What do people have against Emma? I quite liked her.
I like Emma also, but I also like a nice plain bagel with cream cheese on occasion. Her only real issue as a character is that in comparison to the other party members and really, Trails leads in general she's just kinda
there. She's a nice girl who's involved in vaguely sinister subplots but doesn't really act much on them herself (and they end up being not terribly sinister by comparison to others). Even in her own personal subplot, the NPCs are more interesting in their gimmicks and personalities and what they actually contribute to the stories.
Tbh it's not just her, Gaius has the same problem on the guys' side. There's like one twist in his personal story that doesn't come until like CS3 and other than that he's just there being the cool supportive bro. He doesn't even have any major angst other than being a bit of a fish out of water, hence him being probably the least remembered dude of the CS1 cast outside of "talks about the wind a lot".
Both 10/10 people, just not really
messy enough to be fandom attention-getters in a field as packed as Trails, you know?
Since we're talking counterparts: Are there any for Alfin, Cedric and Olivier? Because the princess is apparently around 40, which doesn't really track.
"eccentric Prince Carlos" got namedropped very early on as the patron who brought Arc-en-Ciel in as a performance at the school auditorium some time in the past, and I'd bet a fair amount of money that that's our Olivert.
Meanwhile, Crown Princess Arcadia is closer to Eugen III in age than the elderly Emperor Eugene is, and I don't know if she's going to be playing Eugen's role, Cedric's, or if Arvis is cooking something completely different with the imperial family here. If there's an Alfin counterpart, I don't think we've met her yet.