I'm sorry, but I'd appreciate a touch less strawmanning. My specific words were because some people were legitimately arguing for private water, rails, and electricity, as well as private military materiel production. Due to this, I have suddenly become rahter sure that those people will do their best to take grants way fucking further than I, or I think most of us want. Thus, I don't want to risk them gaining ground.
All Utilities and natural occurring monopolies won't get out of our hands. EVER. I will veto any plan that does that. Not just vote for another plan, but cursing up a storm about such a plan and its poster.
Fucking this.
For fucks sake. Even during Boyle's Treasury, utilities and natural monopolies hadn't been made private. And that fucking bastard was Right-FMP who flirted with Proto-IF ideology.
3. The person who went on that track in discord is a bit of a troll so don't pay too much attention to them
Uhhh. Hi?
First. I'm not trolling. But. Little context, as I've said before. Here in the UK, private water, electricity, gas, and rails is you know, the norm. And for the record, in my opinion privatising rail was a mistake, at least in large part due to how it was handled, but that's neither here nor there. I mention it to make the point that I'm not a free market purist who believes in privatising everything and that the invisible hand shall sort all out. Unrestrained capitalism, leads, in most examples we've seen through history, to powerful monopolies. Which, with a lack of competition then often leads to drops in quality, spikes in prices and so on. Capitalism can be bad.
But let's address these concerns in particular shall we? Water. Here's the thing. People want to keep water solely under government control? Fine. But build water. yellow zone water purification has been sitting there with absolutely 0 interest. We don't *need* it right now because there's enough to cover water needs and the small amount of yellow zone food production. But, i'd like to secure more water in the yellow zones and if it's not something the treasury considers essential, then I'd be fine with opening a well regulated market for private companies to purify and sell water, keeping to all health and quality checks the government requires.
I've said repeatedly. Grants are us extending trust to the market, if they abuse that goodwill and trust we can and should sanction them harshly.
Nowhere is the above more true than water. If they cannot keep water clean and safe then I am wholly willing to fine them into the ground and hand out prison sentences or further punishments if needed. regarding specifically pricing. We're not selling off our own purification plants, we're keeping those and so can set a baseline. Private companies won't be able to charge too much more than us for simple fact is, why would people pay more if we're an option?
All of which is besides the point since the GM noped grants for water. And, there are good in universe reasons for this too. Nod attacked food, it's likely they'd try to attack water. Thus, it's probably smart to keep water in government hands so we can protect it. That said the concept of selling water isn't "Insane" or "trolling". It's fairly normal. There's regulations and laws in place. Both IRL and in quest, so we can prevent any attempted abuses.
Electricity. We're having issues creating enough power. Again, if they can create power plants according to regulations and safely, such as solar, wind or hydroelectric power, if corporate entities want to create more power and sell it. (again, with the governments own power plants generating electricity in competition, providing a soft cap for prices, not to mention we can legislate hard limits to prevent predatory pricing as well)
Beyond that, there's stuff like personal car factory's which haven't been touched all game. And we know there's a grey market for car parts. But if players don't want to spend the time and dice to create automobile factory's then we open up that industry to the private market for them to make cars. Once again
regulated.
Lastly. Military industrial complex. Setting aside that the GM has noped it. It's not that outlandish an idea. Multiple major nations have a military industrial complex. Selling guns, tanks, planes, ships. We've got loads of areas we need to invest in. My argument is why not let them spend the time and money on developing weapons and building the factories, and if needed, we buy what we want. Apart from that... Selling to warlords.
Not as bad as it sounds actually. Again, multiple nations sell weapons, or provide aid to military allies. And we'd be selling to either non-aligned warlords, the independents. Or Nod warlords we can work with. Similar to the qatarists, or those in the middle east. Something else to take into account is nod hardliners will likely attack those who align themselves with us. So, we need to either protect, or arm our allies. It's also treating those not a part of GDI as peers, and showcasing benefits of working with us. They want to buy weapons, they can. What are they going to be buying them with? Well. Probably tiberium they've mined. We'd be subsuming their own harvesting and abatement by stepping into the role of taking the tiberium and manufacturing it into stuff the minor warlords want, that currently Nod is occupying. not to mention. GDi has a long history of working with and Arming 'Friendly' nod warlords like Hassan and Marcion. Warlords who can either be convinced to leave GDI alone, or who can be coerced into working with us.
Now, a lot of the above the GM has said is either not viable, not possible. Not our department. Or whatever other reason certain stuff can't be done after i suggested/asked if we could try some of this.
But my tldr: is this. GDI has strong regulations, we've consistently voted to support laws and to weaken the free market parties influence. And in my opinion they're pretty well cowed and under our control, or at least diminished to where they're not as powerful as they used to be. That being the case, we've got a variety of newer smaller businesses, family trades, co-ops and so on. Grants don't automatically go to line billionaires pockets as they cackle about selling faulty zone suits to GDI. We can support small businesses, our co-ops and start ups. The Plan has consistently rated certain stuff as not worth our time, some options have stuck around for extended periods of time. If we're not going to do them, why not open contracts for someone else to handle it? And beyond all else, light industry grants for consumer goods? Our citizens want consumer goods. It's all very well to talk about a nebulous 'economy' but that represents people. People who until recently were making do with patched clothes. People who've had their homes and possessions destroyed. Call it shallow consumerism if you want, but consumer goods aren't simply a thing our people scream that they want and throw tantrums for every now and again. They're things that make their lives more enjoyable and/or easier. Things they want. Things low priority for the government perhaps, but they're things people are willing to pay for. Thus, the market and grants.