C'mon guys. Don't be all that invested in these people! Let them die a terrible death! Cynric is numero uno here! He proved that when he fled Nirn without a smidgen of hesitation. We should totally drop these people, get Louise, Cattleya, Moira and just team up with another organization.
No need to chance Cynric's very important life on a bunch of nobodies!
C'mon. Don't do the moral thing. Do the "survive this" thing. Pragmatism is where it's at! We'll totes learn magic nd' stuff to resurrect these bozos we leave behind in the future... Maybe.
The problem is that while Cynric might not be too invested in most of these people, the ones he
is invested in
are. Louise is invested in Hinata, Vicky (both of them), Amy, Espinoza, maybe others that I'm forgetting. Cattleya is invested in... I'm blanking right now, but I'm sure there are some. Moira is pretty invested in X-Com in general (and SCIENCE in particular). Shen's also pretty invested in X-Com, and then there's his magical robo-daughter who he just went through the trouble of resurrecting.
Then there's the people
those people are invested in. Hinata is invested in her team (even if the seeds of doubt have been sown, they're still rather fresh). Vicky, both of them, and Amy are pretty invested in New Wave. Espinoza is probably pretty invested in X-Com in general, and probably Granger in particular (since they seemed to work together in the field often from what I recall). X-Com in general is probably pretty invested in
all the refugees of their world, since their job was to protect their world from the aliens, which they failed to do, and these people are all they have left.
While I wouldn't mind leaving a lot of them behind, doing so is definitely a bit of a risk.
The people we definitely have to bring are Louise and Cattleya; there's no real arguing there. Cattleya can probably be satisfied so long as Louise is okay. We might be able to get Louise to accept us not brining anyone, but probably only if we Palpatine it and tell her something along the lines of "it seems, in your anger, you killed them" and try to blind her with guilt (which I admittedly want to do because it sounds hilarious, and this quest is basically
built on Louise's suffering at this point).
Bringing along Hinata would either require us to bring along her team, or come up with a reason we were able to save her but not them. I can't really think of a way to swing that, and we've already got some rogue summons trying to kill us, we don't need more. The same kinda goes for Vicky, especially since we brought half of New Wave through the portal right before we'd abandon them to their deaths (and if we actually
do bring New Wave along, well, they're pretty much useless, and they'll want us to return them back to Bet, so that's just
more work).
Moira... I'm not sure how to swing that one. We'd basically be dragging her away from X-Com and forcing her to start from scratch. I don't even think she'd be that useful without having X-Com to support her. I mean, what equipment would she even manage to salvage? How would she even build new labs without manpower? Same for Shen, who'd be even worse off since he'd also be busy taking care of his daughter (and if we abandoned her, he'd probably just kill himself for having to lose her
twice).
Really, the more people we bring, the more we
need to bring.
… You know what? Fuck it. I started this off trying to argue against your idea, but I'm actually for it so long as we only bring Louise and Cattleya.
[X] Open a momentary portal to another world. You can summon the others at your leisure once you escape, though most of the equipment will be lost.
-[X] Only save your apprentices. The rest are just more trouble than they're worth at this point.
-[X] There's only two you're actually upset about having to leave behind. Lily might have held insights into a potential form of immortality that you'll no longer have the chance to study, but you suppose you can always try to repeat the process in the future; after all, dying now would be rather counterproductive to the whole "living forever" thing, so there's no sense risking your life over this one project. You'll just have to get another one! Then there's
Moira. Oh, so few people can understand you like she could, and even fewer can actually appreciate you after that. Leaving her behind is just… just... ah, who are you kidding, she'd do the same to you in a heartbeat. Truly, a woman after your own heart... admittedly probably so she could study it to learn more about Magicka, but that's just another reason you
love respect her greatly.
Really, I just changed my mind because of the Palpatine bit, that thought amused me greatly. Hell, Louise is even horribly disfigured now, she'll make a great Darth Vader to our Palpatine!