And even then, I'd argue it doesn't matter all that much if they're all that necessary level of nuts. When puritan inquisitors say destroy a cult, but their methods piss people off who later go on to create or join new cults at best its just a net null for the imperium and kicks the can down the road. Its just the inquisitions status quo and one that they refuse to change despite all evidence saying tis the bad move.
Here's the thing: I agree with
this completely. The Inquisition is absolutely dysfunctional on the whole, much like, y'know, the entire rest of the Imperium. The point I'm making is that the Inquisition being dysfunctional as an institution is not predicated on a majority (much less a supermajority) of its members being personally crazy. The Inquisition is dysfunctional as an institution because the Inquisition is
institutionally dysfunctional, if you'll excuse the tautology. I feel it's an important distinction to make because if you imagine that the core of the issue with the Inquisition is that 90% of everyone in it is crazy, then that's fundamentally a personnel issue. But if you conceptualize the core of the issue with the Inquisition as a problem with the institutional structuring of it, then that centers the conversation on institutional-level reform which is where I think it needs to be.
I'm well aware, its that deliberate self sabotage that makes me take such a dim view of trying to reform the imperium in the first place.
That seems quite backwards to me, honestly. It's that deliberate self-sabotage (among rather a number of other things, to be fair) that makes reform of the Imperium so desperately necessary.
As for the inquisition specifically I demand mandatory therapy and breaks for all inquisitors, mental health is not for ****ing around with.
Yes this please actually.
I know and the irony of them having an ordo dedicated specifically to watching the assassins, but lacking an order to watch themselves should both surprise no one, nor should Pandora let the irony be lost on them.
The Inquisition doesn't have a dedicated ordo for watching the Inquisition, because the fundamental premise of the Inquisition's structure is that the Inquisitors who should be keeping an eye on other Inquisitors are
every Inquisitor. That's not a defense of the Inquisition because that's basically a setup that is the deathknell of any effective large-scale collaboration within the institution, but the issue with the Inquisition is most certainly not a
lack of self-directed paranoia.
More generally, you're making a great deal of sweeping statements about the character of 90% of all Inquisitors that I don't feel are really sufficiently supported. Fundamentally, I want to center the conversation re: the Inquisition on "where are the structural failings of the Inquisition, and what would be a good system of reform to address those failings" rather than on "man Inquisitors sure are all crazy huh." Particularly when the latter sentiment still seems rather more meme-generated than anything else tbh. Dysfunctionality does not require madness, and assuming it does is a good way to skate past the reality that people can be perfectly individually rational and still be institutionally complicit in a dysfunctional system. And when you fail to acknowledge that reality, that's the first step on the road to assuming that anybody who's opposed to you must just be crazy, which is not historically a fruitful and productive path to travel.
Anyway, the vote's open now, so:
[X][LEVIATHAN] The Forge World of Antioch
[X][POSTURE] Call upon your Deva and direct them to the most important battlefields.
I've already made my arguments for these, so I don't think I have much new to add at this juncture.