Winterfaye being born that way don't make them not awful especially when we see they can make a choice not to be that way and continually choose to be so. The fact of the matter is being a criminal even someone who kills people for money you are still human you are still not sadistically torturing people for shit and giggles and you don't eat people flat out.1) Its not a moral stance, its a pragmatic stance.
We know very little about him, his history and his entanglements, and he's done enough dirt that he could taint us just by association. Never mind if the cops actually dig up something on him.
Its the same reason we have largely kept John Marcone at arms length in Chicago.
===
2) Many Winter Fae are born that way.
This guy did not choose to be born the son of a Mafia boss, but he chose to become a supernatural hitman and murder people for money. He could have walked away at any time.
He didnt.
Or to use another example: John Marcone.
I like Marcone as a character. Marcone has the excuse of having brought order to Chicago's criminal underworld, and he's filled the void that was left when the Red Court presence in Chicago was wiped out, keeping other nasties out.
And even Marcone palmed a Denarian Coin for power when the opportunity presented itself.
===
Furthermore, Winter generally risk no legal blowback from their activities. This guy does.
I will repeat it, because you seem to forget: The man's crew murdered a senior police officer recently.
Thats literally a legal land mine waiting to explode in some unfortunate person's face, given how US police departments tend to respond to officer homicides.
One phone call from someone in the know to Andrews' squad, and he's all sorts of fucked.
And Im willing to bet that Sandra Marling knows it, since she essentially whammied his entire organization, from the boss down.
I dont want us anywhere near that mess if we can avoid it.
So in my estimation he's better than the vast majority of winter you can claim being born a certain way makes it neutral but that's blatantly not true the things hornets do to worms and things they lay eggs into they're neutral because hornets have no choice in the matter they cannot think they have their instincts and what they do. The FAE that we see all have a choice in how they behave and they choose to listen to their basest instincts because that is what they are instincts that they choose to obey I'm born that way I'm just this way you're not a fucking scorpion man you can speak to me and make choices obviously you're an asshole.