Gestalt, A Worm x PMMM Faux-quest

If you were Sarah, this would be the moment you call for Kyuubey, casually ask it what the difference between a Cape and a Magical Girl is, and then sit back to watch Taylor react to the thing go about on it's usual spiel. Thankfully for Taylor's sanity, you're not Sarah.

Okay but I want to hear it, because that sounds funny and maybe informative.

"My own questionable morality,"

A compelling argument, to be sure.

"Every single magical girl who tried to go public died." Another bite. "Every single one. It goes like this: You come out as a "Cape". You get sponsorship deals. You get publicity. You get appreciation. And then one day you just vanish. No explanation. No body. No sign. Just... gone. Like you never even existed." A pause. "The only person who know's what happened to you is Kyuubey."

There's an absoluteness to this that makes me suspicious. There has to be at least one Magi that made it work, and if so Coobs would mention it or at least use phrasing that doesn't completely dismiss the possibility. Either he's trying to hide something, or there's another factor in play that Rachel doesn't know about. Or both.

<<So! Couple of updates: Emma Barnes is really ungrateful for someone who just had her life saved, and the Junior ABB are out looking for you. Also, a question for our listeners Taylor; has Rachel shown you her costume yet?>>

What the heck did Emma just get up to such that her life just got saved.

Something from the SB thread which should be kept in mind:

Oh you're absolutely right.

Homura would be able to make it work, wouldn't she?
 
Last edited:
The problem is that, even if Gestalt!Homura had survived Kyushu's sinking, it is unlikely that Madoka did it too... and Hommando's Wish is specifically aimed at Madoka. There is no Madoka, there is no Hommando around.
wait, why would Kyushu's sinking come with a risk of Madoka dying?
was it explicitly stated somewhere that Mitakihara existed on Kyushu and not any of Japan's other islands?
 
Rachel: "You know how Capes all have these Unwritten Rules? We don't. Instead of them we have basically the same rules but we don't call them Unwritten."

The gist of the Unwritten Rules:
1. Don't attack each other's civilian life.
and
2. Don't rely on these rules too much. If your opponent is crazy enough or believes they can get away with it, they'll break them.

And that's exactly what Brockton megucas are doing.

was it explicitly stated somewhere that Mitakihara existed on Kyushu and not any of Japan's other islands?
No, it never was stated, so Mitakihara will exist wherever the author wants.

Anyway it still should be about two months before PMMM would have been started.
It's kinda funny that Homura and Skitter start their careers in about the same time, April of 2011.
 
Edited the previous chapter:

"Not saying," you tell her, smile dropping, "Sarah told me, and I can no longer listen to the radio because of that." You take an angry bite out of your sandwitch. Chew thoroughly. Swallow. "But yeah, that's one reason."

"And the other?"

"Every single magical girl who tried to go public died." Another bite. "Every single one, or so close it might as well be every single one. It goes like this: You come out as a "Cape". You get sponsorship deals. You get publicity. You get appreciation." A pause, as you let the jealously flow over you. "And then, you try juggling doing Cape Shit and Magical Girl Shit. Remember that using magic puts corruption in your Soul Gem, and you don't exactly get Grief Seeds from fighting crime. Maybe you realize your mistake and retire early. Or maybe you're some unspeakable badass who can hold a big enough territory, and hunt enough Witches that you've got a surplus and can afford to go about stopping crimes, and you also, somehow, manage to juggle two completely different worlds with very different rules."

Another pause. "Either way, one day you just vanish. No explanation. No body. No sign. Just... gone. Like you never even existed." A pause. "But you're not dead. Not yet. What'll happen to you is..." You sigh. "Well, the only person who knows what happens to the girls who vanish is Kyuubey."

"... Has he, uh... Told you?" Taylor asks.

"Yeah. 'They wished they were dead. And although I could not grant that wish, it became true, eventually'," you quote. You shudder. "And getting it to tell you that much is not easy. Yeah. Not a story for people with imagination..."

Taylor and you come to a mutual, silent agreement to just enjoy your free time, before you have to go back into the school. Naturally, this is exactly when Sarah butts in.

<<So! Couple of updates: Emma Barnes is really ungrateful for someone who just had her life saved, and the Junior ABB are out looking for you. Also, a question for our listeners, Taylor: has Rachel shown you her costume yet?>>

Taylor blinks.
 
Yeah, not buying that every Meguca who went Cape just happened to fail at it.

There is absolutely someone putting some weight on the scale, and it's either Kyubey or Cauldron.

Given that Cauldron would adore having a superpowered individual not linked to the Shard system, the only conclusion I can draw is that Kyubey intentionally kills off any Meguca that goes the Ward route via forced Witch starvation - he practically says so outright that they Witch out and are eventually harvested by replacement Magical Girls.

Again, the system just isn't sustainable without Kyubey constantly forcing Magical Girls into competition, starving the weak into Witches to be harvested by the strong. All he needs to do to kill any Meguca that doesn't know The Secret is... stop feeding them. And even those that know can be killed this way with a bit of intentional thought from Kyubey.

The question is whether he's doing it just to be safe and stay under the radar, or if parahumans et al and Scion pose an existential threat to the Incubator race.
 
Last edited:
wait, why would Kyushu's sinking come with a risk of Madoka dying?
was it explicitly stated somewhere that Mitakihara existed on Kyushu and not any of Japan's other islands?

And if you thing that sinking under mega-waves an island the size of Kyushu has no repercussion to the adjacent ones, even by 'lesser' tsunamis hitting them but not doing a 'sunk land galore', when Mitakihara (regardless of what island of the Japanese Archipelago is on) is a port city, I would gladly point you to Surprisingly Realistic Outcomes.

Nevermind the looting, rioting, collateral damages from said sinking and the Japanese population entering a diaspora after Kyushu's sinking.

No, even if Mitakihara was not located in Kyushu, the fact is that even if it wasn't, the backlash of the Leviathan Vs Lung Epic Match would have neverless wrecked it.


There is absolutely someone putting some weight on the scale, and it's either Kyubey or Cauldron.

I doubt it. Unless the Megucas do things that could cause a planetary-reaching hit to its Energy Harvesting Operation (see Puella Magi Tart Magica) Kyubey is apathetic regarding what a Magical Girl does.

At worst, Incubator would not 'directly help' a Capeized Meguca, but it isn't as it was so helpful even before.

And Entities? Entities I suspect that their existence is a double edged sword for the Incubator Hivemind.

Because on one hand, their operations mean more Contracts in the face of the dangers they pose to planet-bound civilizations.

On the other hand, every series of 1*10^82 planets that they kabloomie when they 'depart' from an experiment sites mean an increase of universal entropy so big that I suspect is making the accounting parts of the hivemind develop emotions simply to be able to scream in rage and despair, because said kabloomies causes the quotas to go in the negative.

And, in the events one of them was able to reach their 'miracle answer' they seek with their Cycles?

It would benefit only the Entity/ies that discovered it, and no one else.
 
Last edited:
@Dalek Ix: So, I don't get why everyone thinks literally not a single Magical Girl pulled off being a Cape. Like, yeah, it'd be stupidly hard and have a high mortality rate, but I'm betting there were some Potentials who Wished to be a Cape. I feel like people are misunderstanding things? There's always at least one person for anything imaginable, so unless Cauldron straight up abduct Meguca Capes… at least one should of succeeded.
 
Hmm… the story needs to progress first, but I do think a lot of attention is being drawn to the idea of Meguca Capes. Seems obvious enough that Taylor and Rachel will become friends, so if Taylor joins(?) the Wards… I could see Rachel actually trying to make it work. Sure, we've barely progressed, but the two settings feel more like they're just side-by-side so far instead of blended together.
 
In which Rachel demonstrates Magical Girl Fashion.
==========
Gestalt
==========

[X] Sarah.

<<Sarah.>>

The psychic message over the network is blunt, monotone, and heavy with a novel's worth of implications, hidden messages, emotion and menace. It speaks of suffering. Of exhaustion. Of deep, complicated relationships. It is a masterpiece of reading between the lines and communication.

Sarah gleefully ignores all of it.

<<Hi Rachel,>> she cheekily voices back, <<So, Taylor? Has she?>>

Taylor glances over towards you. <<Um... No?>> she tells her, <<But... uh...>>

She glances towards you again, and tries to reassure you, "I mean, it's fine if you don't want to," she tells you, although it doesn't take a Thinker to figure out that she's curious.

You eat through the last of your sandwitch, and, closing your eyes, tilt your head back, facing the sky. You stay like that for a few minutes.

Give me strength.

You inhale, and give a tremendous sigh, eyes opening to stare dully at the horizon. "Fine," you say, standing up and dusting off your hands, "You're gonna see it at some point, so might as well get things over with."

You hold out your right hand, palm facing up, and allow your Gem to manifest on top of it. It's easier to transform that way --being able to see the Gem makes focusing on it more natural. And yeah, you've done this enough times to transform without this crutch, but... well. Nerves.

You focus on the gem in your hand, feeling the well of magic contained within your crystaline self. According to Kyuubey, every Magical Girl has a different mental process for transformation. For some, it's like a switch. For others, it's a pull, or a push. In your case, it's like opening a door.

Your vision goes white. Your gem seems to burst into a web of steel, and grey-blue patterns begin to form around your body, splitting and joining and splitting again to form more complex shapes. They pull close to you to your body, and then flare out, dissolving and reforming to form your outftit just in time for your vision to return.

Your boots crunch into the snow when you hit the ground, and the floor seems to tremble from the impact. The drop was only a bout a foot high, and you barely even have to flex your knees to take it. There's a comforting weight to your outfit. As if it were far more heavy and protective than cloth and leather ought to be. To say nothing about the strength now coursing through your body, flowing through your veins, through bone, muscle and sinew. The strength of a Puella Magi.

The rush is, sadly, more than a little spoiled by the nature of your costume. Brushing away some snow, you pause to tuck the diamond-shaped gem hanging from your neck down your blouse, and examine yourself; the changes you've made so far seem to have stuck, although you still aren't happy with the way your costume looks; even bereft of simbols, your outfit has an authoritarian, sinister air to it, and the inspiration is still blatantly obvious.

Taylor lowers her right arm --she'd raised it to protect her eyes from the glare of your magic doing its thing, and just stares at you.

"Thats..." She's just shy of gawking. "Um. Er."

You sigh. "I know."

"It's... er..." She makes a vague gesture towards you. "It's... distinctive?"

"It's a few swastikas away from being something I stole from Kaiser's wardrobe," you deadpan. "I know."

"... Honestly, it's... er..." She's trying. Bless her cotton socks, she's trying. "It looks more... 'generic bad guy' than... uh. That."

"Taylor." You rub your face with gloved hands. "I appreciate what you're trying to do, but I know what my costume looks like."

"... Have you tried changing it?" she squeaks.

"Practically since I've contracted. It used to be worse."

An awkward silence smothers the air around you two.

"... Why is it... um..."

You sigh.

"My brother is basically Empire, and I was naive, impressionable, and a horrible abusive person who worshipped the ground he walked on when I made my wish," you tell her, "Could we move on? Please?"

<<Show her the gun!>>

"The what."

Sarah should thank every god mankind has ever worshipped that there's most of a building between you and her. Your left hand is covering most of your face, and your right reaches forward, grasping.

Your weapon forms itself in a flash of magic and steel. It's a dull black instrument of industrially-produced death, sparcely decorated with silvery, angular flairs, and as long as you're tall. The grip sits easily in your hand, perfectly moulded to it, and a long belt of ammunition --grey links, brass casings and glowing grey-blue bullets-- dangles from the side.

"This," You tell her. Taylor stares at it.

"... That's a machinegun," She states, flatly. "You know, when you told me you were a Magical Girl, I thought you'd be using... I don't know, a wand?"

"Some girls do," you tell her, resting the barrel on your shoulder, "But every Magical Girl I know of gets some sorta weapon with their wish. Sarah's got a sword and shield, Andrea has this glaive that shoots lightning, and Anna has flying knives. A lot of flying knives." You heft your weapon. "And I get this thing."

"... Huh." She frowns. "That sounds more than a little overpowered."

"You'd think so," you say, "And yeah, this thing can pretty much cut apart anything it hits through sheer firepower, but it's also huge, I can only handle one or two of them at a time, and shooting it can eat through my magic really quickly if I'm not careful."

"Also, the noise is awesome in a terrifying sort of way."

Taylor and you swirl around, startled, you being a little faster to do so.

Sarah's standing right by the entrance to the roof, arms crossed and casually leaning against the closed door. She gives both of you a cheeky wave and, pushing off, walks towards you. There's a flash of magic mid-step, and suddenly, she's in costume.

Unlike your own getup, Sarah's is more fantastical. Armoured boots and greaves. A pleated skirt, reinforced by dangling strips of chainmail and secured by a wide belt with a sword sheath that sits at an angle. On her chest, a green undershirt that's unbuttoned at the bottom to expose a peek of her midriff through the layer of silver chainmail she wears over it, and over that a chestpiece, etched with swirling green and golden patterns, that looks more decorative than protective.

Which makes sense, as her actual protection comes from the massive tower shield she's holding in her right arm; a curved, inch-thick plate of solid steel that goes from the ground to above her head and is wide enough to completely cover three people, if not more. The face of it is decorated by a fancy painted star-in-a-pentagram in gold over green; a symbol which is repeated on the brooch securing her forest green cape around her shoulders, and on the gem inset in the circlet around her head.

Also, her dark brown hair is now a vivid green.

Taylor's staring at the transformed Sarah, who just smiles jovially at her. She makes her cape flutter, and then casually leans against her shield. "'Sup~," she greets.

You're less than impressed. "Did you ask me to transform just so you could come here and show off?" you ask her.

She waggles the index finger of her free hand at you. "Ah, normally you'd be correct to think that, but I'm in Puella Magi Sarah Magica mode for more important reasons, if you can believe that!"

"Really."

Sarah nods sagely. "Yes, really," she tells you, "It goes like this: I know we both agreed to leave, as you call it, 'Magical Girl Shit' out of school grounds during school hours --which is a perfectly reasonable thing to do--, but, since we're gonna be meeting a lot more often, I was wondering..."

She pauses for a moment. "Oh, right. You have a street fight after school. Can't forget that." Sarah hums to herself, gauntleted fingers drumming on her shield. "Well, slight change of plans, then. What do you feel about hunting together tonight, Rachel?"

You feel like you'd very much like a Puella Magi of Sarah's powerset on your side. Unfortunately, the only girl you know of that would qualify is Sarah. Still, you recognize an olive branch when you see one.

It could be a scheme, though. God knows for what, but you have a feeling that Sarah's got something up her metaphorical sleeve-

"Oh!" she adds, eyes brightening, "Also, Taylor, you can come along if you're not too busy with stuff!"

What.

"...me?" Taylor asks. "I... uh..." She glances between Sarah and yourself, "Why are you asking me to go with you? I'm not..."

Sarah smiles, and then it hits you. Something which you'd been deliberately ignoring all this time. Because there's one, and only one reason Kyuubey would add someone to the psychic network:

Potential.

You know this. Sarah knows this. The only one who doesn't is Taylor. Maybe she suspects that there must be some reason for Kyuubey to suddenly bring her into your world. In fact, you'd be surprised if she didn't.

Why hasn't she asked, though?

In fact, why hasn't Kyuubey made her any sort of offer, or even hint at it? Why did it just leave Sarah and you free reign to expose Taylor to the world of Magical Girls?

She has to hear it from you.

You're...

[-] ... saddened. You were kinda looking forward to the idea of having someone you could talk to, without having to worry about watching your back.
[-] ... apprehensive. Taylor making a Contract is bound to make thing a lot more complicated for you. And possibly for everyone else.
[-] ... concerned. Taylor is not ready to be a Magical Girl. She's a layer cake of issues and trauma, and that'll kill a Puella Magi as surely as a bullet to the Soul Gem.

With things cleared up, there's one pressing matter to tend to:
[-] Refuse. You have to polish your Soul Gem or something.
[-] Accept, but refuse to bring Taylor with you. No way, no how.
[-] Accept, ask Taylor.
-[-] Encourage her to come.
--[-] Maybe seeing what being a Puella Magi is like would be enough to make her think things over, Contract-wise?
-[-] Discourage her. This is Dangerous.
 
Last edited:
-[-] Bring Taylor along for... reasons?
I believe that this is what's called 'doing a Mami'

Which makes sense, as her actual protection comes from the massive tower shield she's holding in her right arm; a curved, inch-thick plate of solid steel that goes from the ground to above her head and is wide enough to completely cover three people, if not more.
That, and the fact that she's basically undead and this lot seems to be more than less aware of the fact, so they can take advantage of it
 
Also, her dark brown hair is now a vivid green.

That's actually very weird, no one else gets magic hair dye. Did Sarah's Wish in some way caused her to have green hair? Now I think about it, that's probably one of the simplest but major things when crossing anime with not-anime. Nobody really thinks Sayaka having blue hair is weird, which she clearly had before her Contract. So why does Sarah have magic hair dye?
 
I might just change that last bit, actually.

No need to change anything, after all, like @Kkutlord said in hir post above...

Did Sarah's Wish in some way caused her to have green hair?

... it could be a collateral effect of Sarah's Wish, it would not be the first time a Wish caused physical alterations in the Puella Magi transformed form (for a canonical reference, Airi Anri and her shapeshifting Wish to become the recently Witched-and-Deceased Yuuri Asuka, from Puella Magi Kazumi Magica).
 
No need to change anything, after all, like @Kkutlord said in hir post above...



... it could be a collateral effect of Sarah's Wish, it would not be the first time a Wish caused physical alterations in the Puella Magi transformed form (for a canonical reference, Airi Anri and her shapeshifting Wish to become the recently Witched-and-Deceased Yuuri Asuka, from Puella Magi Kazumi Magica).

To be fair, I'm not sure what would of gave her green hair without also doing way more. Airi is the only time we see something like that happen, and she specifically wanted to become Yuuri. If Sarah's Wish really caused her to have green hair, that still requires explanation as to why it would of given her green hair.
 
She plays AD&D and Wished to 'be as like her character as possible'?

Then she probably wouldn't just be "Sarah with Green Hair". She'd probably look very different then, as most people don't make their Tabletop characters a stand-in for themselves. I wouldn't discount it in her case, but in general Transformations never alter physical features unless Wished for.
 
No need to change anything, after all, like @Kkutlord said in hir post above...

I meant the part with Sarah, actually :V. Speaking of which:

She waggles the index finger of her free hand at you. "Ah, normally you'd be correct to think that, but I'm in Puella Magi Sarah Magica mode for more important reasons, if you can believe that!"

"Really."

Sarah nods sagely. "Yes, really," she tells you, "It goes like this: I know we both agreed to leave, as you call it, 'Magical Girl Shit' out of school grounds during school hours --which is a perfectly reasonable thing to do--, but, since we're gonna be meeting a lot more often, I was wondering..."

She pauses for a moment. "Oh, right. You have a street fight after school. Can't forget that." Sarah hums to herself, gauntleted fingers drumming on her shield. "Well, slight change of plans, then. What do you feel about hunting together tonight, Rachel?"

You feel like you'd very much like a Puella Magi of Sarah's powerset on your side. Unfortunately, the only girl you know of that would qualify is Sarah. Still, you recognize an olive branch when you see one.

It could be a scheme, though. God knows for what, but you have a feeling that Sarah's got something up her metaphorical sleeve-

"Oh!" she adds, eyes brightening, "Also, Taylor, you can come along if you're not too busy with stuff!"

What.

"...me?" Taylor asks. "I... uh..." She glances between Sarah and yourself, "Why are you asking me to go with you? I'm not..."

Sarah smiles, and then it hits you. Something which you'd been deliberately ignoring all this time. Because there's one, and only one reason Kyuubey would add someone to the psychic network:

Potential.

You know this. Sarah knows this. The only one who doesn't is Taylor. Maybe she suspects that there must be some reason for Kyuubey to suddenly bring her into your world. In fact, you'd be surprised if she didn't.

Why hasn't she asked, though?

In fact, why hasn't Kyuubey made her any sort of offer, or even hint at it? Why did it just leave Sarah and you free reign to expose Taylor to the world of Magical Girls?

She has to hear it from you.

You're...

[-] ... saddened. You were kinda looking forward to the idea of having someone you could talk to, without having to worry about watching your back.
[-] ... apprehensive. Taylor making a Contract is bound to make thing a lot more complicated for you. And possibly for everyone else.
[-] ... concerned. Taylor is not ready to be a Magical Girl. She's a layer cake of issues and trauma, and that'll kill a Puella Magi as surely as a bullet to the Soul Gem.

With things cleared up, there's one pressing matter to tend to:
[-] Refuse. You have to polish your Soul Gem or something.
[-] Accept, but refuse to bring Taylor with you. No way, no how.
[-] Accept, ask Taylor.
-[-] Encourage her to come.
--[-] Maybe seeing what being a Puella Magi is like would be enough to make her think things over, Contract-wise?
-[-] Discourage her. This is Dangerous.

Edited in the following. Next part will be up today.
 
[X] ... concerned. Taylor is not ready to be a Magical Girl. She's a layer cake of issues and trauma, and that'll kill a Puella Magi as surely as a bullet to the Soul Gem.
[X] Refuse. You have to polish your Soul Gem or something.
-[X] Write In: warn Taylor more explicitly about Kyuubey and apparently Sarah. You can't possibly stick with her at all times, so she needs to know better or she's a s good as dead.
--[X] Write In: No wishy-washy, vague warnings of Doom. Be fully explicity that Sarah and Kyuubey are sizing her up for becoming a Magical Girl too, and that this is explicitly a death sentence for someone who's in Taylor's position.
---[X] Write In: Promise Taylor whatever it takes to keep her from even considering this.


I call it "Plan: I'm-Not-A-Yandere,-Sempai!"
 
Now...what would Taylor wish for?

Something selfish for herself or something centered around another person?
Something quite noticeable causing the Parahuman world to crash into Magicka?

Would her Potential be enough to fuel the death of an Endbringer?

Or, perish the thought, should Kyubey tell her of her wish's capabilities, would she try to game the system in a similar manner just like Madoka did? In the attempt to apply the hero mindset to the Magicka world?


Also hows it standing with the possibility of harvesting the energy storage of a Shard through killing a parahuman?


So many possibilities!
 
Would her Potential be enough to fuel the death of an Endbringer?

I'm reminded of this PMMM/MassEffect fic I read a while back where Kyuubey had become kind of a known thing because the Magical Girl system was exposed during the First Contact War*. Anyway, so Baby Shepard got contracted (and boy howdy!), and later there was some contention that the sheer scale of the wish she was able to make was, in itself, pretty strong evidence for the existence of the Reapers.

*As I recall, there was a scene where Kyuubey commented that he could have still covered the whole thing up at that point, but it would have required killing every person and wiping all electronics in that entire star system if he wanted to be sure, and at that point he'd really be raising more questions than he was answering. Kyuubey didn't seem too put out about it anyway; for some reason he appeared to be under the impression that either way people were going to stop being aware of him again later, somehow. I'm sure that's nothing.
 
[-] ... saddened. You were kinda looking forward to the idea of having someone you could talk to, without having to worry about watching your back.
[-] ... apprehensive. Taylor making a Contract is bound to make thing a lot more complicated for you. And possibly for everyone else.
[-] ... concerned. Taylor is not ready to be a Magical Girl. She's a layer cake of issues and trauma, and that'll kill a Puella Magi as surely as a bullet to the Soul Gem.

These options all are more indirect effects on events going forward, since they're about how Rachel feels about something rather than how she's reacting to something. Each one emphasizes a different aspect of her life/psyche, for whatever differing effects that might have. The first option is a desire for the kind of honest companionship that she hasn't had....possibly ever. She and Taylor have pretty much both bared their dark secrets and painful pasts at each other already, so there's a shared foundation of mutual understanding (kinda) that could build into a pretty strong friendship. I also get the feeling that she didn't really have much of a life outside of Magical Girling, since we haven't really seen any indication of friends that she left behind at Clarendon, so Taylor could help anchor her to normal life, while at the same time Rachel gives Taylor the kind of safe space she needs to be able to unwind and spread her wings again. It is the option focused on Rachel the most, though.

The second option is probably the most business-like of them - it means her first reaction is thinking about the broader-scope implications of Taylor contracting and the ripples that will make on the existing Puella Magi landscape. While it sounds like it's achieved something approaching reasonable stability, throwing a wild-card like Taylor into the picture could upend things quite a bit in unpredictable ways - such as control of the Winslow Witch Mines, and if Taylor's presumed closeness to Rachel means that Andrea and Anna would see that as enough of a threat to seriously try and topple things. It's also the least emotional of them with regards to Taylor, since it's not about her but instead the repercussions of her actions. The "Rachel's reaction as a Puella Magi, not as a human" reaction, sorta.

The final option is the straightforward "Rachel cares about Taylor as a person" one. Being a Puella Magi is a pretty shit existence and friends shouldn't let friends join. The only real major pitfall I can see here is that explaining this sort of reaction to Taylor could be awkward if Rachel tries to be circumspect with it - or possibly even if she's straightforward. Being told "you are too depressed to be good at being special" isn't exactly a fun thing to hear to someone desperately wanting some form of self-actualization.

It'd be actually pretty funny if that sort of apparent rejection makes her spiral into a Trigger, though.

[-] Refuse. You have to polish your Soul Gem or something.

See this is the option that probably makes Sarah offer to take Taylor on a hunt by herself somewhere non-Winslow, which basically means that it's a lot more dangerous for Taylor. Of course, that'd contingent on Taylor accepting such an offer which....I'd guess she wouldn't. Sarah's an asshole and despite having the power to help her didn't do anything, neither of which fosters much goodwill.

[-] Accept, but refuse to bring Taylor with you. No way, no how.

Ah yes, exclude the depressed teen who has just found a social circle that might not reject her or betray her, that's definitely not going to backfire.

-[-] Encourage her to come.
--[-] Maybe seeing what being a Puella Magi is like would be enough to make her think things over, Contract-wise?

Well it'll certainly make Taylor think, though it's a tossup whether it'll be about the danger or the "powers cool" things being shown.

-[-] Discourage her. This is Dangerous.

Ah yes, the bastard child of "include her" and "reject her" that could either be the best option here (giving her a strong impression that this isn't something she should want to be doing) or the worst (giving her a taste of what this side of the world is like and then trying to rip it away from her).
 
Last edited:
Back
Top