These were fun ideas, well-done. The only one I personally would be against is Hermione's- I disagree with putting illegal things down in writing or teach dangerous recipes in written form only (probably requires an in-person lesson).

Meanwhile, the Dumbledore one is perfect and I really want to see his reaction. I kind of object to wasting time on a gift for Snape but it's hilarious and also bonding time with Sirius so really a gift for him?

In Hermione's case, teaching her the recipe is ultimately not really as dangerous as you would believe.
The only danger comes in if she tells on us to a teacher (unlikely) and even then we can probably play it off.
There's an offer of tutoring attached to this gift as well, though I doubt that Hermione would need us for anything more than initial confirmations of the Potion's effectiveness.

The Snape gift is more of an excuse to spend time with Sirius, and I like the idea of Sirius gaining an interest in mechanical puzzles and maybe learning to tackle problems in ways that do not involve magic.

Also, can we get a bit of discussion going for some Gnosis farming?
 
Can someone please remind me why, now that we freed up some time, we don't want to practice our Occlumency? It feels pretty silly not to do so, especially now that we have Geist to help us with it.
 
tbh, i assumed geist was going to be launching random attacks against harry's mental defenses throughout the day until our boy is good enough to protect himself in his sleep
 
tbh, i assumed geist was going to be launching random attacks against harry's mental defenses throughout the day until our boy is good enough to protect himself in his sleep

I am hoping for the same tbh, but I would want to make a concentrated effort.
After all, Occlumency doesn't take a lot of our free time to train, and while it is a skill that we rarely use it's still a massively useful one.

I'll add a passage for Occlumency training to my vote and I encourage everyone else to do the same.
 
[X] _brightwing

Drop the Investigation

This is not a option I want to pike given what ignoring the plot could do to us later

Question Ms. Nettlebane

This option carries a lot of risk if we fail which makes me not want to pike it given the consequences of failure would likely be us being discovered as a dark wizard and having Geist in our head causing us to go to Azkaban. Assuming we capture Tonks how would we get the information out of her. She defiantly has Occlumency and we don't have any Veritaserum either. So either Harry will torture the information out of her which is not something I want harry to do or Harry can't bring him self to do so after getting her where he want her which would make doing this pointless

We would also have to worry about someone finding out about this by reading our or our friends minds keeping in mind we only know basic Occlumency and our friend don't even have that

Question Sirius
This is better in that it is not majorly illegal but is as stated in the option unlikely to work and will just let Sirius know we are get up to things he does not want us getting up to

( It would be funny if this Sirius was like canon Sirius and would just tell us if asked though given his new personality I dough it)

Question Dementor

While this choice has it's dangers we will likely be fine since we have both Geist help and our ability to use the Patronus in a emergency. Also unlike the other options this one is likely to actually give us valuable information and does not have Harry do something immoral and the consequences if we fail are far less bad
 
Last edited:
I think that we don't have enough Gnosis to buy a very good Patronus for ourselves (I'd assume that we would need 25 at least), so IMO it's a bit early for this, the next turn would be preferable probably.
 
[X] Write-in: Fix Our Eyesight

Like, really? You're considering this?

We are considering it obviously, but what means do we have to so so? It is specifically stated in the opening post that this particular demerit cannot be easily removed and would require great potioneering and/or alchemical effort.

Also, the demerit of not knowing what upgrades do unless we have about enough gnosis to buy them is not that significant IMO, at least not to the point where we can't hold off on it.

Frankly I'd probably avoid studying the Patronus for now, but it is what it is.
 
Last edited:
Also, the demerit of not knowing what upgrades do unless we have about enough gnosis to buy them is not that significant IMO, at least not to the point where we can't hold off on it.
Knowing what upgrades do is key if we want to SAVE. On top of that, blurbs equal lore - important lore that is important even for the game itself, and not from only a "ooh funfact" standpoint.
 
Knowing what upgrades do is key if we want to SAVE. On top of that, blurbs equal lore - important lore that is important even for the game itself, and not from only a "ooh funfact" standpoint.

Yeah I agree with you, but what I'm saying is that for now we have no viable methods to remove our eyesight affliction and no open paths to do so, so getting invested in it without any prompts or preparations would require a lot of our resources and over a long period of time, which at the moment is not worth it imo
 
Yeah I agree with you, but what I'm saying is that for now we have no viable methods to remove our eyesight affliction and no open paths to do so, so getting invested in it without any prompts or preparations would require a lot of our resources and over a long period of time, which at the moment is not worth it imo
We can potentially summon infinite demons but we can't find one that can fix our eyes? Come on.
 
We can potentially summon infinite demons but we can't find one that can fix our eyes? Come on.

I mean there probably is a demon with the alchemical ability/talent to cure our eyesight, but we don't necessarily know who they are.
Same way with the super powerful demons: they certainly exist, but our ability to find out about them and then to summon them is actually a whole other problem.

If we had taken an alchemy tris (or rather, would take), then we could just do some magic surgery on our eyes or something.
Until then, maybe Hermione will be able to come up with something in a few years?

Personally though, if given the opportunity I'd rather choose our fourth tris slot to be magical theory, to just give us a massive all-around boost to literally anything and everything.
 
Even if we would have the energy to summon an endless number of demon but we don't know the rituals to summon every demon. To use a demon to fix Harrys eyes we need to find the right ritual to summon the right demon. Our convent strength would not be the issue

We need to get Ornias to check out Impossible Perfection

We never found out what ever happened to that piece of The Dark Lord Harry saw as a kid. Dose anyone think this could come back and bite us
 
Which will dilute it to hell and back, making it a virtual 0.001% +All Stats.

Magical theory is understanding the theory of magic and how it all works and connects together.

When used, it allows for spell creation and research of magical principles, with the most extreme levels being just thinking of an effect and then creating a spell or potion to match it.

This isn't a direct boost to a large variety of subjects (unlike, say, "spells" as a category), but it will grant us understanding of theoretical principles of magic and will give us an opportunity to apply it to our existing base of knowledge, which in my mind can work with pretty much any field super well.

In essence, it's a boost towards "innovation" rather than "magic" so to speak, which in turn will open up the higher end of magic to us that much quicker.
 
Last edited:
Sunlight Shimmer
Sunlight Shimmer

Early December encroached upon Hogwarts, and with it came the first, belayed snowfalls. As sheets of pearly white gathered outside the castle, and children departed to play in the chilly air, Harry was on watch, thoughtful and disturbed. He wasn't that popular now anyway - his acceptance was frayed, given the events of the last school year.

"Are you good, mate?" Ron asked, coming up from behind. He'd put on a pair of woolen mittens and a heavy cloak. Harry dressed more lightly, in a simple jacket, and kept periodically heating himself with muttered spells and Warming Charms. "You're out here sulking and stuff."

"I've been thinking."

"Yeah, I can tell," Ron answered, "It really shows when you do. You get quiet and broody."

"I don't brood," Harry harrumphed. That was Geist's schtick!

"You do." Ron laughed. "What's been eatin' away at you? Some argument with Nev over demons again?"

Harry simply shook his head, contemplating how to respond. He chose pointedly not to question how Ron possessed knowledge of his demons - Ron seemed to have ways of knowing the most inconvenient things, and usually escaped solid answers whenever questioned. If he pushed, Ron would surely reveal the truth, but there was no grounded reason to do so. Harry trusted Ron to reveal his sources should they ever become even in the slightest chunk relevant in some manner. Until then, Harry would allow him to keep those secrets to himself.

If there was one thing that Harry could say he'd learned at Hogwarts - aside from harnessing the magical abilities latent within him - it was that everyone had their own secrets. Secrets they didn't want other people to see. Even people like Dumbledore or McGonagall had dark or interesting secrets.

"It's... the basement stuff."

"Oh, that stuff."

"I've been thinking about finding that Dementor and squeezing the answers out of it."

"Gonna use your Dark magic to beat it into compliance?" Ron snorted. As soon as the words left Ron's lips, Harry looked nervously around. The other boy snorted again, and said, "Relax man, I've warded us. No sound getting through. It seems the Auror's got you on edge."

"Yeah. It's been riskier than ever to practice my usual stunts," Harry answered. It didn't keep him from summoning demons to complete his homework assignments. Maybe the Auror's Office, and wizards in general, truly were as incompetent as Geist claimed? It was a hard pill to swallow, especially given some of the feats of competence he'd observed firsthand. It seemed like there were gaps, or maybe even spots in ability that didn't entirely add up. It was like half the Wizarding World was sandbagging its capabilities, especially the adults. He frowned in thought, but decided to contemplate on that sometime later. "I wish there was some fast, easy way to get a Dementor to behave. I don't want them sucking my happiness out."

"Have you considered a Patronus Charm?"

"A Patronus?" Harry's eyebrows furrowed as he recalled, through the murk of information, the small details he'd read of the advanced magic. It seemed like a stretch to be able to learn a Charm that powerful, but he smiled - if there was anyone who could master it in their Second Year, it was Harry Potter. "Good idea, Ron."

As December went on, Harry practiced the Patronus Charm in private every night. To his frustration, even in his best attempts, he couldn't produce more than a couple of sparks of errant light. After some weary observation, Geist stepped in and began to instruct him directly, but even then, the tired ghost's directions were limited in puissance. They were also occupied with training Harry's Occlumency up to another level and Harry was occupied with preparing for the last of his midterm exams. However, as school went out, and the Aurors, save Ms. Nettlebane, packed up and largely returned to the Ministry of Magic, Harry found himself with a bunch of free time.

And finally, a couple of nights before Christmas, he managed it. Sadly, there weren't any Dementors left in Hogwarts, as it went against Ministry regulations to leave deadly, soul-sucking monsters in the vicinity of school children without appropriate measures put into place towards protecting the children from them.

In absence of anything better to do, Harry decided to handle the Christmas present arrangements. A number of gifts had to be given out, and Harry relished in the task of finding appropriate presents for his acquaintances and loved ones.

Among them, the most difficult was probably Draco's and Snape's - the former because reading half a year into the future, even in the vaguest way, was a trial and a pain; the latter, because it felt shudderingly unnatural to send anything to Professor Snape, even though the gift was simply a piece of parchment veiled with sarcasm and smugness. He genuinely hoped that Snape wouldn't perceive it as some attack on his authority and dock more points from House Hufflepuff. The Potions Master was fond of doing that.

Another gift he'd come up with was the First Year Beret - the hopeful beginning of a new Hogwarts tradition, potentially, assuming that nobody down the line happened to accidentally misplace or lose it. He was planning on gifting it to a young girl he'd seen and vaguely spoke with during breakfast; Luna Lovegood. Among the First Years, she and Ron's younger sister were probably the only ones who hadn't put much stock into Harry's new reputation and shied away from him like from the plague.

And, of course, Neville's sword - the project began ambitiously, but Harry eventually realized that while awesome, the idea of metal absorbing magic so readily wasn't as easily realized as in his mind's eye. As a matter of fact, stacking that many enchantments on a sword was a trial of its own.

And the last gift was the most important. And ironically, it also cost him the least in effort and money.

Gently, Harry stacked the Muggle book on permutation theory on top of the Rubik's cubes, then wrapped everything together. He penned a short handwritten letter, and put the gift away, planning to deliver it personally on the day of Christmas.

Dearest Sirius,

I think that we've made it through some hard times, and I know that it can be even more difficult when all you have left is work. I know that you aren't fully healed, and I doubt I ever will be either. But we have each other, and that's what matters. It's really important to have engaging hobbies to keep one's mental health keen, so I dare you to master this by next December - it'd make me really happy to see you solving it!

Sincerely, Harry


He smiled and leaned away from his chair.

---

Animal forms, such as those of an Animagus and displayed by the Patronus, are dependent on the same aspect of a soul: the Spirit Animal. Although it's often said that such animals are equal, some are undoubtedly more equal than others. Select your Spirit Animal - you've got 22.5 Gnosis to spend.

[ ] Wolf - The intelligent, playful wolf. He is a pack hunter, devoted above everything to his family, ever in service to his loved ones. The wolf fits you exceptionally well.

[ ] Raven [5 Gnosis] - The cunning and wicked raven, freely patrolling the skies in search of adventure and secrets. Its calls of greed are familiar to you already.

[ ] Stag [7 Gnosis] - The indomitable and brave stag, a guardian of the forest, is associated with protection and majesty. It's also your father's very own.

[ ] Chimpanzee [14 Gnosis] - The empathetic and versatile chimpanzee: feels as humans do, and its workings may be arranged in a similar manner.

[ ] Phoenix [25 Gnosis] - The resplendent phoenix: eternal and immortal, its very presence bends the cosmos towards the aspects of justice.

And what are some of the more notable gifts that Harry might've received this Christmas? You may select three (3) or pay a sum of Gnosis equal to the additional options past that amount; one Gnosis per.

[ ] Magical Toothpaste - Apparently, Hermione's been trying to get into enchanting dental and hygiene products. She's managed to produce her first batch of effective toothpaste recently, and claims it can whiten your teeth almost immediately - a good amendment for your caffeine habits, or so she claims. Let's put that hypothesis to a good, hardy test, shall we? (She also wishes you Merry Christmas, of course.)

[ ] Mistletoe Wand - It's from Neville, oddly enough. These are illegal in most Wizarding countries, including Magical Britain. Mistletoe's almost no good for any proper Charmwork or spellcasting, but it can do a whole lot of Dark Arts and "meaner spells" just fine. However, its most notable and favorable attribute is that its spells generally can't be picked up by the Trace, save for especially powerful workings cast in especially public areas. You should be fine, though - just don't go summoning Azathoth or conjuring Reality Marbles out in the middle of the street.

He wishes you Merry Christmas and tells you to keep your secret practices secret.

[ ] Magical Broom - A good flying broom. It doesn't have the newest Charms on the market, but it's still a good piece of work, and it'll serve you faithfully. It came from Ron, alongside a short note, "I know you aren't as big on Quidditch as you pretend to be, but flying's a useful skill. Maybe try to get into it? Merry Christmas, mate -- Ron"

[ ] Jar of Peanut Butter - A whole goshdarn ounce jar of peanut butter. It came from Dumbledore - his initials were carved into the side of the jar, alongside a scratchily-written 'Merry Christmas.' It's odd how the glass seems to reflect the light... Huh.

[ ] Wiggenweld Potion (x6) - An entire batch of very high-quality healing potions, made from the finest available ingredients.

It came with a note, "As I seem to have recovered unusually quickly, I decided I may well put my new time to some good use. And I know that you, of all my students, will sadly need it the most. Attempt not to get into too much trouble this year, Potter: I've got my eye on you, and I remember. Merry Christmas, -- Severus Snape."

[ ] A Letter from D
- An odd letter signed by someone calling themselves 'D.'
 
Last edited:
[X] Phoenix [25 Gnosis] - The resplendent phoenix: eternal and immortal, its very presence bends the cosmos towards the aspects of justice.
[X] Mistletoe Wand
[X] A Letter from D

I believe in Gnosis.
 
Totally called it that Snape gets back his memories. He is the potion master after all, it's not implausible that he'd notice the effects of a forgetfulness potion and brew up an antidote. I think this opens up a lot of avenue for interesting dialogue with him.

He could possibly collaborate with us in the future in case of dire times in Dark Arts. And he'd feel indebted to us and possibly assist us in unexpected ways leveraging his position as a spy.

As for the gifts they represent +++ character interaction. So we should select them based on the character we want more interaction with, not the content itself. Like for example Magical Toothpaste isn't the point - or does compare with the Letter from D, the fact that Hermione is talking about her business enterprise is.

[X] Wiggenweld Potion (x6)
[X] A Letter from D
[X] Jar of Peanut Butter

[X] Gnosis =/> 24.5? Phoenix; Gnosis < 24.5? Wolf

[X] Phoenix [25 Gnosis]

Edit:
I don't have that much free time this week but I'll try to paint something as an apology for being one of the instigators of the dementor debacle. Happy to collab if anyone has ideas? I could work with doodles too.
 
Last edited:
Ron's abilities and insights honestly worry me a bit

We jumped the gun way too much on our Patronus choice, though I said as much previously.
The options are that we either take the Wolf or the Raven Patronus (Wolf is free, Raven offers many advantages that are worth the small investment IMO) or we go all out, get some more gnosis, and go for the Phoenix, though that may be just us overreaching.

Regarding the gifts, I really don't feel like spending any more gnosis on them than we have.

Hermione's gift is a fun one, Neville's is practical and useful (though we have already removed the trace from us and Neville doesn't know that, so at most we would be getting an additional, limited wand), and Ron's is mostly generic (though it might be a hint for things to come?)

Rather, it's the three last gifts that interest me the most.
Dumbledore's gift is weird and unusual enough to make me interested, and although Snape's gift is relatively worthless (we can make Wiggenweld ourselves just fine) the action of taking it would have Harry be informed of the fact that Snape remembers what we did to him.

The letter from D is a letter from Dudley I suspect, and quite a nice surprise for Harry I would imagine, so in my mind taking it should go without saying.


Another worry that I have is that if Sirius becomes too invested in new hobbies then his teaching ability will decline since he won't be putting his all into teaching, which in turn would make the curse take effect and take him out.

As such, I think that removing the curse over the position would be something that's worth doing by the end of the year.
 
Last edited:
[X] Wolf - The intelligent, playful wolf. He is a pack hunter, devoted above everything to his family, ever in service to his loved ones. The wolf fits you exceptionally well.

Don't see much of a point of going against Harry's nature.
 
[X] Wolf
[X] Wiggenweld Potion (x6)
[X] A Letter from D

I don't particularly see how this patronus vote suggests we should've waited. Yep, we have the option to spend Gnosis on different forms. The exchange rate available is 25 Gnosis for a form worth bothering with at all, or 0 through to 14 for not. Mind, I'd take Phoenix in a second if I could then assume Harry would stay in phoenix form at all times and thus be immune to death- but considering Phoenix only has 11 Gnosis-price over 'be a worse human' I somehow suspect this will not happen.
 
[X] Wolf
[X] Wiggenweld Potion (x6)
[X] A Letter from D

I don't particularly see how this patronus vote suggests we should've waited. Yep, we have the option to spend Gnosis on different forms. The exchange rate available is 25 Gnosis for a form worth bothering with at all, or 0 through to 14 for not. Mind, I'd take Phoenix in a second if I could then assume Harry would stay in phoenix form at all times and thus be immune to death- but considering Phoenix only has 11 Gnosis-price over 'be a worse human' I somehow suspect this will not happen.

tbf, a large part of the gnosis required is the extent of which harry has to stray from his nature to achieve a particular form.
Had we played the game differently then the Chimpanzee would probably be free.

The Phoenix form is pretty much the lower end of special forms of magical creatures, though I suspect that it resonates with Harry's nature at least somewhat to be available for us at all.

I also think that having a Raven form would is not at all worthless to consider - it can fly and integrate well with the environment, making it something at least worth considering.
 
Back
Top