- Location
- Pittsburgh, PA
Oh dearie me.
First, replacing the 2e one-dimensional biomechanical monster antagonists with Xenomorphs is not an improvement.
Second, that music video (while really good, and pretty much mandatory if you want to listen to the song) isn't a terribly effective encapsulation of any Primordial. If I had to pick one, I'd actually go with Metagaos over anything - it's a picture of mindless self-indulgence, overconsuming and devouring and absorbing everything without regard for anything but your mad hunger, shamelessly reveling in your own venal nature of what you're doing all the while. There's a sort of dark Shashalme-ism to some of it as well - "admire me, admire what I have made, admire what I have taken for myself."
If you want pitiless evolution, then you go to Ramethus. He's the Primordial that proclaimed that to exist is to be in conflict, that the weak either become strong or become food for the strong, and was so dedicated to his vision of eternal Darwinian apotheosis that when the Exalted Host came to tear the titans from their thrones, he happily took arms against them and died laughing, for by destroying Theion's rule and casting Creation into chaos by force of arms, his killers had only proved him right.
@Dif put this better in one of his earlier Autochthon posts, but the theme of the Great Maker is better described as "technological progress". His imperfection is partially a product of that, because technology is made by failing again and again and learning each time, or even just bludgeoning away at a problem until a solution presents itself through serendipity. He lived and died a billion times just to be born at all, as his Mythos struggled to create itself, failed, and then tried again. Now, the actual process of natural selection definitely has strong parallels with that, but the term evolution as it exists in our lexicon really doesn't. It's the whole "not saying wizards" thing.
Still, the idea of the Void manifesting as both grinding obsolescence and the dangerous road to progress is definitely a good one.
The counterargument for "the Octet is right" is that in terms of actually securing mankind's future in Autochthonia, then no, they're horrifically, dangerously wrong. The old way, the safe path of steady gains and logic-driven decision making, no longer leads to anything but an open grave in the long term unless something further is done. Autochthonia is dying and no amount of well-designed, well-assembled mundane thaumaturgy or Patterning can stop it. Now, one way to fix things would be to find some means of awakening the Great Maker and having him deal with the problem - but 99.9999% of Autochthonians do not consider that a viable option (quite rightly), so once you become aware of the truth of things, you either give up and await death or start feverishly looking for a third option.
Voidtech is pretty much the only hope of survival when "kosher" means prove insufficient or infeasible; not everywhere is as well-stocked as the Octet (and yes, the major Autochthonian cities being considered "well-stocked" is meant to be upsetting), so once you get a certain ways out from the center of civilization, Apostasy is everywhere - not because of some moral laxity or supernatural creeping corruption, but because fuck you Octet, we're asphyxiating out here, don't give us shit for repairing our conventionally unrepairable atmospheric scrubbers by whatever means necessary. The attachment of morality to technology should definitely be there, but as an in-universe belief of the Octet, just like how the main setting has "demons" that the average inhabitant treats like the D&D variety when the truth is much more complex.
Adding another layer of complexity, consider that the stereotypical Apostate behavior - dismantling old things to jury-rig new ones, scrabbling with their neighbors over resources, repurposing & recycling to create living space or arable land or other necessities where none exists, constricting their worldview to let them focus on their monkeysphere or their spiritual beliefs over all other things - are perfectly normal for Second Age Creation. If a bunch of Apostates ended up in the Scavenger Lands, they'd fit right in; it'd be the Octet guys who'd come across as unsettling and weird to the people of the Age of Sorrows.
So yeah, the Octet could totally use "Apostasy" as just a blanket term for "person we think is wasting resources we could use better, a filthy squatter obstructing our maintenance work, and/or disrespecting the Great Maker", so that actual use of the Void (let alone dangerous, irresponsible, or otherwise assholish use of the Void) is less important for determining who's a heretic and who isn't in actual practice than whether or not the Octet says you're one of the "bad guys".
Which is where I blend in the idea of Voidtech as phone phreaking or other outdated tech from your post, as a particularly common form of "apostasy" that most people who live outside of mainstream Autochthonian society have to make use of if they want any sort of security or comfort in their lives. It's not harmful, and it's not really connected to "proper Voidtech" in any metaphysical way, but it's been lumped in with it because the conditions that push people to use outdated tech often also push people to start doing things to the Great Maker's insides that the Octet would rather they didn't.
)
