That depends on the canon and the various QMs.


You are absolutely right of course.

Yet he tried before and failed, despite his determination, while now he has absolutely nothing to lose and no life to live. Death would actually be something he would crave when you think about it. Why not try to have revenge while doing so, even if his chances are slim?
I feel the need to point out that this is folklore, it's not something that actually happened.

(In-universe I mean. Obviously all of this is a story, but this is a story in a story)

This isn't 'in King Charles' reign Count Dumbfuck tried hiding his children from the Fey and was punished', this is 'they say if you try and hide your children from the Fey it won't work and you'll be punished for it. Don't believe me? Then sit and listen to the tragic tale of Count Dumbfuck'.
 
I feel the need to point out that this is folklore, it's not something that actually happened.

(In-universe I mean. Obviously all of this is a story, but this is a story in a story)

This isn't 'in King Charles' reign Count Dumbfuck tried hiding his children from the Fey and was punished', this is 'they say if you try and hide your children from the Fey it won't work and you'll be punished for it. Don't believe me? Then sit and listen to the tragic tale of Count Dumbfuck'.
Yes, I know that.

I simply like the alternative ending way more. :V
 
Yet he tried before and failed, despite his determination, while now he has absolutely nothing to lose and no life to live. Death would actually be something he would crave when you think about it. Why not try to have revenge while doing so, even if his chances are slim?
You're asking why a guy with his own unique personality shaped by his personal experience, from a completely different (and imaginary) culture didn't do a particular thing while confronted by a tragedy. Different people can react differently to the same situation, and are pretty complex at that.
 
Speaking of this, what is your stance on magic-y folks in Estalia/Tilea, then?
There's a 3rd edition WFRP supplement about magic the name of which I can't remember off the top of my head, which briefly touches on Tilea and Estalia, explaining that they are in the same state as pre-Teclisian Empire.

Nobles and rulers might sponsor wizards because they are useful, but the wider population fears and hates magic-users, and in terms of magic-y folks the Cults of the classical pantheon are far more prominent.

Though, of course, that comes with the attendum that Tilea and Estalia are different nations, and are in turn split into various competing city-states and petty kingdoms, allowing for a lot of regional variance.

There's the terrible possibility that parents who have too many children pretend they disappeared overnight while having secretly killed them.
Or parents whose child was born mutated.

In most places in the Old World, the parents would be put to death as well under the assumption that they are also tainted.

I guess my second question would be why would you kill the first son before the second is even born? He doesn't have the Talent, so what was the point? That hiding your kid away from potential gribblies is unchivalrous or something?
Because the lord tried to keep him from being taken by hiding him. The point of this Bretonnian folklore, the lesson it's trying to say is "If you try to keep your child from being taken by the Fae, you will lose them one way or the other. Either they will be taken anyway, or they will be killed to punish you."

If trying to prevent the child from being taken leads to losing them 100% of the time, and not trying leads to losing the child 0.1%* of the time, then that motivates people into not trying to prevent the child from being taken.

*Arbitrary figure

Not really.

A new Enchantress will be selected the next day probably, so Bretonnia will be just fine.
As far as anyone knows, there has only ever been one Fae Enchantress in the history of Bretonnia. She is widely considered to be the mortal avatar of the Lady.
 
Last edited:
I wish Blanks and Pariahs existed in Fantasy. The idea of a Sisters of Silence style group tucked away in some hidden corner of the world would have massive storytelling potential.
 
What about the sheer aura of Dawi Grudging?
That makes them shit themselves, witch is also handy but not as actively dangerous.
The fact hat there's one example of a fantasy world with a guy like that doesn't change the fact that when most people hear "fantasy world" they don't think of anti-magic guys.
Have you heard of an anti magic guy in a setting without magic? (Or something like magic)
 
Speaking of Abhorash, for some reason I imagine he pretends to be a totally average Blood Dragon who pretends to be a human mercenary just so he get some fights and travel around the world. It's too boring to stay inside his cave and do nothing there.

"I'm a dude playing as a dude disguised as another dude!" - Abhorash under the alias of "Steve the Red Knight"

I mean, if he openly revealed his identity most people would either: not know who the hell he is (i don't think his name is well known outside of scholars and Witch Hunters) or know and run away as fast as they can.

In both cases, it wouldn't be any fun for him.

Speaking of being unchivalrous, the worst part of the story is that said lord died a broken man, doing nothing with his lot in life.

I actually expected him to go roaring rampage of revenge for what happened to him. He has no heir, he is already disgraced by filicide and by denying the Fay Enchantress, while the Lady forsook him. All he can do now is to go to wherever the Enchantress is staying and find death in trying to avenge his misery... or succeed. Either alone or with very few loyal followers, that saw the grave injustice done to their lord/friend and are ready to march with him into the jaws of death.

That sounds incredibly epic.

I would read a story abaout that.
 
True, but dwarfs don't cause mages to have seizures by standing near them.
Neither do most pariahs. They have different grades of strength, and use special training and equipment to strengthen their abilities.

Kind of like Dwarf Runesmiths.

Dwarfs, or unicorns? Even a unicorn's skull counts as a talisman counts as a protection against magic.

They're even better in that their resistance is apparently entirely protective. Friendly casters can cast from their back just fine.
Unicorns are magic-resistant by dint of being magical themselves, rather than being anti-magical.
 
Neither do most pariahs. They have different grades of strength, and use special training and equipment to strengthen their abilities.

Kind of like Dwarf Runesmiths.
Fine, I concede the point. I just thought it was an interesting concept is all, imagining Fanriel's reaction to first encountering an omega level blank whether she knew what they were or not.
 
Her being an elf is speculative (though well supported). There only having ever been one is canonical. Or as canonical as anything can be.
6th states that it's believed there have been many Fay Enchantresses. AFAIK the options are 1) it's one person with some form of not-aging, 2) it's an Everqueen style situation where each new Enchantress gets the memories of her predecessors or 3) it's a bunch of different people all raised/trained to act as the Fay Enchantress.

True, but dwarfs don't cause mages to have seizures by standing near them.
Give the Dwarf a hammer and five minutes and they'll fix that.

OTOH I'm not sure the protections offered by a Dwarf would be as good when riding it into battle :tongue:
You'd need another set of protections so the Dwarf didn't kill you first!
 
Back
Top