It isn't erratic, and you're framing things as if this vote we're having right now has already closed. The point of this vote is to let us pick the tone. Stopping to talk was the default because being deflected or literally walking over him were stronger specific choices and the scene paused to let us vote on our response to him challenging our little march into the party.
Disagree with my approach if you like, but I find this line of reasoning on how we've already implicitly accepted yours and anything else would be a startling deviation annoying.
My apologies for any annoyance caused.
But I disagree.
We voted to interact with interesting people, and fish for information.
The point of this entire thing was for us to pick the target we wanted to interact with. We could mouth meaningless pufferies and move on from Vito; Leinth was specifically pointed out as a different target.
But coming the heavy without provocation, after an apparently courteous greeting would actively make it harder for us to interact with other Whamps who are already spooked by the archdevil in human skin that just showed up with a scion of Death in tow.
This is a social event; noone is compelled to talk to us.
Thats my two cents.
COMMENTARY
Interesting note about how his agent promptly dumped his phone once he realized Molly was involved, and a warning to us about spreading around how easily we can use HMP.
We probably want to establish alternate routes to Undertown that dont pass through his warehouse.
A little surprised he didnt consider the possible influence of both Dresden and Michael on our decisionmaking.
The very Catholic Knight of the Cross, and the wizard who has held opposition to Marcone's business as essentially an article of faith since they first met.
I dont think he wants to draw the sort of aggro we are looking to attract.
The FBI hexenwulfen almost arranged to have him killed by the loup garou in Fool Moon. The Denarians almost killed him just as a side effect of laying a trap for the Archive in Small Favor.
Hmm, while I dislike Marcone on principle, he is right. If we can work with ghouls, we can work with him. That, of course, puts him within talking distance of a socially focused exalt. Fairly sure we could reform him over the course of several months.
Any true fantasy city needs a respectable thieves guild (no, it f*cking doesn't).
Doubt we can.
Dude used to be a Marine before he deliberately came here.
Whatever is driving him, its not simple or easy.
And frankly, there are the realities of his crime business, where there's always a bunch of people pushing for advantage
In Storm Front, Victor Sells was looking to take over and kill him, and one of his bodyguards sold him out.
In Fool Moon, the FBI wolves were trying to murder him, and the motorcycle gang came in from out of town to pose a challenge when he was still growing his power.
In Even Hand, he executed two of three men sent from Boston by another organized crime outfit to set up an operation in his city in a direct challenge.In Small Favor, Torelli, one of his sub-bosses promptly tried to stage a palace coup as soon as the Denarians grabbed him.
In Aftermath, one of his in-house enforcers was gathering evidence prior to murdering a housing superintendent who was breaking the rules about drug trafficking and cheating Marcone.
Running a large organized crime operation involves constantly walking a tightrope, and there's a need, a willingness to kill or maim as necessary, and to be seen to do so, because lessons only last so long, and there's always a new batch of bozos looking to see if you've lost your edge.
Thats the reality of a lot of organized crime; the credible threat of force is always just under the surface.
I mean, Marcone's missing a few key facts, but he's got a point. Our guys were definitely guilty of being cannibals.
A partnership with Marcone might be a bit too much for the current Molly but a non-aggression pact like the one with Lara would be okay for me.
Point of correction:
Some of our guys were guilty of being cannibals; the older ones at least.
Especially when they were still working for the Red Court, and bodies needed disposal.
As a group of autonomous ghouls in Undertown, long pork isnt quite so easy to come by.
There genuinely isnt that much meat in a 70 kilogram human carcass.
Subtract 10% for blood, 15% for bone, and you're already down to ~53kg, and we havent even gotten rid of the digestive tract and its contents. And we're talking a human subspecies that can allegedly scarf down up to fifty pounds of meat in a sitting.
He can provide retributive justice against magically aware humans. If we can't actually involve the police, we could involve mafia. It's not a good solution, but it is one.
Also, this would be less about what he can provide and more about how to get rid of (violent) crime in the least bloody way
Unnecessary when we're investing in a Hell and can literally toss people in jail.
Cant get rid of violent crime anyway; can only restrict its scope, within reason.
Yes and we do all of that better then him. We can totally replace him.
We could take over his organization as a weekend getway if we really wanted to.
Like we are so much better than him its insane.
No we cant. Not easily, and not well.
Marcone is a heroic mortal who clawed his way from foot soldier to head of Chicago's organized crime. He's the sort of person who took Denarian confinement and torture for three days running during the events of Small Favor and didnt break.
They dont grow on trees nor are they easy to change.
Furthermore, we dont have any interest in giving our enemies a new attack surface to exploit.
Running an organized crime outfit would close a bunch of doors for us with regards to law enforcement and a fair fraction of the world. And it would give our enemies an easy, cheap way to fuck with us, just by funnelling information to law enforcement.
Marcone spent years dodging the Feds.
Not to mention that Molly sure as fuck does not have the stomach to execute people or smash their kneecaps or threaten their loved ones for infractions.
Molly does not have the stats for that. Things like Finance etc.
Also being a Mafia boss is a full time Job. Molly does not have the time.
Also this.
Mafia bosses dont take holidays or sabbaticals; they are on the job 24/7/365.
Molly aint got time for that.
He's a hell of a lot cleaner than the White and Red Courts, Mab and company, or the actual hells. And we are at least trying to smooth things out with all of the above. We would be a dirty hypocrite by a large margin if we weren't willing to deal with him. He's not great but, seriously, what does he do that we haven't already proven we are willing to turn a blind eye to in the name of general peace and prosperity?
The best we can reasonably ask for is for him to sit down and play the card game with everyone else with agreed upon rules. We're not required to trade favors with him but he's free to try to make his case as to why we should. Sometimes it will be in our interest to, sometimes it won't and he can go fuck himself, but its right and proper to have protocols for how that discussion should go down.
^^^
To swing back to this again, nothing about my plan is particularly irrational or unpredictable.
He burst our intimidation bubble, he's testing if we're puffed up or not in addition to whatever else he's playing at here.
We haven't decided on a mode of interaction yet either other than rejecting the most hostile one of literally running him over. The entire point of this vote is deciding this issue, which is why I find your argument about it already being set annoying.
The benefit of the intimidation play is twofold.
The first is that it confirms rather than refutes the reaction Molly has been deliberately cultivating in the observers. My plan doesn't call for us to attack him or initiate an anima flare, it calls for us to press him without even raising Molly's voice. So it proceeds along the lines we've already been following.
The second is that it disrupts his game plan. Vittorio did do this deliberately, he's fishing for information and trying to set up a con of some kind here. Etiquette fencing with him is probably exactly what he (thinks he) wants, and even if it's something we can win it's still playing to his strengths and preparations.
Intimidation by contrast chokes him up, we stand here to all appearances taking no hostile action and he has to roll not to crap his pants. It's not like he's going to vanish into a puff of smoke at that point, we can proceed to needle him for information while he's still screwing his head back on as we please.
Remember that we're at a vampire party and he's trying to be a political power here. Whimpering and running off like a whipped dog isn't an option for him after he stuck his neck out. Forcing him to split his attention between social combat with us and managing his reactions so that they don't sink his political career is too our advantage.
Fencing with him can also work, but it's giving him advantages for little to no benefit in return.
1)He didnt burst our intimidation bubble; we chose to engage.
We could have gone around and ignored him to the same effect; we could have literally flown over his head if we wanted to make an ostentatious point of ignoring him.
2) We chose to engage to gather information.
Intimidating someone into backing off doesnt actually do very much in the way of making them spill information.
Especially when they are free to walk away, and supernatural etiquette means we have to let him.
3)He's Malvora Heir, and son of Lady Cesarina Malvor, House Malvora Ruler.
He's already a political power here, at least in his generation. A single lost social exchange might be embarassing, but it does nothing to actually affect his power.
Especially since he is gathering information for his various allegiances, in the one place where he might be able to do so safely.
And walking away IS an option for Whites in social combat.
Madrigal Raith did it in his first encounter with Dresden. Lord Skavis did it in White Night when his heir didnt show up to back up his claims. Even Lara has backed down in the face of Shagnasty and Ebenezar McCoy.
Force majeure is a defense.
We totally can. With endless torment emanation and just a small amount of information gathering we totally can. Every gang will become so incompetent at crime that the cops catch them in a week.
Or inner darkness unchained and just turn all criminals into COD that are forced to serve us.
No we cant.
Crime is a social phenomenon. It doesnt just go away because you attacked a couple gangs; others rise in their place.
And its not just career criminals who have to crime to make a living, there are also posers, and thrillseekers, and people who enjoy holding power over others.
Why do we care at all about Marcone right now? I say we focus on the supernatural factions preying on mankind before worrying about the mundane crime. If Marcone makes an issue of himself then thats another matter entirely, but for now we literally have bigger things to worry about.
Because crime is usually the first way that a lot of expansionist supernatural powers gain a foothold in a region.
Before Dresden immolated Bianca St Claire's seethe at the climax of Grave Peril, the Red Court ran a good chunk of the sex trade in Chicago; a point of enmity between her and Thomas was that she wanted Justine for the Velvet Room, but Thomas got to her first. After Dresden killed them off, Marcone took over, and in doing so, has kept others out.
The Red Court notoriously has its fingers in the cartels south of the US border, and in a chunk of crime activities in the US reaching up into Las Vegas.
And thats just the Reds.
When the Black Council first made a move on Chicago in Storm Front, they used Victor Sells, a warlock who started by muscling in on the drug trade. When they tried again in Fool Moon, they used renegade FBI agents. When the Shroud of Turin was stolen in Death Masks, it was by professional thieves.
When the Kemmlerites were after the Word of Kemmler in Dead Beat, they used a professional criminal and smuggler.
When Ariana Ortega was looking to distract Dresden in Changes, she hired professional hitmen.
When the Fomor started their campaign of kidnappings and murders between Ghost Story and Peace Talks, they used a lot of criminals. And some corrupt cops. When Nicky wanted to go rob Hades in Skin Games, he needed to hire a professional thief.
We dont want to run the crime world. Its actively harmful to our interests to do so.
But we are obliged to keep an eye on things at that end, before something grows its strength in the crime world, crawls out of the deep waters and bites us.
We could then make maggot meals to replace all addictions with one that has less side effects. However I agree with other posters that worries about power vacuums in the city criminal world are overblown.
General Addiction Statistics According to the National Center for Drug Abuse Statistics (NCDAS), nearly half of all people 12 and older in the United States have used an illicit substance at least once. Below are some facts and statistics about just how prevalent substance abuse and addiction...
www.addictionhelp.com
Lemme explain the scope of the problem.
Molly produces Essence*100 weeklong meals per use of the Maggot charm. At E3, that's 300 per use.
37
million Americans of the population that's 12 and older used illicit drugs in 2020. 13.5% of Americans 12 or older used illicit drugs in the last 30 days. Thats one in eight or nine people thats of teenage years or older in the US, roughly.
Chicago is roughly 3 million people, of which roughly 18% are below 14; that translates to roughly 330,000 people who have used illicit drugs in a month.
Drugs are massively profitable because so many people use them; in the US alone, its worth 150 billion dollars a year, and Chicago is the third biggest city in the US, and a major transport hub. Then there's illicit gambling, loan sharking, prostitution, burglary, car theft, bank robbery, credit card theft, construction fraud, smuggling and so on.
All the various varieties of crime in a smorgasbord of flavors.
Well I understand what you mean but I somewhat disagree genocide would solve the problem of drugs if you kill enough. Now it'd create a worse problem in that its well genocide but it does fix the previous problem! So at a certain point killing does solve the problem. Just you know very immoral and messed up new problem in its place.
Not true. It never has.
Man has always sought mind-altering substances. Even countries with the death penalty for drug possession still have a drug trade. You can literally cook meth in the back of your car with cough medicine, which is why bulk purchase of cough medicine is currently illegal and requires an ID.
At best you'll drive the demand to another substance.
Its a demented game of whack a mole.