Alright, what weapon should Akemi have?

  • Let her keep the gun!

    Votes: 9 33.3%
  • Give her a sword!

    Votes: 10 37.0%
  • More Magic!

    Votes: 6 22.2%
  • Hand to Hand!

    Votes: 2 7.4%

  • Total voters
    27
  • Poll closed .
My character was created because all the other wishes were so boring and white bread. Every one is so vague and nice like they're afraid to have the character have done a bad thing in the past when in Madoka Kyubey is a conman who targets people who are either arrogant, not thinking things through, entitled, or at their lowest points. I think it's more interesting for the Dark Magical Person made a bad wish in the past that motivates their heroism in the present. It's a angle I've never seen done before.
 
The character concept I used back during Character Generation 0.2 was somewhat popular, even though it didn't win, so I decided to adapt it for this vote as well. Seems like it kept its popularity (that said, I suspect my plan is enjoying a lot of support mostly because of the Old Friend + Aid From A Friend combo, rather than people merely thinking I have an interesting character prepared). I'm still undecided on the wish...

Im just vibing honestly. I suppose once we get to the actual story + seeing how the power sets develop is where the real fun begins. I trus MrKermie in creating some fleshed out characters no mather what plan wins....
As for the wish..... hmmm wishimg for peace.... that kinda could be monkey pawed actually. What kind of peace? Mental? Physical? Emotional? No more battles? (Youre at peace if your dead) want peace from your horrible past? Ok *poof* no more memories of your past!
 
But yeah thats the thing with wishes it kinda defines their personality a bit and probably their powersxand development. Trying to build character because they regreted their wish could be cool. But for most the wish is gonna be tied to a the archetype their building. Things like never wanting to be a weapon again, revenge on thise who wrong them, wishing for success in life. Things like that can be part of a character.... and they can ALL go wrong if the granter takes the Word of the wish instead of the spirit of it. Plus if theyre open ended like a "wish for peace"... thats where the spicy tragedy lies.
 
Last edited:
Edit: Actually, after some discussion with my editor (my sister), @ThatGuyWithIdeas, you can change your wish to an IOU.

[ ] They wished for some guarantee of safety in the future.

Can I get the input of those voting for my plan before I go ahead with making the change? (mostly asking because mass pinging is something that is usually to be avoided...)

EDIT: Since QM hasn't said anything...
@Sonic0859, @Saphentite, @Theonetruelordke, @Unlucky Bibliophile, @Brainbow, @Eternal_0bserver and @BoundaryPhantasm... QM has expressed the willingness to exchange the curent wish I'm using in my plan (aka "Their wish was to live a peaceful life.") for "They wished for some guarantee of safety in the future.". Before making such a change, I'd like to get your opinion on the matter of leaving the wish as it is or making the change QM is willing to allow.
 
Last edited:
QM has expressed the willingness to exchange the curent wish I'm using in my plan (aka "Their wish was to live a peaceful life.") for "They wished for some guarantee of safety in the future.". Before making such a change, I'd like to get your opinion on the matter of leaving the wish as it is or making the change QM is willing to allow.

Go ahead, that's fine.
 
Can I get the input of those voting for my plan before I go ahead with making the change? (mostly asking because mass pinging is something that is usually to be avoided...)
Was doing something, sorry.

But, nobody seems mad with the mass ping, so once at least 4 people get on board with that idea via likes or replies, you should do it. It won't be that hard to implement as a mechanic either.

Edit: I officially grant @ThatGuyWithIdeas full permission to change his plan's wish.
 
Last edited:
Can I get the input of those voting for my plan before I go ahead with making the change? (mostly asking because mass pinging is something that is usually to be avoided...)

EDIT: Since QM hasn't said anything...
@Sonic0859, @Saphentite, @Theonetruelordke, @Unlucky Bibliophile, @Brainbow, @Eternal_0bserver and @BoundaryPhantasm... QM has expressed the willingness to exchange the curent wish I'm using in my plan (aka "Their wish was to live a peaceful life.") for "They wished for some guarantee of safety in the future.". Before making such a change, I'd like to get your opinion on the matter of leaving the wish as it is or making the change QM is willing to allow.

Go ahead.
 
QM has expressed the willingness to exchange the curent wish I'm using in my plan (aka "Their wish was to live a peaceful life.") for "They wished for some guarantee of safety in the future.". Before making such a change, I'd like to get your opinion on the matter of leaving the wish as it is or making the change QM is willing to allow.

I may not be following the discussion right now, but what is driving these changes? I would probably prefer the original wish right now.
 
I may not be following the discussion right now, but what is driving these changes?

Earlier, I expressed some doubts about the wish I've had for the character. Ashen then jokingly suggested that I could rework my original wish into an IOU of getting a guarantee of safety later on. After some deliberation, QM was willing to allow me to change my wish from the original version to the new proposal of "They wished for some guarantee of safety in the future" (and also expressed the belief that it wouldn't be hard to implement in-quest, so it's not), but I wanted to get the opinion on those who voted for my plan first before going ahead with the change.

With the permission of QM and having currently 4 people agreeing with the change, I went ahead and changed the original wish for the plan to "They wished for some guarantee of safety in the future.". Nevertheless, I will still hear opinions regarding the wish matter (aka keeping the wish I've had at the start by reversing the change I've just made or keeping the changed wish).
 
Last edited:
Earlier, I expressed some doubts about the wish I've had for the character. Ashen then jokingly suggested that I could rework my original wish into an IOU of getting a guarantee of safety later on. After some deliberation, QM was willing to allow me to change my wish from the original version to the new proposal of "They wished for some guarantee of safety in the future" (and also expressed the belief that it wouldn't be hard to implement in-quest, so it's not), but I wanted to get the opinion on those who voted for my plan first before going ahead with the change.

With the permission of QM and having currently 4 people agreeing with the change, I went ahead and changed the original wish for the plan to "They wished for some guarantee of safety in the future.". Nevertheless, I will still hear opinions regarding the wish matter (aka keeping the wish I've had at the start by reversing the change I've just made or keeping the changed wish).

I would probably prefer the first wish, since it can be interpreted both as a search for safety for oneself and as a desire to end threats to people's peaceful life in general, but whatever. If you think the new wish is better, I'm not going to insist otherwise.
 
Adhoc vote count started by gamer50018 on Jun 19, 2024 at 4:55 PM, finished with 63 posts and 21 votes.

  • [X] Plan A Different Style of Magical Girl, Second Try
    -[X] ...Pleasant, yet Scheming
    - [X] Girl
    -[X] Kaneko Akemi
    -[X]
    - [X] (1) Old Friends
    - [X] Fellow Weapon
    -[X] They wished for some guarantee of safety in the future.
    - [X] (2) Aid From A Friend
    -[X] (-1) Deficiency In Technical
    [X] Plan: Shouldn't Have Screwed the Rules
    -[X] Regretful and Self-Reflective
    -[X] Male
    -[X] Ryuga Yamamoto
    -[X] This Image here.
    -[X] Who?
    -[X] Hyper-Competitive Shonen Rival. You had to be the best, you had to beat him no matter the cost. It wasn't worth it. It never was.
    -[X] To always be the best in Duel Monsters.
    -[X] (1) Specialty In… Mental, (2) Master of Tech
    - [X] (-1) Unending Grief
    [X] Plan: If I use the term Fem Boy, will I get more votes or less?
    -[X] …Shy and Reclusive.
    -[X] Boy
    -[X]Ren Akiyama
    -[X] Young, and petite, with curly hair and feminine clothing.
    -[X] (0) Who?
    -[X] Always Left Behind
    -[X] Their wish was… To finally be accepted for who they are, and how they express themself.
    -[X] (2) Master of Magic
    -[X] (1) Hero Otaku
    -[X] (-1) Deficiency In Social
    [X] Plan: Back to Back Against the World
    - [X] …Curious and Inquisitive
    - [X] Tori Akira
    - [X] Girl
    - [X] Appearance:
    - [X] (1) Old Friends
    - [X] Fellow Weapon
    - [X] Their wish was to be free. To not be a weapon in someone else's hand ever again.
    - [X] (2) Aid From A Friend
    - [X] (-1) Unending Grief
    [X] Plan A Different Style of Magical Girl, Second Try (Alternate Version)
    -[X] ...Pleasant, yet Scheming
    - [X] Girl
    -[X] Kaneko Akemi
    -[X]
    - [X] (1) Old Friends
    - [X] Fellow Weapon
    -[X] Their wish was to live a peaceful life.
    -[X] (1) Specialty In Social
    -[X] (1) Hero Otaku
    -[X] (-1) Deficiency In Technical
    [X] Plan: Magikal Kombat!!
    -[X] ...Sociable, but Intense
    -[X] Boy
    -[X] Ren Akaba
    - [X] Appearance:
    -[X] (1) Your Kohai
    - [X] Fellow Weapon
    -[X] To find Peace, for themselves and for those who died in their hands.
    -[X] (1) Hero Otaku
    -[X] (2) Master of Magic
    - [X] (-1) Unending Grief
    [X] Plan: Sunshine on a Cloudy Day
    -[X] …Kind and Caring.
    -[X] Male
    -[X] Andrew (Andou) Nikkō
    -[X]
    -[X] (0) Who?
    -[X] Past: Unknown, both to you and to themselves.
    -[X] Wish: To forget there past
    -[X] (1) Hero Otaku
    -[X] (2) Master of Magic
    -[X] (-1) Phlebotinum Incontinence
    -[X] (?) Mysterious Past
    [X] Phantom Assasins, Phantom Thieves, looots of grief.
    -[X] …Kind and Caring.
    -[X] Male
    -[X]Ren Akiyama
    -[X] Apperance
    - [X] (1) Old Friends
    - [X] Fellow Weapon
    - [X] Their wish was to be free. To not be a weapon in someone else's hand ever again.
    -[X] (1) Hero Otaku
    [X] Phantom Assasins, Phantom Thieves, looots of grief.
 
[X] Plan A Different Style of Magical Girl, Second Try
-[X] ...Pleasant, yet Scheming
- [X] Girl
-[X] Kaneko Akemi
-[X]
- [X] (1) Old Friends
- [X] Fellow Weapon

-[X] They wished for some guarantee of safety in the future.
- [X] (2) Aid From A Friend
-[X] (-1) Deficiency In Technical
 
Since your partner will guaranteed not be showing up in the next update, I'll just be rolling dice on site here.
Kermie threw 1 100-faced dice. Reason: Physical Check: DC 70 Total: 30
30 30
Kermie threw 1 8-faced dice. Reason: Piercing Damage (d8) Total: 2
2 2
Kermie threw 1 12-faced dice. Reason: Unimportant Random Event Roll Total: 12
12 12
Kermie threw 1 100-faced dice. Reason: Magical Check: DC 80 Total: 72
72 72
Kermie threw 1 100-faced dice. Reason: Mental Check: DC 50 Total: 6
6 6
 
Last edited:
Since your partner will guaranteed not be showing up in the next update, I'll just be rolling dice on site here.

Ahh what a beautiful day to be not dead, the flowers are blooming, the birds are singing and the immidiate 100 foot radius surrounding us is currently on fire. What a swell day. *sees something approaching rapidly* oh whats tha- *Plot and trauma and failed rolls*

.....I should have stayed in bed..... i still had some.... packs... to open.....
 
Vote closed
Scheduled vote count started by MrKermie on Jun 17, 2024 at 12:22 PM, finished with 70 posts and 23 votes.

  • [X] Plan A Different Style of Magical Girl, Second Try
    -[X] ...Pleasant, yet Scheming
    - [X] Girl
    -[X] Kaneko Akemi
    -[X]
    - [X] (1) Old Friends
    - [X] Fellow Weapon
    -[X] They wished for some guarantee of safety in the future.
    - [X] (2) Aid From A Friend
    -[X] (-1) Deficiency In Technical
    [X] Plan: Shouldn't Have Screwed the Rules
    -[X] Regretful and Self-Reflective
    -[X] Male
    -[X] Ryuga Yamamoto
    -[X] This Image here.
    -[X] Who?
    -[X] Hyper-Competitive Shonen Rival. You had to be the best, you had to beat him no matter the cost. It wasn't worth it. It never was.
    -[X] To always be the best in Duel Monsters.
    -[X] (1) Specialty In… Mental, (2) Master of Tech
    - [X] (-1) Unending Grief
    [X] Plan: If I use the term Fem Boy, will I get more votes or less?
    -[X] …Shy and Reclusive.
    -[X] Boy
    -[X]Ren Akiyama
    -[X] Young, and petite, with curly hair and feminine clothing.
    -[X] (0) Who?
    -[X] Always Left Behind
    -[X] Their wish was… To finally be accepted for who they are, and how they express themself.
    -[X] (2) Master of Magic
    -[X] (1) Hero Otaku
    -[X] (-1) Deficiency In Social
    [X] Plan A Different Style of Magical Girl, Second Try (Alternate Version)
    -[X] ...Pleasant, yet Scheming
    - [X] Girl
    -[X] Kaneko Akemi
    -[X]
    - [X] (1) Old Friends
    - [X] Fellow Weapon
    -[X] Their wish was to live a peaceful life.
    -[X] (1) Specialty In Social
    -[X] (1) Hero Otaku
    -[X] (-1) Deficiency In Technical
    [X] Plan: Magikal Kombat!!
    -[X] ...Sociable, but Intense
    -[X] Boy
    -[X] Ren Akaba
    - [X] Appearance:
    -[X] (1) Your Kohai
    - [X] Fellow Weapon
    -[X] To find Peace, for themselves and for those who died in their hands.
    -[X] (1) Hero Otaku
    -[X] (2) Master of Magic
    - [X] (-1) Unending Grief
    [X] Plan: Sunshine on a Cloudy Day
    -[X] …Kind and Caring.
    -[X] Male
    -[X] Andrew (Andou) Nikkō
    -[X]
    -[X] (0) Who?
    -[X] Past: Unknown, both to you and to themselves.
    -[X] Wish: To forget there past
    -[X] (1) Hero Otaku
    -[X] (2) Master of Magic
    -[X] (-1) Phlebotinum Incontinence
    -[X] (?) Mysterious Past
    [X] Plan: Back to Back Against the World
    - [X] …Curious and Inquisitive
    - [X] Tori Akira
    - [X] Girl
    - [X] Appearance:
    - [X] (1) Old Friends
    - [X] Fellow Weapon
    - [X] Their wish was to be free. To not be a weapon in someone else's hand ever again.
    - [X] (2) Aid From A Friend
    - [X] (-1) Unending Grief
    [X] Phantom Assasins, Phantom Thieves, looots of grief.
 
Base Stats: All 7.

+Ex-Assassin: +10 to Non Phys stats.
+Gain Weapon: M2 Silenced Pistol

-Deficiency in Technical: -15 to Tech rolls. Gain the in-universe title (Tech Klutz).

+She wished for some guarantee of safety in the future: Gain the ability to use the [Wish And A Dream] feature.

+Aid From A Friend: ??? will now be joining both her and you on this quest. +5 to Magical and Physical thanks to him.

Final Stats:
Physical: 12
Social: 17
Mental: 17
Technical: 2
Magical: 22
 
Last edited:
Chapter will probably be out in one-two hours, so I have to ask— what do you guys think about the narrator of some of the character creation episodes? Y'know, considering he'll essentially be Kaneko's mentor.
 
Base Stats: All 7.

+Ex-Assassin: +10 to Non Phys stats.
+Gain Weapon: M2 Silenced Pistol

-Deficiency in Technical: -15 to Tech rolls. Gain the in-universe title (Tech Klutz).

+She wished for some guarantee of safety in the future: Gain the ability to use the [Wish And A Dream] feature.

+Aid From A Friend: ??? will now be joining both her and you on this quest. +5 to Magical thanks to him.

Final Stats:
Physical: 12

Did the companion also get a Physical buff that isn't listed? Because she should be at 7 Physical if I'm not mistaken...
 
Back
Top