Green Flame Rising (Exalted vs Dresden Files)

This is way too much at once. I think we should do this in steps or we risk them getting overwhelmed and saying no to everything in a knee-jerk reaction. We should have tons of good will, but that doesn't mean people won't panic in the aftermath of a disaster like this anyway.

Bring back the wizards back first, then get into the Warlock splendor and FSB patch. It's unclear if you mean to include the pigeon god stuff here too, but if that's the case I think it should be a discussion for later.
The way I see it is this (before sleep claims me):
1) The council is going to be hurting for a solution right now. The normal procedure of "kill all warlocks with very few exceptions" is not feasible - way too many warlocks at once, and hot war with Red Court going on. This is the problem from both senior council's perspective, and young generation / warden perspective.

2) Bringing back the dead (which we totally should do) exaggerates the problem at least a bit - the dead were warlocks, if unwillingly subverted. We don't know if the Wheel will cure their Lawbreaking soul / sanity damage. Wizards certainly don't know that.

3) FSB on its lonesome cannot be proposed as a long term or permanent solution. It creates too great a dependency on Molly on the institutional level. It's an active charm that requires reapplying. So, if something happens to Molly, or the wizard is unavailable to see it reapplied, the effect lapses. It compromises all those to whom it is applied, as they have to follow Molly's orders. It doesn't actually solve / heal the problem, which almost certainly makes it hard to check if someone is under the effect of FSB or not - it would create uncertainty and potential issues.

Based on these points, if we want to bring people back with as few issues as possible, we need to propose something for the mass law breaking issue, and it cannot be just FSB.

Plus, I feel it might actually be a good idea to put out our ideas here, not just in front of some members of senior council, but also in front of the young wardens, who are suddenly facing the uncertainty of their fate, and a possiblity of execution or at least Doom of Damocles. It puts political pressure on the senior council to accept our ideas, or at least to seriously engage with them, rather than dismissing them. Remember, White Council is not a dictatorship:

"I realize that this is hard for you to read Dresden, but do consider the virtues of holding the questions in until the end of the meeting. We have much to discuss in any case. The likely response of the Senior Council will be that this must be put before a full vote of the White Council after the exploratory mission has been completed, in that case Ms Carpenter would be informed of the full vote so that she may make her case in person if she wishes. 'Better to beg forgiveness than ask permission' might have served you well so far, but there is a name for doing that when in a position of leadership, that name is tyranny."

And while Senior Council is the ruling body, "young generation" almost certainly also has political power. I want to use that, by giving them a lifeline.
No that would be stupid we want to tempt loads of other wizards to look into us as their afterlife provider.
Oh, absolutely. I want, however, for there to be fewer issues with some of those wizards returning to White Council.
 
Adhoc vote count started by Anaja on Oct 31, 2024 at 5:10 PM, finished with 45 posts and 12 votes.

  • [X] Plan Grand Strategy
    -[X] Activate Empathy excellency
    -[X] [Dead] Offer to raise the dead wizards
    --[X] Lydia helps to talk to them, uses excellency if applicable
    -[X] [Warlocks] Explain all your plans for saving those who unwittingly break the Laws, the dead spirits, the book of names, all of it
    [X] [Dead] Offer to raise the dead wizards
    [X] [Warlocks] Explain all your plans for saving those who unwittingly break the Laws, the dead spirits, the book of names, all of it
    [X] [Dead] Bring them under the wheel
    -[X][Stunt] "I don't know what after life services you have arranged for yourself, but let me provide a new after last minute offer."
    [X] [Warlocks] Describe False Spring Beckon
 
[X] [Dead] Bring them under the wheel
-[X] With the White Council's permission
[X] [Warlocks] Explain all your plans for saving those who unwittingly break the Laws, the dead spirits, the book of names, all of it
 
Did we get a free demolition for the labyrinth too or is it "just" damaged a bit? I was thinking we'd need to spend AP to burn this place to the ground, but if Markus cleaned up after himself that'd be excellent.

As far as Molly can tell this particular Labyrinth will not survive the death of its maker. The Paris side likely will require clean up anyway since it's not like the ruins of this place are going to be wholesome and you never know what might slip though the veil here.
 
which is good since it allowed you to use that excellency on Murder is Meat which got you the soul without his patrons getting to contest it.
On an unrelated note we learned that we can spend a mote when trying to MiM someone who may be pulled out to have it go through without issue.

@DragonParadox Is that what you meant here or was the roll just too good to bother rolling on their end?
 

faced with this
the laughs with lipless
he laughs? Sentence is a bit confusing.
the cycle that composed
The circle that surrounded?
he? Sentence is a bit confusing.
Contest?
What you can do?
 
[X] Plan Grand Strategy

I think on a purely mechanical level his best option for spite would have been a really big boom.

We can't counterspell that, he would have gotten the Wardens and maybe one or more of the VIPs we brought with us.

Sure, Molly could have toughened it out, but standing between the blast shadows of the people we came here to save would still have sucked.

To be entirely fair, the Merlin or McCoy might have been able to deal with an explosion.

But yeah, his spite got in the way of his practical evil goals - or replaced them, if he wasn't an ideological hardcore kind of soulless cultist.

And hey! We now know that we can't eat Death Curses with MiM (later in the tick order). Our counterspell will protect us personally (as well as keeping a mote retained for EIPP), but we should be more careful about killing more explosion-focused wizards, at least not unless we're alone (and with a perfect defense).
 
Last edited:
but if he went for a matter-to-energy conversion and tried to catch them as collateral, that would've been wiser (and Molly could've died to that too without a Perfect Defense, even if she can respawn).

I think that that is solidly in the realm of 'unless you have a perfect defense you just die, straight up.' Which absolutely should be fucking horrifying.

Considering that matter conversion of even a single kg of matter produces something in the realm of tens of megatons of explosive yield. Let alone something like 80-120 kg.

at least not unless we're alone (and with a perfect defense).

And very far away from anything that we care about.
 
Last edited:
It's is just so crazy that killing two lords of outer night was a less exciting part of this arc. This has been such a big day.
 
You are thinking of the White Council as a monolithic single entity. Each wizard we bring into our kingdom tempts other wizards in.
I get a distinct feeling that we are talking past each other, I apologize. If some of the resurrected wizards decide to remain in our courts (and, in fact, I am all for making an offer), that would be great. However, by keeping the resurrection secret from White Council we close the option for the resurrected wizards to return to their lives. Because normally resurrection is impossible without Lawbreaking.
 
I get a distinct feeling that we are talking past each other, I apologize. If some of the resurrected wizards decide to remain in our courts (and, in fact, I am all for making an offer), that would be great. However, by keeping the resurrection secret from White Council we close the option for the resurrected wizards to return to their lives. Because normally resurrection is impossible without Lawbreaking.
The option of bringing them under the wheel says nothing about keeping the resurrection secret and I have no idea why you read that into it.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top