Green Flame Rising (Exalted vs Dresden Files)

My apologies for any annoyance caused.
But I disagree.

We voted to interact with interesting people, and fish for information.
The point of this entire thing was for us to pick the target we wanted to interact with. We could mouth meaningless pufferies and move on from Vito; Leinth was specifically pointed out as a different target.

But coming the heavy without provocation, after an apparently courteous greeting would actively make it harder for us to interact with other Whamps who are already spooked by the archdevil in human skin that just showed up with a scion of Death in tow.
This is a social event; noone is compelled to talk to us.

Thats my two cents.


COMMENTARY
Interesting note about how his agent promptly dumped his phone once he realized Molly was involved, and a warning to us about spreading around how easily we can use HMP.
We probably want to establish alternate routes to Undertown that dont pass through his warehouse.

A little surprised he didnt consider the possible influence of both Dresden and Michael on our decisionmaking.
The very Catholic Knight of the Cross, and the wizard who has held opposition to Marcone's business as essentially an article of faith since they first met.

I dont think he wants to draw the sort of aggro we are looking to attract.
The FBI hexenwulfen almost arranged to have him killed by the loup garou in Fool Moon. The Denarians almost killed him just as a side effect of laying a trap for the Archive in Small Favor.


Doubt we can.
Dude used to be a Marine before he deliberately came here.
Whatever is driving him, its not simple or easy.

And frankly, there are the realities of his crime business, where there's always a bunch of people pushing for advantage

In Storm Front, Victor Sells was looking to take over and kill him, and one of his bodyguards sold him out.
In Fool Moon, the FBI wolves were trying to murder him, and the motorcycle gang came in from out of town to pose a challenge when he was still growing his power.

In Even Hand, he executed two of three men sent from Boston by another organized crime outfit to set up an operation in his city in a direct challenge.In Small Favor, Torelli, one of his sub-bosses promptly tried to stage a palace coup as soon as the Denarians grabbed him.

In Aftermath, one of his in-house enforcers was gathering evidence prior to murdering a housing superintendent who was breaking the rules about drug trafficking and cheating Marcone.

Running a large organized crime operation involves constantly walking a tightrope, and there's a need, a willingness to kill or maim as necessary, and to be seen to do so, because lessons only last so long, and there's always a new batch of bozos looking to see if you've lost your edge.

Thats the reality of a lot of organized crime; the credible threat of force is always just under the surface.

Point of correction:
Some of our guys were guilty of being cannibals; the older ones at least.
Especially when they were still working for the Red Court, and bodies needed disposal.

As a group of autonomous ghouls in Undertown, long pork isnt quite so easy to come by.

There genuinely isnt that much meat in a 70 kilogram human carcass.
Subtract 10% for blood, 15% for bone, and you're already down to ~53kg, and we havent even gotten rid of the digestive tract and its contents. And we're talking a human subspecies that can allegedly scarf down up to fifty pounds of meat in a sitting.


Unnecessary when we're investing in a Hell and can literally toss people in jail.
Cant get rid of violent crime anyway; can only restrict its scope, within reason.



No we cant. Not easily, and not well.
Marcone is a heroic mortal who clawed his way from foot soldier to head of Chicago's organized crime. He's the sort of person who took Denarian confinement and torture for three days running during the events of Small Favor and didnt break.

They dont grow on trees nor are they easy to change.

Furthermore, we dont have any interest in giving our enemies a new attack surface to exploit.
Running an organized crime outfit would close a bunch of doors for us with regards to law enforcement and a fair fraction of the world. And it would give our enemies an easy, cheap way to fuck with us, just by funnelling information to law enforcement.

Marcone spent years dodging the Feds.
Not to mention that Molly sure as fuck does not have the stomach to execute people or smash their kneecaps or threaten their loved ones for infractions.


Also this.
Mafia bosses dont take holidays or sabbaticals; they are on the job 24/7/365.
Molly aint got time for that.


^^^


1)He didnt burst our intimidation bubble; we chose to engage.
We could have gone around and ignored him to the same effect; we could have literally flown over his head if we wanted to make an ostentatious point of ignoring him.


2) We chose to engage to gather information.
Intimidating someone into backing off doesnt actually do very much in the way of making them spill information.
Especially when they are free to walk away, and supernatural etiquette means we have to let him.


3)He's Malvora Heir, and son of Lady Cesarina Malvor, House Malvora Ruler.
He's already a political power here, at least in his generation. A single lost social exchange might be embarassing, but it does nothing to actually affect his power.

Especially since he is gathering information for his various allegiances, in the one place where he might be able to do so safely.

And walking away IS an option for Whites in social combat.
Madrigal Raith did it in his first encounter with Dresden. Lord Skavis did it in White Night when his heir didnt show up to back up his claims. Even Lara has backed down in the face of Shagnasty and Ebenezar McCoy.

Force majeure is a defense.


No we cant.

Crime is a social phenomenon. It doesnt just go away because you attacked a couple gangs; others rise in their place.
And its not just career criminals who have to crime to make a living, there are also posers, and thrillseekers, and people who enjoy holding power over others.


Because crime is usually the first way that a lot of expansionist supernatural powers gain a foothold in a region.

Before Dresden immolated Bianca St Claire's seethe at the climax of Grave Peril, the Red Court ran a good chunk of the sex trade in Chicago; a point of enmity between her and Thomas was that she wanted Justine for the Velvet Room, but Thomas got to her first. After Dresden killed them off, Marcone took over, and in doing so, has kept others out.

The Red Court notoriously has its fingers in the cartels south of the US border, and in a chunk of crime activities in the US reaching up into Las Vegas.
And thats just the Reds.

When the Black Council first made a move on Chicago in Storm Front, they used Victor Sells, a warlock who started by muscling in on the drug trade. When they tried again in Fool Moon, they used renegade FBI agents. When the Shroud of Turin was stolen in Death Masks, it was by professional thieves.

When the Kemmlerites were after the Word of Kemmler in Dead Beat, they used a professional criminal and smuggler.

When Ariana Ortega was looking to distract Dresden in Changes, she hired professional hitmen.
When the Fomor started their campaign of kidnappings and murders between Ghost Story and Peace Talks, they used a lot of criminals. And some corrupt cops. When Nicky wanted to go rob Hades in Skin Games, he needed to hire a professional thief.

We dont want to run the crime world. Its actively harmful to our interests to do so.
But we are obliged to keep an eye on things at that end, before something grows its strength in the crime world, crawls out of the deep waters and bites us.


www.addictionhelp.com

Addiction Statistics - Data on Addiction in the United States

General Addiction Statistics According to the National Center for Drug Abuse Statistics (NCDAS), nearly half of all people 12 and older in the United States have used an illicit substance at least once. Below are some facts and statistics about just how prevalent substance abuse and addiction...

Lemme explain the scope of the problem.

Molly produces Essence*100 weeklong meals per use of the Maggot charm. At E3, that's 300 per use.
37 million Americans of the population that's 12 and older used illicit drugs in 2020. 13.5% of Americans 12 or older used illicit drugs in the last 30 days. Thats one in eight or nine people thats of teenage years or older in the US, roughly.

Chicago is roughly 3 million people, of which roughly 18% are below 14; that translates to roughly 330,000 people who have used illicit drugs in a month.

Drugs are massively profitable because so many people use them; in the US alone, its worth 150 billion dollars a year, and Chicago is the third biggest city in the US, and a major transport hub. Then there's illicit gambling, loan sharking, prostitution, burglary, car theft, bank robbery, credit card theft, construction fraud, smuggling and so on.

All the various varieties of crime in a smorgasbord of flavors.


Not true. It never has.

Man has always sought mind-altering substances. Even countries with the death penalty for drug possession still have a drug trade. You can literally cook meth in the back of your car with cough medicine, which is why bulk purchase of cough medicine is currently illegal and requires an ID.

At best you'll drive the demand to another substance.
Its a demented game of whack a mole.
I feel you're kind of discounting the level of it I'm talking about. I'm talking full dr.doom police state with campaigns of actual annihilation. Not the real world measures that have been placed but the complete annihilation of anyone who does these things until no one's left. Not that we'd do that but I feel people are discounting things a bit.
 
Maybe they just didn't have the right powers active?
Vampires for example habe Soul Mask at Obfuscate 6, to specifically defend against having their Aura read.
No idea if Fey have an equivalent, or if it has to be specifically activated at a cost, or is passive.
Our meeting with Mab was a scheduled diplomatic meeting arranged months in advance.
Mab even came with a gift.
No way she doesnt have something running if its at all possible, but it didnt impair us.

Then there's Lara Raith, who was present and opposite Molly when we used HC to identify the lesser skinwalker.
And I profoundly doubt that Vito is better at this than the White Queen.
At least not without external mojo giving him a boost.

If we don't know he's a threat IC why would Molly go full damn the torpedoes to snoop on him right this second? She is after all aware of her own essence economy rules.
Because he's literally doing something that Incarna couldnt do?
That the de facto White Queen couldnt do?
Because you dont ignore potential hostiles using stealth magics on the border of a soon to be combat zone?

A similar meeting only in the broad strokes. He doesn't know what we know. It's also possible that he isn't involved yet here, because we got that list from the crown. If he was involved we should know about it.

This whole plot is very different from the books after all. In the DF it had already been running for some time in multiple cities before it made it to Chicago, and the whamps knew what Dresden was going for before he even showed up at the Raith's party.
More importantly, unless you ask a question formulated entirely on meta gaming we won't get information that actually applies here.

Even if it is time sensitive, which we don't have actual evidence for in the AU, we can't articulate how in a way that makes sense.The time critical bit is also barely related to the occult excellency expense in any case.
-The potential goals remain much the same.
Assuming control of, or failing that, decapitating a major Dresdenverse faction. And there's enough major political figures of the White Court here to do so.

And yes, its possible Vittorio Malvora isnt involved here, or that his involvement is peripheral.
We dont actually know yet.


-This has also been running for some time.
The Ants had all apparently been killing people for a while, and if Cage's testimony is to be believed, at least some of them were recruited out west by the "Reverend."


-Articulating it is pretty simple.
We are planning to publicly kill the Heir of House Skavis and his co-conspirators pour encourageur les autres, and we can reasonably assume that House Raith under Lara Raith will not raise a finger to save him or Madrigal Raith.

Gathering information on the Heir of House Malvora goes some way to determine if we have to worry about House Malvora.
Not to mention that, again, he is doing something Queen Mab and Winter Lady Maeve couldnt do.
That White Queen Lara Raith couldnt do.

And he's doing so in a place we intend to fight and kill a whole bunch of people.
You do not want mysteries in your potential combat zone.

Maeve was occupied and Mab distracted. She was also very obviously focusing on putting on a show.
Not being able to use stealth powers while operating at show off levels of strength is a pretty common limitation across power levels. Even exalts have that issue with flaring while under most charm based stealth effects.
No, that is inaccurate.
Mab wasnt distracted when we first had Hellscry Chakra running; we could see her aura from the moment we walked into Mac's, and it literally filled the room with color. We didnt even have an Occult Excellency running.

I quote:
As you push the door open you see her. Looked at piece by piece she should not be that extraordinary, beautiful yes as much as when you had last seen her in the dark halls of the museum, a being incarnate of ice perfect in every line every feature, filled within by a fire that elevates her above perfection. Another time in some other place you might have tripped over your tongue to offer a gift to such a being wondrous fair, but then you see those jade green eyes widen even so slightly as though your entrance, your appearance, something had caught her by surprised and with surprise comes the vision of perfection wavers leaving behind a presence still regal beyond words, but one that leaves enough to think, to speak without haste, the risk of saying something you had not meant to. Is that an iced tea in her hand? Seems kind of redundant.

"Hello," you say with the kind of smile one gives to a new teacher on the first day or the parent of someone you do not really know what well, the words brashly mortal... no more like brashly American. We don't have queens 'round here kind of thing.
She laughs behind her hand, ladylike, though far from coy. All at once you feel absurd like a sic year old balancing on stolen heels.

"Good day Miss Carpenter, I am glad to see you made it." Coming from anyone else this might have sounded like stock pleasantry or at most a compliment on how punctual one has been. From her it's more like she's glad yo see you survived until Halloween, which given the things you have been doing in the intern... fair enough you guess.

One can afford a sheepish smile, gracefully sheepish, the kind of thing you would not have even conceived of once yet which now comes out as though you had done this stuff all your life. All the uncertainty, the sense that you are a child or a fraud you lock it in a box and throw the box into the ocean. Mab does not seem to notice... no, you are sure, does not notice.

As you turn your head you realize the colors dancing though the air like reflections of the aurora borealis are the Queen of Winter's aura reaching all the way to the table in the corner to the door. Without the wardline they might even spill out into the street

Daunting as that may be the colors tell a tale. Among the blue grey of winter, the threat of imperishable silver that marks a queen sure as a crown upon her head you see vivid heart's red, pathos paired with the pulsing yellow like falling leaves, fear, but not the immediate kind that would mix with the red, instead it rises like smoke to play among the rafters, a distant all pervasive dread. One might almost call it existential.
That was literally as we stepped into the pub.
Our ability to read her aura was in part why we felt comfortable IC that she personally was untouched by Nemesis.

To recap:
The Queen of Air and Darkness couldnt hide her own aura from Hellscry Chakra.
And this was a meeting arranged three months in advance, so she didnt come scrambling out of the blue.
We had social Excellencies running, but no Occult Excellency to boost Hellscry Chakra.

Nemesis-in-Maeve required a 5 success roll to detect.


EDIT
Even if there's an Outsider in Vittorio Malvora right now, or an Investment from an Outsider?
It isnt necessarily from He Who Walks Besides, also called Nemesis, Canon simply says an Outsider, so it could be another Walker(there's three: Before, Besides, Behind), or even a lesser Outsider.

Note that neither Lord Raith nor Justin DuMorne dealt with Nemesis/He Who Walks Besides; they both dealt with He Who Walks Behind.
 
Then there's Lara Raith, who was present and opposite Molly when we used HC to identify the lesser skinwalker.
And I profoundly doubt that Vito is better at this than the White Queen.
At least not without external mojo giving him a boost.
This is not a binary better/worse thing.

Literally nobody has all the Elder Discipline powers.
Especially among regular vamps, who have a lot more options than Kuei Wan.

A talented and not too young house-heir might have Soul Mask if they focus on mental privacy, while most other Whampires would not have the inclination or talent to go for such a niche power and instead train some Elder Presence or Celerity stuff.
 
This is not a binary better/worse thing.

Literally nobody has all the Elder Discipline powers.
Especially among regular vamps, who have a lot more options than Kuei Wan.

A talented and not too young house-heir might have Soul Mask if they focus on mental privacy, while most other Whampires would not have the inclination or talent to go for such a niche power and instead train some Elder Presence or Celerity stuff.
For the social/infiltration vampires? That is precisely the sort of thing I would expect them to prioritize over the combat Disciplines.

Especially since its canon that Lara spent a significant portion of her earlier years travelling; she spent several years in Tokugawa Japan back when Japan was still isolated from the outside world between the seventeenth and nineteenth century. And then after that was a porn star for a while.

But Lara did not have it.
I dont find it particularly plausible this dude, at his age, with a Charisma + Etiquette pool of 4 dice, has Obfuscate 6: Soul Mask when she doesnt. Certainly not on his own mojo.
 
VOTE
[X]Plan Double Take
-[X]Take another, closer look at the Malvora as he walks away, burning power to see what he's trying to hide
--[X]Repeat look with Hellscry Chakra + Occult Excellency + Stunt, then Crown question on his outfit
--[X]Occult Excellency: 1m
--[X]Crown Focus: Suit and accouterments. Question: What secrets is the owner/wearer of these items hiding?: 1m
-[X]Go speak to someone else in the crowd
--[X] A dark haired vampire with a familiar resemblance to Thomas who seems to have found your put down particularly funny
-[X]STUNT: Your senses, and those of your companion, follow the whampire as he walks away from you, a little faster than would be accounted normal. "Whats his deal?" Lydia asks, frowning at his retreating back, even as her hand traces out a different question on your wrist. "Not sure" is your reply, eyes intent as you consider, then dismiss calling after him.
Let's ask.

SPENT: 2m

STATUS
Essence: 12/15 Essence
Willpower: 8/9 Willpower
Essence spent so far this scene: 3/4


EFFECTS
Demonic Primacy of Essence: -2 DC to social interactions with lesser Creatures of Darkness
All Things Betray: -3 DC to all Perception rolls for the rest of the scene
Hellscry Chakra: See aura of Creatures of Darkness
Occult Excellency: Essence*minutes


RATIONALE
Going back to check?
Our Jade Dog vampires are all ex-Malvora, according to Arc 5 Post 28.
Which explains how he knows their birth names, instead of just the names they go by.

Occult Excellency and Crown Question on Vittorio because he's doing something that neither Lara Raith, de facto White Queen, nor Mab were able to do when we used Hellscry Chakra around them.
That makes it of critical importance to determine how. Especially if he may be in the audience.

Also, if we ask a Crown question, we should regen +2m of Essence with the right answers; the secrets of a House heir definitely qualify.


We know what the attitudes of House Raith will be. But the visibly amused Raith seems like she (probably she, Thomas has no named blood male relatives besides Madrigal because his father presumably killed them all) seems to not like Vittorio enough to be willing to spill what she knows about him (or the Skavis, actually) if we give a little encouragement.

First talk to the Raith, then Leinth.
We know who Leinth is, but we dont know who the Raith-looking person is.
An alternative contact might be useful.
 
I'm trying to figure out a plausible metaphysical workaround that could allow Vittorio to avoid some of the effects of our powers.

Could the Charm have failed if Vito was no longer in the driver's seat, so to speak? I mean, if he was letting Nemesis take the wheel, or even his Hunger, assuming such a thing was possible, would that add a layer of obfuscation that we couldn't casually overcome?

Alternatively, what if Vito has some ability or artifact that lets him store his own consciousness elsewhere, similar to a Lich's phylactery, so that he is remotely piloting his own body around? Is that possible?

And lastly, what if this wasn't Vito we were speaking with at all? Somehow he was able to avoid getting lumped in with the other conspirators when we used the Crown to learn their names. That could mean he's simply dead through the power of unintended butterflies. We could be speaking with a puppet, a shapechanger, or even an advanced magical projection.

[X] uju32
 
After this -unless we get 2 essence back- I don't really feel comfortable spending more resources before the fight tbh. However this warrants it not knowing wtf is going on here may bite us in the ass in the coming conflict.
[X]Plan Double Take
 
Last edited:
I'm going to vote for you @uju32, but don't you think this question is too open? Isn't it better to ask how he's hiding from our powers.

I'm a little worried that we won't get good answers.

[X] uju32
 
I'm trying to figure out a plausible metaphysical workaround that could allow Vittorio to avoid some of the effects of our powers.
The easiest way is just be high enough level to not be hit by it. Essence 3 = 6th generation for vampires, super strong but a son of head of major family could be 5th generation, or give that we know Nemesis sort of joins with/becomes its host, it/they might be using nemesis rating which is definitely high enough.
 
Last edited:
I'm trying to figure out a plausible metaphysical workaround that could allow Vittorio to avoid some of the effects of our powers.

Could the Charm have failed if Vito was no longer in the driver's seat, so to speak? I mean, if he was letting Nemesis take the wheel, or even his Hunger, assuming such a thing was possible, would that add a layer of obfuscation that we couldn't casually overcome?

Alternatively, what if Vito has some ability or artifact that lets him store his own consciousness elsewhere, similar to a Lich's phylactery, so that he is remotely piloting his own body around? Is that possible?

And lastly, what if this wasn't Vito we were speaking with at all? Somehow he was able to avoid getting lumped in with the other conspirators when we used the Crown to learn their names. That could mean he's simply dead through the power of unintended butterflies. We could be speaking with a puppet, a shapechanger, or even an advanced magical projection.

[X] uju32
This was my reaction as well.

If it worked on Mab, and worked on Lara, even worked on Nemesis, I begin to worry about precisely what we're looking at that allows him to even partly degrade its efficacy. I was even considering if that was the naagloshii in disguise, and the naagloshii has an magic presence thats almost as obvious as Molly's.

His being dead, and something else being in his body, impersonating him or teleoperating him, is a situation I didnt consider though. Nice catch.
I'm going to vote for you @uju32, but don't you think this question is too open? Isn't it better to ask how he's hiding from our powers.
I'm a little worried that we won't get good answers.

[X] uju32
Word of QM established that the Crown is not an evil genie type situation.
It will always do its best to answer our intent in our favor.
He's hiding secrets with whatever that is; we want to know what those secrets are. The QM will adjudicate.
 
[x] Try to push, find out where he knows the name of your vampires from
-[X] [Stunt]: With something almost playful leaking into her eyes Molly replies "Well if we're sharing idle speculation, then perhaps she just didn't feel the need to be so blunt about it".
-[X] Something in her tone shifts, just the right mix of not-quite-condescension and amusement to come off like she wanted to reach out and ruffle his hair "It was a cute little ice breaker, but I hope you don't mind me saying your technique could use some work".
 
--[X]Crown Focus: Suit and accouterments. Question: What secrets is the owner/wearer of these items hiding?: 1m
Isn't this way too broad? I'll approval vote, but I think both the stunt and the question should be changed. The stunt to incorporate the environment, the question to narrow it down.

[X]Plan Double Take

[X]Plan Focused Double Take
-[X]Take another, closer look at the Malvora as he walks away, burning power to see what he's trying to hide
--[X]Repeat look with Hellscry Chakra + Occult Excellency + Stunt, then Crown question on his outfit
--[X]Occult Excellency: 1m
--[X]Crown Focus: Suit and accouterments. Question: How is the owner of these items protected from your powers?: 1m
-[X]Go speak to someone else in the crowd
--[X] A dark haired vampire with a familiar resemblance to Thomas who seems to have found your put down particularly funny
-[X]STUNT: Your senses, and those of your companion, follow the whampire as he walks away from you, a little faster than would be accounted normal. "Whats his deal?" Lydia asks, frowning at his retreating back, even as her hand traces out a different question on your wrist. "Not sure" is your reply, eyes intent as you consider, then dismiss calling after him. Moving to a nearby table to pick up a cup of white wine, you mask the direction of your intense stare by pretending to inspect it to the light.
Let's ask.


The important thing is what are the means by which he shields himself. I also added environmental interaction into the stunt to disguise what we are doing.
 
Hellscry Chakra is interesting in social combat because it doesn't give bonuses to rolls it just bypasses them. Roll a hundred successes on Subterfuge to hide your emotions and Molly doesn't care because Hellscry Chakra doesn't give a subterfuge check to resist. In fact the difficulty of the check doesn't even care about the target it is just set to a default of 6.

Actually in the counter factual situation that another Infernal had Hellscry Chakra I can't see any way for Molly to hide her emotions. Perfect mental defense doesn't apply because it isn't an attack. It isn't shaping. It isn't any kind of attack.
Well it appears that I was wrong there is apparently a defense against HC. No idea how that is supposed to work. It isn't as if we have ever even talked about HC even to Harry so this isn't a case of someone coming up with a specific defense to block us. This random vampire just happens to be able to at least partially block HC when Mab was an open book.
 
Isn't this way too broad? I'll approval vote, but I think both the stunt and the question should be changed. The stunt to incorporate the environment, the question to narrow it down.
I dont think so.
This has been brought up before, multiple times and answered by the QM. I quote:
does it work off intent cause if it doesn't it would ping off literally anyone behind us on the road?
Your power is not a literal genie, no need to worry about that. It would ping people who are tracking you somehow.
Okay why lineage that is incredibly vague? Why not supernatural elements of her life?
Your power is not a literal genie, nor is it trying to trick you. Both would return the same answer, the only difference is is she is not supernatural the lineage one will give you any mortal noble lines or other families of note in her background.
OOC: The question could have been 'What obstacles are on the swiftest path between me and where Cindy is being held?' but your power is not a literal genie, it showed you were she is with the most amount of detail it could manage with an eye for your intent which was a rescue mission.
The QM will correct me if Im wrong, but our power reads our intent and the context, not just the plain letter of the question.
In this case, the secrets pertinent to our asking the question.
Broader parameters are better here within reason, because it gives some wiggle room to apply best judgement.


The important thing is what are the means by which he shields himself. I also added environmental interaction into the stunt to disguise what we are doing.
I dont think I agree?

HOW he is doing it is certainly of academic interest to us, but I dont see how that helps us right now. Especially since knowing how its done doesnt mean we can defeat it, or that the means of defeating it is practical; if he's wearing an amulet for example, we cant just rip it off at a diplomatic event, and if he has an Investment, we cant take it away.

Its something we can explore at leisure.

WHAT he/it is hiding on the other hand? Is of immediate importance to us and our goals here.
Especially since if he's hiding it from us, he's probably also hiding it from all the other vampires here who have Auspex, and who he actually has to live with all the time.

I mean, Leinth demonstrated that he has good enough Auspex to see Molly use HMP back in Agent Greene's house when Molly was Essence 2, and I doubt he's the only one.

EDIT
Consider what constitutes secrets that the heir to a major Whampire House wants to hide from everyone.
Including other vampires.
 
Last edited:
I dont think so.
This has been brought up before, multiple times and answered by the QM. I quote:



The QM will correct me if Im wrong, but our power reads our intent and the context, not just the plain letter of the question.
In this case, the secrets pertinent to our asking the question.
Broader parameters are better here within reason, because it gives some wiggle room to apply best judgement.



I dont think I agree?

HOW he is doing it is certainly of academic interest to us, but I dont see how that helps us right now. Especially since knowing how its done doesnt mean we can defeat it, or that the means of defeating it is practical; if he's wearing an amulet for example, we cant just rip it off at a diplomatic event, and if he has an Investment, we cant take it away.

Its something we can explore at leisure.

WHAT he/it is hiding on the other hand? Is of immediate importance to us and our goals here.
Especially since if he's hiding it from us, he's probably also hiding it from all the other vampires here who have Auspex, and who he actually has to live with all the time.

I mean, Leinth demonstrated that he has good enough Auspex to see Molly use HMP back in Agent Greene's house when Molly was Essence 2, and I doubt he's the only one.

EDIT
Consider what constitutes secrets that the heir to a major Whampire House wants to hide from everyone.
Including other vampires.

I'm going to take the secrets question to be 'what is the most important secret the person is hiding'. Secrets plural would be more than one question
 
WHAT he/it is hiding on the other hand? Is of immediate importance to us and our goals here.
Especially since if he's hiding it from us, he's probably also hiding it from all the other vampires here who have Auspex, and who he actually has to live with all the time.
There's a big assumption here - that he is actually hiding things, rather than his shielding being a side-effect of his condition. Ie that there's a conscious effort to hide things, rather than his aura being shielded because of something else, like an effort to protect him from our influence, or him reaching golconda analogue, etc.
 
Because he's literally doing something that Incarna couldnt do?
That the de facto White Queen couldnt do?
Because you dont ignore potential hostiles using stealth magics on the border of a soon to be combat zone?
Or you're dramatically overestimating HC again, as you have been since before we got the charm.

He's clearly sketchy, but in terms of our immediate concerns he isn't necessarily a drop everything problem.
This has also been running for some time.
The Ants had all apparently been killing people for a while, and if Cage's testimony is to be believed, at least some of them were recruited out west by the "Reverend.
No it hasn't, we got WoQM a while back that Chicago was the first city they tried this in.
And he's doing so in a place we intend to fight and kill a whole bunch of people.
You do not want mysteries in your potential combat zone.
The white court is 80% secrets and intrigue by volume. Seriously, it's a major supernatural nation we'll be here for months if we can have no mysteries in our combat zone before starting.

For all you know - and as far as your question can reach - the secret he considers most important is completely irrelevant to this situation.
The Queen of Air and Darkness couldnt hide her own aura from Hellscry Chakra.
Or she doesn't care to, didn't know we could accurately read auras, or any of a dozen other things. You're jumping to conclusions on a single data point and a fistful of assumptions.
 
Back
Top