Gestalt, A Worm x PMMM Faux-quest

But remember, the canon reaction to the Witchbomb revelations were tainted by the fact that the girls that we saw getting it were either already internally broken or uncaring of the fact.

I would say there's a difference between not caring and being indifferent. Like, some of them choose to not let being proto-Witches stop them, whereas some others kind of pretend like it doesn't mater. Then there are some who have massive freak outs about it, like Sasa preferring to be dead and Mami going all murder-suicide on everyone near her. Though yeah, the Witchbomb tends to have such a negative reaction because we specifically see some of the more troubled girls. I mean, geez, Mami is a bag of issues.
 
Though yeah, the Witchbomb tends to have such a negative reaction because we specifically see some of the more troubled girls. I mean, geez, Mami is a bag of issues.

Well, Yuma-chan's (Puella Magi Oriko Magica) reaction to the WItchbomb revelation was "So? It will happen, it does not mean that it has to happen today." and proceed to reignite the fight in the non-Homura megucas present to the fight.
 
Well, Yuma-chan's (Puella Magi Oriko Magica) reaction to the WItchbomb revelation was "So? It will happen, it does not mean that it has to happen today." and proceed to reignite the fight in the non-Homura megucas present to the fight.

I mean, to be fair, becoming a Magical Girl was more or less a legitimate improvement for Yuma. Possibility of becoming a soul-eating monster? Whatevs, she probably would of Triggered with all the crap she went through before even making her Wish.

Great, now I want Yuma to show up. Poor girl went through enough, and it isn't like Leviathan killed every Asian person. Yuma would totally shrug off being a Parahuman.

Yuma: "So I got some kind of space worm in my head saying I should fight?"
Someone: "Yes."
Yuma: "Okay, I don't see what that changes."

I want Ward!Yuma, she'd totally not be bothered that Shards tell their Parahumans to fight for "glorious conflict". Seriously, at least some of the canon characters must of survived- either pre or post Wish.

Seriously, a lot of them could probably be re-written as Parahumans. Like, Kyoko would totally be traumatized enough to Trigger if she was the only one to survive after Leviathan managed to kill her parents and little sister.

Mami would probably be offended by the ABB just being, like, such a horrible representation of Asian culture. She's the closest to being an actual superheroine, Sayaka even goes all "Heroine of Justice" with Mami as her example.
 
If Taylor contracts to avoid petty teenage drama and territorial brutality she's in a for a rude surprise lol.
Literally dying because your crush didn't like you and getting beaten half to death for the crime of existing in the same city as a different magical girl all happened in canon after all.

The Witchbomb thing is mostly dangerous when magical girls view their activities as benevolent and base their self-worth on that thought.
Given that Mami was basically a magical girl recruiter and hunted down familiars; it's not a surprise that she had such a... drastic response.
I don't think Kyoko would have gave a damn if Madoka and Sayaka hadn't (dangerously) reawakened her old heroic impulses.

How lucid or intelligent exactly are most Witches?
This is my headcanon. It's hilariously dark but really reads as something Homura would say while trying to keep Madoka from contracting. (After eliding most of the FFN.NET-ish parts of course.)
https://www.fanfiction.net/s/6842785/1/It-Definitely-Sucks-to-Be-Alone said:
She pulled a single Grief Seed from the shield as well, and raised it to Madoka's face.

"...Homura... that's-"

"For whatever reason, I was deeply disturbed by the nature of Kyoko's demise... I went back there, and... collected every trace of her Soul Gem, down to the nanoscopic level. I found... this... at the same time... This is what's left of Sayaka Miki: she is equally lost, although in a completely different way."

"A... a Grief Seed...?"

"I naively thought that I could help them - both of them. That Kyoko's Soul might be reparable. That Sayaka's condition might be reversible. There might be a way, I just had to find it myself." She smiled sadly at the memory. "Just the thought of saving them gave me... hope... And, I... I honestly wanted to believe that I could have been wrong about Puella Magi being doomed from the moment they made their wish... Reason dictates that whatever can be broken should have the capacity to be fixed, and that which has been tainted, the capacity to be purified. Usually, the only problem with fixing broken things is that we can't figure out how to do it. I sincerely tried... I did almost anything I thought could have helped... only to confirm what I'd already accepted. It was... a waste."

[...]

"Their souls exist on two completely separate planes of existence; they will never meet again. Sayaka, is here right now, alive in my hand; she's even somewhat aware of her surroundings. You wondered how she's been doing, correct? Her turbulent emotions are radiating out from her Grief Seed and pouring into me. She hates us. Hates you, infinitely more. She resents herself for whatever it was that she said to you before she 'died,' but... she resents you all the more for making her words true. She no longer has the emotive capacity for happiness, or love... She can only feel heartbreak, inadequacy, remorse, hatred, and anger."

[...]

"She wishes that she was never born... that she never met you... that she died a long time ago, or that she died on a Witch Hunt. Anything would be better the pitiful fate she has now. She wishes that you were never born, that you never associated with her, that you would kill yourself, and that she could kill you right now - after all, she was only contracted because of you. She really had almost no potential... it was purely because of her relationship with you that she was a convenient, additional contract for Kyubey. She clings to the hope that she can avenge herself, with the suffering of everyone she saved through her selflessness."

[...]

"Conversely, Kyoko Sakura exists only in our memories of her. Her Soul... the personification of her actual, literal Soul, was obliterated. How could she be anywhere, anymore? How could she be in 'Heaven,' enjoying Sayaka Miki's company, when Sayaka is actually here, begging me to abuse her Grief Seed and revive her again... to free her, so that she can murder us? Shall I, to prove it...?"


May I have the sauce, please?
Can I get a link to the fic with Sloan?
Fargo by Bavitz
It's imperfect but it's one of the best things I've read imo.
The writing has some low-level faults but avoids errors found in the overwhelming majority of even well-written fics.
 
Last edited:
If Taylor contracts to avoid petty teenage drama and territorial brutality she's in a for a rude surprise lol.
Literally dying because your crush didn't like you and getting beaten half to death for the crime of existing in the same city as a different magical girl all happened in canon after all.

I sincerely hope Taylor doesn't make some petty Wish, she literally has the potential to slay a multiversal threat. I don't know how that actually compares to Madoka, but Madoka's sheer Potential was born from Homura's looping.

Tart aka Joan D'Arc had a buttload of Potential to start with, and gained even more after her "fated death" was prevented. She literally only became more powerful because Melissa prevented her from dying in combat- thus her impact on the world increased, due to the simple fact she survived what was suppose to be the end of her influence on the world.

Taylor seems like someone who wouldn't just make a Wish on the spot, as the only reason I could see her panic-Wishing is during the Locker Incident. Honestly, I think it would be more interesting if QA managed to get to her first. It'd be interesting to see how Kyubey reacts to having a Contractee "stolen" from him.

I feel like Taylor would be incredibly suspicious of making a Contract, and insistent on learning everything she possibly could before making a Wish. Her Wish being part of the "endgame" seems better to me, and I'm interested in watching Parahuman Taylor & Meguca Rachel trying to interact with each other despite the very different worlds they live in.
 
I sincerely hope Taylor doesn't make some petty Wish, she literally has the potential to slay a multiversal threat. I don't know how that actually compares to Madoka, but Madoka's sheer Potential was born from Homura's looping.

Tart aka Joan D'Arc had a buttload of Potential to start with, and gained even more after her "fated death" was prevented. She literally only became more powerful because Melissa prevented her from dying in combat- thus her impact on the world increased, due to the simple fact she survived what was suppose to be the end of her influence on the world.

Taylor seems like someone who wouldn't just make a Wish on the spot, as the only reason I could see her panic-Wishing is during the Locker Incident. Honestly, I think it would be more interesting if QA managed to get to her first. It'd be interesting to see how Kyubey reacts to having a Contractee "stolen" from him.

I feel like Taylor would be incredibly suspicious of making a Contract, and insistent on learning everything she possibly could before making a Wish. Her Wish being part of the "endgame" seems better to me, and I'm interested in watching Parahuman Taylor & Meguca Rachel trying to interact with each other despite the very different worlds they live in.
I agree.
We already have an established magical girl and Taylor is the defacto representative of worm.
If the goal is culture clash, putting both main characters on the same side would be a very strange one.
 
Fargo by Bavitz
It's imperfect but it's one of the best things I've read imo.
The writing has some low-level faults but avoids errors found in the overwhelming majority of even well-written fics.
[/QUOTE]
So that's what it was. Man, I should reread that series again.
 
The Capes: Resident Evil, gotta play perfect without screwups
The PMs: Dynasty Warriors

It's even more hilariously skewed if you think about it.

"Ah, for you, they day you stumbled into a Witch barrier was the most terrifying day of your lives. For me, it was only Tuesday. Anyways, I've got homework to do."

"You still go to school?"

Being serious though, do the Brockton girls realize the bizarre similarities between Soul Gems and Grief Seeds? These are American girls, both with a vastly different culture and don't seem to have prior awareness of Magical Girl media. It clearly exists, as Quitterie seems to have been convinced she was a normal Magical Girl. Rachel holds a lot of hostility for Kyubey, and I can't tell if she legitimately thinks something is wrong or is just peeved about her outfit.

In order; having the Brockton Bay girls figure out something which the canon PM didn't do until being explicitly told by someone who did strikes me as being more than a little unfair to them. Magical girl media does exist, but everything after Kyushu got sunk by Leviathan can be assumed to never have gotten out of Japan, and that's not counting how the existence of Capes would've influenced the Magical Girl shows that got made before then.

Rachel blames her costume on her brother. Her beef with Kyuubey is entirely down to him plugging Taylor into the magical psychic network without telling anyone, and then leaving before she could use him as stress relief demand an explanation.

Though I guess the better question is- would they be willing to suicide to prevent their Witch from manifesting, or would they be perfectly fine with it? Like, the Lichbomb is more of a cultural thing, but the Witchbomb would freak out just about anyone.

I suspect that, if they learned of the Witchbomb, they would consider the suicide-to-avoid-IMPENDING Witchdom as a last resort. Remember, Western culture, Suicide is (supposedly) a one-way-only ticket for Hell.

But remember, the canon reaction to the Witchbomb revelations were tainted by the fact that the girls that we saw getting it were either already internally broken or uncaring of the fact.

Another thing that one should keep in mind is that, by the time a girl is close enough to turning for that to be relevant, she's not gonna be thinking straight. The black junk in a Soul Gem is quite literally despair.

Sayaka's spiraling condition wasn't just because of all the revelations she'd ran face-first into; the fact that she refused to clean her gem (a massive no-no for a Magical Girl, and for damned good reason) or otherwise take care of herself had a lot to do how she deteriorated so quickly. The more her Soul Gem filled up, the more emotionally compromised she became, until her soul could take no more.

Literally dying because your crush didn't like you and getting beaten half to death for the crime of existing in the same city as a different magical girl all happened in canon after all.

"So... It's basically High School drama on really violent drugs, but with superpowers and secret fights to the death?"

"Er, maybe? It's kinda bad form to go about killing your neighbours if you can."

"Personally, I'd rather deal with Anna, Andrea and you than the Winslow cliques."

"... That says things about that school I didn't want to- Wait. Why me!? Sarah. Sarah, stop running away and answer my question!"

:V

I'm interested in watching Parahuman Taylor & Meguca Rachel trying to interact with each other despite the very different worlds they live in.

If the goal is culture clash, putting both main characters on the same side would be a very strange one.

I can already see poor Emily Piggot reaching for the whiskey.

In more amusing news:


THERE CAN BE ONLY ONE.

:V
 
In order; having the Brockton Bay girls figure out something which the canon PM didn't do until being explicitly told by someone who did strikes me as being more than a little unfair to them. Magical girl media does exist, but everything after Kyushu got sunk by Leviathan can be assumed to never have gotten out of Japan, and that's not counting how the existence of Capes would've influenced the Magical Girl shows that got made before then.

Rachel blames her costume on her brother. Her beef with Kyuubey is entirely down to him plugging Taylor into the magical psychic network without telling anyone, and then leaving before she could use him as stress relief demand an explanation

I can understand that, but there's also a large cultural difference between them. The Japanese Girls didn't really put it together because Transformation Trinkets tend to have weird names and odd similarities between the heroes & villains isn't too strange to grasp. Most of them are genuinely shocked or horrified, so it seems like none of the Japanese Girls ever really considered it. French Magical Girls, at least from Tart's time, are a lot more chill about it. Granted, they also kind off had more important things to worry about, like the literal war going on.

We don't really see much of Non-Asian Magical Girls, with the vast majority being Japanese. Ashley Taylor is American, but I don't think there's enough to really guess about her- especially since she seems to be a weeabo who clearly wanted to go to Japan. Seriously though, what's up with her? I could actually see her coming to Brockton purely because of the high Asian population.

As for Rachel, I could of swore she was already kind of aggressive about Kyubey even before the Taylor incident.
 
The authors must all fight to the death for rights to the fic name.

Personally, my moneys on the the Dalek.
 
In which Rachel has a small Q&A session.
==========
Gestalt
==========

[X] Keep talking about Witches and Magical Girls. Sarah's... well, Sarah. Pressing her on this will just end in Taylor and you being frustrated.

You can feel Taylor's glare towards Sarah. Sarah, being Sarah, continues to talk with her friends as if nothing's wrong. Briefly, you consider needling your fellow Puella Magi --maybe between Taylor and you, you can corner her into giving a straight answer on why she bent the knee to The Bitches Three and completely ignored Taylor's misery.

However, you know Sarah. And that means you know that you could have her up against a wall, machinegun to her Soul Gem, and she still wouldn't take anything coming out of your mouth seriously. Sighing, you casually reach out and put your left hand on Taylor's shoulder. She jumps at the contact, looking at limb as if it were some sort of vaguely-threatening spider.

You give a squeeze. A very small squeeze.

<<Leave it,>> you tell her, <<Trust me when I say that, whatever you wanna get out of that one, she's not gonna make it worth the effort.>>

<<I'm right here, you know,>> Sarah pipes up.

<I know,>> you shoot back. Sarah pouts over the link, and Taylor looks incredibly uncomfortable from that; you give her a sympathetic look, and-

Again!

Duck, block, grab. One handed. Turn slowly to look at the larger boy wearing ABB colours. He sneers at you, although his confidence plummets when he realizes that he can't pull out of your grip. And then it goes into a nose-dive when you pull him down.

"What the fu-"

"After school," You hiss at him. "Alley three blocks north. Bring friends. Or whatever it takes for you to feel man enough to face little old me."

You push him away, letting the wannabe gangster stumble away from you, and then clasp your hands on your desk, looking as bored as you can. Taylor's look reminds you somewhat of an owl, with how wide her eyes are.

<<... Did you just-.>>

<<-Challenge the manhood of an ABB fanboy and dare him to fight me after school?>> You finish Taylor's question. <<Yes. I did.>>

<<Not to tell the Übermädchen what to do, but try not to machinegun Winslow's junior ABB to death,>> Sarah quips. She's giggling at something her little circle of friends are talking about, and you pretend not to be jealous, <<Last thing either of us needs is the Protectorate sniffing around.>>

<<It's Super-Mädchen,>> you reflexively correct. Taylor stares at you, Sarah cackles like a hyena, and you try not to blush. <<A-anyway! We were talking about Magical Girls so why don't we keep talking about Magical girls, please?>>

Taylor has that look. The look someone has when they realize that the deep end is a lot deeper than they thought. It takes a while for her to open up again --during which the teacher arrives, and begins doing teacher things; your pen flies over your notebook from all the notes you're taking-- but she eventually does.

<<Are you two... friends?>> she asks, tentatively. <<You obviously know each other, but...>>

... Oh dear. How to explain Magical Girl politics.

<<We're not,>> You tell her, bluntly.

<<I am her favorite neighbour, though!>> Sarah pipes up.

<<Anna and Andrea try to kill me,>> you shoot back, <<If the bar was any lower it would be underground.>>

Taylor is staring at you again. <<Um?>>

<<Right, sorry,>> You run your fingers through your hair. <<Magical Girls hunt Witches, which are monsters born of despair and madness and which feed off of... well, people.>> You pause for a moment, speed-writing something on the whiteboard. <<Witches prey on negative emotions; despair, sadness, rage... that sort of thing, and they'll try to drive people further and further into that untill they, er, kill themselves. They do that by either trapping people inside their Barrier --which is this freaky pocket universe the Witch lives in-- or by "Kissing" them and influencing their actions.>>

Taylor bites her lip, obviously taking that information in. <<Okay, but what's that got to do with two other Magical Girls trying to murder you?>>

<<Because there's only so many Witches,>> you tell her, <<Even in Brockton Bay, you can't just stumble out of your apartment and expect to find one right there; you need a good chunk of territory to hunt in if you want to find them consistently.>> You pause. <<Or, you can cheat a little and go for places that tend to attract Witches. Cementeries. Hospitals->>

<<Like I do!>> Sarah chirps.

<<-... and apparently this school,>> you finish off. You sigh. <<Anna and Andrea used to have Winslow as part of their territory; if they're not busy fighting each other, they're trying to get it back from me. Or poaching.>>

<<For the record,>> Sarah butts in, <<The correct way to mooch off of Rachel's hard-won Witch magnet is to ask nicely.>>

Taylor looks like your answer has opened up even more questions for her.

"Why can't..." she mumbles, stops, and then goes with telepahy again. <<Why can't they just... stop hunting Witches?>>

... Silence. You were... Actually, you're not entirely sure what you were hoping. That this wouldn't come up?

Oh, well.

You glance right, towards Sarah. Your eyes shift to look at Emma, Madison and Shadow Stalker. Sarah's out of her grabbing range, and none of the bullies should have an angle to see what you're about to do. Which makes the really stupid thing you're about to do just this side of unthinkably dangerous.

You lay your right hand down on the table, cupping it so that it's like an upside-down bowl. Underneath, there's an almost-imperceptible flash of grey-ish blue light. You lift your hand, being careful to keep what's underneath hidden from everyone save Taylor.

Your Soul Gem glints in the fluorescent light of the classroom. It's a grey-blue colour, and the frame around it is a polished silver. At the top is a little square diamond-and-a-half, with a smaller gem inset and the incomplete half pointed down. You count your lucky stars that there's nothing immediately offensive about your Gem. You're not sure if you could handle that.

<<This,>> you tell Taylor, <<Is my Soul Gem, the source of all my powers as a Magical Girl. The proof of my Wish.>> You wait a moment for her to get a good look at it.

At your self.

<<And no, the name's not a play on words. It's exactly what it sounds like.>>

Taylor makes a noise. She was looking at your Gem with some discretion, but now you have to clear your throat before everyone notices her gawking at it.

<<... That's your soul.>> Her voice is tiny.

<<Yes,>> you tell her.

Taylor's stuck staring at... er, you. Again, you clear your throat and lean in towards her. "You know, it's a little rude to stare," you whisper at her, snapping her out of her daze. She still looks... horrified? Fascinated? Deeply unsettled? Somewhere between all three.

You tilt yourself. You wobble on the desk, enough that the oily black layer on the bottom sloshes around enough to be visible.

<<See that gunk?>> you ask Taylor, who gives you a look as if to say "Yes I can see the gunk on your freaking Soul, thank you very much", <<If you ever wanted to know what negative emotions look like... well, they look like that. Sadness, misery, loathing... Despair, basically. From what Kyuubey told me, a side-effect of having your soul outside your body is that you can't really get rid of that on your own.>> You give your Gem a tap. <<Instead it just... accumulates. Using my powers also fills up my Gem.>>

<<... why?>>

<<They run off of positive emotions,>> You answer her, <<And yes, I know that "powered by hope and happiness" sounds sappy as heck, but that's basically how it works.>> You hum. <<If you think of my Soul Gem like an engine->>

<<No!>> Taylor snaps. Her face flushes, and she speaks again, more subdued, although her pitch goes up towards the end, <<No, I meant... Why does being a Magical Girl involve your Soul being put into a rock!?>>

There's an awkward silence. Taylor blushes in embarassment at her outburst.

<<... Er, I didn't mean... uh... It's a really... pretty rock?>>

...You decide to have a little fun.

You flash her a cheeky smile, and in your most teasing tone of mental voice, say, <<Why thank you! I'm flattered that you think of me that way, but don't you think it's a little too soon?>>

Taylor stares at you for what feels like a few minutes. You decide to give her a hint, and nudge the Gem, making it wobble. <<Hello, Taylor,>> you say, and her eyes widen further when she realizes that your telepathic "voice" is coming from the gem.

It's Sarah's turn to make an uncomfortable-sounding noise. <<Oooh, I wish you didn't do that,>> she mutters, and you can feel her try not to shudder over the link. <<I really wish you didn't do that.>>

<<Don't you know this already?>> You ask Sarah.

<<Yes, but the way your remind people is the most uncomfy way concievable. Brrr!>

You mentally roll your eyes at Sarah. Glancing at Taylor, you get the distinct impression that your attempt at a joke was, er, less that successful. You're not sure it was even possible to look that uncomfortable.

<<Anyway!>> you say, covering the Gem with your hand. A mental nudge, and it's gone, back into its ring form, the flash of magic safely obscured. Taylor blinks owlishly, and visibly shakes herself.

<<Anyway,>> you repeat yourself, <<In order: Witches drop things called "Grief Seeds" when killed; using those, a Magical Girl can clean her Gem. Since Grief Seeds are the only way to keep your Gem clean, and Witches are the only source of Grief Seeds... well, they're really valuable for a Magical Girl.>>

An understatement if there ever was one.

<<And the reason our souls are outside out bodies is because...>> You frown, thinking back to when you were asking Kyuubey questions just like this one. <<From what I understand, half of it is because it's necessary for us to use magic --the "Magical" part of "Magical Girl"-- and half of it is because it makes us just this side of unkillable, since I don't need my body to be alive to be alive.>> A pause. <<And, before you ask; no, I don't know what happens when my Gem fills up. I don't want to know. I don't want to find out. Ever.>>

You let Taylor... process everything you've told her so far. She stares at you for a good, long while, and then her gaze just sort of... drifts forward. She takes a deep, shuddering breath, and raises her hands to hold up her head; palms pressing against the sides of her skull, fingers digging into her hair, and elbows on the desk. She takes another long, deep breath, and looks like she just found out exactly how deep the deep end of the pool is.

You don't exactly blame her. You busy yourself taking notes; between a slightly better teacher and actual interest from you, your History class notes are shaping up much better than your Math ones. You might have to share them with Taylor later, so even more reason to write everything down.

Eventually, Taylor finishes sorting everything you dumped on her inside her head. Or, you guess, she's shoved it into a corner so she can freak out later. <<Putting... all of that aside... Why haven't I heard about any of this before?>> she asks you.

You frown at your notes. You cross something out and write down a correction in the margin. <<Odds are, you did, actually. For example, that mass suicide that was getting 24/7 news coverage three weeks ago?>>

It takes Taylor a moment to realize what you're talking about. <<The one in Ohio? Yeah, it was all over the PHO forums. The news had people saying it must be some sort of unidentified Master cape, but some of the people online said that there was something... I dunno, off about it?>> She halts. <<Er. I have an account there.>>

<<Same. Handle's "FullyAutomaticMachineWand".>> You try not to grin. <<Sarah's is "Big_Sords_Dont_Lie", so you can block her.>>

<<Hey!>>

<<Anyway.>> You ruthlessly ignore Sarah's protests. It's a useful skill. <<Something not a lot of news outlets showed --and which did get passed around on PHO-- was that everyone involved had a little mark on their neck.>> You tap the appropiate place, pretending to be scratching an itch. <<Right here, shaped like some sort of glyph. That's what a Witch's Kiss looks like, and that is what a Witch attack looks like.>>

<<... And what about Magical Girls?>>

Ah. The other part you're not looking forward to talking about.

[-] You know, you've got some questions of your own. Time for some tit for tat, although you might want to be a polite about it.
-[-] What's up with Emma, Madison and Shadow Stalker?
-[-] ... Oh. Right. Sophia's Shadow Stalker. Might want to, uh, lead with that.
[-] Tell Taylor about the Magical Capes. Or: Why the First Rule of Magical Girl Shit is "Don't tell anyone about Magical Girl Shit".
 
Last edited:
<<Why can't they just... stop hunting Witches?>>

Rachel: "Because we'd just become a Witch? I don't know what souls taste like, and I don't wanna know."

Being properly serious, if Rachel already realizes that Soul Gems are completely literal... then the obvious question is "Why do Grief Seeds fix my literal soul?" Granted, it would be reasonable enough to stop at the simple conclusion that Grief Seeds are to Witches what Soul Gems are to Magical Girls. It just, well, leaves out the actual nature of Grief Seeds- and from what I'm guessing Rachel's Magic actually realizes Grief Seeds are even more important than Rachel consciously realizes.
 
I mean, if it were me I would probably assume that Grief Seeds eat Grief from your Soul Gem cause Witches are eldritch abominations powered by Grief. Grief Seeds hatching Witches when used up is about as far as I'd look when it comes to "I don't trust this at all, when's the other boot gonna fall."

It's a pretty big logical jump from "Grief Seeds from Witches eat Grief" to "Witches are Meguca".
 
I mean, if it were me I would probably assume that Grief Seeds eat Grief from your Soul Gem cause Witches are eldritch abominations powered by Grief. Grief Seeds hatching Witches when used up is about as far as I'd look when it comes to "I don't trust this at all, when's the other boot gonna fall."

It's a pretty big logical jump from "Grief Seeds from Witches eat Grief" to "Witches are Meguca".

Fair enough, besides the odd design similarities and that Grief Seeds can drain the "weird black stuff" from a Soul Gem, nothing really screams "Witches are Meguca". At best, one could possibly come to the conclusion they're connected somehow, but most would likely (deliberately) reject the idea they're the same thing.
 
At best, one could possibly come to the conclusion they're connected somehow, but most would likely (deliberately) reject the idea they're the same thing.

My opinion for this setting? The American girls suspect the connection (thus the whole 'turf war' ramped to eleven for good hunting grounds), but they shove the mere idea of contemplating Meguca -> Witch in a box labeled "Shit I do not want to think about, ever!".
 
Personally, I am more curious about the crossover stuff that Taylor is yet to have explained to her, but IC Rachel's been monologueing for a while and would probably appreciate some of her own curiosity satisfied.

[X] You know, you've got some questions of your own. Time for some tit for tat, although you might want to be a polite about it.
-[X] What's up with Emma, Madison and Shadow Stalker?
 
There's just, so many possibilities. Cauldron would totally do stupid experiments regarding Meguca and Witches, there's no way every Japanese Magical Girl is dead- and even if Leviathan was specifically trying to purge them, the uncontracted Potentials shouldn't have been noticeable. Walpurgisnacht shouldn't be dead because of Leviathan- she's practically Endbringer tier herself, the only notable sign of her presence being inexplicably weird weather. Finally, it would be easy to justify Ashley Taylor popping up in Brockton- I could imagine her Wish being like "I want to show the ABB the true power of kawaii", I can imagine her being mad at the ABB for being a horrible example of Asian Culture.
 
It occurred to me the hilarious irony of Rachel's brother joining the E88 to try and take care of her and the fact that "Rachel" is a very Hebrew name.

(also that 3/5 of the Magical Girls + Taylor have names of Hebrew origin though that's probably more representative of the wacky distribution of names that English has)

-[-] What's up with Emma, Madison and Shadow Stalker?
-[-] ... Oh. Right. Sophia's Shadow Stalker. Might want to, uh, lead with that.
Oh yeah the list of revelations that Taylor is going to have to sleep on tonight is extensive and not limited to just magic bullshit now.

Fun times for people that aren't her.
 
Last edited:
Next part will be up tomorrow afternoon.

Personally, I am more curious about the crossover stuff that Taylor is yet to have explained to her, but IC Rachel's been monologueing for a while and would probably appreciate some of her own curiosity satisfied.

Yes, now it's Rachel's turn to be rendered speechless.


*Search-fu*

Huh. Huh. Yeah, that's...

Hm.

It occurred to me the hilarious irony of Rachel's brother joining the E88 to try and take care of her and the fact that "Rachel" is a very Hebrew name.

That particular irony was something that I didn't have in mind when I created Rachel, but I think that makes it even better.

Oh yeah the list of revelations that Taylor is going to have to sleep on tonight is exstensive and not limited to just magic bullshit now.

I mean, she's just found out that the new girl in school is some sort of magical not-cape who kills nightmare monsters to stop her soul from imploding. Also, said girl is pushing towards being her friend and is treating the local junior gang members as a minor nuisance, to the point of straight-up inviting them to a street fight just to get things over with. There are apparently a significant number of these girls running around, and they routinely fight each other over territory, and her hellish school is prime real estate because the abominations they hunt to survive feed off of misery.

Also also, one of her bullies is one of the Wards, and one of her classmates is another magical not-cape who could've stepped in and stopped her misery at any point but just couldn't be bothered to do so. She's apparently the least awful of the girls who stake a claim in this part of Brockton Bay, not counting the one trying to befriend her.

... well, when you put it that way...

:V
 
Man, I just find it hilarious imagining a teenaged weeabo white girl literally telling an Asian Gang that they aren't Asian enough. Canonically, she was perfectly willing to go to another country, she would totally be willing to hop over a few states to show her displeasure at the ABB being insufficiently kawaii.

Lung: "Who the hell is this child?"
Ashley Taylor: "The girl who is gonna teach you how to be kawaii, whether you like it or not!"
Lung: "Why is some white girl going on about kawaii?"
 
Lung: "Who the hell is this child?"
Ashley Taylor: "The girl who is gonna teach you how to be kawaii, whether you like it or not!"
Lung: "Why is some white girl going on about kawaii?"

*after the MG Transformation*

Lung: HELL NO! I ALREADY HAD ENOUGH OF THIS SHIT BACK IN JAPAN BEFORE LEVIATHAN!
 
*after the MG Transformation*

Lung: HELL NO! I ALREADY HAD ENOUGH OF THIS SHIT BACK IN JAPAN BEFORE LEVIATHAN!

Lung, the literal anime villain, that's just plenty hilarious. Like there's one fic where he clearly takes offense at some Power Rangers existing.

Bakuda: "Pfft, you're scared of some 'pretty little princess'? What's she's gonna do, beat me to death with a teddy bear?"
Ashley Taylor: *Proceeds to beat her senseless with a teddy bear.*
 
Last edited:
Back
Top