Green Flame Rising (Exalted vs Dresden Files)

Do we know how the Earth afterlife is supposed to work? Like would we be stealing these souls from heaven or the White God?

Edit: also what happens if a ghost immigrates to our hell, goes to Earth and dies again?

You would at the very least be delaying the passage of those souls by a considerable time. Does time matter? Molly cannot guess. For her part Lydia does not care, her intimacy is 'Help the dead find peace'. If the ghosts are ether at peace being ghosts or they move on to someplace they are content in that is all she cares about.
 
You would at the very least be delaying the passage of those souls by a considerable time. Does time matter? Molly cannot guess. For her part Lydia does not care, her intimacy is 'Help the dead find peace'. If the ghosts are ether at peace being ghosts or they move on to someplace they are content in that is all she cares about.
Frankly, considering the continuously stated position of the actual people we are worried about taking souls from, any pro or con or irrelevancy of delaying or diverting souls from their place in the White God's afterlife... Free Will trumps all of it. So long as souls are choosing of their own free will to go to our realm I suspect the worst response we are going to get is an explanation for why this is bad and to please stop voluntarily.

[X] Yog
 
[] Nope, you are not about to start claiming souls postmortem, let them go to where they are supposed to, even if it takes a while

Can we claim them premortem then? :V

[x] It is a worthy goal
-[X] The details of such a venture, the scope and mechanisms of it would require careful handling and thought, on your part and on the part of your subjects. You'll introduce the idea and Lydia to the people responsible. Both the dead she is set to protect, and people under your aegis could benefit from this if done correctly. You won't harm one for the sake of the other.

I'm kinda 50/50 on this since it fits my morals but might conflict with Molly's more Christian outlook.

Uriel already told us it's A-OK with God, all souls ends up where they should at the end.
 
Do we know how the Earth afterlife is supposed to work? Like would we be stealing these souls from heaven or the White God?

Edit: also what happens if a ghost immigrates to our hell, goes to Earth and dies again?
Uriel told us when people perform the wheel severing ritual they bounce over to whatever the white god has for them.

I'd contend that we're just as valid an afterlife as that though. It's not like we're stealing souls to torture, we don't even necessarily get anything out of this.

If the white god wanted to do something about this he'd send angels of death to escort them on, barring what they might as well live in the FCF instead of lingering as maddened ghosts.
 
Yeah, those Half-Reds already are and there is no real way to stop them short of pulling an Emperor of Mankind on them and Molly isn't that dumb.

Why wouldn't we go the way of the God-Emperor? It's not like he asked to not be revered, or was trying top make his empire Atheist, and failed horribly at both. :V


If the white god wanted to do something about this he'd send angels of death to escort them on

Or, in the case of us working on that, just ask us politely to not do that, we have already proved reasonable, after all.
 
[X] It is a worthy goal
-[X] The details of such a venture, the scope and mechanisms of it would require careful handling and thought, on your part and on the part of your subjects. You'll introduce the idea and Lydia to the people responsible. Both the dead she is set to protect, and people under your aegis could benefit from this if done correctly. You won't harm one for the sake of the other.


If God has any issue with it we'll have to make modifications but... this isn't even unique. Other powers have afterlives, even if many have shuttered their doors, and you could call this rehab for the figures who weren't getting to their proper resting places anyway.

Valhalla, A'Aru, Ukhu Pacha...
 
Last edited:
Or, in the case of us working on that, just ask us politely to not do that, we have already proved reasonable, after all
That's fair, though in that case I wouldn't want to give up so much as engineer excuses for them.

Presumably the white god is restricted by one of his rules from just saving them, otherwise it'd be weird for him to shut down the psychopomps then let them linger.

But there are cases where heaven can help, it's 'just' a matter of identifying them and deliberately inducing one once we have enough souls*. This is the benefit of not working for heaven; we can do shit that benefits the side of the angels they could never actually ask or order us to do.

I think we'll be fine though, Uriel probably would have warned us not to take souls when we asked about the ones we already had.


* I'm envisioning team rocket grade evil plots that are designed to fail, but still check enough boxes that the angels can repo souls. We have a comical little pro forma conflict and lose, take a slap on the wrist as punishment, then set it up again for next Saturday. :V
 
[X] It is a worthy goal
-[X] The details of such a venture, the scope and mechanisms of it would require careful handling and thought, on your part and on the part of your subjects. You'll introduce the idea and Lydia to the people responsible. Both the dead she is set to protect, and people under your aegis could benefit from this if done correctly. You won't harm one for the sake of the other.


With mutual consolation between both groups, I think this could be very fruitful to all parties involved- and also would help introduce the world beyond Sanctuary to its inhabitants, not to mention other (sanctioned) gods and creeds worth following beyond the Empress-Who-Has-Come which would help keep us more accountable and prevent monolithic notions of our supposed "infallibility" or "supremacy" we wish to avoid.
 
[X] Yog

Souls have free will. Either they can choose to follow the White God's plan in a more immediate sense or they can choose to come with us, which is still something the White God is ok with. This shouldn't actually go against Molly's morals, as I read them.
 
[x] It is a worthy goal
-[X] The details of such a venture, the scope and mechanisms of it would require careful handling and thought, on your part and on the part of your subjects. You'll introduce the idea and Lydia to the people responsible. Both the dead she is set to protect, and people under your aegis could benefit from this if done correctly. You won't harm one for the sake of the other.
 
This will look interesting from the outside. The darkhallow was essentially just ascending to godhood by eating a shitload of ghosts, and we're basically sticking a straw into a major city's ghost supply then starting to slurp. :V

Lower level, but it'd still be pretty alarming to see.
 
This will look interesting from the outside. The darkhallow was essentially just ascending to godhood by eating a shitload of ghosts, and we're basically sticking a straw into a major city's ghost supply then starting to slurp. :V

Lower level, but it'd still be pretty alarming to see.
I am interested if we actually get any benefits from it or if it's just charity work.
 
This will look interesting from the outside. The darkhallow was essentially just ascending to godhood by eating a shitload of ghosts, and we're basically sticking a straw into a major city's ghost supply then starting to slurp. :V
Kemmler was a greedy amateur. This is how you become a god that's absorbing the unquiet dead... while somehow remaining in the good graces of all the major powers. 😂
 
Should we craft up some sort of ferryman charm for Lydia to get or is she just going to have to take a few ghosts at a time when Molly manages the transport?

Or maybe this is just a natural option with Rest-Granting Strike (••) when the death god in question has access to a cooperating afterlife.

Maybe Molly will have to do some sort of ritual appointing her to the position?
For her part Lydia does not care, her intimacy is 'Help the dead find peace'. If the ghosts are ether at peace being ghosts or they move on to someplace they are content in that is all she cares about.
If the rest granting strike option works then combined with this intimacy Lydia will be much better able to recover resources far more quickly. Which in turn allows Lydia to be much more active.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top