Green Flame Rising (Exalted vs Dresden Files)

It will be. You are proposing negotiating from a position of desperation and absolute weakness with both Eiko and Gard. And if Gard might, by word of Jim, be considered benevolent, if not nice, Eiko isn't. She's evil, whether it's for her own sake or for Emma-O's. We don't have tools to ensure her loyalty, and that's assuming she is a traitor. Because that's far from a given.
First off, we are not negotiating from weakness with Gard.

If she is willing to help for an okayish price, we pay her.
If not, we don't strictly need her.

For Eiko the situation is worse, but if there are any truly unacceptable demands we can still kill her and at least know that we have weakened Kakuri's forces by depriving them of half of their local Elders.
 
I do not think 9+Str Agg weapons for minions would be in the least balanced given that Molly has a 2+Str Agg weapon that cost her no small number of Character Creation choices. When you can arm your mooks better than most Solarioids that might be a bit of an issue balance-wise. :V

It's not balanced, it's not meant to be, elder vampires can be incredibly powerful in their own way. This is one of them. One of the themes of VtM and KoE is unfairness, that the elders are just better at stuff than you and you can't do much about it.

Yin Prana is a powerful discipline, but it's not unbalanced compared to what exalts can do.
 
[X] Head right to the steel mill, maybe you can beat them there

Alratan you really need to stop arguing with the QM when you have been previously told your wrong.
 
Last edited:
It's not balanced, it's not meant to be, elder vampires can be incredibly powerful in their own way. This is one of them. One of the themes of VtM and KoE is unfairness, that the elders are just better at stuff than you and you can't do much about it.

Yin Prana is a powerful discipline, but it's not unbalanced compared to what exalts can do.

Yeah, but this particular form of unfairness is transitive, is the issue I have. The vampire himself doing unfair amounts of damage is fine, his nearest allies doing so is debatable, but the ten thousand strong mook army armed with 9+STR Agg weapons is a bit too far out there for me.
 
Last edited:
First off, we are not negotiating from weakness with Gard.

If she is willing to help for an okayish price, we pay her.
If not, we don't strictly need her.

For Eiko the situation is worse, but if there are any truly unacceptable demands we can still kill her and at least know that we have weakened Kakuri's forces by depriving them of half of their local Elders.
No we would just be tipping our hand that there are traitors in their midst. We don't know that Eiko is a traitor. That's wishful thinking and rationalization.

Going to Eiko is a waste. Backing us right now would be stupid of her IF she is a traitor.
 
It's not balanced, it's not meant to be, elder vampires can be incredibly powerful in their own way. This is one of them. One of the themes of VtM and KoE is unfairness, that the elders are just better at stuff than you and you can't do much about it.

Yin Prana is a powerful discipline, but it's not unbalanced compared to what exalts can do.
That isn't even an Elder Vampire trick.

Eightfold Yin Mantle is a level 4 power.
If a level 8/9 power were this gamebreaking it would be one thing, but a level 4?
 
My point was, and you damn well know it, that you are either severely underestimating kakuri faction, or overhyping naagloshii to high heavens.
1)No, I do not know it. If that was your intent, it didnt come through.

2)No exaggerations here.

Its canon for Dresden Files that naagloshii are semi-divine messengers in origin, and there's half a dozen in the minimum security wing of Demonreach. Its canon for Kindred of the East that Yama Kings are vastly weaker outside their Hells than inside them, that the Wan Xian were designed to break Yama King plots, and that parties of Wan Kuei have killed Yama Kings.

Its canon for Kindred that at least one Yama King was mortal. Wasnt even a Wan Kuei, just a geomancer.
Its also canon for this Quest that naagloshii are Incarna, same as Yama Kings, but their power does not come from their domain.
The math seems pretty straightforward.

There's working similarities between them, but naagloshii seem way more unrestricted.
Higher minimum power, and all of their power is personal, not from their minions
It will be. You are proposing negotiating from a position of desperation and absolute weakness with both Eiko and Gard. And if Gard might, by word of Jim, be considered benevolent, if not nice, Eiko isn't. She's evil, whether it's for her own sake or for Emma-O's. We don't have tools to ensure her loyalty, and that's assuming she is a traitor. Because that's far from a given.

In fact, dealing with us right now would be very, very stupid of her. Deal with Greater Akuma first, then talk to her. If she's a traitor, shestay out of the confrontation. If she's not, she backstab us. There's no benefit in going to her now, and plenty of downsides.
See what Artemis said. We can walk away.

We arent desperate. If we were desperate, we would still have no choice but to seek help whatever the cost because the alternatives are worse. Advice is to try to avoid negotiating from a position of weakness, it does not say that you should reject a disadvantageous deal if the potential consequences are worse.

I will remind you that we were in a vastly worse negotiating position when we asked for Gard's help with Kattrin. We only had our Dad for backup, and Dresden was in jail. She could have named her price.
The fact that she had a grudge against Kattrin didnt change that.

===
As for Eiko, yes? She has undoubtedly done lots of evil things, regardless of how Emma-O lured her into service.
Can she be redeemed? Other shikome canonically were, apparently. If we can do so for her, great.
At the very least she can be turned against her employer with judicious amounts of social fu.

And I will remind you that you are on record here as talking about attempting to social-fu Lasciel as a goal.
Not Lash, but her progenitor. To redeem a Fallen Angel.
Nothing Eiko's done will be on the scale of what Lasciel has pulled in just her two thousand years in a Coin.

Our father's job is literally to offer forgiveness to people like Nicky.

And here's the thing:
If she tries to deceive us, she has very little chance of success against ATB and an Empathy Excellency.
We have the option of killing or otherwise disabling her.


Regardless, she has to be dealt with.
Because you dont get stuck into a fight and leave enemy reserves to come in behind you and your allies.
Especially not a stealth assassin build.
No we would just be tipping our hand that there are traitors in their midst. We don't know that Eiko is a traitor. That's wishful thinking and rationalization.
Going to Eiko is a waste. Backing us right now would be stupid of her IF she is a traitor.
1) Im not sure why you care after declaring them all evil.

Even if your every assertion is accurate ie Eiko isnt a potential traitor, and we cant convince her to turn, and we cant kill her?
Either she doesnt believe us about there being traitors, and it doesnt matter, or she believes us and start a witch hunt among their own forces in hostile territory, degrading their own ability.


2)Backstabbing is a way of life in much of Yomi Wan. Emma-O in particular cultivates it
There are no ideological loyalties here. No greater ideal to be followed or cultivated, just personal loyalties.
Noone is going to be surprised at the idea of someone looking out for themselves.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, but this particular form of unfairness is transitive, is the issue I have. The vampire himself doing unfair amounts of damage is fine, his nearest allies doing so is dependable, but the ten thousand strong mook army armed with 9+STR Agg weapons is a bit too far out there for me.

Elder vampires can also use Astrology to give their minions a temporary synthetic destiny equal to being a prophesied hero, bone shaping to set their Attributes to 5/the peak of mortal ability, and bind devils into them to give them supernatural abilities as a bakemono.

They're not as good at empowering minions as a solar is, but they're roughly as good at it as an internal.

This is partially, I think, because they have some sects of Resplendent Cranes and Thrashing Dragons who are dharmically obliged to act via minions. It's also traditional for all Wan Kuei to use their 'Scarlet Screens' to operate on their behalf in the mortal world. Regular White Wolf vampires could make supernaturally empowered ghouls, Wan Kuei can't, but instead could empower mortal minions in other ways.

It's also because of the fact that Wan Kuei find it very hard to stay up during the day. That means they usually need powerful minions to guard them from other supernaturals while they sleep.

That isn't even an Elder Vampire trick.

Eightfold Yin Mantle is a level 4 power.
If a level 8/9 power were this gamebreaking it would be one thing, but a level 4?

It's only that good because an elder vampire can spend more chi on it. Regular vampires can only spend one point of chi a turn, and just make weapons that do aggravated damage inflicting one die more than normal.

It's also incredibly expensive in terms of chi. Younger vampires can't afford to spend that much without screwing themselves.
 
Last edited:
Elder vampires can also use Astrology to give their minions a temporary synthetic destiny equal to being a prophesied hero, bone shaping to set their Attributes to 5/the peak of mortal ability, and bind devils into them to give them supernatural abilities as a bakemono.

They're not as good at empowering minions as a solar is, but they're roughly as good at it as an internal.

This is partially, I think, because they have some sects of Resplendent Cranes and Thrashing Dragons who are dharmically obliged to act via minions. It's also traditional for all Wan Kuei to use their 'Scarlet Screens' to operate on their behalf in the mortal world. Regular White Wolf vampires could make supernaturally empowered ghouls, Wan Kuei can't, but instead could empower mortal minions in other ways.

It's also because of the fact that Wan Kuei find it very hard to stay up during the day. That means they usually need powerful minions to guard them from other supernaturals while they sleep.



It's only that good because an elder vampire can spend more chi on it. Regular vampires can only spend one point of chi a turn, and a just make weapons that do aggravated damage inflicting one die more than normal.

I do not disagree with anything you say, but that amount of infinitely scaling (since they have all the time in the world and in the Hells all the chi in the world) would I think break the setting. Your average fomori can probably beat up a ghoul and particularly powerful examples could take on a Tzmice horror no problem so I do not think they need enchanted objects that strong, some scalable permanent magic, sure. Bette- than-an-infernal at dealing aggravated damage... I think that is too much for the mooks.
 
Even if we assume that Yin-Crafted objects are permanent, I think you are reading this wrong:

Creating mundane tools costs a point of Yin, while creation of Melee or thrown weapons costs one Yin for a weapon inflicting Str aggravated damage, +1 Yin per additional point of damage the weapon deals.
My interpretation would be that it costs 3 Yin to create a Sword, because a Sword deals Str+2 damage. And an Axe costs 4 points, since it deals Str+3 Damage. And that's already the upper limit for weapons in VtM.

And not that you can infinitly scale this to deal as much damage as you are willing to spend in Chi.
 
I do not disagree with anything you say, but that amount of infinitely scaling (since they have all the time in the world and in the Hells all the chi in the world) would I think break the setting. Your average fomori can probably beat up a ghoul and particularly powerful examples could take on a Tzmice horror no problem so I do not think they need enchanted objects that strong, some scalable permanent magic, sure. Bette- than-an-infernal at dealing aggravated damage... I think that is too much for the mooks.
Also? The fact that the Yama Kings had to resort to attempting to corrupt the Wan Xian instead of just empowering other mortal servants? The fact that they are still attempting to recruit the relatively rare Wan Kuei instead of just having a couple akuma or Kura Sau recruit lots of mortals?

Straight up says its not a viable strategy in the meta.
 
I do not disagree with anything you say, but that amount of infinitely scaling (since they have all the time in the world and in the Hells all the chi in the world) would I think break the setting. Your average fomori can probably beat up a ghoul and particularly powerful examples could take on a Tzmice horror no problem so I do not think they need enchanted objects that strong, some scalable permanent magic, sure. Bette- than-an-infernal at dealing aggravated damage... I think that is too much for the mooks.

You can give a mook a thermobaric rocket propelled grenade launcher and they'd do more damage than they would with a Yin sword.

All the Yin sword does is slightly rebalance the playing field between the traditional and tech-Hells. Emma-O's servants would use incredibly lethal Yin-naginatas, katanas, and arrows. Mikaboshi's would use devil-possessed RPGs and automatic combat shotguns with smart-ammo.

Both do large amounts of aggravated damage.

Also? The fact that the Yama Kings had to resort to attempting to corrupt the Wan Xian instead of just empowering other mortal servants? The fact that they are still attempting to recruit the relatively rare Wan Kuei instead of just having a couple akuma or Kura Sau recruit lots of mortals?

Straight up says its not a viable strategy in the meta.

They do both, but Wan Kuei are a lot more powerful than mortals individually.

It doesn't mean that Ravana isn't doing his best to recruit mortals to trigger nuclear war between India, Pakistan, and China.

Seriously, while Yin weapons are nice, they're small scale compared to things like man-portable anti-tank weapons, let along even conventional air launched weapons or missiles. A regular human in charge of a Reaper drone with Hellfire missiles can do more damage than a regular human with Eightfold Yin Prana gear, and a Wan Kuei can use four dots of the Obligation discipline to control them.

Note that the Yama Kings need Wan Kuei servants for both arming mortals with Yon weapons or mind controlling them to get access to military weapons.
 
Last edited:
You can give a mook a thermobaric rocket propelled grenade launcher and they'd do more damage than they would with a Yin sword.

All the Yin sword does is slightly rebalance the playing field between the traditional and tech-Hells. Emma-O's servants would use incredibly lethal Yin-naginatas, katanas, and arrows. Mikaboshi's would use devil-possessed RPGs and automatic combat shotguns with smart-ammo.

Both do large amounts of aggravated damage.

A thermometric missile is:
  1. Expensive to make, we are not talking about an RPG7 here.
  2. Complicated to use , see above
  3. Noticeable to everyone magical and mundane
Also universal Agg is not something you can achieve by mundane means, it does not matter if you dip something, in acid, douse them in liquid nitrogen or blow them up with a nuclear weapon, there is going to be something supernatural that drinks acid martinis, finds liquid nitrogen refreshing or gets a nice tan from nukes. Agg against everyone is a special kind of omnicidal power.
 
I do not disagree with anything you say, but that amount of infinitely scaling (since they have all the time in the world and in the Hells all the chi in the world) would I think break the setting. Your average fomori can probably beat up a ghoul and particularly powerful examples could take on a Tzmice horror no problem so I do not think they need enchanted objects that strong, some scalable permanent magic, sure. Bette- than-an-infernal at dealing aggravated damage... I think that is too much for the mooks.
It's also worth noting that this isn't a straight WoD game anyway. Tweaks to the powers to fit the setting make sense even ignoring the other issues with it.

Basically nobody in the DF can do this sort of thing. Unless the idea is to make the Jade court the hidden gods of reality some of this stuff needs pruned.
 
there is going to be something supernatural that drinks acid martinis, finds liquid nitrogen refreshing or gets a nice tan from nukes
Off hand I would say, Lernaen Hydra, Mab and a Light Elemental (and possibly Ravana).

With regard to other sorts of aggravated damage:
Fire/Heat - Summer Fae
EM Radiation - Light Elemental again
Particle Radiation - Solar/Space related spirits
Poison - potentially almost anything spawned from concentrated impurity

There does seem to be a pretty obvious exception to every type of normal aggravated damage.

EDIT: Further even in WoD universal aggravated items are generally wonders that cost quintessence per use, Path of Echantment 5 creations or high end fetishes. While you can make them in significant numbers (the Technocracy certainly does) they do require some significant effort.
 
Last edited:
I am sorry. But I don't think you understand how potent Yama Kings can be: even outside their domain.
Yama Kings, but their power does not come from their domain.
The math seems pretty straightforward.
(...)
There's working similarities between them, but naagloshii seem way more unrestricted.
Higher minimum power, and all of their power is personal, not from their minions
Restricted yes, but that does not mean they are by necessity less personally formidable than their competitors. I even have citations on how powerful Yama Kings can be whilst wandering the mortal world:
Kindred of The East The Ten Thousand Hells page 49 said:
In the material world, the power of the Yama Kings ebbs to a fraction of what it was in Yomi. While that's still enough to annihilate all but the greatest ancestors and certain other powerful shen, this weakening makes the Yama King feel intolerably vulnerable.
According to the bolded: they feel small and weak, but that is still enough to murder anybody who is not an Arhat/Sixth Rank Changing breed/Archmage.

Fudge it; I will even give you an example of just how mighty a prospective Yama King could be without her Hell-Realm:
Kindred of The East The Ten Thousand Hells page 39&40 said:
Others tell the story that Rangda wanted this domain and the enormous Yama King who claimed the realm made himself the size of a small continent so that he could pulverize the young Queen. By afflicting the brute with every conceivable disease all at once, Rangda destroyed the Yama King and carved out a niche for herself in the Thousand Hells.
Keep in mind: this feat of killing a continent size Devil Tyrant was in Rangda younger years before getting empowered by the Hell of Burrowing Maggots, and the advent of the late fifth age. How strong do you think she is now, after so many years? After gorging on the Corrupt Chi of ten to the power of ten thousand mortals?

Just as a bench mark: here is what a fully mature Yama King can do inside their estate:
Kindred of The East The Ten Thousand Hells page 48 said:
The demonic lords of the Yomi realm wield unfathomable power. When they are in their own domain, the Yama Kings rage makes volcanoes erupt or oceans freeze; reality itself shifts to appease them.
And Rangda as a youth could still destroy this - no wimp gets to play pretender at the throne of God.
 
Last edited:
And then we have our method of universal Agg damage, which is either using our Exalted backdoor channels into reality to rewrite our enemies dead, or just what happens when you point a superweapon designed to kill multiple Primordials with wildly different themes at anything that isn't a reality-bending titan of cosmic power. Or maybe some combination of the two.
 
A thermometric missile is:
  1. Expensive to make, we are not talking about an RPG7 here.
  2. Complicated to use , see above
  3. Noticeable to everyone magical and mundane
Also universal Agg is not something you can achieve by mundane means, it does not matter if you dip something, in acid, douse them in liquid nitrogen or blow them up with a nuclear weapon, there is going to be something supernatural that drinks acid martinis, finds liquid nitrogen refreshing or gets a nice tan from nukes. Agg against everyone is a special kind of omnicidal power.

A thermobaric RPG-7 round, the TP-7V costs around $250. We literally are talking RPG-7s. Currently Wagner is sending squads of untrained conscripted prisoners on suicide runs into Bakhumut each carrying multiple of them to soften up Ukrainian defences. They're not complicated to use.

Now, they are incredibly obvious, but then it comes down to how much the user cares about that. Particularly when they're operating on someone else's territory so any mess they make is their problem.

Now, you may want to change this, but Fetish (possessed) weapons tend to do universal aggravated damage, and it's relatively easy for Wan Kuei to make non-permanent ones.

EDIT: Further even in WoD universal aggravated items are generally wonders that cost quintessence per use, Path of Echantment 5 creations or high end fetishes. While you can make them in significant numbers (the Technocracy certainly does) they do require some significant effort.

Pentex does as well, and they're similar in capabilities to a Hell.

Having permanent Yin-constructs in Hell, where the will of the Yama Kings defines reality is one thing, having them in our world another.

It's mainly a power for regular Wan Kuei. While a greater akuma can use it as well, they can also get devil possessed items as well.

And then we have our method of universal Agg damage, which is either using our Exalted backdoor channels into reality to rewrite our enemies dead, or just what happens when you point a superweapon designed to kill multiple Primordials with wildly different themes at anything that isn't a reality-bending titan of cosmic power. Or maybe some combination of the two.

Note that the Wan Kuei can also get their own demon Shintai with a demon weapon that does universal aggravated damage exactly like Molly can, and they can use their Demon Shintai a lot more freely than she can.
 
Last edited:
A thermobaric RPG-7 round, the TP-7V costs around $250. We literally are talking RPG-7s. Currently Wagner is sending squads of untrained conscripted prisoners on suicide runs into Bakhumut each carrying multiple of them to soften up Ukrainian defences. They're not complicated to use.

Now, they are incredibly obvious, but then it comes down to how much the user cares about that. Particularly when they're operating on someone else's territory so any mess they make is their problem.

Now, you may want to change this, but Fetish (possessed) weapons tend to do universal aggravated damage, and it's relatively easy for Wan Kuei to make non-permanent ones.



Pentex does as well, and they're similar in capabilities to a Hell.



It's mainly a power for regular Wan Kuei. While a greater akuma can use it as well, they can also get devil possessed items as well.



Note that the Wan Kuei can also get their own demon Shintai with a demon weapon that does universal aggravated damage exactly like Molly can, and they can use their Demon Shintai a lot more freely than she can.

Universal aggravated damage does not work well with Dresden-verse where a lot of high grade supernaturals have what the RPG calls 'the catch', inherited silver for a loup garou, the noose for Nicodemous etc... If that is made common for mortal mooks those beings get a lot less scary then they should be according to canon
 
Universal aggravated damage does not work well with Dresden-verse where a lot of high grade supernaturals have what the RPG calls 'the catch', inherited silver for a loup garou, the noose for Nicodemous etc... If that is made common for mortal mooks those beings get a lot less scary then they should be according to canon

Fair enough. Although, that mainly applies to arming mortals. Wan Kuei are relatively high tier supernaturals. One of the notable things about them compared to regular White Wolf vampires is that they have particularly easy access to ways of doing aggravated damage. Whether that's from their demon Shintai's demon weapon like Molly or the multiple different other disciplines that give it, it's something they're particularly good at.

As a side note; I'd interpret the loop garou's ability to heal from any blow save those made with inherited silver and Nic's noose as perfect defences with flaws rather than something that aggravated damage is meaningful to.
 
Last edited:
Fair enough. Although, that mainly applies to arming mortals. Wan Kuei are relatively high tier supernaturals. One of the notable things about them compared to regular White Wolf vampires is that they have particularly easy access to ways of doing aggravated damage. Whether that's from their demon Shintai's demon weapon like Molly or the multiple different other disciplines that give it, it's something they're particularly good at.

As a side note; I'd interpret the loop garou's ability to heal from any blow save those made with inherited silver and Nic's noose as perfect defences with flaws rather than something that aggravated damage is meaningful to.

True. I am not saying they cannot have agg, altough it may struggle with things like the Noose and other top of setting defenses, not so much because it will not work as because it would be healed through.
 
Fair enough. Although, that mainly applies to arming mortals. Wan Kuei are relatively high tier supernaturals. One of the notable things about them compared to regular White Wolf vampires is that they have particularly easy access to ways of doing aggravated damage. Whether that's from their demon Shintai's demon weapon like Molly or the multiple different other disciplines that give it, it's something they're particularly good at.

As a side note; I'd interpret the loop garou's ability to heal from any blow save those made with inherited silver and Nic's noose as perfect defences with flaws rather than something that aggravated damage is meaningful to.
Regular Vamps can also easily deal aggravated damage.
Claws, made with Protean 2, deal aggravated damage.

True. I am not saying they cannot have agg, altough it may struggle with things like the Noose and other top of setting defenses, not so much because it will not work as because it would be healed through.
Agg is not that big a deal in WoD.
Almost all supernatural creatures deal it with claws and teeths, if they have some.
Werewolves for example.
 
Actually; thinking about it, the way I'd control the distribution of Yin weapons wouldn't be to nerf the discipline but to say that they make great arcane links, so Wan Kuei are hesitant to hand them out to mooks because of the risk they'll be hit with sympathetic magic.

Regular Vamps can also easily deal aggravated damage.
Claws, made with Protean 2, deal aggravated damage.

That's true, but claws also aren't great weapons.
 
Back
Top