Status
Not open for further replies.
So… what exactly is Paul doing here? Either get on with fixing her or go do something productive.

What, Paul can't talk to people just because? Despite what people keep saying Paul is still human and humans are social creatures that like to do things beside working all the time. He isn't a robot so I don't expect him to constantly be doing 'projects' every single second of their existance since I expect Paul to have a life.

See, THAT makes sense to me! Like with Robin - have something she really wants right in front of her, let her get it, and then see what she does once her biggest desire is granted.

Again, Zoat mentioned the SI is looking for mental stability and how people will act long term. Considering that Blackfire is a villain in most universes I wouldn't expect the SI to just consider giving her a ring until he was sure he even wanted her in his Corps.
 
If she isn't mentally stable without being able to fly then she probably isn't going to be much better with the ability restored.

That's actually pretty silly thinking. It's not like flight is something extra for her people. It's something so fundamental to her species and culture that people don't even bother with ground floor doors. Basic design philosophy goes "not for you, cripple, lol". And she deals with that constantly.

'If that Atlantean can't be mentally stable without being able to swim, while living in an aquatic environment, then they're probably never going to be mentally stable.'

I can't speak for mobility impaired or wheelchair bound people everywhere, but I do have a friend who is, and he can get incredibly frustrated about the lack of mobility, and the lack of accessibility to things. That's pretty freaking normal for people in that situation, and it takes a saintly person to not get angry, or sad, or what have you.
 
Can. Is choosing not to right now because he doesn't know her well enough. Nothing about not fixing her right away prevents him from doing so in the future.
I think comparing things to Jade is useful here - she needs a certain amount of stability in her life to build herself into a person who can use the Orange Light safely.

Trying to see what someone is like at their worst is one thing... but keeping someone from forming normal, healthy bonds is counterproductive.
Paul qualifies for Agent Orange and without social ties he would have gone the route of a more benevolent Larfleeze if lucky... or if he thought of assimilating people to make them get along at the wrong moment, Earth would have had a significant proportion of every resident soul torn out.

Needing help, needing to improve one's self, these are necessities and not deal breakers.
Consider the future visions of Azula - she needs massive change and therapy before being allowed near a ring. Luna would have been unsuited for a ring if she hadn't got help and guidance through her thousand years of isolation. And both of them were villains - Azula a rather unrepentant one, at that.
 
Control (part 1)
Control

16th July
11:27 GMT


Busy, busy.

I do a fly-by of The Space Station Formerly Known As Scratching Post, letting the rings display a detailed image on the inside of my helmet. Thanagarian work crews are already hard at work, ferrying materials back and forth from their carrier and the docking section. It'll be a while before it's turned into something they can conveniently dock with, so they're using shuttles to go back and forth for the moment. A few point me out as I pass, and I give them a wave.

It'll be… I don't even know how long until Tamaran is a functioning space age civilisation again, but at least they're starting to head in the right direction now. The Princes and Princesses Regent of the other states were beginning to arrive in Tamarus for talks as I left. How to rebuild, who gets to focus on what and who profits are going to have to be hashed out at the beginning.. and… Probably again and again as power relationships shift. Myand'r sounded pretty upbeat about the talks and Karras said that he'd try to stop his parents doing anything foolishly confrontational… I hope it goes well, but at this point it isn't strictly speaking my problem any longer.

Transition.

And I'm outside of the Liot'r system. With the interdiction fields fully engaged even I can't warp where I please in-system any longer. They'd probably turn it off if I asked -me being just about the most popular person on the planet at the moment- but I don't think it's worth the risk in case someone in Citadel Complex turns out to be unusually on the ball. And it's not as if I'm aware of time passing while I transition anyway. But, warping is faster and the next leg of my journey is a lot longer than the brief flight here from Earth.

I could fly directly to Maltus. I know where it is, and I could enter it at a crawl while shooting messages towards it so that they have plenty of advanced knowledge that I'm on the way. The thing is… If they didn't respond to that Guardian ship I sent them, I'm worried that I might have seriously misjudged them. Maybe they know about Larfleeze and don't want anything to do with the orange light. Maybe they think I'm more likely to be a threat or a hindrance than a boon and they don't want anything to do with me in particular.

So, I need more information. Going to Oa seemed like a bad plan, at least until I know for certain whether these Guardians are the Alpha Lantern-Third Army creating versions or the stern but basically reasonable versions. Going to Zamaron? Hah, no. Where does that leave?

Ring, plot warp for the border of Reach space.

Compliance.

The Reach is… Huge. Not galaxy-huge, but according to the records -an orange tunnel forms around me as the warp activates- that were on John's ring, pretty darn big. The periphery zone, the area they're attempting to subvert but haven't formally seized yet, is wider than the Vega systems at their broadest point. From those reports I had access to from Lanterns in that general area, that appears to be where Darkstars are most active. In fact, their membership appears to be split evenly between some sort of pseudo-insect and species whose worlds are falling under Reach control. Or which already have.

Reach ships are good. Advanced technology and highly skilled crews. Not peak technology; a Psion or Qwardian warship would be more dangerous, but I wouldn't want to have to fight more than two or three of their actual war cruisers. The ships they use in the periphery zone tend to be more like armed merchantmen, so unless they actually have a Beetle onboard I'm not all that worried about them. Sure, they can kill me with weight of fire, but they have the advantage of being Reach; I have no problem whatsoever with destroying them and killing everyone on board.

Of course, if they do have a Beetle… They used to be the Reach's go-to Lantern killers, and they're still allowed to serve as bodyguards to Reach 'Negotiators'. If I go to a planet they're trying to absorb there will be one. I'm not… Sure how much of their kill count came from Lantern reticence in using lethal force and lack of practice at large scale engagements and how much from their own power. I'd rather avoid fighting one until I can check.

And… Now my longest warp so far. Maltus is on the other side of the galactic core from Earth, and Reach space is beyond that. If we take Games Workshop orientation as 'correct' then Earth is in the galactic west, Maltus is east and Oa is northeast. That sounds a bit like they should be close together but they're really not. The galaxy is about a hundred thousand light years across and -outside the core and ignoring the halo- about a thousand light years thick. There's more than enough space between them for even their egos.

Of course, the thing about space is, there's lots of space in it. Most of everything is nothing, and most of the rest is black holes, stars and gas giants. Actual small habitable worlds are rare enough that they're not worth fighting over. A species evolving in a system with small rocky worlds will almost always find it easier to render the others habitable than to take a small rocky world somewhere else. And then they'll find it easier to build their own space habitats than conquer someone else's planets. Unless they're absurdly close together as they are in Vega at least…

The only reason to try conquering someone is that you're an arsehole.

And the Reach… Are massive arseholes.

Warp terminating in three, two, one.

Space snaps back into focus.

We have arrived at our destination.

Hm. Haven't made bad time. Thirty thousand light years in a few minutes. Ring, scan.

Compliance.

Nothing nearby. I mean, turning around, the starfield looks different as the core is now in the 'wrong' direction. Heh, I wave in the direction of Earth. See me in thirty thousand years. Right then. Ring, scan… Scan the planets around the border. I'm looking for Darkstars, anywhere they've been active. Preferably fighting the Reach.

A sensor array construct appears as the ring gets to work. The Reach are perfectly capable of shielding their secure installations and core worlds, but places on the periphery should be a bit more accessible. Particularly since I already know where to look.

Hm.

Darkstar activity detected on Urrigen.

Show me.

A planet appears in my mind. Post-industrial, maybe a century more advanced than Earth-. Than Earth Prime. Asteroid mining and some off-planet settlement. The inhabitants are standard pattern humanoids with green skin. No contact with other intelligent species until the Reach arrived. Looks like Reach presence is relatively recent… Good show, the societal dependency shouldn't be all that advanced yet.

Ring, plot warp to-.

Warning: will detected.

I raise my left eyebrow at the same time as my construct armour. Sure, I know that Green Lanterns patrol the border-.

There's a small flare of green as the Green Lantern appears. Oh dear. Green swimsuit, gloves and thigh boots? Someone failed-. And a red cloak. This is a member of their Honour Guard. However daft she looks, she knows what she's doing with that ring.

Though it doesn't look like she's been to the anti-me lectures yet.

Stewart-ring, who is she?

Honour Guard Lantern K'ryssma, formerly of Sector One Eight Nine Zero.

Ring, open channel.

Compliance.

"
Hello there, Lantern K'ryssma. What can I do for you?"

The glow around her ring brightens for a moment. A scan, probably. "Oh. You."

"Me indeed."

"I had intended to warn you that you were about to enter Reach space, in case you were an innocent traveller or merchant. Since it is you, I imagine that you think you know exactly what you're doing."

"An accurate surmise."

"Therefore, my only concern is that the Reach may see your presence as a breach of their treaty with the Guardians."

"I'm going to be aiding Controller agents. It should be fairly obvious who I work for."

"True." She pauses. "Orange Lantern, I have seen Reach space expand by twelve systems during my time overseeing this region. The Guardians' treaty may be better than all out war, but I would be more than happy to see the Reach suffer a reversal of fortunes."

I nod inside my armour. "I'll see what I can do."
 
Last edited:
Don't think that a new story post is enough to distract us from denying someone normal medical care because they might be a villain, maybe, Paul can't remember but they sound shifty,

We like the story post, but we do not simply forget.
 
Lantern K'ryssman seems extremely reasonable for one of the GL honour guard.

Also, some suggestions:
but they have the advantage of being Reach
but I have the advantage of them being Reach

Actual small habitable worlds are rare enough that they're not worth fighting over.
Perhaps "common enough" or "rare, but common enough".

See me in three hundred thousand years.
Diameter of the galaxy is 100,000. I suggest "sixty thousand years".

Lantern, I have see Reach space expand
seen
 
And… Now my longest warp so far. Maltus is on the other side of the galactic core from Earth, and Reach space is beyond that. If we take Games Workshop orientation as 'correct' then Earth is in the galactic west, Maltus is east and Oa is north east. That sounds a bit like they should be close together but they're really not. The galaxy is about a hundred thousand light years across and -outside the core and ignoring the halo- about a thousand light years thick. There's more than enough space between them for even their egos.

Hm. Haven't made bad time. Three hundred thousand light years in a few minutes. Ring, scan.

Compliance.

Nothing nearby. I mean, turning around the starfield look different as the core is now in the 'wrong' direction. Heh, I wave in the direction of Earth. See me in three hundred thousand years. Right then. Ring, scan… Scan the planets around the border. I'm looking for Darkstars, anywhere they've been active. Preferably fighting the Reach.
Unless Vega is in one of the Milky Way's satellite galaxies and I somehow missed it, I'm pretty sure that neither arithmetic nor trigonometry work that way. 30,000 LY from Vega to Sector 1890 seems much more reasonable.
 
The SI calls them that due to the fact that they don't guard the universe.
Yes, but the quoted section said that "They are called the Guardians of the Galaxy." Only the SI calls them that, because he wants to be snarky. Other people don't.
Hm. Haven't made bad time. Three hundred thousand light years in a few minutes. Ring, scan.

Compliance.

Nothing nearby. I mean, turning around the starfield look different as the core is now in the 'wrong' direction. Heh, I wave in the direction of Earth. See me in three hundred thousand years. Right then.
Think you mean 30,000 light years, or some other number. As you said above, the Galaxy is only 100,000 light years in diameter.
A species evolving in a system with small rocky worlds will almost always find it easier to render the others habitable than to take a small rocky world somewhere else. And then they'll find it easier to build their own space habitats than conquer someone else's planets. Unless they're absurdly close together as they are in Vega at least…

The only reason to try conquering someone is that you're an arsehole.

And the Reach… Are massive arseholes.
They could want slave labor, or industrial capacity without having to build it. Or maybe the species is special in some way like the Kryptonians and would make excellent warriors.

Or if they are trying to claim territory, it could be easier to conquer a planet and then build space habitats there rather than move existing habitats. Same with shipyards.
Don't think that a new story post is enough to distract us from denying someone normal medical care because they might be a villain, maybe, Paul can't remember but they sound shifty,

We like the story post, but we do not simply forget.
Maybe he wants her to do it herself if he decides that she is worthy of a ring, but will heal her himself if he decides not to give her one? She was recently abused quite nastily, so giving her power over her own life would be beneficial psychologically, and it's not like a few more weeks without flight would be all that bad.
 
The only reason to try conquering someone is that you're an arsehole.

And the Reach… Are massive arseholes.
Ha! Suck Reach and all other groups that want to conquer others!

Only reason why you do so is cause you are jerks.
"True." She pauses. "Orange Lantern, I have see Reach space expand by twelve systems during my time overseeing this region. The Guardian's treaty may be better than all out war, but I would be more than happy to see the Reach suffer a reversal of fortunes."
Whoa, despite being an Honor Guard she has a good head on her soldiers and will at least give moral support.
 
Don't think that a new story post is enough to distract us from denying someone normal medical care because they might be a villain, maybe, Paul can't remember but they sound shifty.
Alright then, what about all of the other people suffering from that condition? I don't recall anyone complaining when he didn't fix every spinal injury on Earth.
"The only reason to try conquering someone is that you're an arsehole."

Hah! sick self burn by Zoat.
The SI is more into policing actions and regime change.

Those don't count, right?
Also, some suggestions:

but I have the advantage of them being Reach
Being attacked by the SI is a privileged, not a right.
Perhaps "common enough" or "rare, but common enough".
Those both mean the exact opposite of what I'm saying.
Diameter of the galaxy is 100,000. I suggest "sixty thousand years".
seen
Thank you, corrected.
 
Whoa, despite being an Honor Guard she has a good head on her soldiers and will at least give moral support.

Sorry, I don't follow. Admittedly I've only read the Johns era GL titles and the drunk driving one from the 90s/80s, but aren't Honor Guard the best and brightest of the GLC?

Alright then, what about all of the other people suffering from that condition? I don't recall anyone complaining when he didn't fix every spinal injury on Earth.

Paul isn't denying those people healthcare because they might be evil.
 
Sorry, I don't follow. Admittedly I've only read the Johns era GL titles and the drunk driving one from the 90s/80s, but aren't Honor Guard the best and brightest of the GLC?
Well yeah, but also have to gain approval by Guardians who can be stickler for rules so usually prefer Honor Guard that are similar in thought process I believe so likely most Honor Guard members have a bit of a stick up their asses.

At least that is the impression I got from my limited reading of them.
 
Well yeah, but also have to gain approval by Guardians who can be stickler for rules so usually prefer Honor Guard that are similar in thought process I believe so likely most Honor Guard members have a bit of a stick up their asses.

At least that is the impression I got from my limited reading of them.
Didn't Guy make Honor Guard? Guy isn't the type to have a stick up his ass; he's the type to have a construct stick up other people's asses.
 
Alright then, what about all of the other people suffering from that condition? I don't recall anyone complaining when he didn't fix every spinal injury on Earth.
Okay, I actually agree with you in that OL isn't acting out of character at all here, but that's a bit of a flawed analogy.

If he was an Indigo Lantern that could work, but he's an Orange Lantern. He most likely couldn't actually do that on such a massive scale, because like with the children on that bridge, it just wasn't emotionally possible for him to personally care about each and every one of them on a deep enough level to maintain the avarice needed to heal them. But fixing someone right in front of him? That's completely doable if he wanted to.

Again, I agree that OL isn't actually acting out of character here.
 
Alright then, what about all of the other people suffering from that condition? I don't recall anyone complaining when he didn't fix every spinal injury on Earth.
An easy question to answer. We accepted the explanation that the ring is powered by Want and not Compassion. For healing, it is not an endless or unprejudiced source of power; it can heal individuals because Paul has a general desire to see people whole and happy, and it is extremely good at healing those personally close to Paul, but the power of the ring to heal fades as many healings cause Compassion to crowd out Desire.
However.

1) Paul has previously made a big deal about how he wants supervillains to become well-adjusted and join society peaceably. This indicates that Blackfire's 'future probably supervillainy' almost certainly doesn't count. (Especially on the off-chance that he mixed up the names and it's the other sister who goes villain.)
2) She's an alien princess valuable to a society he has decided to value; if he can determine how the damage to her flight capabilities is supposed to be healed with a scan-comparison to her sister (likely; he was able to do it with Kon because of intense want that is lacking her - but his skill with the ring and his Orange Enlightenment is massively greater as well.)
3) She was there, in front of him, suffering. Paul has previously indicated that he does have significant Compassion, though maybe not up to Ring standards; his desires can extend that to healing those presented directly to him, those he is friends with, or those who he considers 'his responsibility'.

EDIT: Oh, and to be clear - my concern here is not with 'rar Paul did a not-moral thing!'
My concern is that Paul is behaving in a way which seems to me causelessly discontinuous both with regards to observed external actions and with regards to the explanations inside and outside the chapter of his internal reasoning.
 
Last edited:
The Reach gon get it
Smash cut to OL busting through Reach blockades with "X Gon' Give It To Ya" blaring.

"True." She pauses. "Orange Lantern, I have seen Reach space expand by twelve systems during my time overseeing this region. The Guardian's treaty may be better than all out war, but I would be more than happy to see the Reach suffer a reversal of fortunes."

I nod inside my armour. "I'll see what I can do."
And then... Reach Civil War.

"And I think I'm done here."

"What did you do."

"Oh just a little bit of this and that."

"Several systems have declared independence from the Reach, either total independence or declaring themselves apart of the New Reach Republic. Reach warships are firing upon each other, entire systems have been plunged into chaos."

"Okay. So It might have been more than a little."
 
Hm. Haven't made bad time. Thirty thousand light years in a few minutes. Ring, scan.
Pointing this out because it will likely be important later: it took the SI 30 minutes to travel the 60 light years to Vega, and less than 2 hours to travel 30,000 light-years. That means that for an OL, travel time to anywhere in the Galaxy should be less than 6 hours from any other point in the Galaxy.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top