A Little Vice (Trans Magical Girl fic)

Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
That would require recurring male characters.
Let's see, we have Mr. Noir/Superbia, and (apparently) C.
Annnd I'm going to stop my brain right there before it grosses me out.
There's also C's Dad. [Edit: I am assuming that some of how bad C's home life is has been shown by the anime as context for the times C stayed over with Inessa, and thus that C's Dad would actually, y'know, exist as a character in the show before the point where he'd have to show up as part of C's Breaking Point scene.]

Which admittedly isn't any less bad an option.
 
Last edited:
I shall curse you with the knowledge that Harry Potter/Snape is the sixth most popular ship in the category on ao3.
Look, I know how gross Ao3 can be. My first forays in it were through the Batman fandom.

I try to read slash fics on it sometimes and the tag system kinda helps, because you can avoid the very disgusting stuff.
(I also try to read femslash, but a lot of the Ao3 femslash is particularily weird, especially should you go searching for porn.)
I tend to make a beeline with anything tagged « fluff » in it, and usually for pairings I'm familiar with.
 
Last edited:
I shall curse you with the knowledge that Harry Potter/Snape is the sixth most popular ship in the category on ao3.
There's also C's Dad. Which admittedly isn't any less bad an option.
...
this forum does not have a reaction button which reflects my reaction to these posts

Anyways. There's probably some male Resinners that awakened something in certain viewers. Let's assume they're involved in the SVAH M/M fics. Except for the Mr. Noir/Someone's Dad fics.
 
Anyways. There's probably some male Resinners that awakened something in certain viewers. Let's assume they're involved in the SVAH M/M fics. Except for the Mr. Noir/Someone's Dad fics.

"I choose to believe there's at least one fan with dozens of dedicated M/M Charlie/Fidget Spinner fics who was disappointed at the Invidia reveal."
 
Bit late, various reactions:

Chiro is cute when she's in "I am totally getting good grade in Being A Normal Girl, totally am right?" mode, and it's jarring how she can immediately swap between that and "Oh yeah, that teacher has repressed bed vibes, he's perfect for turning into a terrifying monster!". Speaking of monsters, someone (maybe Simon? I can't remember who) noted that while C was just "dreaming" of being a Beast, the Resinners (s)he created always had wacky side effects but were pretty ineffective and minimal threats overall. This being representative of 1)How C's density and lack of self-loathing makes it impossible for him to make progress on anything 2) C subconsciously not wanting to actually HURT the saints.

But now that C has openly embraced Invidia, this is GONE. We don't see clearly what Beaker Breaker's chemicals do (whatever it is, it's bad enough subconscious-C really does not want them to hit any muggles), but they forgo prominent side effects in favor of plain hitting like Truck-Kun. Just its emergence is enough to knock Ina out cold until the end of the fight, and while in the fight itself it mostly just throws the saints off-balance so Invidia or Avaritia can attack it still tanks a lot of direct hits without going down. Meanwhile Invidia herself is directly resorting to lethal brute force- seemingly effectively on instinct (notice it's only after she's started choking a downed Inessa that she has "wait, am I really doing this" thoughts). Across the fight Invidia alternates between having worries about hurting the saints too bad, and sprouting outright villain lines about how she'll be their doom. Said lines are not inspirational, and sound like a bad actor who absolutely cannot get into character of the improv role they're stuck in. Stuff like this:
"Right! To be clear, Castitas, it's because in the depths of my envy I have copied your pronouns as well as your face! Not, like, any other weird reason or anything!"
Is not the words of someone even remotely confident in the evil evildoer who does evil persona act they're putting on. Yet she attacks with murderous force anyways.

Fully unlocking the sin seed has changed C drastically. Oh it has technically alleviated some of their issues- at the cost of implanting a pervading urge to go commit violence that their conscious mind is largely unfit to carry out but is unable to consciously resist. Hot damn, the Abyssal Forest is REALLY BAD BUSINESS.



That was a tough one. I obviously couldn't talk about my taste in media; it was mostly osmosed from Inessa, and Ida would absolutely push us closer together if she saw a chance. Besides, it was embarrassing! The weird fanfics and online fiction were even worse. No one would ever be allowed to know my browser history even if I had to die to protect it.
I'm sure they're talking about, like, fanfics of in-universe shows, they're normie enough. But with the recent talk in this thread about fanfics I'm now wondering what sort of madness is written about the Saints under TTL!AO3's "real person fic" fandom.
Ida hesitated for a moment, "I guess bats aren't so bad," she said in the tone of someone pretending to talk about bats while actually ruminating over a gross ex-friend who turned into an evil bat-girl and betrayed her kindness for no good reason besides that they had secretly always been a horrible jealous monster deep down.
"Not so bad" eh? You say that like there's reason to consider them bad at all sometimes. Ida. Talk to me. What do you have against chiropterans Ida?

Besides, Beaker Breaker might not forgive himself later if he really hurt a student and the Saints weren't around yet to save them because someone had gotten herself knocked out like an idiot.
This is interesting. Since the Resinners are nonsentient as we can tell, here Invidia is using "Beaker Breaker" to refer to Mr Brown after his likely untransformation. Is it just forest-brain causing her to only think in terms of Resinners for the moment and forgetting real names... or does she expect she'll be able to make Mr Brown "sprout" multiple times into the same Resinner so it's worth keeping the "Beaker Breaker" attached to them?

Wait Macroeconomics is something studied in highschool? I thought any sort of economics class with a prefix was university-level stuff.

Also dang creating an entire fictional class schedule for three separate people, fanfic writers really are built different.
There's also C's Dad. [Edit: I am assuming that some of how bad C's home life is has been shown by the anime as context for the times C stayed over with Inessa, and thus that C's Dad would actually, y'know, exist as a character in the show before the point where he'd have to show up as part of C's Breaking Point scene.]
....Actually, I can see Mr. Noir | Superbia Dragon/C's Father working as a ship. In a a deliberately cursed "match made in hell" type of affair. And I wouldn't put it past the fanfic writers to form an image of C's dad on inferences even if he's never shown on-screen.
 
Honestly I think that talking about unlocking the Beast seed as making her do it seems a bit... off? Like, she's just getting into it and wanting to prove herself. That with the kind of power she has it's not hard to turn this into potentially lethal force is... a problem, but I don't think it's, like.

That easy?
 
If we all work together, we can gaslight new readers into thinking this is a real television show, Goncharov style. Any takers?
 
If we all work together, we can gaslight new readers into thinking this is a real television show, Goncharov style. Any takers?
That's going to be difficult, since there are already 1,133 posts speculating about the SVAH fandom, which would be very weird if you could just check the AO3 tag. Also, Goncharov only worked because 90% of Tumblr decided it would be fun to make fan content for an imaginary movie.


Chiro is cute when she is in "I am totally getting good grade in Being A Normal Girl, totally am right?" mode,
FTFY

and it's jarring how she can immediately swap between that and "Oh yeah, that teacher has repressed bed vibes, he's perfect for turning into a terrifying monster!".
"Cute" and "concerning" are not contradictory. Speaking of concerning...

Speaking of monsters, someone (maybe Simon? I can't remember who) noted that while C was just "dreaming" of being a Beast, the Resinners (s)he created always had wacky side effects but were pretty ineffective and minimal threats overall. [...] But now that C has openly embraced Invidia, this is GONE.
Very good catch!

Fully unlocking the sin seed has changed C drastically.
Not sure that this bit is on point, though. It seems to me less like mind magic and more like Invidia trying to be the villain she thinks she has to be. (The fact that she's terrible at some key parts of villainy seems to support this hypothesis.)

I'm sure they're talking about, like, fanfics of in-universe shows, they're normie enough. But with the recent talk in this thread about fanfics I'm now wondering what sort of madness is written about the Saints under TTL!AO3's "real person fic" fandom.
I hope none of the characters know that real-person fanfiction is a thing. Barring that, I hope Lupin hasn't written any.

Just [Beaker Breaker's] emergence is enough to knock Ina out cold until the end of the fight...
Oh, I didn't realize this was a Hololive crossover!
[/quote]
 
This is interesting. Since the Resinners are nonsentient as we can tell, here Invidia is using "Beaker Breaker" to refer to Mr Brown after his likely untransformation. Is it just forest-brain causing her to only think in terms of Resinners for the moment and forgetting real names... or does she expect she'll be able to make Mr Brown "sprout" multiple times into the same Resinner so it's worth keeping the "Beaker Breaker" attached to them?

I figured Resinners were just in a similar sort of dreamlike fugue to how C was doing it?
So they wake up later with bits of memories from the event, or something, and it's their repressed desires so they probably realize the connection. I wonder if anyone does anything there, like counselors talking to them or the police trying to follow up on incidents or not.
 
and chiro getting into cs as soon as she comes out as trans? yeah checks out

Avaritia picked most of her classes. Otherwise she'd be trying to work herself to death again.

Wait Macroeconomics is something studied in highschool? I thought any sort of economics class with a prefix was university-level stuff.

Also dang creating an entire fictional class schedule for three separate people, fanfic writers really are built different.

AP Macroeconomics – AP Students | College Board

Explore the principles of economics that apply to an economic system as a whole.

Chiro is cute when she's in "I am totally getting good grade in Being A Normal Girl, totally am right?" mode, and it's jarring how she can immediately swap between that and "Oh yeah, that teacher has repressed bed vibes, he's perfect for turning into a terrifying monster!". Speaking of monsters, someone (maybe Simon? I can't remember who) noted that while C was just "dreaming" of being a Beast, the Resinners (s)he created always had wacky side effects but were pretty ineffective and minimal threats overall. This being representative of 1)How C's density and lack of self-loathing makes it impossible for him to make progress on anything 2) C subconsciously not wanting to actually HURT the saints.

To be clear the age regression monster was one of the closest to an outright losses the Saints came to having with two out of three benched and Ida forced to fight on her own. Kopier Kat was also much more a real threat with difficult gimmicks than weird but harmless. Invidia's monsters have trended odd so far, but not particularly safer than anything else.
 
The way it normally works in GaoGaiGar, the closest thing I've watched to a normal magical girl show the afflicted party has a breakthrough after forcibly getting their "negative" emotions out and learns to deal with them in a healthier way, either through idealism or space magic.
 
But yeah, the end there really driving home that sin is bad actually. Chiro just nearly killed her best friend because of her jealousy and self hatred.
 
My joking idea for how the first Invidia vs the Saints throw down would go was pretty different. I imagined it would involve Ida moving in for a grapple(literally just a hug, yay tall girls). That would tick off Lupin's greed instincts so ey would try to tug of war Chiro out of there.
 
I'm starting to think Chiro and Lupin have the potential to be the Saints of their opposing virtues. Between all the talk of C being so kind and Lupin showering people ey like with gifts I can see them as Kindness and Charity if it goes that way. We already have a concrete example with Temperance being Gluttony before changing sides as well.
 
I'm starting to think Chiro and Lupin have the potential to be the Saints of their opposing virtues. Between all the talk of C being so kind and Lupin showering people ey like with gifts I can see them as Kindness and Charity if it goes that way. We already have a concrete example with Temperance being Gluttony before changing sides as well.

I think it's almost so far as to seem as if you cannot be a Saint if there is not a bit of the Sinner in you, or visa-versa. Not in some, "Everyone's a little bit everything" or "Are Saints actually the good guys? What about a Grey Saint that's like a Beast!!!*" But that working hard exhausts you, that "C" was always incredibly Kind and always incredibly filled with Envy, etc, etc.

*Brought to you by Star Wars Discourse.
 
Back
Top