Alienated (part 6)
- Location
- Hampden Park
5th October
09:27 GMT -6
"…investigation for his Court Martial."
Arnus' 'Augustus Freeman' personality is as different from his 'Icon' personality as Clark Kent is from Superman. Gone is his taciturnity and growly delivery, farewell his static posture. Mr Freeman is all smiles and animation and I'm forced to wonder which -if either- is Arnus' real personality.
"I will testify without hesitation."
Lantern Xor on the other hand is still barely animate. Outside of combat, he doesn't let his emotions show all that much. Graak has left his former client's shoulder in order to peruse Arnus' office, clearly rather enamoured with the comforts which our civilisation allows a successful lawyer.
"I wouldn't be quite that eager. Exactly how much reading have you done on America's legal system?"
"I sleep. I eat. I read and study. Last time I stood before magistrates I lost my freedom, my name and my voice. I will not enter a fight unprepared again."
"I don't recommend thinking of it as a fight. Particularly given how we're having to fight the image of you being an 'alien invader'. I'll go over-."
"Image?"
Lantern Xor's hands have formed fists, and Graak looks around from the leather-bound book he was reading with a look of alarm.
"Do they care more about appearances than truth? Am I simply to go from one travesty of justice to another?"
But he doesn't smash anything, which is definite progress.
"Not.. exactly. The problem is that in a lot of these cases, the penalty that gets levelled depends on things that can't be determined by a study of the physical evidence. A jury or a panel of officers have to be persuaded to… Let's say, correctly understand a person's motivations. And while they're supposed to limit themselves to evidence and testimony, it's unavoidable that they're going to interpret the way a person giving evidence behaves when they try and decide whether they're a credible witness or not."
Lantern Xor calms down a little.
"And since you're from a totally different culture and species, that's obviously a little awkward for you."
"I will not lie."
"I wasn't going to ask you to lie. I'm going to teach you how to present yourself so they believe you when you tell the truth."
Lantern Xor doesn't look entirely happy, but his anger is subsiding.
"What will happen to the General?"
"That's up to the Court Martial. If I were the one defending him, I'd probably try and make out that he had to make a decision based on incomplete information, that as far as he knew based on the police reports you were a belligerent attacker and needed to be taken down as quickly as possible to prevent things escalating further. That fact that he's written any number of reports on the potential for using military force in policing metahuman criminals shows he might have his own biases, but it'll be hard for the prosecutors to prove that he acted purely for that reason."
"You will not be able make them punish him?"
Arnus shakes his head. "I won't be prosecuting the case. The military has appointed a prosecutor, and General Hardcastle will select his own defence attorney. I'll be in court, but I'll just be there to advise you."
Lantern Xor snorts. "The American military tries an American general. My expectations are low."
"Even if some of them agree with him on using military power against superpowered criminals, General Hardcastle didn't make any friends amongst his peers when he shot up an American town. To say nothing of how his blatant disregard for the lives of the American civilians in the area is playing on Capitol Hill and in the news. Taking time to heal them was an extremely intelligent move."
"They were not military, not attacking me."
"Even so, it's strong evidence that you weren't planning on attacking Thayer's Notch when the police started shooting you." He looks at me. "Did you have anything to do with that?"
"I suggested that it couldn't hurt. But he's using an orange power ring."
He nods. "He had to want to do it in order to make it work. Okay, that's good to know. But… I do need to know why you didn't just leave town as soon as you got attacked. The police didn't have anything that could have hurt you, and even if you couldn't get away from the military the collateral damage from fighting them outside of town would be far less than fighting them inside it."
"I will not flee from an attacker. Especially one in uniform."
"I understand the attitude, but that's a problem in Massachusetts. A civilian who comes under attack is obligated to retreat rather than attacking unless that's.. clearly impossible. In your case, you could reasonably be considered to have known that the police issue firearms couldn't hurt you after the first few shots bounced off your skin. The prosecutor in your case will almost certainly make the argument that you had an obligation under law to leave the area. Did you..? Think they had heavier weapons available?"
"I did not think about it."
"Do you have a..? Lot of military experience?"
"I have been a soldier for two thirds of my life. I was a Warhound of the First Array."
"Okay, so… Would you say that you responded in the same way you would have on a battlefield?"
Lantern Xor frowns. "If I were on a battlefield I would have attacked them first."
"Alright, but if you suddenly found yourself confronted by.. enemy soldiers you weren't expecting..?"
"I would have recognised their weapons, so I would have prioritised them differently. But I would have attacked in the same way."
"Alright, that's something. Do your people have any enemies in this part of the universe?"
Lantenr Xor considers the question, then calls up a galaxy map and studies it intently for several moments. "Not that I have fought before."
"The reason I ask is that if you might reasonably have believed that you were attacking people allied to your species' enemies, it becomes a lot easier to justify your reaction."
"We might. I had little interest in high politics. I had not even thought to find out our location until you asked me."
"You didn't know where Earth is?" Lantern Xor shakes his head. "How did you get here?"
"Something went wrong on the prison transport. They didn't tell the prisoners what it was, but the containment system failed when main power did, and by the time I had freed the other prisoners the crew had already evacuated. The automatic navigation system locked onto Earth as the closest survivable destination. I expected there to be other survivors here."
"You broke the other prisoners out?"
"They would have died in their cells if I had not."
"And the crew didn't have time to open the doors?"
Lantern Xor shrugs. "I do not know why they did what they did. I am not responsible for their behaviour."
"No, of course not. Okay, we're going to need to go over a lot of details about your personal history and species' legal system. And we've got another police interview in a couple of hours. Now, I know-" He glances at me. "-that you've been living on Paul's Ice Fortress, but it would help me manage your case if you could start living inside US territory. Is that something you're prepared to do?"
Lantern Xor nods, grudgingly.
"Thank you. I'll-".
"I can move the Fortress back-."
Arnus holds up his right hand. "I don't think that's such a good idea. I'll have my assistant sort something out, somewhere secure and large enough for you. Why don't you.. tell me about your full military record?"
09:27 GMT -6
"…investigation for his Court Martial."
Arnus' 'Augustus Freeman' personality is as different from his 'Icon' personality as Clark Kent is from Superman. Gone is his taciturnity and growly delivery, farewell his static posture. Mr Freeman is all smiles and animation and I'm forced to wonder which -if either- is Arnus' real personality.
"I will testify without hesitation."
Lantern Xor on the other hand is still barely animate. Outside of combat, he doesn't let his emotions show all that much. Graak has left his former client's shoulder in order to peruse Arnus' office, clearly rather enamoured with the comforts which our civilisation allows a successful lawyer.
"I wouldn't be quite that eager. Exactly how much reading have you done on America's legal system?"
"I sleep. I eat. I read and study. Last time I stood before magistrates I lost my freedom, my name and my voice. I will not enter a fight unprepared again."
"I don't recommend thinking of it as a fight. Particularly given how we're having to fight the image of you being an 'alien invader'. I'll go over-."
"Image?"
Lantern Xor's hands have formed fists, and Graak looks around from the leather-bound book he was reading with a look of alarm.
"Do they care more about appearances than truth? Am I simply to go from one travesty of justice to another?"
But he doesn't smash anything, which is definite progress.
"Not.. exactly. The problem is that in a lot of these cases, the penalty that gets levelled depends on things that can't be determined by a study of the physical evidence. A jury or a panel of officers have to be persuaded to… Let's say, correctly understand a person's motivations. And while they're supposed to limit themselves to evidence and testimony, it's unavoidable that they're going to interpret the way a person giving evidence behaves when they try and decide whether they're a credible witness or not."
Lantern Xor calms down a little.
"And since you're from a totally different culture and species, that's obviously a little awkward for you."
"I will not lie."
"I wasn't going to ask you to lie. I'm going to teach you how to present yourself so they believe you when you tell the truth."
Lantern Xor doesn't look entirely happy, but his anger is subsiding.
"What will happen to the General?"
"That's up to the Court Martial. If I were the one defending him, I'd probably try and make out that he had to make a decision based on incomplete information, that as far as he knew based on the police reports you were a belligerent attacker and needed to be taken down as quickly as possible to prevent things escalating further. That fact that he's written any number of reports on the potential for using military force in policing metahuman criminals shows he might have his own biases, but it'll be hard for the prosecutors to prove that he acted purely for that reason."
"You will not be able make them punish him?"
Arnus shakes his head. "I won't be prosecuting the case. The military has appointed a prosecutor, and General Hardcastle will select his own defence attorney. I'll be in court, but I'll just be there to advise you."
Lantern Xor snorts. "The American military tries an American general. My expectations are low."
"Even if some of them agree with him on using military power against superpowered criminals, General Hardcastle didn't make any friends amongst his peers when he shot up an American town. To say nothing of how his blatant disregard for the lives of the American civilians in the area is playing on Capitol Hill and in the news. Taking time to heal them was an extremely intelligent move."
"They were not military, not attacking me."
"Even so, it's strong evidence that you weren't planning on attacking Thayer's Notch when the police started shooting you." He looks at me. "Did you have anything to do with that?"
"I suggested that it couldn't hurt. But he's using an orange power ring."
He nods. "He had to want to do it in order to make it work. Okay, that's good to know. But… I do need to know why you didn't just leave town as soon as you got attacked. The police didn't have anything that could have hurt you, and even if you couldn't get away from the military the collateral damage from fighting them outside of town would be far less than fighting them inside it."
"I will not flee from an attacker. Especially one in uniform."
"I understand the attitude, but that's a problem in Massachusetts. A civilian who comes under attack is obligated to retreat rather than attacking unless that's.. clearly impossible. In your case, you could reasonably be considered to have known that the police issue firearms couldn't hurt you after the first few shots bounced off your skin. The prosecutor in your case will almost certainly make the argument that you had an obligation under law to leave the area. Did you..? Think they had heavier weapons available?"
"I did not think about it."
"Do you have a..? Lot of military experience?"
"I have been a soldier for two thirds of my life. I was a Warhound of the First Array."
"Okay, so… Would you say that you responded in the same way you would have on a battlefield?"
Lantern Xor frowns. "If I were on a battlefield I would have attacked them first."
"Alright, but if you suddenly found yourself confronted by.. enemy soldiers you weren't expecting..?"
"I would have recognised their weapons, so I would have prioritised them differently. But I would have attacked in the same way."
"Alright, that's something. Do your people have any enemies in this part of the universe?"
Lantenr Xor considers the question, then calls up a galaxy map and studies it intently for several moments. "Not that I have fought before."
"The reason I ask is that if you might reasonably have believed that you were attacking people allied to your species' enemies, it becomes a lot easier to justify your reaction."
"We might. I had little interest in high politics. I had not even thought to find out our location until you asked me."
"You didn't know where Earth is?" Lantern Xor shakes his head. "How did you get here?"
"Something went wrong on the prison transport. They didn't tell the prisoners what it was, but the containment system failed when main power did, and by the time I had freed the other prisoners the crew had already evacuated. The automatic navigation system locked onto Earth as the closest survivable destination. I expected there to be other survivors here."
"You broke the other prisoners out?"
"They would have died in their cells if I had not."
"And the crew didn't have time to open the doors?"
Lantern Xor shrugs. "I do not know why they did what they did. I am not responsible for their behaviour."
"No, of course not. Okay, we're going to need to go over a lot of details about your personal history and species' legal system. And we've got another police interview in a couple of hours. Now, I know-" He glances at me. "-that you've been living on Paul's Ice Fortress, but it would help me manage your case if you could start living inside US territory. Is that something you're prepared to do?"
Lantern Xor nods, grudgingly.
"Thank you. I'll-".
"I can move the Fortress back-."
Arnus holds up his right hand. "I don't think that's such a good idea. I'll have my assistant sort something out, somewhere secure and large enough for you. Why don't you.. tell me about your full military record?"
Last edited: