blood intensive methods to heal
-Bloodbuff
-Skinsuit/True Form switch works like a Garou changing from human to Crinos, two successes needed either way on their Stamina+Animal Ken Equivalent
-Narcotic Saliva (Combat use and enthrallment)


Creature: Black Court Vampire

Soak:
-Bashing:
Full Stamina, halved past soak
-Lethal: Full Stamina
-Aggravated: Only through Disciplines or equipment/magic

Specialities on Soak: Bullets deal bashing damage unless aimed at the heart (Dracula in the book did not seem that phased at a headshot)

Weaknesses: Sunlight (Elders somewhat resistant), can Frenzy from Hunger, True Faith, Running Water, Elders need twice twice their successes to access their powers during the day, three times in direct sunlight

Fuel/Powersource: Bloopool
Refill-Method: Draining blood

Supernatural Powers:
-Vampiric Disciplines
-Bloodheal-equivalent
-Bloodbuff
-Enthrallment very mentally damaging to the target, its own discipline

Creature: Jade Court Vampire

Soak:
-Bashing:
Full Stamina, halved past soak?
-Lethal: Full Stamina
-Aggravated: Only through Disciplines or equipment/magic

Specialities on Soak: Bullets deal bashing damage unless aimed at the head

Weaknesses: Sunlight, can Frenzy from Hunger/Fear/Demon Arts, True Faith

Fuel/Powersource: Chi-Pool
Refill-Method: Draining Chi, usually from people, Elders from Environment

Supernatural Powers:
-Wan Kuei Disciplines
-Yang-based healing
-Chi-Buff
-Innate Chi-Sight

Creature: Wizards

Soak:
-Bashing:
Full Stamina
-Lethal: Only equipment/Magic
-Aggravated: Only equipment/Magic

Specialities on Soak:

Weaknesses:
Nothing

Fuel/Powersource: None, magic is omni-present
Refill-Method: Time and Rest

Supernatural Powers:
-Sphere Magic from Mage
-Death Curse for more powerful magic than usual
-No Path magic, a sorcerer receiving formal training or just through sufficient experience breaching the barrier converts their path dots into spheres
-Can heal even Aggravated damage with time and rest at 3xLethal healing times
 
Last edited:
Back
Top