Voting is open
1. Then why did you only make reference to the Jedi fucking up during the Clone Wars due to being inexperienced commanders? Force Users work fine as long as they do not have to do that and can focus on using their powers in other ways, like as assassins, strike teams, interrogators, and Battle Meditation practicioners.
2. He says he can offer insight into their methodology, not that he has any notable (particularly Force-based) solutions to them. Things like how their armor resists blasters, how they can't be telekinetically lifted, or how they use terraforming (and even this is a stretch considering all we know is that his fleet was destroyed by them), not ways to win against them.

Edit: Regardless, I'm pretty sure the Chiss themselves have more extensive knowledge of the Vong than what Jack could provide.
1 Because that is the most recent example of force users fucking things up in the military when they have no place in it. I also never said shit about the new order being used to lead troops that was all you.
2. Blazing chain and Matukai are literal hard counters to Vong dude. More Matukai then the former because the Vong can only be affected by physical attacks all other forms of force techniques either are majorly nerfed or don't do anything. Matukai is all about physical boosts to the user making them far more deadly and perfect for dealing with the Vong.
Now that is unusual. He has less of a problem with the dedicated Darksider than the balance-specced one.
Because that kind of "balance" isn't real dude. This is a guy that was desperate that means he is very unlikely to have the mental strength to actually control himself instead of falling into a feedback loop of the darkside. Also the Witches of Dathomir are not darkside users they use the force in a different way than the Jedi and the Sith. Only the Nightsisters use closer to the darkside and even then it isn't the same.
 
1 Because that is the most recent example of force users fucking things up in the military when they have no place in it. I also never said shit about the new order being used to lead troops that was all you.
You brought them up as commanders, I responded to them as commanders.
2. Blazing chain and Matukai are literal hard counters to Vong dude. More Matukai then the former because the Vong can only be affected by physical attacks all other forms of force techniques either are majorly nerfed or don't do anything. Matukai is all about physical boosts to the user making them far more deadly and perfect for dealing with the Vong.
You know what else is a hard counter? Throwing a rock at a few hundred kilometers per hour. Vong are more of a hard counter to Blazing Chain than the reverse because their armor resists blasters, unless the user is good enough to direct their shots precisely into the armor's gaps. Matukai, fair enough.
Because that kind of "balance" isn't real dude.
That is something to ask the QM about, because how the Force behaves varies a lot between different fan works and even official material.
This is a guy that was desperate that means he is very unlikely to have the mental strength to actually control himself instead of falling into a feedback loop of the darkside.
Considering he still wants to instruct his potential students in the ways of the Light Side instead of viewing the Dark as stronger and better I have my doubts about that. I may be wrong and he's just lying but still hardly a sure thing.
Also the Witches of Dathomir are not darkside users they use the force in a different way than the Jedi and the Sith. Only the Nightsisters use closer to the darkside and even then it isn't the same.
Nokkra is a Nightsister. It said so in the first sentence of the interview.
 
Just found this quest. Looks very interesting.

Looks like there's not much interest in Vesha Dey. Shame. I'd love to see a aggressively diplomatic thrawn empire.
 
You know what else is a hard counter? Throwing a rock at a few hundred kilometers per hour. Vong are more of a hard counter to Blazing Chain than the reverse because their armor resists blasters, unless the user is good enough to direct their shots precisely into the armor's gaps. Matukai, fair enough.


If I remember correctly, one of the blazing chains tricks is curving the trajectory of blaster bolts, so blazing chain snipers taking off the Vong commanders should be on the table.

Matukai can strengthen their force connection via movement meditation, ergo a bigger recruit pool.

Honestly, I know that I repeat myself like a broken record, but Jack really is the least dangerous of all three, and he brings more to the table in terms of things useful in conventional warfare.
 
You brought them up as commanders, I responded to them as commanders.
I brought up the Sith and Jedi fucking up military operations because they are used as commanders when they had no place in that position. I said the order would be trained to work with the damn military I never said they would be leading anything. That was all you. As for the chucking a rock that won't work because the Vong are invisible and if you need to be close enough to see them for that kind of attack then it is too late. It also still requires that they be sensed in the force to aim the blast and rock at them without massive loss. But I am done with this.
Nokkra is a Nightsister. It said so in the first sentence of the interview.
I know she is a Nighsister and like I said the Nightsisters are not using the darkside the way a sith or fallen jedi does. They use different things.

Also one very big issue everyone voting for the droids is forgetting about. The Entire Galaxy hates Battledroids. Normal Droids are only hated slightly less. SO this action uses droids for war will have a major malus to relations. Not only are there several examples of why droid rights never work because the Droids always try to kill all organics but the most recent example of droids threw the galaxy into the largest war the galaxy has ever seen and will retain that title until the Vong invasion. A war that killed billions and displaced billions more.
 
Last edited:
Xuyul Kanuas I think is more useful in just the breadth of his knowledge on the force especially since Dark Nox had a lot of experience in dealing with force ghosts. Which will help massively in dealing with Palpatine and it will not need a miracle to make sure he stays dead this time. Also in the next 20 years I know of 3 sith lord ghosts that try to make a comeback in legends this isn't including Palpatine himself. So getting the best thing in the galaxy as an expert on the force to deal with force ghosts would help.
 
Last edited:
Guys I think you all underestimate the fact that the imperial propaganda machine has been at work for 2 decade's making it anything to do with battledroids means your nothing but a dirty sep and this only played on already present feelings due to the clone wars.

People hate battledroids and nothing we will do will change it anytime soon.
 
Guys I think you all underestimate the fact that the imperial propaganda machine has been at work for 2 decade's making it anything to do with battledroids means your nothing but a dirty sep and this only played on already present feelings due to the clone wars.

People hate battledroids and nothing we will do will change it anytime soon.
People have hated droids long before the Empire and the Clone Wars. The Empire made it worse but the Separatists and all the droids before have caused the majority of the hate.
 
People have hated droids long before the Empire and the Clone Wars. The Empire made it worse but the Separatists and all the droids before have caused the majority of the hate.
Oh im aware of that I just wanted to point out the hate for droids is a lot more stronger now then it could of been before the clone wars.
 
The fact that the CIS were a bunch of megacorps meant they didn't design droids with effectiveness in mind but how cost-effective they would be yet they still managed to fight the clones for years.

Droids are still gonna be easier and cheaper rather than using live troops whether regular senteints or clones. Feeding, training, paying and in the case of clones ;growing them is gonna be much more expensive.

Better AI and aiming won't really be as expensive in the long term and less waste of life and resources.

Edit:Ninja'd.

Yeah basically what NB said.
So the thing to keep in mind about the standard battle-droid the CIS used?

The Gun was more expensive than the droid.

In return, what they got was actually a reasonably effective unit. Note that Tactical Droids were actually pretty good at their job. The issue of Droids in SW is that SW is as a whole uses bad doctrines for ground warfare. a good doctrine would have let the CIS absolutely wreck face. Just between the Megacorps and the Sith, the CIS wasnt inclined to actually develop good doctrine.
 
@Daemon Hunter How do you have the population, ship, soldier, etc. numbers in this quest? Since there's multiple ways of looking at them and different authors have had different fleet and army sizes for the galaxy, not to mention the fan interpretations
 
@Daemon Hunter How do you have the population, ship, soldier, etc. numbers in this quest? Since there's multiple ways of looking at them and different authors have had different fleet and army sizes for the galaxy, not to mention the fan interpretations

Galactic Population: 3E20
Inhabitted Systems: 3E9
Total Systems: 4E11
IS2 Class Ships: ~30k
Total Warships: ~500k
Civilian Ships: ~400 million
Soldier Count: ~1E13
 
How much of the GAR was non-clones? Assuming you take the standard planetary defense forces out of the equation.

I figured the clones made up around 5% of the GAR's army. But the clones were used on essentially every mission of importance and for key areas.

One of the things that you'll be seeing is that only a few systems tend to matter during wars due to how expensive it is to build up planets quickly. Shipyards and industrial powerhouses are the worlds you need to take.
 
There is a reason that the Clone Wars was the biggest war in history until the Vong invasion. People tend to forget that we only ever see the important battles or ones that certain Jedi happened to be involved with.
 
I figured the clones made up around 5% of the GAR's army. But the clones were used on essentially every mission of importance and for key areas.

One of the things that you'll be seeing is that only a few systems tend to matter during wars due to how expensive it is to build up planets quickly. Shipyards and industrial powerhouses are the worlds you need to take.
Note everyone: 3 million units does not mean 3 million clones. Well, ok, it does in Traviss land. But Traviss is an idiot, so thats a given.

That said, your Imperal II count seems a bit high. It is unlikely they built more Imperial II in 2 years less timeframe. They only built 25k-26k Imperial 1s when they switched to Imperial IIs in 5 BBY. Its only been 9 years, when the Imperial I begin production with the empire itself. It make more sense if there was around 20k to 25k, with the total Imps being 40k to 50k between all variations and sub-variations.
 
Voting is open
Back
Top