All of the Dursley family is dead.
...damn

and it was an AUROR Spell that killed everyone.


I'm starting to think that maybe the conflict is not that black-and-white.

If we go by canon, the death eaters should NOT have been able to enter the house... IF they had evil intentions towards Harry.

Maybe the Dark Lord tricked them into thinking he had good intentions. Or maybe, the Dark Lord is not actually THAT evil here.

Or maybe both sides are evil.

[ ] Rest In Peace

[ ] Beg On Your Knees
- If you are willing to pay the price, there is yet hope for young Dudley Dursley. By destiny's resolution, he is to die within a Muggle hospital or on the way there, in but a few minutes from now, but the Chooser of the Slain is more than willing to tip destiny's scales in your favor. And by the Chooser's decision, a single Auror within the ranks will find enough pity to abuse his powers, contrary to the law, in order to heal your cousin to a state which resembles survival. Enough to tip the scales.

However, the prices of denying Death his obols are steep - he demands nothing less than sacrifice of equal or greater value. As such, you will now pay a regular tribute - 100% of the Gnosis you earn from your Blessing, "An Equal in Truth" will be conveyed into Death's coffers.

None of your other family members can be saved. A sad pity, but Death is unwilling to budge on this. "Actions have consequences," too, is a primordial maxim.

...the Aurors are NOT authorized to heal our family? Seriously?!

...Well, we already have messianic fame from Boy Who Lived and the likely loyalty from 1/4th of all english wizards thanks to Lord of Hufflepuff. I think that, if we get a chance, we might want to have some laws changed


I'm honestly not sure if I want to pay this price, but even beyond morality having a friendly muggle could help with Excalibur.
[ ] Mr. Auror Kingsley Shacklebolt - A man that Harry is already familiar with, having met him during the incident that we do not speak about. He's a relatively affable man, with a nice smile, and shows understanding and sympathy for Harry's plight. He moves Harry to a wizarding orphanage in the interim for finding him better accommodations. (If Dudley is alive, he will reluctantly attempt to split the boys into separate orphanages and won't hear any of your bullshit, though.)

[ ] Headmaster Albus Dumbledore - An old man with a thick fluffy beard, that Harry doesn't remember meeting before, although Mr. Dumbledore claims they'd met once, when Harry was too young to remember him. He tentatively offers Harry (and Dudley) a place to stay at his brother's until they can together figure out more permanent accommodations; Dumbledore knows more than a few people who'd be willing to take the boys in.

...not sure. Wizarding orphanage might mean more financial independence once we get access to our vault. Also less oversight, but also probably being split from Dudley.

Dumbledore means a magical family... but which ones?

Lupin? Sirius? the Weasley or Longbottom? Maybe someone more unexpected? maybe Hogwarts itself/a professor, if we're lucky?



well, lesson learned. shit is real here, and we should think twice before taking dangerous options.

You all chose a kidnapping option. What did you all expect? That it would end up perfectly fine and dandy?
I think we didn't expect an OOC vote to decide the death of all of our family. We underestimated things.

[ ] Attempted Kidnapping! - A number of men in dark cloaks and skull masks sneak into the Dursley house at night and wake Harry up from sleep, ordering him to come with them. Before he can fully process what's going on, a number of men in dark blue robes appear and a fight breaks out! [Action Update]

Yeah, I don't think most voted for this thinking a OOC choice about wanting something literally labeled a action update was going to kill off Harry's family, who up till now were written in a way to maximally endear us and some of the only prevalent recurring characters in the story, for shock value and completely change the tone of the quest out of nowhere.
Still, this makes us truly understand the tone of the quest. it's a shock, but we'll learn from it.

Some torture and trauma is okay and expected but not the death of family? Come on, folks. Even in the books harry saw Sirius die in a fight. Other people also died fighting Death Eaters. This story is billed as being darker. Expecting Harry's family to be in danger should have crossed your minds.
I think we didn't expect it before even Hogwarts!

I'm going to be blunt and say absolutely nothing about the quests tone would have in anyway made me expect this. We fought off Voldemort's wraith with a super soaker full of holy water and it was played for laughs ffs.
Don't say the name!

Which, given that happened, I guess we know how useful the ward Harry mom set up is in this AU.
The wards supposedly stop people having bad intentions towards harry... but what if the Death Eaters DIDN'T have bad intentions?

Maybe they though we'd be the next Dark Lord and wanted to train us and indoctrinate us? From their point of view that would be "good intentions".

Am I the only one shocked that it was an Auror that killed the entire family? I expected it from the Death Eaters, not the guys meant to protect Harry
The lesson here is: Don't necessarily trust the Ministry. Which, fair enough, we kinda already knew that one.

Also that there might be more to the Death Eaters, as if they could go beyond the wards we have to wonder what they wanted to do with us that the wards would not stop them.

It's not like Tom Riddle's shade was treated with this level of seriousness.
have all people decided to just ignore the "don't speak the name" rule?

Are you assuming that the Gnosis tithe wouldn't be a more severe consequence than Dudley's death? Because it looks a lot like that's a thing you're doing right now.

More interesting to me is why Dudley's survival is something a god is willing to offer at all. Sure, the god stat is always nice and having more is always on the table, but any Power able to transcend death isn't going to be playing checkers. There's got to be another angle here.
I can only imagine that a muggle and a wizard considering each other brothers and being genuine allies will be important in the future.

Mostly because Excalibur.

[X] Beg On Your Knees
[X] Headmaster Albus Dumbledore
 
All Away
All Away

Harry Potter wasn't sure how long he'd sat in the rubble and dust, muttering incantations to himself interspersed with hacking coughs. It could've been minutes or hours, as his mind was lost in an abyss of time; every moment infinite yet no more or less distinct from any other. His weary eyes danced over the familiar elements of broken furniture once in assembly, causing him to stop from his ceaseless incantation for moments at a time to cry more, sobbing uncontrollably while Geist in his mind spoke words that the part of Harry's brain usually responsible for translating them from pure intent into British English was too tired to convey.

At one point he'd stood up, clenched his fists, and lashed out with his foot, kicking at the standing remnant of a wall in futility, before falling over from sheer vertigo and landing on top of the broken kitchen table. And there, clutching the miraculously still-attached table legs, as if for support, he kept crying and chanting spells.

And such was the state the Auror team recovered him in.

A young woman in somber black robes had taken Harry up, away from the collapsed and overturned table, and gently led him away from the rubble of Privet Drive 4, as if prompting him to leave it behind. He felt disgusted and horrified at the idea, but his feet moved on their own, without conscious input.

They made a stop outside, at the sidewalk, where men in robes had stopped the flow of traffic, including police cars and ambulances. There was something of a stand-off now, bobbies yelling and making orders at the Aurors who refused to budge. The Auror woman brought Harry in front of a man with the facial features and grace of a lion, a mane of tawny hair with gray streaks, wearing a brown trenchcoat and wielding a gnarled staff of oaken wood. A grim look adorned his face as he looked emptily at the collapsed Dursley house. He introduced himself, but Harry didn't listen and didn't hear his name, and noticing this, the man said something to the woman, and she led him away.

And then he sat, on the back edge of a horse-drawn carriage that seemed to have no horses, and he observed the scene unfold. All of the events of the night started to blur together incomprehensibly in his mind, as if someone had bleached a sharp line of the portrait and then rubbed it so raw the sharpness dissolved into a smear covering half the painting - the moment where several bodies were wheeled out on gurneys no more distinct in his mind than when he'd seen an Auror fall over with his throat split. He felt stuck. Like someone had pressed a button in his brain so hard that something gave in, and now the button was stuck and couldn't be unpressed.

As the scene developed, a squad of Obliviators wiping away the memories of the Muggles as he'd seen them do some time ago, a team of consultants forming a plausible explanation for the incident, Harry received a warm blanket from someone and was later asked if he needed anything - to eat or to drink. He'd simply said no.

All of it was blurred, indistinct, smoky - an impressionist's painting of a memory. And there was something twisted about it, something off.

Everything changed, at least partially, when he arrived - maybe an hour into the incident, once the investigation and clean-up efforts were long underway, maybe even nearing their zenith. He was a gaunt and thin man, maybe as tall as Aunt Petunia had been, and he was very old, judging by the shining moonsilver of his splendid hair and thick beard, which were both long enough to tuck into his belt. He was wearing light blue robes, a white cloak that swept the ground, and high-heeled, buckled boots. As he walked through the scene, the atmosphere changed palpably, and Harry found himself running in his direction before he even knew who the man was, to cry into his stomach.

"Oh Harry," said Albus Dumbledore. "I'm so sorry."

Nothing else was said, at least, not until Harry was done crying. At that point, Mr. Dumbledore had introduced himself and offered Harry to sit down with him, so they could talk and figure out what happened. Slowly, in between stops, pauses, and sobs, Harry recounted the night's events in a shaky puzzle of images, and though he kept pouring the events out of himself as fast as he could, Dumbledore had told him multiple times to slow down, take his time; to reassure him that it was horrible and wretched, what had happened, and that he didn't need to hurry anywhere, that they could take their time.

As sedate as the old man's appearance was, these words, too, blurred into the night's events, with Harry's brain too exhausted to even begin processing them. Almost respectfully, Geist had kept silent for the rest of the night, though Harry could feel his lingering presence in his mind.

An hour into his somber appearance, as the scene was being cleaned up - the police and ambulances long gone, only a small team of Aurors left on the scene, and the only major undertaking they had to take care of was to transport Harry somewhere else for the night and obliviate the neighbors - Dumbledore offered Harry to stay at his brother's house for a couple of nights until they could figure out better accommodations for him. Dumbledore promised Harry that he would have input over what happened next, that there was no reason to be afraid for now - the shadows were gone.

Are you there? Harry asked, his mind feeling like the cold strum of a cordless guitar.

I am, Geist said, You haven't been listening or even hearing. I understand. I wanted to tell you that I'm sorry.

Not your fault,
Harry thought at him, putting the issue aside, even as he felt a sickening lurch in his stomach, You- You have memories of being a wizard, right? Scattered memories, but you recognized that Bellatrix woman.

A note of hesitation appeared in Geist's response, but he did respond, Ye-es.

I- Should I go with Dumbledore? To his brother's place?


A moment of thought, as Geist considered the question in depth. I don't think we have any other choice. I don't want to give you biased advice, Harry, so here's what I'll say about him for now: Dumbledore, as far as I know, isn't a threat to you. If he trusts someone, I think we can trust them as well.

A heavy silence ruled the street that Harry was on - Privet Drive. As the night continued, the commotion of familiar neighbors and people coming out to see began to wane and then finally die down, Obliviators and Aurors cleansing away the memories of bystanders. As Harry was about to vocalize his decision, Geist interrupted him.

Harry, wait.

Yeah?
he asked tiredly.

Do- Do you trust me?

Harry didn't have to think long about it. Yes. You're- You're a pain, but you're my friend, too.

What he didn't, actively, think was that Geist was probably one of his only friends left, aside from rats and friends that he'd shared with Dudley. And he wasn't sure he'd be able to face the latter group, not without his cousin.

I need you to speak some words for me, in a specific way, and channeling specific emotions. I know it'll seem weird, and arbitrary. It's-

I'll do it. What words?


"I hate this," Harry said, quoting Geist - prompting Dumbledore to look over with concern - voice dipping low, "I can't bear it. Why? Why did this happen, Mr. Dumbledore?"

The old wizard's features softened into a deep remorse as he listened.

"Harry..." And then, Geist spoke - no longer as a basis for Harry to quote, but in unison with Dumbledore, as if equally predicting and testing the man, "Muggles die when wizards fight. It's the saddest and most horrible truth of the world we live in, something that I learned myself, and not without consequences. I pray for a day when this is no longer the case; when our kind can be responsible enough with our powers that it does not result in the loss of people who are innocent, and I hope that day is soon."

So it's you, Albus. Let's go, Harry.

Upon receiving his assent, Dumbledore took Harry by the arm and made them both Apparate.

---

As per his promise, Harry would have input on who he'd live with from now on.

[ ] Sirius Black

According to Dumbledore, Sirius Black is your godfather, and the person your parents designated as your guardian should they ever die. However, after their death, he became depressed and inconsolable; a terrible drunkard, and not in the state to take care of a child; he begged Dumbledore to find someone who'd be able to take better care of you. As the years passed, Sirius cleaned up his act, slowly, and even became a professor, teaching Defense Against the Dark Arts at Hogwarts, now teaching the subject for over five years as its most stable paragon and educator. Hogwarts is the magic school that you're supposed to be going to in the future.

As such, there is a minor logistical issue, in the fact that he won't be able to personally attend to you for most of the remaining year until the summer arrives, but his House Elf should be able to care for you in the meantime, at least in the departments of meals and laundry.

Geist Opinion: "By himself, I think Black is trustworthy and reliable. Although I must say his choice of profession betrays what I can only rightfully call refined anti-wisdom. I suppose he was feeling suicidal after what happened to your parents."

If you'd prefer someone who can take care of you until the summer, however, Dumbledore is aware of several magical families that'd be willing to take you in. And you had to admit, the prospect of meeting a family of people who could do the same things as you sounded like a good distraction from what happened.

[ ] The Weasley Family

A large wizarding family, popular in most social circles, Dumbledore trusts in their kindness and the inner mother of Molly Weasley, knowing her to be a person that can take good care of you. He'd be more than happy to introduce you to them and knows they'd be more than happy to have you as a guest until the end of the summer.

Geist Opinion: "I think Molly's fine, but I never liked the father, and I can't remember why. Did he bully me in school or something?"

[ ] The Diggory Family

Amos Diggory is one of the Ministry of Magic's most reliable workmen - according to Dumbledore, he is fair, kind, and has expressed an eagerness to meet you in the past (a fact which confused you, but with Dumbledore promising to explain later,) so Dumbledore is confident that he'd be a reliable caretaker.

Geist Opinion: "Amos is fine, I think. Also, the longer I think about it, the more I realize that every person of import I ever met now works for the Ministry of Magic, and isn't that a chilling thought?"

[ ] The Longbottom Family

A family of Aurors, and they have a son your age, whom Dumbledore states with confidence has similar interests to you, and thinks you could become good friends. Although something in you aches at the thought, his offer seems to be genuine. Also, apparently, you already met Alice Longbottom - she was the one to help you out of the rubble.

Geist Opinion: "Ugh. If I ever get any physical money, I will pay you to pick someone else."

[ ] The Lovegood Family

A very jovial sort, or so says Dumbledore. However, the moment their name was brought up, Geist began screaming loudly in your head and only stopped after five seconds, upon realizing there wasn't actually a Lovegood in the room.

Geist Opinion: "Anything but these people, Harry. I'm pretty sure the husband snorts chalk dust. Why is this even an option? Dumbledore must have rocks in his head!"
 
Last edited:
[X] Sirius Black

Dangerous world requires something more then extended childhood. Besides i could see us convincing him to go find excalibur with us which is probably in the lake near hogwarts. He also gives us tons of free time to ourselves and open rein of a magical house filled with dangerous shit.
 
[ ] Sirius Black

Despite what many in this thread believe, I actually trust the Geist. He is an little bit of an asshole, sure, but as far as I know, he never did anything to put Harry In danger, hell he did his best to save us, one could say he did it to save him self, but someone like that wouldn't try to comfort a crying child. This may change in the future, but for now he is trustworthy so when he screams when he hears about the Lovegoods, and doesn't really like anyone other than Black and Diggory, I'm tempted to trust him as he does this for a reason, it may be an shitty reason we don't know about or whatever, but he still has an reason. Besides, the Lovegoods may or may not be insane and snort unicorn poop, the gingers' are too many people already, the Longbottoms' have that name for a reason and I'm sure its not because their ass is very big or something and Diggory is an goverment tool and since an Auror just straight up killed our entire family, I'm not too entitled to trust them. So, Sirius it is for me.
 
Last edited:
Despite what many in this thread believe, I actually trust the Geist. He is an little bit of an asshole, sure, but as far as I know, he never did anything to put Harry In danger. This may change in the future, but for now he is trustworthy so when he screams when he hears about the Lovegoods, and doesn't really like anyone other than Black and Diggory, I'm tempted to trust him as he does this for a reason, it may be an shitty reason we don't know about or whatever, but he still has an reason. Besides, the Lovegoods may or may not be insane and snort unicorn poop, the gingers' are too many people already, the Longbottoms' have that name for a reason and I'm sure its not because their ass is very big or something and Diggory is an goverment tool and since an Auror just straight up killed our entire family, I'm not too entitled to trust them. So, Sirius it is for me.

Huh, good point. Geist has been relatively good with advice so far and him being against the Longbottoms is a decent enough reason.
 
I'm also very curious about the Death Eaters, the Geist( He really need a better name ) didn't see them as good news based on his comment when he recognised Bellatrix, but why did she protect us when that asshole auror did an magical grenade with innocents in range? Also, she could have knocked us out or forced us with her, but she tried to talk us into coming, with that wizard adventure stuff, and it's not because they didn't want to trip the wards or anything with their way of opening our door and she also said Harry is ours if I read correctly. So, what I'm thinking is that either we are kidnapped by the goverment and the Death Eaters want to save us which is unlikely or, the more plausible explanation, we have something that they want. Maybe one of our traits and Perks or they just know we will be a powerful wizard or something.
 
Just curious. Have you read anything that wasn't a shonen battle manga or...?

Do you believe that only shonen battle manga deal with powerscaling? Powerscaling is something that also applies to social situations, politics and the direct application of knowledge among other things.
If a character that's bad at math suddenly aces a math exam out of nowhere then that's also "scaling" so to speak.

Powerscaling is a part of the narrative and ignoring powerscaling for the sake of taking the plot a certain way is the same as ignoring charactarization or making stupid choices for the same reason.

Ignoring powerscaling means presenting an inconsistent narrative which is automatically bad writing.

Besides, battle shonens are usually the worst offenders when it comes to scaling so I have no idea why you would single them out like that.

No need to be sarcastic. This series of events in response to a vote about what childish hijinks kid Harry gets into, where every other vote is minor and predetermined to be mostly harmless, does sincerely seem unreasonable.

I'm not complaining that it doesn't make sense for this to happen in-universe. But it would make just as much sense for the angry rottweiler vote to end in Dudley getting his throat torn out, or the Wraith vote to end in Vernon being possessed by the shade and I would have roughly the same tonal complaint.

Some people are talking about powerscaling, but I think that's a complete red herring here. Aside from nonverbal Unforgivables and maybe casting spells a little faster, nothing we've seen is outside the realms of canon wizard fights in terms of sheer power.

I'm not being sarcastic, I'm also willing to accept the argument that the "punishment" here was excessive.
I disagree with the idea that it is unfair or unreasonable.

I also don't think that your comparisons are fair.
In both the Rottweiler and the shade scenarios we are specifically told the outcome of the events beforehand (harry get away from the dog with only a few bite marks, harry fights off the shade successfully) when in this scenario we weren't.

If these other scenarios were as open-ended then the outcomes that you discribed would have been acceptable as well.
 
Last edited:
Meme votes are fun and all, but we *just* had major consequences for a vote. Can we not put ourselves with the crackpots of the wizarding world? This could have serious consequences regarding our ability to form relationships at Hogwarts.
 
Back
Top