Voting is open
As someone who hasn't been following the thread exceptionally closely, could I ask that the actual bodies of the plans folks are voting for get included in at least some of the early votes? It'll make the tally a lot more comprehensible to latecomers.
 
[X] Plan To Form A More Perfect Union v1.67 Dream Drop Disco

I actually like this plan the most but I wouldn't be too upset if Reconstruction won either.
 
Dropping a vote

VOTE
[X]Plan Reconstruction
-[X][GOAL] Direct Integration: +0 with all minor American factions and FCNY; -1 with NCR, Northern Mexicans, and Canadians; -2 with Mexican Revivalists.
-[X][STRUCTURE] Web of Association: +1 with Canadian factions, western and southern American factions, and northern Mexicans; +0 with NCR, FCNY, and Mexican Revivalists.
-[X] Concession:
--[X] Cloture: +1 with Canadian factions and the Mexican Revivalists.
--[X] Multilingualism: +1 with all Mexicans and French-Canadians.
--[X] Southern Strategy: +1 with southern American factions, the Mexican Revivalists, and the Northern Mexicans.
--[X] Financier: +5 with FCNY.
--[X] Lifeline of the West: +3 with NCR.
--[X] Truth and Reconciliation Commission: +1 with all Canadian, minor American, and northern Mexican factions. -1 with NCR.
--[X] Military Exchange: +2 with all minor American factions, all Canadian factions, and the northern Mexicans.
--[X] United Post Office: +1 with all factions.
--[X] Mexican Autonomy: +3 with Mexican Revivalists and guarantees that they at least attend, but locks them out from joining the body proper right now and enforces a hands-off policy for their territory.


Ending Relations
The FCNY (1): 1+0+0+5+1=7
The NCR (-1): -1 + -1 + 0 + 3 + -1 + 1 = +1
Anglo-Canadian Factions (0): 0 + -1 + 1 + 1 + 1 + 2 + 1 = 5
French-Canadian Factions (-2): -2 + -1 + 1 + 1 + 1 + 1 + 2 +1 = 4
Northern Mexican Factions (2): 2 + -1 + 1 + 1 +1 + 1 + 2 + 1 = 6
Mexican Revivalists (-3): -3 + -2 + 0 + 1 + 1 + 1 + 1 + 3 = +2
Western Minor American Factions (0): 0 + 0 + 1 + 1+ 2 + 1 = 5
Southern Minor American Factions (0): 0 + 0 + 1 + 1 + 1 + 2 +1 = 6
Interior American Factions (N/A):



Also approval voting this from Sir Travelsalot, which seems identical

[X] Plan: Party Up & Down the Coast to Coast v.1.2
 
Plan All Together Now

[ ] Steps On the Road:
[ ] Web of Association:
[ ] Multilingualism:
[ ] Southern Strategy:
[ ] Financier:
[ ] Lifeline of the West:
[ ] Truth and Reconciliation Commission:
[ ] Independence Referendum
[ ] Military Exchange:
[ ] Mexican Revivalist Special Status:
[ ] United Post Office
[ ] Mexican Autonomy:
 
Does it really need cloture? It's still in the positive without. I am admittedly one of those Americans fed up with it. What was the reasoning?
Think of it this way.

You have a 100 seat assembly.
51 of the representatives want to pass a new legal provision. 49 reps are opposed
Under simple majority rules, the 51 can do it at will. Fuck what you think.

Cloture means that, unless there is supermajority support, the group of 49 legislators(or 30. Or 20. Or 1) can call for a pause before the vote is taken. Maybe for 1 day. Maybe for 2.
Maybe even a week or a month, depending on the system. Time for discussion, politics, lobbying.

Then the vote can be repeated, but now instead of requiring 60 votes, maybe it requires 55.
If cloture is invoked again, and there arent 55 votes for it, then a second pause, more time for discussion and lobbying and politicking. And meantime the requirement drops to 51.

TLDR
Its not a stonewall. What it does is allow the minority to compel the majority to allow them make their objections to their colleagues and the public without being able to permanently block the process of government. It also serves as a safety measure against rushing through legislation before its been reviewed properly.

And it mitigates shenanigans like a narrow majority forcing through controversial legislation without discussion.
See Texas.
 
Last edited:
[X]Plan Reconstruction
-[X][GOAL] Direct Integration: +0 with all minor American factions and FCNY; -1 with NCR, Northern Mexicans, and Canadians; -2 with Mexican Revivalists.
-[X][STRUCTURE] Web of Association: +1 with Canadian factions, western and southern American factions, and northern Mexicans; +0 with NCR, FCNY, and Mexican Revivalists.
-[X] Concession:
--[X] Cloture: +1 with Canadian factions and the Mexican Revivalists.
--[X] Multilingualism: +1 with all Mexicans and French-Canadians.
--[X] Southern Strategy: +1 with southern American factions, the Mexican Revivalists, and the Northern Mexicans.
--[X] Financier: +5 with FCNY.
--[X] Lifeline of the West: +3 with NCR.
--[X] Truth and Reconciliation Commission: +1 with all Canadian, minor American, and northern Mexican factions. -1 with NCR.
--[X] Military Exchange: +2 with all minor American factions, all Canadian factions, and the northern Mexicans.
--[X] United Post Office: +1 with all factions.
--[X] Mexican Autonomy: +3 with Mexican Revivalists and guarantees that they at least attend, but locks them out from joining the body proper right now and enforces a hands-off policy for their territory.
 
Starting Positions:
The FCNY (1)
The NCR (-1)
Anglo-Canadian Factions (0)
French-Canadian Factions (-2)
Northern Mexican Factions (2)
Mexican Revivalists (-3)
Western Minor American Factions (0)
Southern Minor American Factions (0)

[X] Plan To Form A More Perfect Union v1.67 Dream Drop Disco
-[X] Steps On the Road: The body will accept a slower track to membership featuring escalating levels of involvement, with things like mutual defense agreements coming earlier and common diplomatic policies coming later. The resulting state will take much more time to be viable. +1 with all American factions, Anglo-Canadians, and Northern Mexicans; +0 with French-Canadians and Mexican Revivalists.
-[X] Web of Association: While the decisions will be made by the above central council, non-state actors can seek association status and gain guaranteed audiences with said council and permanent representatives to deliver petitions for them. Adds a layer of complication, but this status is still up to the Council, so no states are going to be angry about it. +1 with Canadian factions, western and southern American factions, and northern Mexicans; +0 with NCR, FCNY, and Mexican Revivalists.
-[X] Cloture: Nobody wants to enact the liberum veto, but you have several attending factions who are concerned with being swallowed up in the tide of voices. Filibustering and the legislative measures that enabled it are a dirty memory for Americans, but there are ways to guarantee that minority voices are heard and respected that avoid some of the pitfalls. Institutes a supermajority requirement to close debate and move to a vote, with that requirement declining with each attempt at doing so in a session until a simple majority is required. +1 with Canadian factions and the Mexican Revivalists.
-[X] United Post Office: While the body itself will need to thresh out the details, you could establish as a part of its charter that it will create a postal service operating in all member states (associated groups as practical). This is a significant project to commit the body to undertaking, and with your own commitments, you can't be sure that you'll be able to help in a significant capacity if it needs support, but it is valuable and broadly popular, and could realistically be done in the early stages of things. +1 with all factions.
-[X] Multilingualism: The body would doubtlessly vote to set its own language of business, and by simple majority, that language would doubtlessly be English, but you have an opportunity to reach out and accommodate the more...skittish...of your participants, here -- at the cost of a tripled administrative workload and the dire need for a large mass of translators. +1 with all Mexicans and French-Canadians.
-[X] Mexican Autonomy: Agree to recognize the Mexican Revivalists' formal organization's current or future membership as beyond the body's scope, and grant them a non-voting representative with the right to address the voting council at any time, along with the right to petition for entrance to the body at a later date by simple majority. +3 with Mexican Revivalists and guarantees that they at least attend, but locks them out from joining the body proper right now and enforces a hands-off policy for their territory.
-[X] Southern Strategy: The Caribbean Sea and the Gulf of Mexico are becoming areas of increasing international interest in recent years, and the various people down there have virtually zero interest in any of that. Making a policy of not accepting the membership of any states found by the people in those regions to be inappropriately under foreign influence would be quite the draw to southern factions, but it would set a confrontational tone with Brazil and their bloc, given their newly-announced interest in the mouth of the Mississippi. +1 with southern American factions, the Mexican Revivalists, and the Northern Mexicans.
-[X] Lifeline of the West: The NCR, despite presently being in the flush of victory, is also feeling uncomfortably exposed, at the moment. It wants the body to commit to a project of reopening an infrastructure link across the Rockies, so that aid can reach them overland. Fortunately, Burns has just cleared out the largest concentration of bandits along the I-70, so this simplifies the question tremendously. Still, this is a big project. Without the FCNY's assistance, finding the funding for this is probably going to be the body's first big hurdle to clear. +3 with NCR.
-[X] Truth and Reconciliation Commission: An idea lifted from pre-Collapse Canada intended to examine the impacts of their residential schools for First Nations children, you plan to adopt it on a far grander scale. Make, as part of this body's charter, a commission with the aim of documenting the history and lasting impacts of the Collapse in humanitarian terms, and then making recommendations to the body as to how it should inform their formal decisions -- such as whom to favor in terms of who is the legitimate controller of a given patch of land. Broadly popular, but the NCR is going to see this as a slight against them. +1 with all Canadian, minor American, and northern Mexican factions. -1 with NCR.
-[X] Military Exchange: Various minor factions are interested in building up their militaries, now that Victoria (and California) are no longer factors opposing that. The CFC, having just crushed Victoria in two consecutive force-on-force contests, has significant cachet in military matters. Announce that members of this body will have the opportunity to send officer candidates to CFC military schools. This will give them the insights they desire and expand your own influence, although every spot in your academies is precious, at the moment, and if you're handing them out to others, you'll need to push harder for access to foreign academies than you were already going to have to. +2 with all minor American factions, all Canadian factions, and the northern Mexicans.

Ending Positions:
The FCNY (3)
The NCR (3)
Anglo-Canadian Factions (7)
French-Canadian Factions (5)
Northern Mexican Factions (10)
Mexican Revivalists (4)
Western Minor American Factions (6)
Southern Minor American Factions (7)
 
[X] Plan To Form A More Perfect Union v1.67 Dream Drop Disco

[X] Plan To Form A More Perfect Union v1.69 FCNY Finance
-[X] Steps On the Road
-[X] Web of Association
-[X] Cloture
-[X] United Post Office
-[X] Multilingualism
-[X] Mexican Autonomy
-[X] Southern Strategy
-[X] Lifeline of the West
-[X] Truth and Reconciliation Commission
-[X] Military Exchange
-[X] Financier

[X] Plan: Yeah that sounds good, what is political capital?
[X] Plan Don't Step On The Smoking Snake
 
Last edited:
[X] Plan: Yeah that sounds good, what is political capital?
-[X] Steps On the Road
-[X] Web of Association
-[X] Cloture
-[X] Multilingualism
-[X] Southern Strategy
-[X] Financier
-[X] Lifeline of the West
-[X] Truth and Reconciliation Commission
-[X] Military Exchange
-[X] United Post Office
 
Voting is open
Back
Top