This only up to page 21, but I'm getting annoyed not posting for some reason.
Mesonoxian: 241, them explaining their reasoning of suspicion on Rosen's posts at the behest of Est for expansion, what I find fascinating is "until we get some votes or actions to analyze" couldn't one push towards that by voting themselves? 285, answering for Absum, really perhaps jumpy perhaps protecting ally? 290, seems like further set-up to a Rosen Lynch we'll see if they ever fire on it. 298, lynch all liars set-up is such a scum thing to do really, because there are plenty of reasons for deception and lying as town that Lynch-all-liars is more likely to be utilized in favor of scum than town. 410, okay we finally see the Rosen lynch vote they've been indicating being in favor of for awhile now, find it fascinating that they call it a gut reading though, when they have been giving reasons around it previously, distancing from the mislynch perhaps? 445, fine post. 465, fine post.
-Rosen: 301, is legitimately not that great of a post, but I kinda get it, but I like to predict exact scum comps fairly early its just how I play. 302, it'd be better if it was a talk of unverifiable randomness, but pushing the yeah I did something random thing isn't a great look.
Look to the Left
Cyricubed: 294, really not a fan of this post. 320, says finds Rosen weird, eventually ends up on the Rosen isn't scum argument though, we'll see how this develops. 421, so they sheep Nictis here, but they do have a post saying they feel weird on Rosen, they also reasonably go after TD for the reasoning given on their vote. But choose to not vote for them because TD is new, it is a reason I see used a lot but I also see it used as a lets kill an experienced player first and set up a easy lynch for later dynamic, which this falls into easily. 422, why only ping QT, and not also Meso… that comes off weird to me… like Cyric has a habit of trying to poke his known allies in particular to action, 1k last game, this game he's done it with DG, and sort of with Meso here. Kinda Absum as well with the previous vote of them. 463, I don't really get why Cyric has been shaken off the Rosen lynch, no quotes were made, they just choose to go after TD without any further reasoning. 504 (Post not found), reason is weird and seems pretty bad, but why do so many want TD to bleed more information it keeps reading badly especially post the way the lynch and night kill are verbalized. 524, okay didn't read the whole reasoning thing personally, but like I don't know I find it strange that they gain a strong TD and Absum scum pair from this, I guess maybe its reasonable, but does Cyric really believe TD would be that plain about it?
PyrrosWarrior: 183, not sure why town should be paranoid about about the doc claims, I totally get frustrating, not sure I get paranoid around it.
Est: 248, set-up spec day 1 rarely leads anywhere, and falls apart during the night phase, I find it strange that Est believes that its possible for town to get split by set-up spec pushed by a scum Rosen that scum would then be able to infiltrate. I don't see that as a viable scum tactic so not really seeing the point of this post other than to throw shade on Rosen. 255, calling Rosen Mislynch bait, okay… they've helped lessen my scum read from that last post. 283, good question. 366, could be scum signalling, but I really doubt this is the design.
QTesseract:
InterstellarHobo: 143, was honestly not far off my initial predictions, so I like this post. 297, really don't like this wish I was taking hard notes on who exactly keeps asking questions of what Evensar is doing/can do in their neighborhood, because there is no need to do so that really helps town, while it certainly helps scum. 412, this post reads like such a scum slip I could write an essay on it. It coming from a newbie is the only thing that makes me not want to really dive into it though. 508, others talked about this so I'm not going to be a broken record. 511, I'm just going to point out the whole "almost entirely thanks to Nictis's actions," putting all credit for any lynch on one individual even day 1 is dangerous and scummy.
1KBestK: 92, Not much of a fan of this post, somewhat genuine analysis of their past play, but I don't know directly stating this is my X-town game seems needlessly specific as if trying to push the idea of being town again stronger than the already pointless "I'm town" statement. 333, says if you're in a neighborhood don't trust your partner(s). Seems a bit pointless to say, I'd probably only say it if well I was scum and didn't really have any or maybe only 1 known neighborhood infiltration role in my party to make sure people don't utilize them in full. 361, we only have 1 claimed neighborhood, if 1k isn't in one themselves, I'm growing more suspect of this because one doesn't make a game's conceit focused on neighborhoods. 399, a reads post. 407, not all lynch votes are intending to lynch the person they are intending and with 5 new players in the game of 17, its not unreasonable to vote and pressure new players day 1. 491, Yes pressure the newbie to revealing information willy-nilly, and stay off the rosen lynch, that totally reads like the best play for a scum to do whilst others of their faction push the Rosen lynch, let the newbie bleed more potential info. I will say this argument is pretty mutually exclusive if Absum is scum though. 505, if TD does have pressure you don't want to be on it? Strange.
Nanimani: 124, really… just ugh. 145, reads so hollow to me, there isn't anything really here. 350, first line is fine pretty softball though. Last line seems a bit vicious, especially knowing that Rosen is town. 403, true post but like why isn't Nanimani really making any moves? 517, I don't like this, at all. Just a bandwagon post on a strong player.
TurtleDucks/ComiTurtle: #264 is just a bad post, "I'll be serious, have some wine." 270, sigh. 277, why past me? 400, huh? 477, past me is weird, do we get a response from absum though?
Nictis: 310, good post. 383, you were already leaking knowing more of the set-up than the average joe before this, agree in full though that game appears to very bad for town to reveal information needlessly. 417, its a legitimate post, certainly Nictis's classical bulldoging. Against known town now but reasonable at the time, though scum Nictis does the same sort of stuff, generally there is something you can poke at being wrong but day 1 scum Nictis doesn't make those mistakes really as there isn't anything that can be really twisted as everyone has super limited posts to work off of, so its really NAI.
Happerry: 142, Happery is town, scum Happery would not make this post.
DimensionalGuy: 416, there was a reason behind Evenstar's reveal, but I get that, I really can't recall a proper claim from QT… other than them saying they thought they were scum at first, which didn't make sense with their role as something one could influence, like the only thing is them basically claiming a power-role I guess, but yet you don't extend that suspicion on Nictis who has claimed to know more about the set-up than the general group seems strange to me. We'll see if they vote Rosen, but so much distancing from the vote is done in this post.
BanTheFairyKing: 431, Toss up, I disagree with the thought process but I can follow it. Don't like the last line of distancing from the lynch itself.
Absum: 112, I find it interesting that they question if scum would choose to just not respond. I mean if you think about it if town as a whole basically does an action it forces scum to do it does it not? Also I find it fascinating that Absum comes out right away assuming we don't have a traditional set-up. 133, Interesting that its the first post really interacting with Nani's "claim" outside of a joking matter. 143, I don't see the point of Absum saying it could help, but scum don't need to respond as town positive outside of trying to reverse-psych them into being alone in not responding. 426, there isn't a decent reason I'm aware of. 428, great post actually. 436, this is a strange post. 487, great question, I don't even know the answer here. 489, is fine, TD is being weird and the question they asked for was just bad.
Evenstar: Very early posts are fairly low effort, but they do attempt and act like they are trying to get people to be active and act. 205, feels like proper substance, especially given the later neighborhood claim, I can see this being very directly related to knowing one's own role and then extrapolating that to be part of the game as the whole and being sensitive, so this is a post I consider fairly towny from them, despite me finding it probably very off the mark. 209, the neighborhood claim. 220, okay I did just say I'm townreading them but this post concerns me, if they truly have only 1 other member, then they are basically shouting at their neighbor "look at me I'm town you can treat me as concerned as you," which is something I'd personally do as scum in a neighborhood if I felt I could get away with it. 330-340s, Evenstar is just being helpful but not in any truly alignment indicative, just being informative on what things can exist and general terminology, really wish I was seeing something more from her. 481, this is rude Evenstar, can we not make a habit of it please?
