- Location
- Alice Springs, Australia
You are rightWell the Volume is called "The Storm" so I assume it will only come to an end when the warp storms plaguing our sector end, revealing us once more unto the Galaxy.
You are rightWell the Volume is called "The Storm" so I assume it will only come to an end when the warp storms plaguing our sector end, revealing us once more unto the Galaxy.
That's centuries away though.Well the Volume is called "The Storm" so I assume it will only come to an end when the warp storms plaguing our sector end, revealing us once more unto the Galaxy.
@durin, how is it that the Asgard sub-sector has experienced time differently to the rest of the galaxy? It is behind a Warp Storm rather than in one, and Warp Storms affect the Warp rather than the Materium, which is why its safe to travel through them so long as you stay in the Materium and don't use the Warp for FTL. The planets and the stars should be no more in the Warp than they were before the Emperor's death, yet somehow they moved slower than they otherwise would. The Tau were behind a Warp Storm for 6k years according to the rest of the galaxy and when they came out, it had been 6k years for them as well. Did the Emperor use the last of his power to secretly throw us into the Warp or something? Will we end up in an entirely different part of the galaxy than we should as a result?
That's centuries away though.
Edit: Huh, I thought that a Chaos God induced Warp storms would last longer.
There's "thinning the veil" and then there's "moving an entire sub-sector's worth of material matter when absolutely none of it is in the Warp". An event like that is unprecedented. It also doesn't make sense. When Jotunheim came out of the Warp Storm, we learned that it had been two years more for them than for anyone else. How is it not closer to the big Warp Storm now? Why is it in the same place relative to the rest of the Nine Worlds if it was moving slower than them? If it has changed position relative to the other star systems, will we see the Jotunheim star suddenly move very quickly in the night sky after a few years when its light hits Avernus?Warp Storms sometimes thin the veil between the Materium and the Immaterium, which allows for affects like altered time. It's not always the case, but such unpredictability is the nature of the Warp. And who knows what affects Avernus is having on all this as well?
There's "thinning the veil" and then there's "moving an entire sub-sector's worth of material matter when absolutely none of it is in the Warp". An event like that is unprecedented. It also doesn't make sense. When Jotunheim came out of the Warp Storm, we learned that it had been two years more for them than for anyone else. How is it not closer to the big Warp Storm now? Why is it in the same place relative to the rest of the Nine Worlds if it was moving slower than them? If it has changed position relative to the other star systems, will we see the Jotunheim star suddenly move very quickly in the night sky after a few years when its light hits Avernus?
You are assuming the realm made of the quintillions of screaming souls throughout galactic history, eternally tormented by thirsting gods, is consistent.Warp "physics" are bullshit but they only apply within the Warp and a mere thinning due to a Warp Storm isn't enough to do anything on the scale or magnitude of what's happened. It's why even though the Warp covers the entire galaxy, only places like daemon worlds stop making sense. Heck even Avernus makes sense for the most part and it's got two warp rifts on it! Warp rifts are less "thinning of the veil" between reality and unreality and more "great tearing rips".
And there's a fuckoff huge Warp Storm around us. Things don't make sense in Warp Storms. I'm p sure it's canon that they fuck with the timestream if they want to, in as much as a giant fuckoff storm can want something.The Warp might not be consistent but the Materium certainly is. A=A and A+B=A+B. Within the Materium, things make sense. Within the Warp, things don't make sense. The planets are not in the Warp. They are in the Materium. Things should make sense.
Warp "physics" are bullshit but they only apply within the Warp and a mere thinning due to a Warp Storm isn't enough to do anything on the scale or magnitude of what's happened. It's why even though the Warp covers the entire galaxy, only places like daemon worlds stop making sense. Heck even Avernus makes sense for the most part and it's got two warp rifts on it! Warp rifts are less "thinning of the veil" between reality and unreality and more "great tearing rips".
But the planets are not in the Warp Storms. They are behind them, which is a pretty crucial difference. There is a time and place to call Warp shenanigans but this isn't one of them. I haven't read anything about Warp Storms messing with the timestream this bad outside of the Eye of Terror which is a much more powerful Warp Storm than the one we're in and actually covers the planets within it.And there's a fuckoff huge Warp Storm around us. Things don't make sense in Warp Storms. I'm p sure it's canon that they fuck with the timestream if they want to, in as much as a giant fuckoff storm can want something.
The physics makes sense in every other respect. The laws of motion and thermodynamics work just as well as they did before. Not even psykers have reported a difference in their abilities after the Warp Storm showed up. Maybe if the Warp Storm actually covered the planets like what's happening to Vanaheim, Midgard, and Niflheim, but it's not, it just surrounds them. That's a big difference.1. A Warp Storm thins the veil over a large area. That there might be some strange effects isn't that unusual.
Do you honestly believe I'm applying real world physics to 40k in any capacity? I'm comparing 40k physics to 40k physics. In 40k, A is A and B is B unless you're in the Warp. That's how it's always been in 40k.Frankly it's just better not to question things too much here. You're asking 40k to make sense. Again, just accept that your notions of sense and physics don't apply to the universe in question.
The planetmind is practically confirmed but do we really know it's the Old Ones? As far as we know, the Sirens are just Eldar who got stranded on the planet and evolved after millions of years of evolution or else got eaten by some kind of genestealing species. Unless I'm remembering my history wrong, Chaos came after the Old Ones.2. Remember that Avernus was at least partially engineered by the Old Ones and is maintained by whatever the hell the planetmind is. It having some degree of stability in it's bullshit makes sense.
you have no clue@durin, how is it that the Asgard sub-sector has experienced time differently to the rest of the galaxy? It is behind a Warp Storm rather than in one,and Warp Storms affect the Warp rather than the Materium, which is why its safe to travel through them so long as you stay in the Materium and don't use the Warp for FTL. The planets and the stars should be no more in the Warp than they were before the Emperor's death, yet somehow they moved slower than they otherwise would. The Tau were behind a Warp Storm for 6k years according to the rest of the galaxy and when they came out, it had been 6k years for them as well. Did the Emperor use the last of his power to secretly throw us into the Warp or something? Will we end up in an entirely different part of the galaxy than we should as a result?
They might not be in the Warp Storms but they are maintained within themBut the planets are not in the Warp Storms. They are behind them, which is a pretty crucial difference. There is a time and place to call Warp shenanigans but this isn't one of them. I haven't read anything about Warp Storms messing with the timestream this bad outside of the Eye of Terror which is a much more powerful Warp Storm than the one we're in and actually covers the planets within it.
The physics makes sense in every other respect. The laws of motion and thermodynamics work just as well as they did before. Not even psykers have reported a difference in their abilities after the Warp Storm showed up. Maybe if the Warp Storm actually covered the planets like what's happening to Vanaheim, Midgard, and Niflheim, but it's not, it just surrounds them. That's a big difference.
Do you honestly believe I'm applying real world physics to 40k in any capacity? I'm comparing 40k physics to 40k physics. In 40k, A is A and B is B unless you're in the Warp. That's how it's always been in 40k.
The planetmind is practically confirmed but do we really know it's the Old Ones? As far as we know, the Sirens are just Eldar who got stranded on the planet and evolved after millions of years of evolution or else got eaten by some kind of genestealing species. Unless I'm remembering my history wrong, Chaos came after the Old Ones.
Ok, so it's definitely something that doesn't usually happen. I'm fine with that.
Cathacans?Yeah. The Avernites are nuts. Who voluntarily lives on a planet that's actually actively trying to kill you?
Can we ask for assisstance with the ship graveyard so that both we and the Trust could get more ships faster?
That is smarter than my ideas. why didn't i think of such an obvious solution?Next there is a proposal by Champion Surt to require that each High Councillor both have a Lower Councillor and have a second representative on a third world. This should reduce the chance that there are unrepresented worlds as there are at the moment.
Can we use the opportunity of being in person here to not make an official proposal, but rather schmoose with the other delegates about proposals we intent to make on the next full council?There were no other proposals given his year thanks to the agreement to delay non urgent matters until the High Council is complete. However you have the opportunity to put forward your own proposals now, keeping in mind that only urgent matters are being considered at this meeting.
This is probably a good thing to ask when they return from the warpstormGiven the two planets with large populations and experience with orbital work are behind the Warp Storm I'm not sure what they could offer. Muspelheim and Svartalfheim are both busy beefing up their defenses, I believe.
Yeah. The Avernites are nuts. Who voluntarily lives on a planet that's actually actively trying to kill you?