Green Flame Rising (Exalted vs Dresden Files)

and my own understanding that to others would be called Intellectus
Only bit of that that I'm leery on. The Crown is one thing that I'm still on board with keeping top secret, and would rather not even put the word intellectus in their heads. Just leave it an understanding of our own power. It includes slightly less absolute certainty, but the sources that we've already mentioned there seem suitable for that.
 
Only bit of that that I'm leery on. The Crown is one thing that I'm still on board with keeping top secret, and would rather not even put the word intellectus in their heads. Just leave it an understanding of our own power. It includes slightly less absolute certainty, but the sources that we've already mentioned there seem suitable for that.
Molly did tell Merlin back when they had their meeting.

Another pause, this one unplanned as light blooms around you, eyes uncounted like a shoal of strange fish floating though the air "You know intelectus is really weird, I cannot put into words how wierd it is not to know something until you think about it, especially when your previous assumption about how something works turns out to have been wrong."
So the intellectus thing is already out of the bag. They just dont know the full extent of the crowns power.
 
Only bit of that that I'm leery on. The Crown is one thing that I'm still on board with keeping top secret, and would rather not even put the word intellectus in their heads. Just leave it an understanding of our own power. It includes slightly less absolute certainty, but the sources that we've already mentioned there seem suitable for that.
This is a near-quote of what we told Merlin:
For once you do not even consider the devious option and even Usum does not bring it up, maybe because he is cooking up something more subtle but still... "Unfettered access." As you say that the wizards, well all wizards not named 'Harry Dresden' at least tense up. "Well that needs some temporizing, they will be bound to their word the same as any other spirit you might call and right now I don't know how to unbind them, but I am certain with that understanding that is called in tomes of gramaire intelectus that is I try I could."

As you collect your thoughts you turn off the tablet, flip Clippy closed, though of course she is still recording. "All of them are part of me, the me that is the sponsor, like higher dimensional Molly and..."

Lost 1 Essence -> Now at 10/15 (Occult Excellency)

Another pause, this one unplanned as light blooms around you, eyes uncounted like a shoal of strange fish floating though the air "You know intelectus is really weird, I cannot put into words how wierd it is not to know something until you think about it, especially when your previous assumption about how something works turns out to have been wrong."
White Council already knows that we have some manner of Intellectus somehow related to this world.
 
Let's see:

[X] Disabuse Wu Min of her misunderstanding in order to prevent a seed of distrust growing between you and the council
-[X] Use the following pieces of information:
--[X] That the rules are different here as compared to hells - without mentioning that Amoracchus couldn't follow MIchael here
--[X] That the exaltation predates Yomi hells
--[X] That the Courts are inherently a part of the exaltation, not something you conquered or chanced upon
--[X] That the exaltations were made for mortals and mortals only - what Uriel told you
--[X] Your inherent understanding of your powers
-[X] Subterfuge excellency, ATB, Occult excellency
-[X] STUNT: "I thank you for the advice in the spirit it was given, but your conclusions are wrong. These things I know, from the angels of the Lord, other forces trustful beyond reproach, and my own understanding that to others would be called Intellectus: This power of mine was made for mortal hands, and mortal hands only, in ages past, so that impossible can be made inevitable; Before I first stepped inside, this world existed in-potentia only, and yet its history is no less true for it, time as mortals know its flow not applicable here; it is connected to my power, and to myself in a way more akin to how an arm is connected to the brain than how a conquered realm is connected to its conqueror; it is unlike other realms, hells included, the rules are different here"

I really, really dislike miscommunications like this that have a strong chance to harm future relationships. And this one has that potential, if White Council concludes that we are sitting on a Yama King shaped bomb.

EDIT: And now I am waiting people to tell me why all the information should be held close to our chest, and sharing it would do more harm than good.

EDIT2: changed wording, added our own understand of our powers to the mix.
Couple of questions here: first of all, is Subterfuge the right one for this? I'm not as familiar with the mechanics of Exalted vs. WoD as I could be, but this doesn't really feel like subterfuge - we're explicitly trying to convince her of something true in an effort to build trust, after all.

Second, would you be alright with me adding a bit to this stunt? Just looking to give it some interaction with the scene in addition to the dialogue, hopefully to get a better chance at convincing her. I really can't stand the whole "harmful miscommunications that could be resolved if anyone just talked" trope either.

Was thinking something like this, additions in bold:

-[] STUNT: You join Wu Min in gazing out at the city for a moment, then let your eyes shift focus to her faint reflection in the glass. You see a pensiveness on her face, for all that she hides it behind a diplomat's practiced serenity - a worry that could turn to fear, and a fear that could poison all of your efforts towards a good relationship with the White Council if unaddressed.
-[] STUNT: You shift purposefully in your chair, drawing Wu Min's attention back to you, and meet her eyes across the library table. "I thank you for the advice in the spirit it was given, but your conclusions are wrong. These things I know, from the angels of the Lord, other forces trustful beyond reproach, and my own understanding that to others would be called Intellectus: This power of mine was made for mortal hands, and mortal hands only, in ages past, so that impossible can be made inevitable; Before I first stepped inside, this world..." and here you look out again to the city for a moment, letting Wu Min see the solemnity with which you view your duties, "...existed in-potentia only, and yet its history is no less true for it. Time as mortals know its flow not applicable here; it is connected to my power, and to myself in a way more akin to how an arm is connected to the brain than how a conquered realm is connected to its conqueror; it is unlike other realms, hells included, the rules are different here."

Even if not, though:
[X] Yog
 
Couple of questions here: first of all, is Subterfuge the right one for this? I'm not as familiar with the mechanics of Exalted vs. WoD as I could be, but this doesn't really feel like subterfuge - we're explicitly trying to convince her of something true in an effort to build trust, after all.

Second, would you be alright with me adding a bit to this stunt? Just looking to give it some interaction with the scene in addition to the dialogue, hopefully to get a better chance at convincing her. I really can't stand the whole "harmful miscommunications that could be resolved if anyone just talked" trope either.

Was thinking something like this, additions in bold:

-[] STUNT: You join Wu Min in gazing out at the city for a moment, then let your eyes shift focus to her faint reflection in the glass. You see a pensiveness on her face, for all that she hides it behind a diplomat's practiced serenity - a worry that could turn to fear, and a fear that could poison all of your efforts towards a good relationship with the White Council if unaddressed.
-[] STUNT: You shift purposefully in your chair, drawing Wu Min's attention back to you, and meet her eyes across the library table. "I thank you for the advice in the spirit it was given, but your conclusions are wrong. These things I know, from the angels of the Lord, other forces trustful beyond reproach, and my own understanding that to others would be called Intellectus: This power of mine was made for mortal hands, and mortal hands only, in ages past, so that impossible can be made inevitable; Before I first stepped inside, this world..." and here you look out again to the city for a moment, letting Wu Min see the solemnity with which you view your duties, "...existed in-potentia only, and yet its history is no less true for it. Time as mortals know its flow not applicable here; it is connected to my power, and to myself in a way more akin to how an arm is connected to the brain than how a conquered realm is connected to its conqueror; it is unlike other realms, hells included, the rules are different here."

Even if not, though:
[X] Yog
I love your additions, thank you very much. I'll edit them in when I get home in an hour or so.

As to Subterfuge- not sure. This is to conceal that knights of the Cross can't carry their swords into our realm, while still telling Wu Min that the rules are different here. This is the shakiest part here.
 
I love your additions, thank you very much. I'll edit them in when I get home in an hour or so.

As to Subterfuge- not sure. This is to conceal that knights of the Cross can't carry their swords into our realm, while still telling Wu Min that the rules are different here. This is the shakiest part here.

You would have to make up some other example that made that clear so yeah, it would be manipulation+subterfuge.
 
On the time thing @Yog you might want to clarify that it wasn't the same but now is. We have no capability to warp time here, and don't want to simply we Rumplestiltskin'd them with the diplomatic invitation in any case.
 
On the time thing @Yog you might want to clarify that it wasn't the same but now is. We have no capability to warp time here, and don't want to simply we Rumplestiltskin'd them with the diplomatic invitation in any case.
Oh, very good catch. Done.
-[] STUNT: You join Wu Min in gazing out at the city for a moment, then let your eyes shift focus to her faint reflection in the glass. You see a pensiveness on her face, for all that she hides it behind a diplomat's practiced serenity - a worry that could turn to fear, and a fear that could poison all of your efforts towards a good relationship with the White Council if unaddressed.
-[] STUNT: You shift purposefully in your chair, drawing Wu Min's attention back to you, and meet her eyes across the library table. "I thank you for the advice in the spirit it was given, but your conclusions are wrong. These things I know, from the angels of the Lord, other forces trustful beyond reproach, and my own understanding that to others would be called Intellectus: This power of mine was made for mortal hands, and mortal hands only, in ages past, so that impossible can be made inevitable; Before I first stepped inside, this world..." and here you look out again to the city for a moment, letting Wu Min see the solemnity with which you view your duties, "...existed in-potentia only, and yet its history is no less true for it. Time as mortals know its flow not applicable here; it is connected to my power, and to myself in a way more akin to how an arm is connected to the brain than how a conquered realm is connected to its conqueror; it is unlike other realms, hells included, the rules are different here."
Added to my vote.

Also, added Empathy excellency (up to 4 essence points spent, on the edge of anima flare), and am tempted to spend a willpower point for 1 success.
 
Anything we tell the wizards is going to make its way to the red court.

Let them think it's yomi Wan, it stops them from looking into the mystery of our power because they already have an (incorrect) answer.
 
How you could claim that empty throne I do not know Ms Carpenter

I see, she got the completely wrong idea there it seems, we did not claim an empty throne, we made ours, and it is ours only, never has been another's.

I fear some shadow of your predecessor lingers in the heart of the Labyrinth.

Not of any of the emperors of the thousand hells, that much is sure, but she does not know enough to understand that, there might be a spark of
Malfeas here, but not something as lowly as what she fears, funnily enough, this is a good thing IMO.

EDIT: And now I am waiting people to tell me why all the information should be held close to our chest, and sharing it would do more harm than good.

I even already have a pretty good idea of who would spear the movement....

Anyway:

[x] Yog

Because miscommunications does kill, particularly in diplomacy like this.

Let them have their misconceptions for a while longer.

You don't let a miscommunication that big alone when it comes to diplomacy that important, that's how you get problems, we should kill it in the crib before it can do any damages.

Anything we tell the wizards is going to make its way to the red court.

Let them think it's yomi Wan, it stops them from looking into the mystery of our power because they already have an (incorrect) answer.

Them looking in the mystery of our powers is not going to help them, we already know that some people know more than us, or at least think so, and the only ones that do are basically the all knowing guys, like, Odin is well known for how informed he is about everything and anything, and he is the only *not an archangel* person we met who seems to know enough to gain an advantage out of it.

We are also talking with one of the Wizards we know for a fact is not a spy in any way, and is discrete, so telling that *everything we tell to her will be known by our ennemies* is not really realistic IMO.
 
I don't really see the point in explaining all this.

Let them have their misconceptions for a while longer.
We don't want them to think we are sitting on a Yama King bomb, or that our realm is metaphysically a hell (rather than weirdly an afterlife, yet still a separate Creation) and likely inherently corruptive.
The Red Court maybe, the Black Council certainly, you have a list of all their agents in your head.
Surprisingly enough, I am far less concerned about Black Court learning this, then Red Court. Being creations, servants, and possibly first circle demons of a Neverborn, they might already know what we are.
Let them think it's yomi Wan, it stops them from looking into the mystery of our power because they already have an (incorrect) answer.
Possibly. Possibly not - there are inconsistencies with this already, like our matter being real. And possibly mortal humans living in it. @DragonParadox are there populations of mortal humans in other Yomi hells?
 
[X] Yog

So I like the blurb but it makes it so it doesn't conclusively tell them our stuff is older than yomi wan? But, the vote does include telling them its older than yomi wan right? Will dp just insert more dialogue or will it be lost in translation?
 
This is not terminology. If it was, she would have spoken of Chi and Ying-Yang. But she listed those among other examples of names. She is talking about essence. This stuff:
Somewhere somehow Ancient Mai has at least remnants of ancient lore.
Its terminology.
Mage the Ascension uses Quintessence, which literally means Fifth Essence, to describe the same thing that other splats call Chi, Sekhem, Gnosis, and Glamor.

My line of thinking is that the thing is still there and can't go anywhere else without going through Cleveland first. The whole end of that encounter seemed pretty clear that it was just putting the genie back in the bottle.
It needs to die or reform before it emerges again.
For one thing, its not imprisoned in Cleveland; Cleveland just had enough people of the right Finnish ancestry to attempt to open a hole to its prison.
For another, its been imprisoned since pre-history and never managed a prisonbreak.

For a third, it's linked somehow to the Finnish pantheons and people; the primordial Finnish hero/god Valmainonen that allegedly imprisoned it is his son in some versions of Finnish myth. We dont know the second and third order consequences of opening its prison to kill it. Or even how difficult such a thing would be.

The current solution appears to have worked fine for millenia.
This is clearly a case of leave well alone IMO.
Faces of Truth​
11th of December 2006 A.D.
COMMENTARY
Interesting.
Bao Zhong doesnt have more than a passing paragraph in Blood and Silk, so there isnt much
I suppose we could use this conversation as a Crown focus to learn what the White Council knows about Bao Zhong
Which would presumably give us access to what Elder Mai knows/believes about Bao Zhong.

As for arhats?
We could go to the Library and ask for access to the akuma we handed over to them. And ask some questions.
OR we could call in that favor and go talk to Tuzi and the shen of Chinatown about what arhats are.


Yep as far as she knows all the Nevernever is made of ectoplasm, or rather it decays into that when brought into reality. This is something she knows is odd, but every other sign Wu Mei sees reads 'Yomi Wan'.
I dont buy it. If they are spending so much time looking at weapons in the Brass Courts?
Then they have to be of the impression that it wont simply evaporate like ectoplasm when sunlight hits it in the real world. And Dresden saw Izzy and Alec leave with physical stuff.

And while the Merlin wouldnt have mentioned everything Molly discussed with him, Molly pulling out working technology at Mac's place in the daytime would have been noted as well.
If you guys want to change her mind you can write in an attempt to do so
Im not really seeing why.

We literally have artifacts of Yomi Wan (the sword, the Essence jewel, the Will's body) that demonstrate that not all parts of Yomi Wan are made of ectoplasm.
And the senior members of the White Council will know that there are parts of Yomi Wan that are as physical as everywhere else.


To the more cautious around us - why can't / shouldn't we say to her (and/or Ancient Mai): "Your conclusion is wrong. I don't know what it is exactly, but mine is the power that predates Yomi hells and current iteration of the universe. Archangel Uriel confirms this, even if he is vague about what it is exactly." What is the danger to us here?
I am generally loathe to namedrop really heavy hitters.
I am especially loath to do so when we are asking said people to take our word for it with no supporting evidence. Especially since we dont have Michael here vouchsafing something as ridiculous as "Met an archangel"

Also, the senior members of the White Council know that all of the NeverNever is not made of ectoplasm
Even Dresden knows this; we see him react to mordite/deathstone in Death Masks.


Actually - there's one big flaw in her reasoning that she should know about. Matter in our Courts is not made of ectoplasm. Dresden took samples with him that I assume he shared with the Council. @DragonParadox could you comment on this? If I understood correctly, normally afterlives are part of the NeverNever and their matter is ectoplasm / not eartly matter. Ours, however, is as real as the world is, if not more so.
For one thing, given the canon for how Yomi Wan was formed, there are parts of Yomi Wan that are going to be physical.
Just like there are parts of the NeverNever that used to be part of the physical world. Remember the village we stumbled across on the Way to Monoc's base that apparently came from somewhere in Germany?

For another, we have canonically seen wizards stabilize ectoplasm under certain conditions; McCoy did it in Peace Talks if I recall correctly. We dont know all the rules of how things work in the NeverNever.

For a third, she clearly knows this.
Else there would be no point of looking over the weapons of the Brass Courts if they were all going to melt in the sunlight of the physical world.


That's not the sort of intellectus we claimed.
That particular ability is almost always about or in relation to something, which is why the crown is so weird and broken.
What we claimed was intellectus in relation to how certain workings of our soul world operate.
Also worth noting:
There is no guarantee that the Merlin, or Ancient Mai, would share everything they know with lower-ranked wizards
See how Wu Min's master barely mentioned Bao Zhong's history to her.
Or how McCoy didnt really share any details of his first encounter with Molly with all the Wardens.
 
We don't want them to think we are sitting on a Yama King bomb, or that our realm is metaphysically a hell (rather than weirdly an afterlife, yet still a separate Creation) and likely inherently corruptive.
Our realm is metaphysically a Hell.
Reread the Infernal Chapter in ExWod.

I know Molly is doing her best and DP is playing Infernals a lot less evil than the book presumes you do, but our hell is a hell.
 
I think we're being a bit too cautious in not telling them I'm kind of tired of being so secret about things. I understand there is a place for it but this is not that risky and I'm just generally tired of subterfuge. I can see no mechanical way this could backfire on us other than someone plotting against us. But it is a hell yeah.
 
I am generally loathe to namedrop really heavy hitters.
I am especially loath to do so when we are asking said people to take our word for it with no supporting evidence. Especially since we dont have Michael here vouchsafing something as ridiculous as "Met an archangel"

Also, the senior members of the White Council know that all of the NeverNever is not made of ectoplasm
Even Dresden knows this; we see him react to mordite/deathstone in Death Masks.

Note that in the actual vote I say "angels of the Lord", not "archangel Uriel". It is plausible / possible for us to have met an angel. It's possible to interpret this as having talked to one of the family's angelic protectors, existence of which should be known or at least suspected by White Council. I am trying to be somewhat protective of information even while sharing it.

Other than this concern, which I hope I have answered, what are your thoughts in general? I feel that this sort of misunderstanding might taint our future relationship if left to fester.
Else there would be no point of looking over the weapons of the Brass Courts if they were all going to melt in the sunlight of the physical world.
Actually, there would. Their uses would be more limited, but if they could be used to secure routes and areas in NeverNever, they would still be damn useful. And at least parts of this meeting is about setting up terms for summoning kill teams of power armored nuclear dragon men.
 
I dont buy it. If they are spending so much time looking at weapons in the Brass Courts?
Then they have to be of the impression that it wont simply evaporate like ectoplasm when sunlight hits it in the real world. And Dresden saw Izzy and Alec leave with physical stuff.

Ah, to be clear I am not saying 'they think anything in here will melt', they probably have proof that it will not. My point was that in spite of that one oddity Wu Mei still thinks this is a sort of Yomi Wan.
 
VOTE
[X] Artemis1992

A lot of the elements of the leading vote are based on what appear to me to be mistaken premises.

And even if she thought this was a standard part of the NeverNever?
All we'd do is have her leave with a scarf, or a book, or something else from the Brass Courts that she can puzzle over to her heart's content. When it doesnt evaporate in sunlight, she'll have to figure out what happened.

The rest is just making a fuss over something that ultimately isnt that important.


We don't want them to think we are sitting on a Yama King bomb, or that our realm is metaphysically a hell (rather than weirdly an afterlife, yet still a separate Creation) and likely inherently corruptive.
We voted for a version of the Brass Courts which is a very alien place with very alien people as compared to Earth.
Maybe a third of the people here look human. There is no sun. No moon.
The magical energies of the place is nothing like Earth; there's balefire elementals around here.

That in and of itself supports the idea that this is a Hell, and telling a person not to believe their own eyes and senses seems like one of those very high DC rolls.
You cant have it both ways my friend.

And they have no way of confirming any comment about Yama King bombs or corruptiveness.
WE have no way of confirming that; we explicitly admit that we dont know whats in the Labyrinth.
And we havent been in charge for more than six months anyway.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top