For the record, I am thinking of this from an in character perspective rather then a "what do I want to know about the game world" perspective.

The QM said this is probably the right mindset to take so...

What is the most important thing to ask in character?

Please take into account the vague if accurate nature of this sort of thing when considering the question.

We should not ask something we can find out ourselves. At least not easily.


...Actually we could ask about Selvaria. Even in character we have good reason. After all she is the biggest threat left in Green Hills. Even if it was with help she beat Neo Metal. And with the Six and Arms out of the picture (or soon to be), she is the biggest threat we have.

Memories might end up in vague uselessness, kindness and control we can figure out ourselves.

But Selvie? Only way we'll figure her out is out-of-context information. If nothing else we'll probably learn about the Final Flame. We really need to know about that.

So here's my question.

[ ] "Who is Selvaria Blest?"
 
Warning about full moon vote New
For the record, I am thinking of this from an in character perspective rather then a "what do I want to know about the game world" perspective.


I don't want to influence the votes too much, but this is probably the best way to look at things

I hace tk agree, i really encourage you to think this fron an Incharacter perspective

Dont try to meta game please, that Wont end Well, i promise.

Dont try to be sneaky or game the system, think fron Eggman perspective lf what he would want to know.

Thats my Only advice to give you
 
Last edited:
As much as I would love to get Selvaria away from Max, this is not the time to get a tarot reading on that, Eggman in character knows too little unfortunately.
 
I much prefer the about some hint about the mystery of the Shattered Memories, we need some sort of clue to star handking the situation and I very mych sure this could also help Shadow and is linked to the nature of the Shattering.

Starline only did a patchwork at best and Eggman knows he's receiving memoreis from alterntive counterparts, dreams of events that never happen and blackouts.

Even before the Raid Eggman is concerned about what happen to him according to Side stories.

What future holds if I stick to my old ways?

I pretty sure a painful demise or a lonely life.
 
Here's how I think the question for the shattered memories would be asked by Eggman.

"What is the ideal way for me, Eggman, to take control of these shattered memories that are plaguing me, so that I won't suffer from any negative consequences from them?"
 
i can see "can kindness and control exist together?" as a question that bothers him, but is out there just enough that eggman can simply pose it as both philosphical and intention enough to try and get a read on.
 
As much as I would love to get Selvaria away from Max, this is not the time to get a tarot reading on that, Eggman in character knows too little unfortunately.

We do know she took Neo Metal down, and with all other threats accounted for she's the only one we need to worry about.

She beat NEO METAL SONIC. Eggman would want to know as much as he can about her, if only so he can take her down.

What future holds if I stick to my old ways?
i can see "can kindness and control exist together?" as a question that bothers him, but is out there just enough that eggman can simply pose it as both philosphical and intention enough to try and get a read on.

Though I'm fine with these too.

I don't think we can even ask about the Shattered memories in a way that'd give us a coherent answer.
 
Here's how I think the question for the shattered memories would be asked by Eggman.

"What is the ideal way for me, Eggman, to take control of these shattered memories that are plaguing me, so that I won't suffer from any negative consequences from them?"

He does not knwo the name of condition or what's happening to him.

He know he get headaches, memories, balckouts and apperently alternative counterpats take control of his body by small amount of time.

Eggman is someone that trives in controlling stuff, the fact something is influecing him in a fundamental way and lose control of his own body probably would be disturbing for him in some levels.

I mean I certanly would be disturbed if something were happening to me this way and would search everywhere to have a clue why this is happening and make it stop.
 
I don't know why, but Old Ways feels like it'd be too muddled by Mr. Tinker to really be a question Eggman would ask. (plus I don't see him asking that any time soon anyway because he doesn't regret shit.)
 
We do know she took Neo Metal down, and with all other threats accounted for she's the only one we need to worry about.

She beat NEO METAL SONIC. Eggman would want to know as much as he can about her, if only so he can take her down.

Mmmh. Yup…she…definitely did.

Wasn't saved at the last minute or anything by an X factor no one foresaw…

That aside. Asking about her is to Meta of a question. Eggman really doesn't care about her.
 
Last edited:
Serious guys is not better to ask about the Shattering Memories?

This sound sounds like a topic that would deeply disturb him in some ways and want a solution orbat least a hint for a solution.

He may even be desperate enough to even ask for a Fortune Teller about it since he does not have the facilities to study it and he himself is being chnaged by them as well.
 
Last edited:
Serious guys is not better to ask about the Shattering Memories?

This sound sounds like a topic that would deeply disturb him in some ways and want a solution orbat least a hint for a solution.

Unironically it's because Eggman would want to know what the hell is causing it that he'd not ask that unless he has no other option. Eggman's not someone who believes in magic, so unless it's easily verifiable or something that is so out of left field no on should reasonably expect it, I don't think Eggman would ask.

Kindness and Power is just an idle curiosity that happens to fit with "no one would expect this question from me."
 
Last edited:
Serious guys is not better to ask about the Shattering Memories?

This sound sounds like a topic that would deeply disturb him in some ways and want a solution orbat least a hint for a solution.

He may even be desperate enough to even ask for a Fortune Teller about it since he does not have the facilities to study it and he himself is being chnaged by them as well.

We Can attest that no, eggman isnt at that point.

Eggman isnt at that level lf desesperation you are suggesting.

What he is asking Elizabeth is more as curiosity, in case she is the real deal. Its not a shot in the dark HoPing for a miracle answer.

Just a curiosity that May or not Pay off

Edit; please Dont make this more than or os ir assume wild possibilities, lf that were the case be aware we will inform you guys
 
Last edited:
We Can attest that no, eggman isnt at that point.

Eggman isnt at that level lf desesperation you are suggesting.

What he is asking Elizabeth is more as curiosity, in case she is the real deal. Its not a shot in the dark HoPing for a miracle answer.

Just a curiosity that May or not Pay off

There goes the idea.

[] Tell me, what is in store for I, Doctor Ivo "Eggman" Robotnik?

A simple reading for his future, vague enough that can tell a good thing or a bad thing.

Plus he did try something similar in Tailstube with Amy tarot reading but get the meaning of the cards completly wrong.

I would ask about the Chaos Emeralds but considerable how the they are iz doubftul even the Velvet Room can offer a helpful hint. There's a reason why they are called the Miracle Gems.
 
Last edited:
Part of the reason I don't want to ask about our memory problem is the reasoning that Kingster gave us for not worrying too much about Archie Eggman. "There's no reason being afraid of the inevitable." We'll get our answer sooner or later. Perhaps as a result of the Council of Eggs Achievement.

"Can kindness and control exist together?" Just feels lovely from a character development standpoint. And asking about the Chaos Emeralds is... probably the closest to actionable intel we can get here? These folks are usually great for giving us vibes and hints, but not so great for actionable intel.
 
The Maria and Gerald one would be a good way to go then.

Just like his beautiful daughter was brought back to him.

Who is to said his estemeed grandfather and his cousin aren't also within the land of the living too.

TBH Eggman would have both hope and probably terrified of meeting Gerald.

He modeled his life after the man in the end and was pretty much his idol growing up.

But there is also the fear, the fear that instead of meeting one of the greatest man in the scietific field, he could instead meet the man which wanted nothing more but to destroy the human race for what GUN did.

Doesn't help the later encounter would go a lot like the one in the movie.

Where Eggman tries to reason with his grandfather only for the coming words to go out.

''YOU ARE NOT MARIA!
 
We Can attest that no, eggman isnt at that point.

Eggman isnt at that level lf desesperation you are suggesting.

What he is asking Elizabeth is more as curiosity, in case she is the real deal. Its not a shot in the dark HoPing for a miracle answer.

Just a curiosity that May or not Pay off

A curiosty huh? Right as far as Eggman knows this is just an ordinary woman. He has no reason to expect an actually useful answer.

That crosses Shattered memories out, possibly not the Shattering though.

...Wait this just means that he might ask about Selvaria!

He doesn't care no, but he isn't actually expecting an answer so why not?
 
Actually we could ask her the location fo the Seven Chaos Emeralds.

If she describe our base then we would know she's the real deal.
 
A curiosty huh? Right as far as Eggman knows this is just an ordinary woman. He has no reason to expect an actually useful answer.

That crosses Shattered memories out, possibly not the Shattering though.

...Wait this just means that he might ask about Selvaria!

He doesn't care no, but he isn't actually expecting an answer so why not?


Why in the world he would ask about Selvaria.

If following your logic he would more likely ask about Sonic.
Perhaps he could, perhaps he couldnt, again, sorry do we didnt explain this Well enough it o. The uldate and left it too open.

Eggman knows enough about the Mystic side to not discount the possibility lf a Fortune teller being thw real deal, but also Just doesnt fully believe it.

He sends Piastol to check out and Either is a scam or she os the real deal and gets something out of it.

But its as I said, a curiosity, something Just to confirm, he isnt expecting an answer, but wouldnt be against getting it

Asking about Selvaria could be a possibility, dependa how you Word it thought, thats the key.
 
Last edited:
kingster is right ultimately it depends how you word the question like out of all the vary factions in Greenhill, who is the biggest threat to me?

I can also be used as to ask like a character thing I can change choices it can influence us in the future essentially, it just comes down how you word the question and how in character it feels to you
 
Back
Top