■
Welcome to the Parahumans Online message boards.
You are currently logged in,
Placeholder_User
You are viewing:
• Threads you have replied to
• AND Threads that have new replies
• OR private message conversations with new replies
• Thread OP is displayed.
• Ten posts per page
• Last ten messages in private message history.
• Threads and private messages are ordered chronologically.
■
♦ Topic: East's Coast Worst
In: Boards ► Brockton Bay
Redcross (Original Poster) (First Responder)
Posted On Apr 26th 2011:
OKAY! So this thread is primarily a discussion thread about the current state of the city and the events that took place prior and during the month of April (Debut of Apeiron).
This ISN'T speculation about the future, it's a discussion about the current state of the poorer parts of the bay and what led it to this state. So let's stay on topic people.
And a reminder that as calm as Brockton Bay has been it still was a disaster just a couple days ago so please be respectful. I've already contacted mods to watch the threads.
(Showing page 1 of 5)
►TwoBitz
Replied On Apr 26th 2011:
2 really discuss the full scope of events, where do we even begin??? D.Piggot getting the job? formation of the BB gang scene and marquis?
TBH, BB has been a timebomb since 4ever. every problem compounds onto the next, and it just keeps goin.
i dont think there is any 1 thing that can take the full blame for this. its just compounding failure n short shortsightedness.
but the srysly, the biggest failure is how BB managed to stay in that position 4 so long w/out outside help. dont we have ppl 4 this kind of sit8tion?
the youth guard should have been on their asses the minute a ward was anywhere near lung TBH. everything w/ vista is just disgusting
►Drahtwire
Replied On Apr 26th 2011:
I'd like to start this thread of to a positive start.
Thank you to everyone who has been helping out in the Black Out Zone. We've been getting donations from everywhere and people from all over the city have been coming to help out.
The same goes for the first responders who've been risking their lives helping my neighbors out.
►MiteyLion
Replied On Apr 26th 2011:
There's something to be said about people coming together in times of stress, from our emergency workers and volunteers, to donations coming in from outside of BB.
Honestly, we haven't been appreciating our local emergency forces lately, with all this focus on the Protectorate imploding, they've been hit hard by the attacks. Current death toll is a lot, to say the least.
Normal people have been picking up the slack when the cape side of the city has been eating itself, and this might be Parahumans Online, but all of us normal folk are important too.
Y'all, go check around for charity drives or places you can donate too. Every bit matters.
Speaking on the political side of things: Director Piggot clearly has her days numbered. How did we get into this holding pattern where half the city was run by gangs and villains?
►EvilToaster
Replied On Apr 27th 2011:
Gotta say, I respect people who live in this city full time. I only passing by and got caught in all this nightmare and yet next day people just... start salvaging situation just fine. Sure, few long faces here and there but fact that people can rise up and keep pushing forward really inspiring hope.
I got caught in one of the blasts, but nothing serious, it was glancing blow at best. Although I've seen on my way to the hospital what other glancing blows could've done to me... brrr. I think medics going to let me go today, so question: where I can sign up to be a volunteer? Do I need some equipment with me? I have old pickup, it's not old enough to enter blackout zone, I checked (this list if someone interested; if your car IS NOT on this list DO NOT attempt to enter blackout zone!), but I have some construction equipment in there, might be useful. Thanks in advance!
►SapphicForSapphires (Cape Wife)
Replied On Apr 27th 2011:
I'm going to come right out and ask the question that is the entire reason I read this part of the boards. Does the Nazi infestation look like it is metastasizing?
►2schooled4cool
Replied On Apr 27th 2011:
As controversial as this might be i think things really went south when Marquis was caged, i still vividly remember feeling like the world was starting to tilt when The Brigade got on scene and were applauded for bringing him in (through methods that would have them all killed now days).
Was proven right in the following months as nice parks (nice for BB, atleast) went from the daily place to visit to the playground of the Hitler youth, or how without the organised neighborhood-watches suddenly the BBPD couldn't respond to break-ins and muggings in time anymore.
Not to blame New Wave or anything (atleast not the ones actually doing the heroing), it's just that Marquis was basically doing the Protectorates, cops and PRT's job for them, and suddenly they had to pick up the slack.
►VerifiedCape (Verified Cape)
Replied On Apr 27th 2011:
@2schooled4cool maybe you're too young to remember the stuff you think you remember, but Allfather filled that town with Hitler youth so badly they spilled into Boston before Marquis even triggered. Hell, noble Marquis, our lord and saviour (this is sarcasm), straight up butchered Iron Rain. On one hand - couldn't happen to a more deserving psycho - on the other hand - they nearly evacuated the city during the retaliation, which they've never had to do when a Cape was arrested and sent to trial.
Unless you try to trace the whole ungodly hour to Lung getting nicked, which is a really oversimplified take
►Camealot
Replied On Apr 27th 2011:
@MiteyLion
HoW dId We GeT iNtO tHiS hOlDiNg PaTtErN?
Well, I tell you how. Because the feckless government and its fat cat leaders couldn't be arsed to help people that don't donate to their overglorified protection racket. After all, why risk life and limb for people when you get no money out of it, right? Dirtbags.
@SapphicForSapphires
Ha! As if that'll ever happen. I can assure you, the skinheads will be out in force soon enough.
@2schooled4cool
EX-FUCKING-CUSE ME! Marquis? Making things better!? What bloody city did you live in? That monster was a thug and nothing more, he just had some nice PR because of his 'rules' and shit. I had to bury some friends because they ran afoul of of that skeleton with delusions of grandeur!
@VerifiedCape
Oh dear god, I remember that. Some of the worst days of my life, me and some friends actually pooled our funds to build a shelter afterwards in case it happened again, it was that bad. Seriously, Marquis was scum, may he rot in the Birdcage for the rest of his miserable life.
►NeoTheMatrixSpamBot
Replied On Apr 28th 2011:
Ah good to see people smacking around morons who whimpering about "ohh mah markisee mah hira". You never saw shit this bastard did to others, my pal left police because he once got to clean up what left of poor sobs that crossed Marquis's way, he had troubles looking at steaks for months. This shit ain't okay. For each person Marquis saved he murdered like five.
@EvilToster, here, bring all equipment you want, nobody would say no to that.
End of Page. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
(Showing page 2 of 5)
►CourtedByCrimson
Replied On Apr 28th 2011:
If you actually go and do the analysis, he probably would have saved more than he killed if he didn't consider certain crimes in "his" territory an instant death sentence but the man had zero chill on sexual assault and always stepped straight up to murder, especially if it was multiple people sexually assaulting one person. If you're using the five to one number though, that tells me you're only counting people who were saved from murder, not sexual assault victims who "probably would have survived" according to the police who were friends with one of his early public examples as to why cops should absolutely not sexually assault motorists under the pretense of a traffic ticket. When you look at the fact that most of the people he saved could be called oppressed, and most of the people he killed could be called in power, it is not surprising at all that his bad deeds got more airtime than his good ones. I'm in no way saying he was a hero, or that he didn't do the terrible things people say he did, but I am saying that in a world where nazis get to walk after admitting to murdering a hero like Fleur, it's not surprising that someone who killed to protect the oppressed got the book thrown at him in a way you'll never see with, say, Hookwolf or Victor, despite each of their comparatively impressive kill counts. Why? Because the DA cares about the kind of people Marquis' victims portrayed themselves as more than they care about the victims of the Empire.
►Camealot
Replied On Apr 28th 2011:
Excuse me, are you out of your mind? Marquis didn't give two fucks about how oppressed the people he saved were, just about his fucked up sense of right and wrong. The people he killed were 'in power'? Well, let me tell you something:
Will Burton
John Banker
Gabriel Washington
Three friends of mine, who got ganked by that sick fuck. A taxi driver, an office worker and the owner of a small store. None of them committed any crime, or had any influence on the politics of the city. Each left behind a grieving family. And all of that because some dickbag decided that he needed to 'make an example'.
Someone who killed to protect the oppressed my fat ass, the thing they needed protection from was that skeletor in a fucking skinsuit motherfucker. Seriously, he didn't do shit to protect anyone, he just didn't like other people committing crimes in his backyard, that was something only he could do, you know.
Also, your claim that Hookwolf wouldn't get the book thrown at him is ludicrous, since he got sentenced to the Birdcage as well, his buddies simply broke him out of the transport.
►NeoTheMatrixSpamBot
Replied On Apr 28th 2011:
@CourtedByCrimson, tell this to those smugglers my pal packed away. SMUGGLERS. Those weren't even some drug addicts, no-no, those were just dudes who pick up cargo in one place and offload it in other. Basically, porters, but illegal. Why they were killed and mutilated beyond belief? Why, they didn't pay the fee for Oh So Holy Marquis.
Frankly, anyone who claims that Marquis was somehow "good" for the city is delusional and one of those nutjobs who claim that ABB/Nazi dipshits are also good cuz "they keeping balance". If you want to see how well it ended look out of your window if you in BB and if you not then look up a tiny tiny local cape event called Ungodly Hour.
►MacrossPicrossWhen
Replied On Apr 28th 2011:
Don't know anything about the other two, but the daughters of John Banker, VP of Medhall's opioids division, who could loosely be described as an office worker, were absolutely not grieving him when he died. Any tears were of relief. Also kind of funny that they announced the exact day Hookwolf was being transferred on the news. They didn't do that with any other villains, not since they took down Madcap.
►Judge (Moderator)
Replied On Apr 28th 2011:
@Camealot @NeoTheMatrixSpamBot, while your outrage is understandable, it is very out-of-topic at this point. You two will be let off with a warning, with @CourtedByCrimson getting a bigger one for exacerbating the issue. Any further mention of Marquis-related incidents that don't have any relevance to current topic will be met with further infractions.
►Camealot
Replied On Apr 28th 2011:
Alright, warning received.
On another note, anyone has any idea what it's like on the ground in the former ABB territory? Recently a lot of 'legitimate businesses' got exposed and subsequently stormed by police. With Lung taken down for good and the gang gone, just how bad is the damage? Are there even any shops left there? Or any houses still standing?
Cause, you know the shelter I mentioned previously? Well, we stocked it with enough supplies for all eight of us and our families to last for two years, and since there are only two of us left and all our families have left the Bay, we have a lot of surplus food, clothing, etc. So if any of you guys need it, give me a call and I'll see about sending some of it to you.
►NeoTheMatrixSpamBot
Replied On Apr 28th 2011:
Well. If we going on topic, than it was biggest shitshow this city saw PERIOD. And this city saw all out brawl between all gangs which culminated in fight between Teeth and S9 dipshits. God I was never ever more relived that I ditched this city and left to Boston.
While we - and by "we" I mean me, my friends and all our relatives - did make it out of the last disaster without loses, this one... Well.
Marcus Bright was a good man, had amazing wife and two beautiful children. All of that was wiped out without a trace when some ABB piece of shit fucking erased their flat out of existence. We dont even have anything to bury, not even albums or something. Four people, full family, all of their belongings, just gone an instant. I am not envying his brother, who will have to deliver news to his parents and a third brother back in LA.
After this is over, I am going to do my darnedest to persuade all my friends to leave this city for good. No offense to BB, but I would like to see my friends alive and well, thank you very much.
@Camealot, try asking people there, they trying to coordinate volunteers and distribute help.
►Camealot
Replied On Apr 28th 2011:
@NeoTheMatrixSpamBot
You and his family have my utmost condolences.
On that note, I'd like to mention Fabian O'Connel, a 20 year veteran of the BB Fire Fighters, who perished during the Ungodly Hour due to a piece of shrapnel. Rest in peace old chap.
No offense is taken, if you can get your friends out of this hellhole, I'd recommend you do it. With news that the Butcher and Lost Garden are in town, and Uber & Leet's whereabouts unknown, I foresee no end to the violence plaguing this dungheap.
Thank you for the information.
►2schooled4cool
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
You'd think that hospitals, even our glorious capitalist ones, would be able to handle disasters better but they've practically fallen in on themselves.
Not throwing any flack on the nurses and doctors sweating their asses off on their >24 hour workdays but the general management of resources and beds, especially in the bigger places, is abhorrent.
I've legit heard from a handful of people (mostly friends and coworkers) how they expected patients with broken legs, major skin burns and skull damage to be up and going within hours instead of days.
►Septiumsenpriu
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
@2schooled4cool I'm pretty sure that's because they relied on Panacea too much, this kind of thing is what NEPA-5 is supposed to prevent, and this is a good reason why. (Not to say that it doesn't have it's flaws, but it's got a good reason for existing.)
End of Page. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
(Showing page 3 of 5)
►BrocktonBroiled
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
She's been volunteering because NEPEA says she can't get paid. If she'd been getting paid all along, at least the budget would be there now that they need it. Budgets work on a use it or lose it basis. It didn't look like anyone else needed it so Medhall's CEO got half and the hospital admin who gave it to him got the other half.
►LunaC
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
@BrocktonBoiled That reminds me of something I've been asking around about that nobody seems to know the answer to: Just how much work has that girl been putting in?
Companies don't have to track volunteer work, since it's free Good Samaritan labor, but it's good to do it anyways in order to help the management figure out which of their employees they should not be paying for sitting around on their asses during volunteer work hours. Helps everyone keep their practiced workers practiced.
And yet, by all accounts I can find, Miss Panacea has been putting in those hospital hours for years and not one official has bothered to actually log her overall time. I'm trying not to bash you guys at the hospitals, you clearly keep everyone you can in one piece while she's not there, but what exactly have you all been doing while miss magic-hands sends a patient out the doors every five minutes for hours on end?
►BrocktonBroiled
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
Believe it or not, Brockton General is one of two hospitals in Brockton Bay to place in the top five in the country in terms of neurosurgery, largely because Panacea can't touch brains. You hear talk about "medical tourism" to Brockton Bay and it's not people waiting in line for Panacea. It's our neurosurgeons.
►LunaC
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
@BrocktonBoiled I'll admit I did not know that, but my point was missed. A hospital, a full fledged, worthy-of-the-name hospital, is not run on neurosurgeons alone. If it was, it'd be called a neurosurgery clinic, not a hospital.
So I ask again, rephrased: what did all you non-neurosurgeons do while Panacea blazed trails through your wards during her hours? Again, I'm not trying to bash, blame, or slander any of y'all, especially not while you're eyeball deep in shit after UH. But someone has clearly fucked up something if I can't find a single record of Panacea's hours on any BB hospital website, aside from her initial volunteer testing on the PRT's website.
Did she literally just walk in, roll up her sleeves, and start working? Every day? That's not how hospitals are supposed to work people. That's not how any business is supposed to work.
►EverydayMan
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
I can't comment on Panacea's situation with the hospitals, but I can venture a guess as to how things got so bad in the city.
The general gist of things is, from a law enforcement perspective, it makes zero sense for the Protectorate or PRT to exist as outside of normal law enforcement. The Protectorate should be treated the way that S.W.A.T teams were treated before the PRT came around - they existed, part of an existing organizational structure, and were used for very specific purposes. They weren't a separate organization - there was none of the jurisdiction insanity that currently exists today (I don't know if it's as bad in other cities as it is in Brockton.)
It seems like every time you hear about some Empire thugs getting arrested now ('now' being prior to 'that night'), their cases would end up getting taken over by the PRT because the leader of the gang is a parahuman - sometimes even when a parahuman wasn't involved. The thing is... the PRT isn't set up to deal with normal crime. It never has been; it's meant to be the anvil to the Protectorate's hammer. And maybe it works better in other cities where crime isn't so intrinsically tied to parahuman gangs, but here it causes jurisdictional and budgetary clusterfucks, and thus makes all the organizations involved work less efficiently. The information exchange is broken, with the PRT often hiding or simply not telling normal cops information they deserve to know, and thus puts them in more danger than necessary.
My brother is on the force, and he could tell you of tons of stories about cases being stolen out underneath them by the PRT, with often no real justification being given. And more often than not, they 'seem' to screw things up, or just ignore them because 'oh, we have other concerns.' From what my brother told me, a particularly nasty case one of his colleagues had in a school here a few months ago got swiped with no explanation, and when they tried to find out the status of the investigation a week or so ago, they found out that nothing had been done as of yet.
►CSellsCShells
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
Gonna be frank, BB took a supersonic kick to the balls when Leviathan showed his fugly mug, and it's been dying a slow death of gonad hemorrhaging ever since.
See, for those of y'all that failed history class, BB used to be a pretty busy little port. Not the biggest per say, but most everyone who couldn't make Boston's mile long shipping queue would end up dropping by Brockton Bay as their next choice. This meant that BB got an average amount of business, and was actually on the global oceanic trade map.
Now, can anyone guess what happened to global oceanic trade when an aquatic Endbringer popped up out of the eldritch depths of the sea? Go on, guess. Nevermind that by all accounts the fucking lizard's never even been recorded pasting a boat that hasn't been in a city he was smashing, when thar be dragons under those waves, no corporation wants to be the brave one.
So oceanic trade got dragged out to an empty parking lot and shot full of holes, and now BB is a port city with no trade. And then a bunch of maritime nutjobs got pissed there was no work because of no trade, so they blocked off the fucking bay with the biggest damn boat they could find. So now BB is a port city that can't port.
Couple this with the railroad as an entity going to complete hell as containment zones started springing up like weeds, and BB finds itself dropped to priority numero nope in the eyes of the world overall.
►King_of_the_sea
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
@CSellsCShells those "maritime nutjobs" weren't mad because there was no work they were mad because a bunch of the were either laid of or had a massive pay cut while the owners of the port had the biggest bonus in 15 years. Like i get that they are an easy target because their protest got out of hand but they were not the problem. if you want somebody to blame, blame the merchants it's because of them that the railroad the other major source of income got abandoned.
►codexmaster
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
The Bay's history really just is one long, slow, fuckup. The worst thing happens, at the worst possible time, in the worst circumstances, rinse and repeat. It's like somebody channeled every surrounding city's bad luck into the place. Shit has been hitting the fan for decades, the fan was just set at a really slow speed and it was only a few balls of shit at a time.
The Leviathan might have started the cascade, but it's snowballed due to human actions.
There should have been a larger response years ago to handle the local issues and fix the gaping holes in the system. Damn profit incentives and media coverage over peoples lives.
Wonder where they stuck the case files? The trashcan? Even just taking a deeper look into the lineups of the gangs versus the heros should have been cause for some investigation or support. BB has been crawling with capes, where was the outside regulation? Off in more prosperous cities. Still, you'd think we'd be able to prioritize one of the 'cape capitals' rather than just allowing the villain scene to grow unchecked for so long. But I guess that would have choked BB's last revenue stream in its crib.
The most irritating thing about all of this is that realistically, there is no one to blame. There are many, many people who contributed, but each were a tiny cog of idiocy and short term planning in this massive machine of incompetency. Sure, a few people fucked up more than the rest, but definitely not everything. Theres not many people we can point fingers too, just systemic issues compounded in shitty situations.
(Yes Director Piggot did absolutely fuck up here, not denying that, but theres more complexity to the situation)
BB has basically been a hellhole run by drugged up supervillains for years. Now it's just completely literal.
It's like everything in this city was balancing on fucking toothpicks, and it falling down has initiated some horrible goldbergs machine of shitty situations. Every goddamned thing has apparently been held together with tape, a single person, and hopes and prayers.
I wonder how badly would things have been if BBB/NW hadn't been around to cover the Protectorate's asses for so long? Was their presence a reassuring thing to everyone else? How did NW even survive for so long without any investigation on Panacea with the Youth Guard? If she was that vital to keep the medical system from collapsing, shouldn't help have been sent, rather than just fudging the paperwork to keep exploiting a child? Who made the calls on letting the literal Nazi infestation get so bad?
What even is this cities Wards program? Has Piggot ever talked with the police or anybody, at any point?
Figuring out how bad BB has been is like trying to solve a rubix cube, except it's covered in shit and on fire, and you're trying to roller blade on a treadmill at the same time, all well there's a gun to your head.
TLDR: BB sucks, go donate and support emergency workers.
►ThatGuy
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
I mean, the PRT may leak like a sieve but it's not like anyone empire would go to jail even if the police did keep the cases. It's practically an open secret that at least 90% of them are empire. I wouldn't be surprised if most empire thugs aren't even brought in after being "arrested". Hell, I'm pretty sure I saw the same thug walking the street barely an hour after getting cuffed once.
►Camealot
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
Alright, so you wanna know why the Bay's a shithole? Stupidity and fucking laziness, that's why.
We can blame the fucking sea lizard all we want, but the main reason why trade decreased is that everywhere's fucked due to capes showing up and exacerbating every issue they involve themselves in. Because of that stability has gone down the drain, best seen with Africa (where there's almost only warlords now) and China (where the fucking CUI made sure that they became an isolated international pariah). Nobody's gonna trade overseas if there's a) nobody to trade with because there's either no government at all or a totalitarian dictatorship that can at any point utterly fuck you over and b) some cape can at any point decide that piracy is fun, and powers make all the difference in combat. So trade was decreasing anyways.
So when the remaining merchants looked for a port at the Eastern Coast they saw both Brockton and Boston very close by, one of which had more infrastructure than the other, and it wasn't the Bay. In other words, Brockton became superfluous.
But there was still some trade going through BB, so the port remained open. But with a lower demand for their services the fuckers working at the dock got their pay docked, because guess what, that's how the fucking economy works. Instead of doing something productive, these chucklefucks decided to sink some tankers in the Bay, insuring that no ships could come to the Bay, putting themselves out of work. Fucking brilliant of those guys, truly a scheme worthy of Accord.
Anyways, now with everyone even remotely connected to maritime trade (which amounts to a lot more people than just the dockworkers) out of work, a lot of people turned to crime. Nobody wanted to invest into the city because having the inhabitants literally sink you investment to the fucking bottom of the sea discourages that rather thoroughly.
Now, crime was an issue before, the E88 has a long history in the Bay, this truly kicked it off. Local lawenforcement didn't have the means to kick the gangs out and nobody outside the Bay cared enough about this place to send anything but empty platitudes, allowing the gangs to entrench themselves to such an extent, that the removal of the ABB will actually result in a significant drop of the city's GDP and income, because so many businesses were connected to the gang.
So yeah, that's why the place is a shithole. Political and economic instability, dumb fucks who couldn't find their way out of a wet paper bag even if you handed them a map, and a political system which refused to do anything about the city's issues so long as nobody was paying attention.
End of Page. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
(Showing page 4 of 5)
►Mewwmix
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
So, TLDR: everythings gone to shit, and everyone in power managed to fuck it up. Also, capes suck.
Yup, business as usual!
►NeoTheMatrixSpamBot
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
Amen to that. Especially "Capes suck" part. BB may be was a shithole, but before those powered freaks started running the show properly, it was at least tolerable shithole.
►Judge (Moderator)
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
Okay let's pull it back on the Anti-Parahuman sentiments we're getting really close to breaking PHO's discrimination rules.
►BeleagueredModerater (Moderator)
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
Hey everyone, I'm here in this thread, reading it. Please resume following the rules like I know you all can. I don't want to have to infract anyone. Yes, that's right. We got so many reports that TWO mods showed up. That doesn't make anyone happy.
►Dread_P1rate_Steve (Shipping Enthusiast)
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
The economy and political situation in Brocton is definitely endemic to many towns that were on the rise in the advent of parahumans. Said problems, mostly class disparities, were only made worse with the emergance of the endbringers. While I will always support unions the Association at the time had made what was probably the worst decision they couldve made at the time, blockading the bay lead to an already anemic maritime industry being finally taken off life support as the Mayor and several companies at the time already saw industry in Brocton as a money sink and not as investments.
There have actually been several proposals for what to do with the boat graveyard, seeing as many of the companies who's boats were sunk there sought to recoup losses in any manner and the private vessels were already removed.The problem is politically and economically the amount of effort spent on the graveyard isnt worth it. As a matter of fact some the proposals have been posted very publically by both the DAU(can be found within the news & events page on their website) and Brockton University's maricultural department(can be found in their school newsletter section they have many articles dedicated to the proposal and subsequent rejection). Both host some very promising ideas the problem is scraping up the political and physical capital to do it, and with a city that's bleeding tax payer money just to keep the status quo Brockton isnt going to see a whoke lot of relief effort done without some major federal intervention.
Unfortunately Brockton has always been at the bottom of the list when it comes to economic stimulus it seems. Like as much as I want to blame the PRT and the shitshow that is jurisdiction in Brocton Bay I can legitimately say Piggot was handed an old faulty pressur cooker when she took up the position. Now, the government on the other hand I can definitely place direct blam onto, they shouldve at the very least called in the coast guard to deal with the blockade in a manner that didn't wreck Brocton's shipping industry.
►Camealot
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
@Dread_P1rate_Steve
Oh, thank god, FINALLY someone who gets it. Yeah, of course no company wants to set up here, after all, you wouldn't build a house in a fucking swamp. So long as crime is so ridiculously high and the workers too willing to trash your property, nobody's going to look at BB and be like 'yeah, this looks like a great place for a factory'.
It also has to be mentioned that the supply chains have already adapted to the loss of the Brockton harbor, so even if the Graveyard was cleared, we most likely still wouldn't see any real recovery.
Still doesn't excuse half the shit she's done, yeah, she was handed a fucking trashheap but for fucks sake, not getting dozens of people kidnapped and enslaved really shouldn't be so fucking hard.
I can't believe I'm doing this, but I'm gonna have to, ah, defend the gov here. Having been a minor bureaucrat at the time, I was somewhat privy to the going ons at the time, and I can tell you this, shit was really chaotic. Nobody knew what was going on, everyone was screaming their heads off or alternatively not saying anything at all, shit was fucked. So when we got told that somebody was blockading the Bay, we first had to ask for confirmation, because shit was so bad. Just to illustrate my point, a few moments before that, we got a message claiming that Kaiser was agitating the rioters. He wasn't, but that should just show you how bad it was. Now, with the city on fucking fire, it took a whole while to reach someone and tell them to check out the fucking Bay. They in turn needed a longass time to actually get somewhere where they could actually overlook the port, and then some more time to report back. By the time we actually had confirmation what those fuckers were doing, the crazy assholes were already scuttling the fucking tankers.
So yeah, I feel really sick for doing this, but the government for once was not responsible for that fuck up.
►SirSailsAlot
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
Alright so I've been mostly unaware of Brockton's history until this thread but this Piggot woman? How long has she been Director. Like from all the shit the city's been through before the March and Bakuda incident, did Piggot somehow keep the PRT from falling apart through that? And if so, how did she fuck this situation up so spectacularly? Like with the city still standing after a conflict between the Teeth and the S9, the Empire and Marquis escalating things and whatever the hell Lung's been doing after fighting an Endbringer to a standstill, there's no way Piggot's just been getting lucky. and if she wasn't in charge during this shit how did the person before her fuck up hard enough that she needed to replace them?
►Camealot
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
@SirSailsAlot
Director Piggot became the Director almost exactly a decade ago, back in the late spring of 2001.
Ah, but you see, here's the issue: Piggot did dick to actually kick out the gangs and reduce crime. She just contained it, made sure it happened away from the rich folks homes and was generally kept quiet. It helped that the gangs themselves mostly kept it on the down low, to keep people from outside the Bay from noticing. Inside, we just dealt with the shit situation as best as we could, which wasn't all that well.
And once again you prove that you're not a Brocktonite. See, Piggot kept the 'peace' in the same way the US government prevented a race war after the Civil War in the South: she didn't. Just as the Klu Klux Klan was free to murder blacks who couldn't fight back, so too were the gangs allowed to persecute their reign of terror against the civilian populace.
Piggot maintained a facade of peace so the rich fuckers could sleep soundly at night, by sweeping all of the skeletons her policies resulted in under the rug. All that that fucking cunt March did was, was tear that rug from right under her self-righteous ass. All of the shit that had built up over the years spilled over in a single hour, the results of which speak for themselves.
Actually, a lot of these things occurred before Piggot became Director. Remember, Marquis, who kicked out the S9, the only good thing he ever did in his scummy life, was arrested in 2000. A year before she took office. So she never had to deal with a true crisis before.
After she took office, the gangs were happy to play her game. They got effectively free hand in their territories, so long as they didn't do anything too outrageous. Fucked over the poor, but who gives a shit, right?
Director Ludwig actually retired due to medical issues, if I remember correctly he suffered from a heart attack.
►Farslayyer
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
@Camealot
Only complaint here is that the 'UH' definitely was not a hour. CF vs Lung was an hour-the bombing, attacks, and general chaotic mess was definitely longer. I hate to agree with Big Goverment, but yeah, calling it the Ungodly 'Hour' undersells things
.
.....I mean, the absolute farthest you can stretch the situation is....two weeks, maximum, but still!
►Camealot
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
Oh, I'm in full agreement with you here. We're still dealing with the aftermath of the situation. But all most people would focus on was the UH, which really showed the fissures underlying Brockton Bay's foundation. Guess I wasn't being clear enough.
End of Page. 1, 2, 3, 4
(Showing page 5 of 5)
►Farslayyer
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
Ah yeah, sorry about the confusion there! It's a annoyingly common issue. Though, I guess you can't really blame people for fixating on the whole 'Apeiron vs Gigantic Fuck You Dragon' that much. Too much happening at the same time, I guess.
Speaking of the events surrounding that fight, since when has Brockton had a 'no help from villains' policy when regarding massive threats? I mean, Marquis basically did the Protectorates job for them that one time. Half of the reason that BB hadn't been set on fire before this was other villains taking out villains or self regulating. TBH, Ludwig was a indecisive dumbass, but he would have taken the warnings we got a bit more seriously. 'Ah yes, supplying one (1) set of knives to some random villians means you are insane and untrustworthy. Goodbye!'
►Camealot
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
Don't sweat it, at least you were polite about it.
Why, since Director Piggot took over. What did you think?
►SirSailsAlot
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
To be fair I wouldn't be surprised if that was a common stance for other directors (not counting the S-class Truce, that's federal policy). The only difference is that other directors are never going to dealing with what Brockton classifies as a "massive threat" and any that are even close quickly rethink their priorities.
►Camealot
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
Not really. You see, what you have to keep in mind is that villains are still people, shit people, but people nonetheless. And that means that they have friends and homes and shit. So when that gets threatened, they oftentimes help out. Best example I can think of was back in 2007, in Detroit, when that big fire broke out there, a small gang of villains, the Sled Gang, if I remember correctly helped out with rescue operations. The local PRT let them, because even though they are criminals, they were helping people in that moment. Now, just to make clear, the fire was entirely natural, not cape caused.
Something like that wouldn't happen in Brockton. This shithole is one of the worst places regarding hero/villain cooperation, in that they wouldn't piss on the other if they were on fire. So yeah, while Piggot certainly isn't unique in this regard, she is the exception rather than the rule.
End of Page. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
■
♦ Topic: Apeiron and Marquis
In: Boards ► America ► Brockton Bay
Point_Me_@_The_Sky (Original Poster) (New Wave)
Posted On Apr 29th 2011:
Hey all... So, the week's been a bit rough and I haven't really made any posts because of Family drama, but I'm back. Most likely. Anyway, I'm rambling, so here's my predicament.
Everyone knows Apeiron now, right? Enigmatic Artificer holds to his contracts to an almost religious degree, has tried to keep civilian casualties to a minimum in all of his fights?
So I came home a few days ago, before the Ungodly Hour to hear my mother rambling on about how much Apeiron and Marquis are alike, you know, with rigid sets of rules/codes of conduct, the fact that they are mostly polite, and it got me thinking, how alike are they.
Like Apeiron hasn't actually done any criminal stuff since his first recorded appearance, and I've heard that Tinkertech sale is dubious in a legal sense, same with healing my sister. He hasn't asked for protection money, he hasn't taken territory and he hasn't killed anyone on purpose other than Lung, but the PRT tells me even that's up in the air because of Lung's regeneration. That, and I don't even know if he was originally wanting to be a villain. When he talked to my sister, he said that he considered going to New Wave, but looking back, I doubt he'd consider it now.
And for all of Marquis' supposed honour, he wasn't above killing civilians if they didn't follow his rules or if they, you know, told him to fuck off and leave them alone.
Honestly, I can't see where my mom was coming from and I'd like to hear your opinions.
(Showing page 1 of 5)
►Sothoth
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
First off, let me be the first to say on PHO welcome back, and I hope you're doing okay there GG.
Second, what the hell? Besides being more of a Rogue Tinker than a villainous one, there is NO similarity between the two, as you have said. Marquis has his fiefdom, Apeiron seems to be more of someone who tried to help and gets rebuffed, leading to the fiasco we had today.
I, personally, didn't live through Marquis's era in BB, so I may be biased. Any counterarguments?
►DapperGator
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
Alright, I'm not all that well versed in the cape scene in Brockton Bay, not living there and all of that, but even for me a short wiki-crawl made it clear that there really is no comparison between the two.
Make no mistake, Marquis was a criminal. irregardless of his code of conduct, it doesn't matter if you murder someone because you want to steal his stuff or because he violated your personal sense of honor, murder is still murder. And looking at just how many people ended up in body-bags because of him, it's no wonder they put him in the Birdcage.
Meanwhile, the closest thing to a crime Apeiron has committed is selling those knives to the Undersiders, and at least according to a friend of mine, who has some experience in that field, depending on the exact details of that transaction, he could easily be cleared of any wrongdoing.
Similarly, Marquis had a 'territory', as ill-defined as it was, meanwhile Apeiron has made no claims to any part of the town, or even has an area he frequents more often than others. Based on this document where someone has compiled a summit between the various underground elements of the city, Apeiron never even mentioned the slightest interest in owning territory, even declining any claim regarding the ABB's former holdings.
So all that leaves is 'polite behavior' and 'rigid code of conduct' which are traits a lot of people, even those who aren't capes, exhibit. So yeah, I really don't see the similarities.
►EverydayMan
Replied On Apr 29th 2011:
Well, that's a loaded question, and probably not for the reasons you think. Opinions on Marquis tend to be fairly... diverse around Brockton, depending on who you talk to, so I'll do my best to provide some impartial insight.
First of all, before anything else, Marquis was a villain. He had a body count, and he had no qualms about hurting people to get what he wants. Let's put that out there now. There's a reason why his organization was able to stand against Allfather's Empire back in the day, despite outnumbered on capes (to my knowledge, Marquis didn't have any capes in his group besides himself.) And it was due to his willingness to do ruthless things that would make the Empire blink in hesitation.
That being said, as you mentioned, he held to certain... codes is too strong of a word. And honestly, I can't say how accurate it really is because even after he went away a lot of people who had worked for him wouldn't sell him out. He didn't attack women and children. He had his men treat rapists or dealers trying to sell to kids caught his territory... harshly, to say the least (not that I can disagree). Whether those are the rose-tinted rumors or not, I can't say (PHO wasn't what it is now, back then, so we didn't have access to guys in the know like @ Bagrat). But what I can remember is that when Marquis and his group were driven to violence, it was kept contained to their targets.
Nothing like the current crop of E88 or even Lung's rampages before the UG. Hell, Lung used to go off and we'd lose blocks to damage or fires. Empire shitheads often cause as much damage as possible, so long as they're not downtown. The Merchants do whatever the hell they want, often tearing up the streets due to Squealer-mobiles destroying pavement and asphalt or just clipping buildings because the crazy bitch tried to take a corner too sharply.
I think some of those who maintain those Rose-tinted goggles of the man remember that more than anything else - the fact that if a cape showdown he was involved in began, that it wouldn't spread to where they were and they'd at least be safe. It's a selfish view of things, but one that you can't ignore. Nothing like the capes we have today (present company excluded, of course.) If anything, Marquis likely reminded people of the old Mafiosos rather than a traditional cape gang. Yes, they were criminals, but they had a veneer of respectability, and often shared that respect even to their enemies unless crossed. Quite frankly if even half the rumors are correct, Marquis (without powers) would have fit in well with the old Mafia down in New York back in the age of the mob.
As to the comparison to Apeiron... I think it's an odd comparison, and mostly just because despite all the commotion he's caused, we really haven't seen enough of Apeiron to really draw a conclusion one way or the other. People want to blame him for the UG, but anyone with a lick of sense knows that is BS of the highest-order. I'm not advocating for him - I don't know enough to, and the man himself seems to have no interest in talking, despite how much camera posing he seems to do - but it's clear the blame for the recent insanity is with the ABB. But outside of the initial sale of a set of knives (even if they were crazy super-knives) to the Undersiders... has he actually 'done' anything illegal yet, or at least anything that wouldn't be tolerated by a vigilante or independent hero?
I don't know. Maybe he's just has the reputation, but Apeiron doing any of the kind of stuff that Marquis used to do, or even the E88 or ABB.... just seems beneath him.
►ExStellar8
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
Kinda feels like Brandish is equating apples and oranges there doesn't it? Monkey Steel may not be held in the greatest official standing with the legal cape scene, and sticks to his contract code of conduct like superglue, but aside from those correlations, it's essentially comparing a hacker to a mob boss.
No to... bring up or belabor a sore subject, but Brandish may be feeling pretty bitter that Aperion's Thinker power insights ended up exposing her infidelities, and conflating him with Marquis, New Wave's arch nemesis back when they were the Brockton Bay Brigade, lets her justify her way into seeing him as the root cause of all her problems.
►
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
Territory wise i understand why apeirons not so interested in it. He could probably claim the whole city if he really tried. He's obviously got the resources he needs, if he didnt we might be dealing with territorial behavior. What he'd do in the turf is up for debate.
Marquis was like a mafia don, Apeiron's more like a corporate overlord
terrifying, you dont actually know much about him, and he probably has too much power for anyones good, but probably not going to murder you unless you really piss him off. More interested in the returns from his real estate than selling drugs and breaking kneecaps
Code of conduct wise, marquis was just not women and kids and everywhere else he was a shitty person. Apeiron is a far messier situation, like, we know he isnt up for mass murder of civilians and thats obviously a plus, but like, not saying much. rumor is that he refused a contract with the butcher, which is also sick, but also not saying much. he's not on the far end of Evil, but neither was Marquis.
His ethics are obviously questionable tho, it might just be a power dynamics thing. hes so far out of Marquise league that he wouldnt bother with the whole gang stuff even if he wanted too
What a nice start to this thread tho, before it devolves into violence!
►Fafnoire
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
While everyone seems to agree that Marquis and Apeiron being quite I have to wonder how they'd see the other if they were both operating in Brockton.
I might not know much about Marquis but his devotion to his set of rules is famous. I imagine there'd be a certain amount of respect afforded to Apeiron for his own devotion to a self imposed(?) code. Though that would have to depend on how Bakuda and March fit into his code. He might abhors their mutilation as they're both women (though scum would probably be a better descriptor). Then again he killed Iron Rain so how much he might bend his code based on the situation couldn't be said.
On Apeiron it's even harder to say. Considering the Empire and the Merchants are still here it's unlikely he can get rid of the gangs without the S-class alarms ringing off the hook. I imagine Apeiron would leave Marquis alone to prevent others from coming into places he can't defend who might be worse (devil you know vs devil you don't after all).
Any holding actions between the two would of course only last until their rules conflicted, but Marquis would still probably outlast the other gangs from his time.
►DapperGator
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
@EverydayMan
Huh, that's actually an angle I hadn't considered. Probably becuse I don't live there. But yeah, that would explain why some people fondly remember the man.
Considering what you have just revealed, I'm surprised just how reasonable and neutral your response was. So no issues there.
@Yamm0
That's rather insightful of you. And I have to admit, imagining Apeiron as an CEO is quite an amusing image. Congratulation my good sir, I'm pretty sure you've just created a meme.
►Meme-Masted
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
Challenge accepted. Although I'm sure the image of Survey dressed up as a secretary will cause quite a few jaws to drop.
►NeoTheMatrixSpamBot
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
BULLSHIT THEY ARE ALIKE. Your mother was the one who took the bony bastard down, how THE FUCK she can say they anything alike?! I dont remember Marquis risking his life to remove tinkertech bombs from peoples' heads. I dont remember him going on streets and fighting various dipshits to protect citizens. I dont remember him being any help to general public and I certainly cant remember him saving the city.
Marquis, for all his oh so holy code of honor, was murdering people left and right whenever he felt like it. I dont think Apeiron even tried to kill someone. Aside from ABB cape assholes and their nerd allies, but that doesnt count, anyone would've tried to murder those after seeing shit Bakuda was pulling off (I know how mad bitch evaded her Kill Order, but what the fuck PRT, how in the world Lung, Oni Lee, March, Uber and Leet didnt got one?!)
End of Page. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
(Showing page 2 of 5)
►Gumayusi
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
I can see where your mother was coming from - bitterness and delusion.
To equate a ruthless villain with a person who in his first appearance healed your daughter, on second saved hundreds of conscripted victims, on third - all but destroyed ABB economically, leaving it as anything but a bunch of stupid gangers and capes and finally - on fourth saved the whole DAMNED CITY! You need to be either an idiotic PRT director or woman unable to accept that when her family ruined as a result of her adultery coming in the clear, the one to blame is not a person who uncovered her cheating, but the adulteress herself. That is to say - your mother.
►Judge (Moderator)
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
@NeoTheMatrixSpambot Watch your language. The sentiment is understandable, but tone it down a bit.
►
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
Quick question: Why the fuck would we trust Brandish of all people about Apeiron? Like, there are only a handful of options that are worse. Mostly Piggot.
NW is fucked over but TBH....that's kinda entirely on them unless hes actually way older than we all thought and is a precog. No offense GG but thats all yalls shit, not Apeirons fault. I mean, he shouldnt have dropped it randomly like that, especially if he expected the bombing spree, but he was working with TT
►Camealot
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
Excuse me, but is your mother on fucking drugs? Apeiron and Marquis, a-fucking-like? Really? Like, fucking seriously?
What kind of bullshit is that!? Marquis was a fucking butcher who murdered people for fucking laughs and somehow got some idiots to buy into the fact that that he had 'standards', which somehow justified his fucking murders, made him any less of a piece of shit than he was.
Compared to that, where's Apeiron's bodycount? Funny thing, I can't seem to fucking find it. But it certainly isn't around 80 or so.
What are we supposed to blame him for? The fuck-ups of Piggot and co.? That he defended himself against the ABB? That he sold some knives to some idiot wannabe robbers? Yeah, he did that last thing, and I want him in court for that shit, because what the fuck was he thinking. But really? Apeiron similar to fucking Marquis? Don't make me fucking laugh.
►EverydayMan
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
Thanks DapperGator. I know Marquis is a touchy subject around the bay (as a few posts have already shown), so I'm trying to not let my personal feelings affect my answer to the kid's question.
And while I'm not a mod and wouldn't presume to have the ability or patience for it, let's try not to insult the kid's mom when she's just trying to understand why her mom might think this.
►TeaPot (Moderator)
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
@Camealot Swearing is allowed but you seriously need to cool it. This thread is being watched folks, keep it civil, otherwise it's the infractions hammer for you. Take a step back before posting please, and remember to not harass the child.
►DapperGator
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
You're quite welcome, and yeah, we should really stop insulting Brandish. In spite of her indiscretions, which have recently been revealed, she still has rights and insulting her while she's not even here is just low.
►BadassTeen
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
You mother right, and it's infuriating to me that no one sees it!
Seriously, people, what's wrong with you all?! How are you forgetting that Mammon's knifes were the thing that injured Wards on live television! You say: "he's not a butcher - like Marques was"! Try saying it to Aegis and Gallant. Oh, you can't! Because they're not around anymore!
Brandish have all right to call Mammon a villain as bad as Marquis was. That monster first used his no-less villainous girlfriend to harm her daughter, then attacked her himself, in a fucking hospital, not even allowing her to help wards injured by his good-for-nothing friends! And after that, he used his thinker powers to destroy New Wave from inside and mastered Amy so that she couldn't help real heroes when they were needed, and he could pretend to save the city! From a disaster he had his hand in creating!
Mammon is a villain through and through, and the fact that most people can't see it behind all the posturing is just stupid!
►DapperGator
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
@BadassTeen
You do realize that Gallant and Aegis are still alive, right? Just transferred. For the latter there were even articles about his heroic actions in Boston.
You do realize that there is no proof, let alone logic behind those claims. If Apeiron had actually physically harmed Apeiron he'd already be on the national list for villains (link here), because assault is illegal. Similarly, based on everything we know, all that he did was hint that there may have been indiscretions in the family, which appears to have been true.
Lastly, he didn't pretend to save the city, he actually did or are you claiming that it wasn't him who kicked Lung into the curb?
►Yamm0
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
Calling the Panacea Tape a 'attack' is more than a bit unfair. it was a shitty conversation at a horrible time, but nothing outright violent. The whole mess sucked and it was kinda shitty of apeiron to do that but the mess that made the shit in question wasn't his questionable conduct, but not outright bad or evil
Also did you really do the 'apeiron is a MaStEr' meme? I thought we all got tired of that ages ago lol.
Apeiron is 100% questionable and should be treated with caution but he's not a trigger happy murderer who likes kicking puppies for fun. He might be definitely unstable, and very scary, but treating him like that will probably make it worse. Also Apeiron hates masters by his own admission
realistically also our only choice is to be nice tho. its just our only bit of good luck that keeps apeiron being only 'kinda a dick sometimes' instead of 'crazy mass murderer'
End of Page. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
(Showing page 3 of 5)
►IllogicalFallacy
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
Think about it this way, imagine one of them calls you up and wants to make a deal.
If it's Marquis, this is a bad thing.
He was a crime lord and any deal he makes is almost certainly meant to advance his criminal agenda.
You probably don't have an option to refuse.
If it's Aperion, then it might be a good thing.
He has a lot of options for bribery so he's less likely to threaten for cooperation, and he has more benign activities.
Maybe he wants help removing bombs or creating a movie to beam into people's brains?
►DapperGator
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
That's probably the best illustration of the differences between the two that I've ever seen. Sure, Apeiron may be bad, but Marquis is definitively bad.
►Secent
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
I can see why a lot of people are freaked out by the two.
On one hand, Marquis was the known bad. Like, definitely bad but the bad you could understand. Kill some people, do some drug selling, blah blah blah well being occasionally helpful.
On the other, Apeiron is the unknown bad. Sure, he's made a point he wants some stability, but thats after the UH. What about when (if) things calm down? Will he be fine just outfitting one gang? Want to contact the Protectorate? What are his ethics regarding contracts? His experiments? What a damage can he do? What happens if (x)? What wont happen if (x)? Can we do anything about him?
A sheet full of question marks is a very frightening thing indeed. Not the same, but the dread of living near his active sites (if there is anything left) is sort of similar. Probably a lot worse in most cases, but well...
Apeiron might be the more unstable of the two, but his obsessiveness with contracts seems to be a counterbalance. Hopefully.
Anyways the biggest thing they had in common was they fucked up NW when they encountered it, Marquis for whatever reason, and Apeiron with the Panacea thing, for unknown reasons. Probably just shit planning though. Powerful Thinkers and tinkers tend to be high INT and low CHA/WIS, just look at Armsmaster
►zZz_Abyss_Ninja_ZzZ
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
Behind all this moral measuring shit yo all missed real interesting thingy.
Monke wanted to join New Wave!
How it would even work yo ask. I thought they were only family business yo say. I know how! Apeiron wanted to marry one of the members! And when somthing hapen, and marriage was canceled - Apriron gone apeshit and decied to take revenge on New Wave by dstroying the family. That all make sanse!
Only qustion, who was de bride? "Laserdream"? Don't be sily! How would it even be callrd? Limitless dream? Ha! Actually, sounde prety good. Yeha, de bride wasas lazerdream. Picees fittt togther like a giod puzle.
►Riddon
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
@ zZz_Abyss_Ninja_ZzZ
Do you need a ride from whatever bar you're in?
►Lethe (Verified Cape) (Celestial Forge) (Verified Pain in the Ass)
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
Laserdream and the boss? I ship it. He needs to get out of the lab more often as it is.
►Point_Me_@_The_Sky (Original Poster) (New Wave)
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
@ Lethe, I genuinely don't know how to respond to that. Like, seriously, I have no idea. I mean, Laserdream did meet him once, after his fight with Uber and Leet, and she shot at him. I'm just not going to talk about this topic anymore, maybe I'll go get my cousin's opinion, but be warned, she'll probably not think highly of it.
Anyway, @IllogicalFallacy, that's probably one of the best ways I think anyone could've explained it. And yeah, TBH, I do think my mother is wrong about Apeiron being the same as Marquis, I also wanted more opinions. From what Amy, both my Cousins and Weld have said, Apeiron is actually a nice guy when you're speaking to him. At least, he doesn't coat every word in some veiled threat like some villains do.
@BadassTeen, I feel like that might be a bit heavy-handed. Apeiron hasn't actually killed anyone yet. At least not directly.
Edit: And about my mother being salty about her marriage, that's entirely on her. And Uncle Neil. But no, New Wave was like a ticking time bomb, this stuff was going to come out eventually. It wasn't the best time to come out, but I think it also could've been worse.
►DandyWingman
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
>has he actually 'done' anything illegal yet, or at least anything that wouldn't be tolerated by a vigilante or independent hero?
Read: 'Apeiron'. That thing is a violation of sanctity of mind! Some might think that inserting couple words into our heads isn't an issue, but it actually is, or would have been if anyone else was in Apeiron's place.
Apeiron, or at least his huge robot caused a massive amount of collateral during his battle with Lung, many would argue that he should have retreated instead of fighting Lung. Apeiron is legally responsible for at least some of that damage.
Also weapon that Apeiron deployed against Lung might be illegal to possess. Tinkertech laws are murky, but it would be illegal for conventional weapons of that yield.
His robot caused a lot of collateral during his first fight against Bakuda, and the man himself later slashed more to the pile. In my mind, what he did for Bakuda's victims offsets that, and I don't care all that much for old containers when lives were on the line, but a court is likely to say 'excessive force'.
Selling knives to teenagers is illegal! Tinkertech or not tinkertech. On the other hand it might not even count as a sale.
Healing without consent is illegal, and I doubt Panacea would have agreed to be healed in this case (unknown, untested tech at a minimum!), but I also doubt that the sweet girl will pursue any charges, especially not against a fellow healer (and not like those will change anything).
From my point of view Apeiron would be tolerated by 'a vigilante or independent hero', but not in a way you meant. Instead of 'eh, can't cook omelette without breaking some eggs', it will be 'that monster is not a villain and I would rather take that and stay alive.'
P.S. Also the way Apeiron's got into the hospital to heal Panacea might have been illegal.
►Submariner (Verified Anti-Shipper)
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
Marquis deserves some credit. He's the reason that none of the gangs have attacked the hospitals or bus-lines. The way the story goes, when Bone-man came to town, he made it clear the other gangs in town (Empire, and the various gangs that Lung eventually corralled into the ABB) that the hospitals were off-limits. Rumor is that some cape tried to rob one for drugs and the guy was found the next day impaled to a warehouse with bone spikes, with all the stolen drugs sorted and identified in neat handwriting.
Apparently, the criminals in town at the time took notice, and that's the reasons why none of the freaks in this town ever fucked with Brockton General.
Supposedly something happened with the bus-lines as well, and he had to step in to make an example out of some scumbag. But according to the rumor mill in the city, ever since then there's been an official 'Do not fuck with hospitals or the bus-lines' policy from the various scumbags in our city. Even long after Bone man up and got sent to the cage. Considering the kinds of assholes we had running around back then, I can't see anyone else pulling that off.
And let's not forget that he's a big reason the Teeth and S9 left Brockton all those years ago. Any man who steps up to that fucker Jack and tells him to fucking run and actually gets him to do so deserves a round of fucking applause.
@DandyWingman
Dude... how long have you lived in the bay? It wouldn't surprise me if half the brats in my kid's daycare were packing weapons.
►577Tonitee
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
Y'all, Marquis was a crime lord but at least he was relatively stable. I dont really give much of a shit if Apeiron spends his day giving kindergartners unicorn rides and shooting rainbows and sparkles out of his ass, if theres any chance he's gonna go buttfuck crazy and aim that kind of shit at the heros, i'm firmly in the AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA camp, if I do say so myself.
At least with Marquis, you understand what the fucks actually killing you. God forbid Apeiron feed you to his hell-weasel teammate/experiment. Yeah, boneboy over insane tinker anyday. The whole 'not having superweapons' is a point in bonedudes favor, fundamentally.
End of Page. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
(Showing page 4 of 5)
►CourtedByCrimson
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
Your mom is right by accident. Both of them are unfairly maligned heroes who work to make the city safer by dealing with trash like rapists and sleazebags who addict kids. The big difference is Apeiron is strong enough that he can afford to show mercy because he has a big team backing him up, while Marquis was working on his own, so he had to be harsh to send a message.
►Yamm0
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
Look buddy be glad for marquis all you want personally, but hero is a massive exaggeration.Tthe whole 'murder and drugs' thing is kind of a...well..not hero thing to do.
Marquis was a crime lord with some basic standards. Seriously, a villain isn't cartoonishly bad and people start defending them like it's their job.
'Harsh to send a message' is not murdering people. Apeiron fought against villains who wanted to destroy the literal city. Most of marquis' kill count does not fall in that category. Marquis had a interest in keeping his turf safe, and a basic moral code. Period.
►Unfiltered_Imagination
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
Apeiron? Marquis, not even fucking close, Apeiron takes it by miles. If he had started anywhere else in the U.S. we wouldn't be having this conversation but Brockton Bay's so damn corrupted by incompetence and taking the worst thing imaginable to be the possible first value. God my city is so fucked up...
Marquis had a cool motive, had a neat set of rules, still murder. He was black that sometimes lapsed into grey, Aperion is varying shades of grey and white.
►NeoTheMatrixSpamBot
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
@DandyWingman OH ITS ON.
1. I sincerely doubt that it violates anything. Is it annoying? Yes. Is it scans your mind to find which porn you watched today? Yeah, no. You would think someone of Apeiron's caliber would be able to mass read mind without notice. That, and telepaths aren't real. Even Winged Bitch iirc dont qualifies to that
2. Ah, yes, letting Lung (and Oni Lee by the way) get away scott free with March would've been MUCH better decision. By any chance, are you ABB loyal? Sure talk like one.
3. I am dying laughing. Apeiron isnt recognized as villain AND he is not Protectorate hero. They can't restrict him and his tinkertech. ToyBox is a thing you know, and those guys have some serious tech that by all accounts shouldn't be allowed in anyone but PRT's hands yet here we are.
4. When you dealing with bomb tinker with unwilling suicide bombers running around, there is NO such thing as an excessive force. Note that Apeiron used relatively non-lethal weapon instead of making his bot shoot lighting or fire or freeze people solid. What is more important: a bunch of containers or people lives? By the looks of it, you choosing containers.
5. Tinkertech sales in REALLY gray zone so if court would decide is it violation of the law or not, they can swing both sides really.
6. Me, being half-unconscious and dying under debris: ... Panacea, not receiving my permission to heal: Well, I did all I could!. Fucking stupidest argument by far. This permission shit is PRT paranoia which, I might add, never led to anything good.
7. Me, walking into wrong door: Oh man, I am criminal now, guess I'll go to jail.
Get the hell out, ABB loyal or Marquis fanboy. I dont even know which is worse.
@CourtedByCrimson, he sure as hell taught lesson to those innocent civilians, yep.
This thread is a giant fucking joke. Marquis is villain asshole, who was mildly good at PR. Apeiron is a hero who at odds with PRT ENE (not even entire PRT, just local fucking brunch). End of the story. Anyone who claims anything else is either troll or delusional.
►All_I_Survey (Verified Cape) (Celestial Forge)
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
@ Lethe, Apeiron has requested you not 'stir the pot'. He already feels bad enough for all the trouble he has inadvertently caused New Wave. He says that if you continue, you will no longer be allowed any of Kataklyzein's milkshakes.
In regards to the data related to the criminal Marquis and the Celestial Forge, the only commonality is that both neither fit into the pre-determined slots of 'good' and 'evil'. Marquis committed a number of crimes (See Dossier 'Marquis', A0001-93), and as such, when caught was sentenced to the Bauman Correctional Facility. This does not change the fact that he was a stabilizing force in Brockton Bays for a number of years (See attached crime rate historical analysis BB-00281FA). It could also be argued that his removal is what allowed the Archer's Bridge Merchants, and what was known as the ABB to form into the groups they were later on. (Attached items A0047-15, A0048-43)
In contrast, the Celestial Forge's primary operational goal was the removal of Bakuda from Brockton Bay once Apeiron became aware of her. The initial contracts with the Undersiders were made in order to facilitate that design. This became complicated once March began conducting missions in the city, and as such, changes in tactics were required in order to accommodate. The ABB chose to escalate faster than anticipated, given their recruitment of subcontractors Leet and Uber (A0049-61), and Bakuda's 'conscription' victims (See Bomb Analysis PFA-39152 through PFA-39371).
The 'Ungodly Hour' as many refer to it, is the culmination of the attempts to counter the ABB's expanded threat range. People have attempted to blame Apeiron for March's actions, but Apeiron going out that night was chance, and it is highly improbable that March's operation would have been delayed if Apeiron had chosen to stay in with a movie instead. It is more probable that Bakuda and March's initial broadcast would have just been a taunt to draw Apeiron out into the open, while still attempting to destroy the city. The analysis of the coordinated detonations of Tinkertech explosives after Apeiron entered the battle at the container yard confirms this. (See Bomb Analysis TQR-0241 through TQR-0273 for more details.)
In terms of end results and starting reasons, from the data I have collected the two groups could not be more different. Marquis' actions were designed for his own well-being and comfort, and he inadvertently brought stability. Apeiron has rarely acted for himself, and inadvertently brought chaos. It is a logical and moral conundrum, in certain respects, and I think it would be fascinating to actually speak to Marquis about his actions for local historical purposes (Proposal: Personal Interviews with Parahumans within Brockton Bay for Historical Analysis.)
►Fafnoire
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
Well at least we now have confirmation that Apeiron was a Cape before he appeared on the Brockton Cape Scene. For those wondering Panacea said he told her that he sold those knives to the Undersiders so that he could get funds to put up a fight against Bakuda. That "once Apeiron became aware of her" strongly implies the Celestial Forge had one or more objectives before their working relationship with the Undersiders
►RedHogColdTomato
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
This thread proves to be surprisingly deep well of analysis and insights.
It gave me a question, if Apeiron caused chaos "inadvertently" then why he called himself in the name of primordial Chaos? What did he expect, didn't he know a thing about names?
►UpDownSideWays
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
Jeeze, a CF response?? Unexpected much!
(Though I guess that should be expected for the CF!)
@All_I_Survey
Hey, how prepared was Apeiron for that fight? I'd love to think it was the culmination of the previous week of planning, but if that enounter was purely by chance and Apeiron using what he had on hand at the time.....jesus fucking christ on a cross.
@Fafnoire
Perhaps it was just Apeiron, which was why he was attempting to aquire funds in the first place, rather than....whatever the hell he does now.
►Apeiron (Verified Cape) (Celestial Forge)
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
As Survey said above, there are distinct differences between myself and Marquis. In my personal opinion, people who make the connection between myself and Marquis are looking at surface-level details and little else. That said, confirmation bias is definitely something some people may experience, as Glory Girl mentioned.
To begin, I would like to say that I grew up during the point of time when Marquis was still active, in Brockton Bay. I know what he did and how brutal he was in his actions. Believe me, I do.
Marquis was a powerful cape, controlling most of the area the ABB came to inherit, who regularly clashed with both the Empire and the Protectorate, as well as smaller, unaffiliated Cape Gangs. He himself held to an ethical code, though I will say how strictly he held to it was debatable. He was also, strictly, a villain, who acted solely for self-benefit, and any cape convention he may have put in place was purely for his benefit, stability being most likely a byproduct.
Comparing Marquis to myself, I find many faulty assumptions that are made in regard to any similarities we may have. Marquis mainly did what we might consider a good act solely for his own benefit, and at the end of the day, was still a villain. Crossing him would lead to your death, and even with what happened during the Ungodly Hour, I still tried to keep casualties to a minimum. Regarding Lung's death, even that was mainly undertaken by Fleet, with help from the rest of The Celestial Forge. I mostly lined the shot up as to not affect the city in a too major way
@UpDownSideWays
During the Ungodly Hour, I went out with most of my currently available loadout. I hadn't expected it to get as bad as it did, especially towards the end, so there were still some things I was reluctant to bring out. The first deployments of Proto Amia, Matrix and Lethe were events that I would have liked to avoid until a more peaceful time, but they happened nonetheless.
Lethe, as Survey said, I understand what you're doing, and I ask you to please not fan the flames on that particular issue. Khepeiron was enough of an issue for me to deal with and I can almost guarantee you that Laserdream hates my guts. And I do get out of the lab, just not for dates. It's not like I am a shut-in.
►Fafnoire
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
@UpDownSideWays
That is absolutely possible however if that were the case, why why differentiate between the Celestial Forge and Apeiron? The topic of conversation was solely Apeiron vs Marquis so just saying "Apeirons primary objective" would have been more fitting. I might be reading something that isn't there but if Ms Survey is detailed enough to bring up incidents with specific case numbers I don't see her dragging the rest of the Celestial Forge into this by accident.
EDIT: oh my god he's here. What do we do? Do we pretend he's not here? Do we panic? I'm on board with that last one.
End of Page. 1, 2, 3, 4
(Showing page 5 of 5)
►Apeiron (Verified Cape) (Celestial Forge)
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
@Fafnoire
Preferably, just have a calm, collected conversation like the semi-rational humans I know we all are. Panic is usually not good for having any productive discussions about any topic.
►Mrgreenpant
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
I am a little terrified by the possible answer but the curiosity is too strong, what was the equipment, teammate or others that you did not want to deploy during the UH (other than Proto Amia, Matrix and Lethe) ?
►Mobile Oppression Device (Moderator)
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
This isn't the place to discuss the details of the Ungodly Hour or the Celestial Forge's actions. Let's also not derail this into a technical discussion (as much I also want to know these things...) It hasn't happened to a significant degree, but we are watching...
If you want to discuss the Ungodly Hour, see this thread
If you want to discuss the Celestial Forge or the capes involved, see the following threads Apeiron, Celestial Forge, Fleet, Survey, Proto Aima, The Matrix.
Technical Discussions regarding confirmed Apeiron/CF technologies can be found here, here, here, and here.
For historical context regarding Marquis: See this thread.
For historical context regarding New Wave: See this thread, this one, and this one.
►Apeiron (Verified Cape) (Celestial Forge)
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
As I have stated to the PRT and the Protectorate, I will not be taking questions regarding specifics of capabilities, both in regards to abilities or equipment, of either myself or my teammates. As the moderator above has stated, there are many threads in which to discuss these topics. Survey might open up a thread later for people to submit questions.
Either way, let us return back to Glory Girl's question, as I would also like to hear a response from the public of Brockton Bay.
►Iron_Angel
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
All Hail the God of Technology may he guide us to a never ending Golden Age of Technology!
►VerifiedCape (Verified Cape)
Replied On Apr 30th 2011:
I think you're all missing an important point of commonality between Marquis and Apeiron. Being the only cape in town to face down the Butcher and make them blink.
Not that that's a good thing per se. The last time the Butcher felt like they couldn't hold territory in Brockton they got help from someone we try not to mention on PHO. Maybe they wont be that stupid this time?
End of Page. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
■
[Written with the help of CorEagle's "PHO Blacksmithery - Brockton's Celestial Forge"(PHO Blacksmithery - Brockton's Celestial Forge) and the users who frequent the thread.]
Edit: Fixed the timing and usernames that didn't show up for some reason. Thanks for pointing that out!
@LordRoustabout please threadmark this