A Little Vice (Trans Magical Girl fic)

Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Reading most of this chapter: EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE of joy.

Reading Chiro still in her egg even after turning into a magical girl multiple times in different ways: :/
 
At this point Chiro mostly seems hung up on the label and is willing to do everything else to socially and physically (well, hormonally, no one's brought up any surgical options yet) transition so like...whatever works in your head, girl.
also, while I may have joked earlier, questioning whether you're sufficiently (trans/lesbian/w/e) to describe yourself with that label is very #relatable to me at least, so I can't fault her too much.
 
Well, the only complaint I could possibly think of for any of this is that there's not even more of it.
I need three more volumes of the novel at least and an anime adaptation! And a marketable bat plushy! XD

In all seriousness, genuinely might be the best fiction I've read with a transfemme protagonist, and by god I am craving more of that now. The use of the magical girl genre was also masterful, both in how you've used its conventions to streamline the story, and turned them to the ends of writing Chiro's gradual development. That and you've made such a likeable cast I can't deny longing to see where they go from here
 
Last edited:
Image Song Lyrics by Galestorm Winds
So re: image songs.

After the topic got brought up, it kind of made me want to write some lyrics. Not one song, but a linked pair--one for Invidia Bat, one for Angelic Saint Humanitas. I decided to finish them after this chapter got revealed, though unfortunately I didn't think about the possibility of a Castitas song for Envy the Light to riff on.

First would play, spoilers and all, at the end of Invidia's reveal in Chapter 10. Second would play after this episode.

There's a light that shines so brightly
From those beside me
A light I can always see
A light that I'll never be
So why not envy?
A shadow in the night
A mirror to the bright
Hiding in the rafters 'fore I take wicked flight
And so I envy
I envy the light

Caught by the shadows time and time and time again
Caught in the web of sinner after sin
Just a dude in distress
Nothing to express
Despite how I hate this role I'm given

A seed of doubt takes root within my barren soul
Planted instead of pride's control
Ey planted the seed
Ey claim to be greed
Yet why does this feel like charity?

(spoken) It's all just a dream, right?

There's a light that shines so brightly
From those beside me
A light I can always see
A light that I'll never be
So why not envy?
A shadow in the night
A mirror to the bright
Hiding in the rafters 'fore I take wicked flight
And so I envy
I envy the light

I see their virtues, fight and fight and fight again
Rescuing C from sinner after sin
With bright angel hearts,
I can't even start
To say how I crave that role they're given

The jealous seed digs deep into my wretched soul
Verdant envy will take control
It beats through my mind
Through cruelty I'm kind
But why does it feel like a lie?

(spoken) Just a dream…until it isn't.

There's a light that shines so brightly
From those beside me
A light I can always see
A light that I'll never be
So why not envy?

Even if there was a way
A way to make myself change
A way to feel less deranged
I wouldn't take it
Just tear myself apart
To feel my beating heart
I'll always fake it

(screams) I'M NOBODY

There's a light that shines so brightly
From those beside me
A light I can always see
A light that I'll never be
So why not envy?
My shadow in the night
Scream challenging the bright
As I hide in the rafters 'fore I take wicked flight
And so I envy
I envy the light

Invidia Bat takes flight!
There's a glow that sings so softly
From where I can't see
A glow I kinda envy
A glow that I wouldn't be
But why not try?
A breeze begins to rise
A music in the sky
Finding both a virtue and just a little vice
Maybe a kindness
A kind of light

I've been captured time and time and time again
Caught by the hate directed within
Just a weird boy to loathe
Parasite without host
No matter how much the love I'm given

What if that deep self-hate within my soul was wrong?
Maybe humbly I could join the song?
Purified part in rain,
Reflection now gained,
In my friends' lust for saving me?

(spoken) It's more than just a dream, right?

There's a glow that sings so softly
From where I can't see
A glow I kinda envy
A glow that I wouldn't be
But why not try?
A breeze begins to rise
A music in the sky
Finding both a virtue and just a little vice
Maybe a kindness
A kind of light

I've seen their virtues, fight and fight and fight again
Powerless 'til I let envy win
My sin beats my heart
Still bitter and dark
So why, suddenly, am I forgiven?

But maybe there's a way to want within my darkened soul
Maybe kindness can share control
A virtue I find
I really don't mind
It doesn't quite feel like a lie

(spoken) Just a dream…until it isn't.

There's a glow that sings so softly
From where I can't see
A glow I kinda envy
A glow that I wouldn't be
But why not try?

Even though there's still self-hate
Although it's hard to change
Although I still feel deranged
I won't let go
And though it's still slow
I feel myself hope
For tomorrow

(spoken, uncertainly but gently) I'm...Chiro.

There's a glow that shines so gently
From where I now see
A glow I kinda envy
A glow that I wouldn't be
But why not try?
Spring breeze begins to rise
Supporting from the sky
As I find both this virtue and just a little vice
Probably kindness
This kind of light

Angelic Saint Humanitas, rise!

Regardless...damn. Still not quite getting it, but finally trying. Still an egg that could scratch a diamond, but finally learning. Chiro's finally taking the first steps towards something better, and it feels great to see.

Well done, Shadell. Well done.
 
Last edited:
Gods strongest egg shell. She is going to be saying she's not really trans on her deathbed at this rate.

Either she goes to the grave, having lived for decades as an out trans woman, being all "well, actually…."

Or she is getting canceled in three months for writing a well-meaning, but profoundly annoying "things I wish I knew when I started my transition so so long ago" advice thread on social media.
 
Last edited:
It's hinted at with Temperance. Ira to Patientia would be a lot of going from blind anger at the world and lashing out at anything in reach to taking her time, making sure what she's doing is right and acting appropriately in measured ways, even if not giving up the underlying rage.
i very much like this interpretation, it mirrors a lot of my own experiences and it just
really rings true to me, i suppose
 
Chiro specified Charity for Avaritia in the most recent chapter as well.
It's evidence, of course, but it felt less significant since Avaritia rejected the offer. Characters which did go from Beast to Saint seem much more relevant than one character talking about what another character might be if ey were a Saint.


So as for my logic, along with being aware of the Seven Virtues/Vices model, I'm also aware of how the Catholic tradition that developed the standardised model you're talking about with Wrath vs Patience is not only not being culturally adjusted for the drift of time, culture or language (it's in Latin); but also it is also has its roots in Jewish traditions which were then passed through the sieve of non-Christian Greek and Roman philosophies by the time we hit Paul's virtues and then later Prudentius' list of Seven Virtues and Vices in the form of poetry. And since I don't feel like it'd be productive for textual analysis to try and get into the head of a Roman Christian in the 5th? century to try and justify the Wrath vs Patience thing in the Latin of the time, I think, lacking the aforementioned contextualisation, it seems fitting to set that aside that dichotomy as inappropriate for this instead.
Okay. And why doesn't this apply to the Envy vs. Kindness thing? Or the Gluttony vs. Temperance thing? Or (based on Shadell's out-of-story comments about Luxuria Fox) the Lust vs. Chastity thing?

Shadell's apparent solution is not to reject the iconic dichotomy of sin and virtue, but to redefine its terms until it fits her ethics and story. Thus, Inessa the saint of Chastity having a big crush on Lupin that a 5th-century theologian would probably call lustful. But Inessa is still Castitas, Chastity, and her hypothetical Beast self would be Luxurias, Lust.

It's true that the framework of the Deadly Sins and Heavenly Virtues, strictly applied, doesn't fit modern values or those of the story. But that framework, or at least its labels, are still what the story actually uses. You're throwing aside the framework and digging at its roots to come up with something that you like better, which I probably wouldn't complain about if you were writing a fanfic about the Saint of Righteousness, but if we're speculating about an ex-Wrath saint who might exist, we should pay attention to what patterns are established in the actual canon. (...canon as in the story we're discussing, not the religious canon it's pulling symbols from.)

If we're just making up rules we like better, without actually building anything on those rules, what are we even doing? Definitely not discussing A Little Vice, since none of its characters or worldbuilding or anything are involved.


At this point Chiro mostly seems hung up on the label and is willing to do everything else to socially and physically (well, hormonally, no one's brought up any surgical options yet) transition so like...whatever works in your head, girl.
Gonna drive Temperance up the wall, though. Which sounds like a fun fanfic idea that I am too cis to pull off.
 
It's hard to notice you were a scavenger your entire life, if you never had a feast.

I never had anything even remotely like this to read when I was a kid and teenager. What was there... wasn't much help.

Some of the story tropes here I actually have seen, read before... in the..other media, unconventional storytelling techniques, hehe, yeah.

This story hits so many familiar beats in my own life, too. Letting the mask be all that there is, dissociating into complete numbness. Letting my intelligence and misguided 'wisdom' be my own torture rack. Following the roles suggested to me, to do something, only to we wither away quietly. Dream, as my only real way out, but ever left dissatisfied. My faith cast off next with the guilt, to keep exploring myself, yet not set free.
One could say, that I came all this way also through "sin", as well, but the vague intuitions, half-realized dreams, blind luck and obsessive need to understand helped, too. Philosophy only to understand empathy better, not solve or resolve anything within. Hope always there, one way or another. To this day.
Of course, there were no guardian angels nor caring demons in my story, at least not at the beginning ;).
Just a mix of somewhat neglectful, somewhat supportive people, deep in their own shit.
And my story haven't ended yet, of course, no matter where I put the dot. Wounds not healed, anxieties not calmed, uncertainties and risks not solved. 'Step after bloody step'.
Many beautiful cherished things, as well, things I don't want to lose, things I want to see blossom and bloom into more beautiful things.

Life being life.
What I want to say is "Thank you".

It was a beautiful, kind, brave story. I wish that 'I' from many years ago – way before the egg started crackling – could read this, but now, that this story exists, somewhere somebody else certainly will – many, hopefully. And it'll help them unlock the hidden treasure of their soul. ☺️
 
Last edited:
I just hope the Saint's magical HRT works well and that it was just waiting for Chiro to decide on who she wanted to be in this chapter. Might be the case given Avaritia's comment post fight (and it clearly worked for Temperance, so...).
 
I just hope the Saint's magical HRT works well and that it was just waiting for Chiro to decide on who she wanted to be in this chapter. Might be the case given Avaritia's comment post fight (and it clearly worked for Temperance, so...).
Not gonna lie, if magic made ME look like Chiro back in the day I'd be very "Oh noes, I'm too perfect, too good, too fake! So sad! I guess if I can't do anything I guess that stays. Forever. What a misfortune. I'd have to live with that. Well, anyway..." (said in nearly emotionless Temperantia's tone with a note of sarcasm)
 
Last edited:
Inessa, Temperance and Ida by ArlequineLunaire


Another sketch of Inessa, Ida, and Temperance. Started on this before the last chapter was posted, which made me then feel bad about not having room for Chiro, so I drew a little bat to compensate.
I felt their poses were too static, so I drew them standing for a yearbook photo to make the basic poses more diegetic. While they're still mostly based on Snowe's designs, I did add a few extra details like Inessa's arrow-patterned trousers, Ida wearing shorts and fingerless gloves, and Temperance's scale-pattern dress
 
Last edited:
Hey, now I know why osmium is so rare in Earth's crust:

Chiro here has used most of it for her eggshell.

...then again, maybe that's iridium -- that gets denser than osmium under high pressure (2.98ish GPa), and she's put herself under a lot of said pressure for a while now. :thonk:
 
Hey, now I know why osmium is so rare in Earth's crust:

Chiro here has used most of it for her eggshell.

...then again, maybe that's iridium -- that gets denser than osmium under high pressure (2.98ish GPa), and she's put herself under a lot of said pressure for a while now. :thonk:
Iridium has lovely rainbow sheen to it, hence the name, and I'm pretty sure Chiro would reject using anything visibly rainbow-pretty in her eggshell, arguing that either she doesn't deserve it or that it looks too much like a pride thing and she doesn't deserve it.

Could be absurdly compressed iridium under (as you say) about thirty thousand atmospheres of pressure, with something else layered over it.

But the something else needs to be very, very resilient to all but the most powerful scratching/cracking forces.
 
The main forces stressing the eggshell are Temperance and Avaritia. Depending on how you look at it, either any old metal can stand up pretty well to two organic predators gnashing at it, or no earthly metal could resist the forces a Saint and Beast united can bring to bear.

(No, not you, Acedia. Go back to bed, it's still winter.)
 
I wonder. Michael hinted that hybridising magical girls may lead to unexpected side effects.

Had Temperantia her seed purged away before/after joining Saint squad? 🤔

Emphasis, admittedly, on the second syllable.
Well, what do you want. They were already 'partners'! The next straight logical step was only to move in together. Platonically.

Hey, now I know why osmium is so rare in Earth's crust:

Chiro here has used most of it for her eggshell.
Considering her density in all things and a permeating sense of hollowness, I'd hazard a guess, that her egg is not of earthly origin at all. Its crust is either neutron star matter, or possibly even black hole material.

Compared to the egg of that density everything would feel hollow. No wonder that trying to crack her egg inevitably approaches event horizon... All your ironclad arguments touch her AT field Schwartzschild radius, redshift and get spaghettified in its inescapable gravity.
 
Last edited:
I will say that I can't really relate to the trans themes of this story, being cis. I can, however, relate to a good story well told, and one of the few around here to get finished. Well done, @Shadell.
 
Back
Top