I've made an edit to the effect of "If forces (including Lamenters) need to be detached to ensure their safe capture, they should be." I do want to reiterate that we spend 2 actions infiltrating the megafreighters. We have a ton of assets in place already and I'm going to leave the actual game-time decision of if more forces are necessary up to our people who have all of the actual information & have the direction that taking the megafreighters is top priority. This is effectively equivalent in my mind of @ing the QM and asking if those forces are necessary, then assigning them if they are.I feel this is a MASSIVE oversight. We have a full chapter of Space Marines, we can spare a single company or even two for capturing the Megafreighters. Yes bringing full strength to bear is important but QM has stated we can both board and capture BOTH the ringyards and Megafreighters considering the 1000 Lamenters we have with us.
How? The fight is going to involve the enemy fleet, the stations and the defense platforms? I'm assigning the Lamenters role in that fight, but not taking them out of it. And "lowest priority" doesn't mean "Don't board them if given a good opportunity." It means "If you have the choice, pick the stations/psytech ships/defense platforms/fleet in that order.assigning a company or so to it would do wonder for speeding up that stuff. And so given this, you're assigning the Lamenters out of the fight so to speak? the stations consist of 2 SBG's worth of defenses so the defensive stations are fair but the rest of the enemy fleet being lowest priority?
plus this seems like it will seperate them from the rest of the SBG"s and leave them on their own and given the boarding focus, seems like a bad match up since the Dutchy are Torpedo swarm focus.
I think they're all good options. We're choosing the level of flair vs. by the book. I'm quite surprised by the description of Huntress as "Ms Warcrimes." To me she reads as "A lot of aggression in a small package" and that's exactly what we need here.The author has done a good job making the choice of admiral a hard one. Agree with not picking Ms Warcrimes even though she would be the most effective.
Choosing between effective enough but risking blowing up the space station shiny, and a maybe ineffective drama queen is hard.
In the end I think I will forgo the space station shiny if that is how it must be in order to have a smooth operation, and vote for:
Edit: Oh, you meant K541. Fair enough.
I'll note that the plan emphasizes catching the enemy by surprise to emphasize the effect of our infiltration. We want to go in at full speed to catch them with their pants down so that when our sabotage kicks off it is even more effective, and we can capture ships and sow discord as fast as possible. I think Mr. Shiny Pants is much more likely to proceed slowly, cautiously and by the book, therefore wasting the advantage of surprise and not synergizing as well with the infiltration we've done.
Last edited: