Green Flame Rising (Exalted vs Dresden Files)

Us using some social on her to help?

Really, it's that simple.
At which point we are back to "bag of cocaine as a peace offering" analogy. The point of giving something of his to Lydia is that it serves both as a punishment to Charles (something of his is taken away and he loses access to it), and appeasement to Lydia (she is given something of value). While the first goal might be fulfilled (depending on how much he values the woman, given how the incident started, he might not value her or even wants to get rid of her), the second isn't. Because she's not an asset, she's an obligation / burden.
Great situation for Lara (punishes Charles and puts the responsibility of caring for this woman on Lydia and out of her hands) bad for Lydia (either stay in a situation you don't like or spend time and resources to ensure the situation doesn't come back to stay same as the beginning).
Yes, that's it exactly. So, do we want Lara to publicly social-judo throw us? Because that's what this is. Or do we resist and invert the situation somehow?
 
That's true. The issue is - Lara is probably smart enough to realize that Lydia doesn't want a slave, unless she very badly misread us and bungled intelligence gathering stage. So, she can expect Lydia to let the woman go almost immediately. At which point, what's stopping the woman from going right back to Charles?

A pissed off Exalt ripping off his head? At least that is Molly's guess. In all honesty she does not think Lara gives a damn about the woman, she seems to be punishing Charles for failures of deportment.
 
[X] Let the judgement go through

I think I agree with the thread gestalt here; he's an asshole but also a distraction from the main point of this gathering and this at least immdietely removes the woman from her abuser. Long term help would have to come later.
 
[X] Point out that the attempt to overawe Lydia is not addressed by the restitution proposed (Social Combat with Lara)

We're here to make a statement, and 'this random girl can punch you to death' is a much better statement.
 
[X] Let the judgement go through

Fuckers will be shitting themselves and begging for forgiveness by the end of the night. Not everyone is sufficiently in-the-know right this second... but this will change. People will realize that they are dicking around with, effectively, the Grim Reaper and Yaldabaoth.

Take our problems one at a time. The right eldritch horrors tonight, other eldritch horrors tomorrow, random dickbags later.

I trust Lara to do what is right for Lara and, right now, what is good for Lara works for us.
 
Last edited:
I hate what this guy is doing, but we shouldn't shoot ourselves and by extension the ordo in the foot here.

Not to put too fine a point on it, but it's not like this is some grand moral gesture here. Or at least it's a very hollow one considering that the same and worse is happening all around us right now:

She is pretty sure the vampire does not see the woman as a person, more as a talking lunchable, people who do not see them like that would be on the other side of the room where they aren't swapping them.
Companions, people are being measured out, paired with food and drink, tasted with hands and lips, with hungers yet more esoteric.

There's a whole side of the room we're in right now where humans are being traded like baseball cards, and we knew coming in that some of the mortals coming into this party wouldn't be leaving it again.

Long term we're pretty much all on board with forcing them to cut that shit out, but here and now making a point of the single case that caught our attention against the backdrop of all the ones we're ignoring seems kind of counterproductive and tone deaf to me.

[X] Let the judgement go through
 
Delayed answers, even if they are no longer relevant:
We did not need to tell Mab about anyone sans maybe Maeve too. We still did
Giving Lara this info now gives her an opportunity to clean house now. Sweep everyone at once. Or at least sweep pne more figure off the board.
We told Mab in a setting where we were alone, with no witnesses besides the rogue angel, and Mab's presence projects an anti-scrying effect according to Odin.
For the purposes of that meeting, Mac's bar was a SCIF. We could talk more or less freely, and even then we took precautions.


For one thing, the White King is still putatively in charge.
For another, neither Lord Raith at the height of his power nor Lara is an absolute monarch, and dealings with black magic and Outsiders are legal by the laws of the White Court. Lord Raith did it, and Lara did not have him killed for it.

This is not the White Council, where the Seven Laws are a guiding principle
The White Court is still allied to the Reds who are using Outsiders in combat.

Yes we do?
There is an outsider agent walking freely as a ally of someone who is explicitly a member of the task force against outsiders, you don't hold that kind of information in the back burner, that's how you get people killed.
In the absence of an immediate threat, she had no need to know immediately.
We could have told the next morning, in a secure location.Instead of taking the risk of leaking it in front of a bunch of Whamps of unknown loyalties . Not everyone shares our concern about Outsiders, or wont seek personal advantage.

Lara is not a member of any task force against Outsiders.
She is a member of the True Venatori, who fight the Oblivion War; its not the same thing.


The True Venatori are a secret organization organized on a cell-like basis that explicitly holds information like that on the back burner. Thats how they operate. Need to know is paramount, and Lara does not determine need to know for the organization; thats for the Archive afaik.

Thomas, as a True Venator operative, couldnt even tell his brother Harry about the job when he was trying to protect him from members of the Stygian Sisterhood in the short story Backup.
I think the word husk is strongly indicative that he's basically dead.
Husk seems to be referring to the wizard-turned-Outsider.
Not Vito.

But seriously, after we get the Kingdom charm I'm going to vote to get the Inner Darkness charm and use it on Daniel. Feeling really, really bad when I read where we were leaving for the party.
I want to help him.
Why? This is what Charity has to deal with every time Michael is Called.
If he's going to stay involved with Lydia, he has to get used to that sort of thing as a fact of life.

==
In canon, Daniel was a member of the Chicago Alliance post-Changes because the Fomor War Dresden was dead, his sister was missing, his father was invalided out of being a Knight and he was one of a very few people who knew about the Swords.
And even then he was in his early/mid-20s and an Afghanistan veteran.

And even then he got bodied by a single scrub-tier street sorcerer with a knife and a gimmick while at 2:1 odds in favor.
Put him in the hospital with stab wounds.
Once Dresden got back, and Molly started running around officially again, he shuffled back out.


None of that holds true in this scenario.

His father Michael is alive and active with Amoracchius, Dresden is alive and active, Lydia is alive and active, Molly is active and significantly more powerful than she was as the Ragged Lady in canon.
He brings no special talents and no special knowledge or faith to the table. Not enough to weaponize a kid.

And my dude Daniel right now is 16. 17 at best.

Worse, putting him in makes him a legitimate target for a bunch of people who have left him alone till date.
There's pretty good reason why we try to avoid putting the children and relatives of heads of state in combat; they become priority targets because of their value as coercion against their relatives. They put their comrades at greater risk.

And none of Molly's enemies will be scrub-tier mooks with knives.
 
Why? This is what Charity has to deal with every time Michael is Called.
If he's going to stay involved with Lydia, he has to get used to that sort of thing as a fact of life.
Charity got used to it because she had no way of becoming powerful enough to help Michael and even then when she needed to she would rush in like she did with Molly, even though the chances of death for her were very, very high.

I don't see why we shouldn't help our brother, who will eventually be targeted so much for being Michael's son, Molly's brother and Lydia's boyfriend, being impotent (ordinary human) doesn't bring much security since Harry got Lash because he intercepted the coin thrown in the direction to Michael's young son.

I'd rather have the tools and leave the decision to accept being empowered by us up to him. So I'll support Yog's plan for this (even if it's too time consuming to take full effect for my taste, but the power in the end is great so...).

@Yog I was also having the idea of using the creation charm (which looks like we'll eventually get because we have a lot of ideas that will need him *cough*Chicago God*cough*) to eventually reinforce and upgrade Kakuri's sword and give it to Daniel , along with the other enhancements tof your plan, as I like the aesthetic of the three of us (Michael, Molly and Daniel) standing next to each other with drawn swords against a great evil and that Michael's work as a true Holy Knight has given desire for magic swords for his children (and he already knows a little swordplay so it's easier to take him to higher levels). Of course this is just a suggestion.

@DragonParadox along with the action from Hundred Eyes in the Sky could we do an action to create a kind of supernatural rumor mill paying WldFae with food for tell us the news? I'm tired of being the only major supernatural power in town who is literally blind to the supernatural news. We don't know how the story of what happened to Maeve is being told, we won't know what our reputation is with the wider world, as it will seen even after killing several Wampires, including the heir to one of the Three Houses, how the hell are people taking fact the daughter of a Knight of the Cross suddenly get the aura of the Archdevil and that even with that amount of dark power continues to live normally in the his house guarded by angels without problems, etc.

(I'm curious about how others view the protagonist and they actions in quests, so I like things like negaversions, sue me)
 
@DragonParadox along with the action from Hundred Eyes in the Sky could we do an action to create a kind of supernatural rumor mill paying WldFae with food for tell us the news? I'm tired of being the only major supernatural power in town who is literally blind to the supernatural news. We don't know how the story of what happened to Maeve is being told, we won't know what our reputation is with the wider world, as it will seen even after killing several Wampires, including the heir to one of the Three Houses, how the hell are people taking fact the daughter of a Knight of the Cross suddenly get the aura of the Archdevil and that even with that amount of dark power continues to live normally in the his house guarded by angels without problems, etc.

(I'm curious about how others view the protagonist and they actions in quests, so I like things like negaversions, sue me)

Sure you could pay Wyldfae for that.
 
COMMENTARY
Of note here is that either Will or Clippy, possibly both, has sufficient field of view to see and recognize Charles Barrowill.
If they can see him, they can see everyone else here.

Which means that we can reasonably expect to have the faces of essentially every vampire and thrall here, representing a good cross-section of the upper levels of the White Court and their companions.
Thats a decent intelligence windfall.


Worth noting that unlike the Red Court, these....companions are largely here without coercion.
I dont know if I would call it uncompromised free will, because I dont know if it varies by person to person, but there's sufficient ambiguity that most people who might object hesitate to take the effort to do so.

There's a reason even someone as irascible as Dresden doesnt raise objections even when he sees them.


Charles Barrowill. Father of Connie Barrowill. Canonically based in eastern Oklahoma, where he's a big oil guy, and has a bunch of Congressmen in his pocket, and a short platoon of ghouls on his payroll.And while apparently a shit date, a.....concerned father who doesnt have the best relationship with his daughter. Not the worst, but not the best.

Most important for us is the fact that he's the father of Connie Barrowill, whose dating Irwin Pounder was a significant background event. But that is a discussion for another time.
Cold and Cutting Words
COMMENTARY
Wasnt the smartest thing to let this go ahead. IC, but still not the smartest.

I get the impression that the elders are being characterized as a separate power block in the White Court.
People like Leinth, who are generally aloof from the day to day internal political struggles of the White Court and the risks thereof, but with enough influence to matter as a bloc when they choose to exercise it.

Going to note that Barrowill has to be drunk, or otherwise intoxicated to pick this fight.
He's House Raith, and just embarassed Lara in front of her guests. Thats gonna have personal Consequences. Not to mention that he is attempting to bully a teenager, something that earns him no cred even if he succeeds, and is fractally worse if he fails.

Nevermind that the person he's picking on came here in company of the person who dealt with a greater akuma in Chicago, which he definitely has reason to have heard of by now.
In his defense, six feet is two inches above average for a US male. Molly is just being catty :V

Dread Gaze is offensive use of vampire magic and is in and of itself a breach of supernatural custom towards guests.
Not to mention casus belli for Lydia to demand satisfaction.
Dresden would be tempted to light him up for it, and been justified by the letter of the law to do so.

Lara's best (social) dice pool is 13 dice before Disciplines. Dunno if she's doing the equivalent of burning a blood point for it, but its better than Lydia's Excellency-boosted dice pool, even if not by much.
Worth keeping in mind.

@DragonParadox
Pointing out that you forgot to apply this:
Lydia Merit said:
Natural Linguist (2 pt. Merit) You're especially good at understanding how people communicate. Every purchase of the Language Merit (see above, and Mage 20, Appendix II) secures two languages for you, not just one. You also get three bonus dice when making rolls based upon clear communications, typically ones employing Art, Expression, Etiquette, Leadership, and other Traits that involve "speaking their language" to impress someone else.
She should have had +3 to her social dicepools for most of this scene.
On a different point, in hindsight this plan really looks kinda stupid, doesn't it?
The talent-killers are deliberatly provoking the White Council with their actions while being a relativly weak sub-faction of the White Court.

Sure, they propably can't spare a heavy hitter to deal with you during the Red Court war, but what if they can?
What if the White Council decides that the serial-murder of Talents is threatening their substance and future and they should make an example even at the cost of taking a loss against the Reds somewhere else?

Then someone like McCoy or Joseph would kill a dozen Whamps and the conspiators lost hard.
Thats because its goal wasnt to be smart, it was to destroy the White Court.
The immediate plan of the conspirators was to do something flashy to get enough political support inside the White Court to overthrow Lara, then put their own monarch in place.

The ultimate goal of their external backers was to use them to help destroy the White Council, and that they suffer enough damage in the doing to be destroyed in turn, leaving the field open for new players.
Its not like the White Council needs heavy hitters to return the favor of going after the White Court's rank and file, and their children.
Either way it is another chink in the barriers that defend creation. Remember the White Court is part of the Oblivion War.
The White Court is NOT part of the Oblivion War. Two of their vampires are.
Lara and Thomas Raith are True Venatori, but thats all.
As far as we know, they are the only ones.

Given that she has a Dex Excellency a decent Brawl skill and Ox Body to tank hits that seems likely, though to be fair Molly does not know what Charles' skills are.
Charles canonically got beat up by a Bigfoot scion with no combat training.
Yes, he'd just spent most of his mojo on whammying an entire college dorm full of students into an orgy, but his attacker had just been comprehensively fed upon by a Whampire who was being mindcontrolled to kill him, and still managed to put him down.

Lydia would murder him before he even got into range.

The biggest question is - does Lydia needs a slave (because let's be honest, that's what Lara is offering, and that's what the woman is), and would the woman go right back to this guy if Lydia cut her loose? If the answer to the first question is no, and to the second yes, then this is essentially creating nothing but trouble for Lydia
Its a test and a lesson, combined in one.

The Raith families, generally prey on willing victims; its not that coercion doesnt exist, because it does, as Lord Raith demonstrates. But 99% of the time, fascination and sex appeal (and frankly, money) will bring lots of people into their orbit, and the sex is supposed to be mind-blowing into the bargain, ensuring repeat business.

See Thomas never lacking for sex partners, and getting messages from one night stands looking for repeats.

Add to the fact that Charles is canonically a very big oil baron in Oklahoma, with truckloads of money and plenty of politicians in his pocket. Including multiple Congressmen.
Someone like that will never lack for people willing to endure abuse for economic security.

So you have to figure if you're saving someone who actually wants to be saved.And if you're willing to invest the effort to do so, rather than just acting on impulse. Which both tells Lara Raith important things about your character, and is an oblique way of reminding Lydia that shits complicated.


Charles will probably have a....frank Discussion with Lara after whatever he imbibed clears out of his system.
Because lets be clear, he nearly died here.
 
@uju32 Dread Gaze is kind of marginal as offensive powers go, all it does it frighten the victim, it does not provide ongoing control, it does not make them more susceptible to ongoing control except maybe in the way intimidation does. Not saying Charles is not in deep shit with Lara, but it is not as much as someone who used say Dominate or Dementation.
 
@Yog I was also having the idea of using the creation charm (which looks like we'll eventually get because we have a lot of ideas that will need him *cough*Chicago God*cough*) to eventually reinforce and upgrade Kakuri's sword and give it to Daniel , along with the other enhancements tof your plan, as I like the aesthetic of the three of us (Michael, Molly and Daniel) standing next to each other with drawn swords against a great evil and that Michael's work as a true Holy Knight has given desire for magic swords for his children (and he already knows a little swordplay so it's easier to take him to higher levels). Of course this is just a suggestion.
If he goes for swordsmanship, I think we might be better served by making one from scratch, and specifically for him.
Why? This is what Charity has to deal with every time Michael is Called.
If he's going to stay involved with Lydia, he has to get used to that sort of thing as a fact of life.
For one, Charity is a mess. She has a lot of issues, and at least some of them get projected into her behavior towards her children (ie her being overly controlling). If she somehow miraculously recovered her gift, she could most likely stand with MIchael. In fact, as indicated by her participating in the raid on Arctis Tor, she can be a combatant. Doesn't want to / is satisfied not to be.

Daniel wants to actively participate. We can make it happen. I see no reason not to. "He'll just have to accept his lot as mortal" is not something I want to see.
 
Charity got used to it because she had no way of becoming powerful enough to help Michael and even then when she needed to she would rush in like she did with Molly, even though the chances of death for her were very, very high.
No, thats not true.

Charity was born with magic. Thats why she almost ended up as a sacrifice to a corrupted dragon.
If this shit was her priority, she would have cultivated it, instead of suppressing it to die. Even now, she's Michael's primary training partner, makes his armor, and can wield warhammer and sword, and has low level faith magic.

Yet she stays home. Watches the kids.
I don't see why we shouldn't help our brother, who will eventually be targeted so much for being Michael's son, Molly's brother and Lydia's boyfriend, being impotent (ordinary human) doesn't bring much security since Harry got Lash because he intercepted the coin thrown in the direction to Michael's young son.
The foes that Molly and Lydia are looking to deal with are not the sort of foes you go up against with a bakemono package.
He's gonna run out and get splattered by a Denarian in warform.

And like I said, he's too high profile to make a good foot soldier.
People who want to get at Molly, or at Lydia, or at Michael, will go after him, and once he becomes a combatant he forgoes the protection that being a member of the Carpenter family has largely bestowed on the rest of the family due to his father's service.

If he wants to make himself useful, play support.
Bulk up on his Occult, throw points into Medicine, that sort of thing. Any fighting should be strictly a last resort, and preferably from inside a fortified building. The traditionally female role is kind of a twist, but its logical.
@DragonParadox along with the action from Hundred Eyes in the Sky could we do an action to create a kind of supernatural rumor mill paying WldFae with food for tell us the news?
Thats just Background: Spy (Wyldfae).
Its one of the two Spy Backgrounds I have been considering for Lydia, after Background: Spy(Ghosts)
Molly already has Background Cyberdevils.
Daniel wants to actively participate. We can make it happen. I see no reason not to. "He'll just have to accept his lot as mortal" is not something I want to see.
Shouldnt matter what he wants, its what is warranted by the needs of situation.
His participation in the field increases the risks for everyone else on his side because his political value warrants an outsize response, and it distracts his family.

Where it might not be worth the effort to grab some rando footsoldier, it very much is worth it to grab the brother of an Infernal Exalt as leverage. Aint nothing you are giving him that will prevent, say, Deirdre Archleone murdering his companions, picking him up by an ankle and absconding, leaving a ransom note behind.

Prince Harry got pulled out of Afghanistan once it was leaked that he was there for much the same reason.
 
Last edited:
@uju32 Dread Gaze is kind of marginal as offensive powers go, all it does it frighten the victim, it does not provide ongoing control, it does not make them more susceptible to ongoing control except maybe in the way intimidation does. Not saying Charles is not in deep shit with Lara, but it is not as much as someone who used say Dominate or Dementation.
Fair enough.
I recall it being used to stunlock people, so it definitely counts as offensive to me, but it does depend on whether the victim chooses to press the matter. And Molly isnt really looking to escalate anyway.
 
So how do you even start treating trauma like what happened to this woman? There's some overlap with stuff like the ants, but I don't think the overall needs of those guys and someone held as chattel are the same.

Even if we had in the know therapists this might be more than they can handle. Maybe there are specialists in managing the fallout of human trafficking we could clue in ourselves?

these....companions are largely here without coercion.
I dont know if I would call it uncompromised free will, because I dont know if it varies by person to person, but there's sufficient ambiguity that most people who might object hesitate to take the effort to do so.
Raith ones maybe, though I'd argue the supernatural power involved makes them compromised enough that it really isn't ambiguous at all.

The Malvora and Skavis thralls are decidedly less likely to want their attention.
 
Raith ones maybe, though I'd argue the supernatural power involved makes them compromised enough that it really isn't ambiguous at all.

The Malvora and Skavis thralls are decidedly less likely to want their attention.
The Malvora shouldnt have that much more trouble actually. Adrenaline junkies, people with an erotic asphyxiation fetish, rough intercourse enthusiasts, people who live for that edge of uncertainty in their relationships, of fear..... are not as common as people attracted to vanilla lust, but they arent that thin on the ground.

Its the Skavis who would have trouble. Because despair is not precisely something you cultivate in a willing partner.
 
Malvora are also the ones with the easiest time to get a quick snack.

A Vampire with some measure of Presence can very easily scare some people, even in ways that makes it nearly impossible to pin him down for doing it.

They don't really need to cultivate partners the way Raiths do.
 
The Malvora shouldnt have that much more trouble actually. Adrenaline junkies, people with an erotic asphyxiation fetish, rough intercourse enthusiasts, people who live for that edge of uncertainty in their relationships, of fear..... are not as common as people attracted to vanilla lust, but they arent that thin on the ground.

Its the Skavis who would have trouble. Because despair is not precisely something you cultivate in a willing partner.
Malvora are also the ones with the easiest time to get a quick snack.

A Vampire with some measure of Presence can very easily scare some people, even in ways that makes it nearly impossible to pin him down for doing it.

They don't really need to cultivate partners the way Raiths do.
Pretty sure we see this play out in the books when Harry shows up for this sort of event, and the whamps have what are basically torture dolls composed of people kept barely coherent enough to register their surroundings until needed.
 
Malvora are also the ones with the easiest time to get a quick snack.
A Vampire with some measure of Presence can very easily scare some people, even in ways that makes it nearly impossible to pin him down for doing it.

They don't really need to cultivate partners the way Raiths do.
Having an attractive piece of human eye candy on your arm is more about prestige and showing off than it is about a snack.
Not that some dont indulge.
But you dont go to a high end party hungry. At least most dont.

Pretty sure we see this play out in the books when Harry shows up for this sort of event, and the whamps have what are basically torture dolls composed of people kept barely coherent enough to register their surroundings until needed.
Not quite.
White Night chapter 36
I snickered and slid out of the car to follow Lara—and the three more bodyguards waiting for her—into the woods beside the gravel lane.
The last time I'd found the entrance to the Deeps, I'd been stumbling through the woods, focused on a tracking spell and tripping over roots and hummocks in the old-growth forest.
This time, there was a lighted path, with a red carpet, no less, leading down between the trees. The lights were all of soft blues and greens, small lamps that, upon a closer glance, proved to be elegant little crystal cages containing tiny, humanoid forms with wings. Faeries, tiny pixies, each surrounded by its own sphere of light, trapped and miserable, crouched in the cages.
Between each cage knelt more prisoners—humans, bound by nothing more than a single strand of white silk about their throats tied to a peg driven into the earth in front of them. They weren't naked. Lara wouldn't have gone in for anything that overt. Instead, they each wore a white silk kimono, accented with strands of silver thread.
Men and women, arrayed in a variety of ages, body types, hair colors, every single one of them beautiful, their eyes lowered as they knelt quietly. One of the young men sat shivering and was seemingly barely able to stay upright. His long, dark hair was marred with streaks of brittle white. His eyes were unfocused and he seemed totally unaware of anyone around him. His kimono was torn near the neck, leaving a broad swath of muscled chest exposed. There were raking nail marks, deep enough to draw tiny trickles of blood, all the way across one pectoral. There were repeated teeth marks deep in the slope of muscle between neck and shoulder, half a dozen sets of messy bruises and ugly little gashes. There were more nail marks, four side-by-side punctures, rather than rakes, on the other side of his neck.
He was also obviously, even painfully, aroused beneath the kimono.

Lara paused beside him and rolled her eyes in irritation. "Madeline?"
"Yes, ma'am," said one of the bodyguards.
"Oh, for hunger's sake." She sighed. "Get him indoors before the conclave is over or she'll finish him off on her way out."
"Yes, ma'am," he said, turned aside, and began speaking to nobody. I spotted a wire running to an earpiece.
I kept walking down the long line of kneeling captives and trapped pixies, and got angrier with every step.
"They're willing, Dresden," Lara said a few paces later. "All of them."

"I'm sure they are," I said. "Now."
She laughed. "There is no shortage of mortals who long to kneel before another, wizard. There never has been."
We passed several more kneeling men and women who looked mussed and dazed, though none so badly as the first. We also walked past spaces where there was a peg and a strip of white cloth—but no person kneeling within.
"I'm sure they all knew that they might die by doing it," I said.
She shrugged one shoulder. "It happens at these meetings.
Guests have no need to dispose of a body, since as hosts we are responsible for such necessities. As a result, many of our visitors make no effort to control themselves."
Torture dolls? No. Barely coherent? Apparently not.
 
Back
Top