Green Flame Rising (Exalted vs Dresden Files)

Current tally:
Adhoc vote count started by uju32 on Feb 16, 2023 at 11:36 PM, finished with 89 posts and 10 votes.

  • [X] In the time honored tradition of younger siblings getting the hand me downs of their elders, once Daniel gets his driver's license you will give him the Beige Wagon, with the understanding that he will care for it properly and eventually pass it down to a younger sibling himself once he has the means to acquire his own vehicle.
    [X] Offer to buy him a car as soon as he gets his license, you have the money and you can make more
    -[X] Empathy excellency to prevent him from feeling insecure or resentful
    -[X] It won't be something luxury, but your parents got you Beige Wagon, so it's only fair that now that you have the means, you even the field and get him something equivalent
    [X] Offer to buy him a car as soon as he gets his license, you have the money and you can make more
    -[X]Empathy Excellency
    -[X]STUNT: You hiss melodramatically at him, clawed hands outstretched. "Its my precious. Mine! Nasty hobbitses cant have it. Gollum, Gollum." You hold the pose and a straight face for almost five seconds, then Olivia bounces an empty beer can off your head, and all of you simultaneously crack up. In a more normal voice, you continue. "Yeah well, I can drive, and according to the Illnois Secretary of State's office, you can't. Yet." Daniel makes a face at you, and you stick your tongue back out at him before continuing. "Get your license, and I'll see about buying you wheels."


Can I please get some votes?
We can afford to buy the guy a new car. Lets buy him a new car.
We already have plans to buy new cars for a whole bunch of people, from our parents to Rosie and Dresden.
 
Last edited:
[X] Offer to buy him a car as soon as he gets his license, you have the money and you can make more
-[X]Empathy Excellency
-[X]STUNT: You hiss melodramatically at him, clawed hands outstretched. "Its my precious. Mine! Nasty hobbitses cant have it. Gollum, Gollum." You hold the pose and a straight face for almost five seconds, then Olivia bounces an empty beer can off your head, and all of you simultaneously crack up. In a more normal voice, you continue. "Yeah well, I can drive, and according to the Illnois Secretary of State's office, you can't. Yet." Daniel makes a face at you, and you stick your tongue back out at him before continuing. "Get your license, and I'll see about buying you wheels."
 
Current tally:
Adhoc vote count started by uju32 on Feb 16, 2023 at 11:36 PM, finished with 89 posts and 10 votes.

  • [X] In the time honored tradition of younger siblings getting the hand me downs of their elders, once Daniel gets his driver's license you will give him the Beige Wagon, with the understanding that he will care for it properly and eventually pass it down to a younger sibling himself once he has the means to acquire his own vehicle.
    [X] Offer to buy him a car as soon as he gets his license, you have the money and you can make more
    -[X] Empathy excellency to prevent him from feeling insecure or resentful
    -[X] It won't be something luxury, but your parents got you Beige Wagon, so it's only fair that now that you have the means, you even the field and get him something equivalent
    [X] Offer to buy him a car as soon as he gets his license, you have the money and you can make more
    -[X]Empathy Excellency
    -[X]STUNT: You hiss melodramatically at him, clawed hands outstretched. "Its my precious. Mine! Nasty hobbitses cant have it. Gollum, Gollum." You hold the pose and a straight face for almost five seconds, then Olivia bounces an empty beer can off your head, and all of you simultaneously crack up. In a more normal voice, you continue. "Yeah well, I can drive, and according to the Illnois Secretary of State's office, you can't. Yet." Daniel makes a face at you, and you stick your tongue back out at him before continuing. "Get your license, and I'll see about buying you wheels."


Can I please get some votes?
We can afford to buy the guy a new car. Lets buy him a new car.
We already have plans to buy new cars for a whole bunch of people, from our parents to Rosie and Dresden.
Don't much care about this vote. But, since you said please sure.
[X] Offer to buy him a car as soon as he gets his license, you have the money and you can make more
-[X]Empathy Excellency
-[X]STUNT: You hiss melodramatically at him, clawed hands outstretched. "Its my precious. Mine! Nasty hobbitses cant have it. Gollum, Gollum." You hold the pose and a straight face for almost five seconds, then Olivia bounces an empty beer can off your head, and all of you simultaneously crack up. In a more normal voice, you continue. "Yeah well, I can drive, and according to the Illnois Secretary of State's office, you can't. Yet." Daniel makes a face at you, and you stick your tongue back out at him before continuing. "Get your license, and I'll see about buying you wheels."
 
Current tally:
Adhoc vote count started by uju32 on Feb 16, 2023 at 11:36 PM, finished with 89 posts and 10 votes.

  • [X] In the time honored tradition of younger siblings getting the hand me downs of their elders, once Daniel gets his driver's license you will give him the Beige Wagon, with the understanding that he will care for it properly and eventually pass it down to a younger sibling himself once he has the means to acquire his own vehicle.
    [X] Offer to buy him a car as soon as he gets his license, you have the money and you can make more
    -[X] Empathy excellency to prevent him from feeling insecure or resentful
    -[X] It won't be something luxury, but your parents got you Beige Wagon, so it's only fair that now that you have the means, you even the field and get him something equivalent
    [X] Offer to buy him a car as soon as he gets his license, you have the money and you can make more
    -[X]Empathy Excellency
    -[X]STUNT: You hiss melodramatically at him, clawed hands outstretched. "Its my precious. Mine! Nasty hobbitses cant have it. Gollum, Gollum." You hold the pose and a straight face for almost five seconds, then Olivia bounces an empty beer can off your head, and all of you simultaneously crack up. In a more normal voice, you continue. "Yeah well, I can drive, and according to the Illnois Secretary of State's office, you can't. Yet." Daniel makes a face at you, and you stick your tongue back out at him before continuing. "Get your license, and I'll see about buying you wheels."


Can I please get some votes?
We can afford to buy the guy a new car. Lets buy him a new car.
We already have plans to buy new cars for a whole bunch of people, from our parents to Rosie and Dresden.
Also I'll note I'd buy him a turret if we could a cars nothing.
 
[X] In the time honored tradition of younger siblings getting the hand me downs of their elders, once Daniel gets his driver's license you will give him the Beige Wagon, with the understanding that he will care for it properly and eventually pass it down to a younger sibling himself once he has the means to acquire his own vehicle.
 
I really don't see Olivia of all people throw something at us over a bad joke. Not at all.
We barely know each other and most of that time together we were glowing with hellfire and crafting a minor deity.
And she doesn't seem like the most outgoing person.

Soooo, could you change the stunt?
1)Normally, no. But the previous update explicitly says they just got done splitting a sixpack of beer.
While it might have no effect on Molly, and probably Lydia, both Olivia and Daniel are mortals without Exalted immunities.
So I wrote the stunt with the expectation that she's a little loosened up.

2)We do know Olivia. She was the one we were talking Power Rangers lore with, remember?
For her part Olivia Deol gives a quiet laugh. Everything about Olivia is quiet, from the muted colors of her leotard and tights to the way she hardly seems to make a sound across the creaky floorboards of the turn of the last century apartment building and it is not all wholly mundane. She seems to slip out of focus around the edges of vision, slip out of mind when she goes into the kitchen to fetch some tea.
"It sounds a little silly to admit, but that is why I took up dancing, the lights, the music, the story, all focus the attention of the crowd beyond what my wallflower power can hide." She laughs quietly. "I mean that is probably not the technical term for it, but if I were a Power Ranger my color would be beige or cream."
"Nothing wrong with beige," Lydia says stoutly.
Part of you wonders why she does not dress more obviously if it bothers her, but you do not want to put your foot in your mouth even if she is just eight months older than you, the youngest adult in the Order. Instead you note: "You could be one of those Ninja Rangers, like from the new one, Power Rangers Ninja Storm."
"There is a new Power Rangers?" Olivia asks, startled.
"Sure, they are always making new ones, they cost like fifty cents and a pack of gum per episode to produce..."
"And are they actual ninjas or still wearing primary colors?"
"They are ninjas in spirit," you giggle.
You do give some thought to poor Anna as her eyes start to glaze over, but it's been a long time since you have been able to talk Power Rangers 'lore' with anyone and Lydia is such a perfect straight woman for the sillier parts of the show.
She wasnt at the first Order meeting where we raised the household god, we met her later.
Molly isnt her bosom buddyy, but they are at some degree of friendliness. And she's apparently even closer to Lydia.

3)Also?
Two people have already copied that version of stunt. I dont think its currently worthwhile to change it
 
Last edited:
[X] Offer to buy him a car as soon as he gets his license, you have the money and you can make more
-[X]Empathy Excellency
-[X]STUNT: You hiss melodramatically at him, clawed hands outstretched. "Its my precious. Mine! Nasty hobbitses cant have it. Gollum, Gollum." You hold the pose and a straight face for almost five seconds, then Olivia bounces an empty beer can off your head, and all of you simultaneously crack up. In a more normal voice, you continue. "Yeah well, I can drive, and according to the Illnois Secretary of State's office, you can't. Yet." Daniel makes a face at you, and you stick your tongue back out at him before continuing. "Get your license, and I'll see about buying you wheels."
 
[X] In the time honored tradition of younger siblings getting the hand me downs of their elders, once Daniel gets his driver's license you will give him the Beige Wagon, with the understanding that he will care for it properly and eventually pass it down to a younger sibling himself once he has the means to acquire his own vehicle.
Why though?

Molly made 450k from diamonds this month, after taxes and expenses, including Thomas' cut.
Thats a net income of 2.7 million dollars every year if she only does it every other month, 5.4 million a year if she does it monthly. And its not the only income avenue open to Molly.

Molly herself is driving a sports car that went for around 130k new iirc, and would still be worth around 80-100k on the open market for a low mileage example.

The Toyota Echo subcompact was around 11k new.
en.m.wikipedia.org

Toyota Platz - Wikipedia



Its small, its barebones, its driver safety measures are pretty minimal, with a used car rater putting it at 2/5 in the event of an accident. Its associated with Molly, so people may well target it thinking Molly is inside it.
What is the justification for handing this down?

Its not that we lack the money to pay for something modern.
Its not that we value a low profile over personal or family safety.
Its not even that we are trying to lord shit over him.

So why?
 
Lol. :V

God, a classic Beetle as a daily driver is essentially a death trap.
I have no idea how Dresden survived driving that car for more than a decade with everyone who tried to kill him inside it.
Especially given that he's six feet nine inches tall.

Once we get enough cash in 2007, Im voting for stuffing him into a warded Lexus or a Yukon as a daily driver.
At least that should have legroom. And poor Mouse will actually be able to ride.
If we do replace the beetle for harry we should melt down the old one to make parts for his new vehicle, it's bound to have picked up some sort of mythic narrative from everything he's put it through.
 
Honestly this makes alchemy and Enchanting basically a none option. Way way to much XP 50+ to get to good stuff, and worse even more valuable AP. That is at least two 5 dot charms.
Could I see your math? Because I don't agree.

We get sleep reduction at 6 XP spent, i.e. right here. That's +7 waking hours per day, assuming Molly slept 8 hours per day normally. We got 6 AP with 16 hours awake previously. That's 2.7 hours per AP. This means that we should reasonably expect to get 7/2.7=2.6 = 2 (rounding down) bonus AP. Assume 1 AP is spent on actually making the potions. That's still 1 AP increase overall. Even if this AP is specialized, because it'd be at night, that's a big plus.

Now, XP calculations:
We spent 6 XP already. To get to alchemy 5 we'll need:
6 XP to alchemy 3 9/2=4.5=4 XP to alchemy 4
12 XP to alchemy 5
22 XP total left to spend, 28 XP total.
We get 3 free recipes per dot. This is much more versatile than most 5 dot charms, except Kingdom one. And by getting the kingdom charm we essentially negate the issue of alchemical recipes, if we take advanced technology, and fluff the realm to have alchemists loyal to us in large numbers, who will share their recipes with us. Why is this much more versatile? Well, here's the quote from QM about what we get at 5 dots:
Theoretically yes, magical awakening, perfect immortality, creating entirely new forms of supernatural being that are self-sustaining are all within the grasp of alchemy. Practically that is not something that is easy to make even if you have the dots for it (Alchemy 5) and it requires rare and valuable reagents

Let me rephrase; it's not a sin I care about. This isn't exactly a clean problem, so the solution won't be perfect for everyone. One person suffering social consequences is one is the lowest prices possible for this sort of thing.
It's not one person, though? It's her entire social circle. There are enough skavis and other types of whamps running around for them to have peer groups in Chicago, in which the type of awakening you have (i.e. "how you murder someone") are discussed, planned and determine one's social standing. MMP and a bit of social engineering ("I got to have a meal with the new and ultra-cool celestial demon queen! She personally made me dinner! And I got my powers out of it, and my hunger is super easy to control now!" talk writes itself) can totally solve the whole issue.
White vamps don't get mutated that way normally per that last ruling, but I think feeding someone a magical mutagen related to the darker aspects of their spirit to fuel a pretty significant magical transformation based on the same is something it's reasonable to have reservations about.
White whamps don't. Fledgelings do become something else:
The philosophical questions of choice, free will, and resisting duress when making choices are pretty central to Butcher's universe. Murder is a pretty big sin, even if the outcome was not intended (for white court scions who were kept in the dark about their condition). I assume that the metaphysical corruption / damnation / damage caused to one's soul for becoming a murderer gives White Hunger more power over influencing their host (sorry, this sentence is very clunky, I mean that White Hunger might affect their host more easily if the host killed someone during the initiation). Same with the evil nature of Red Court vampires - the murder as choice (and it's more explicit with them).

This leads to the question of "what happens if one undergoes the initiation / transformation without having to give into the demon at all".
Given that the mechanism for not giving in would have to do with primordial Essence and the nature of that Essence being transformational I think it is a fair guess that something unusual would happen
I would appreciate Citation.
Here:
IIRC, you dont have to buy a ritual.
As long as you are on the same level of dots? You can perform it for a +1DC increase in difficulty.
I really want a confirmation on that. If so, this makes alchemy a must get. @DragonParadox ?
I'll be honest given the sheer scale of what can be done with sorcery peculiarly as an exalted I think it would be rather overpowered to have every possible ritual of a level available. I mean potential rituals are only limited by the broad paradigm and the imagination of the player. This feels like how you get Mage's crafting 'rules'. I think it is a lot more balanced and thematic to give you guys some rituals to start with and then you can collect others in play.

So yeah, we DO need to find a way to awaken her without killing people other than "Things Morally worse than Mind control"
So, let's actually brainstorm what we can do about it with our toolset. What do we want? To feed her hunger, in a way that is at least somewhat moral, and ideally leads to her being loyal to us. We definitely want to avoid mortal deaths.

What tools do we have that are at least somewhat related to the task? We have alchemy 2. We know that in canon Dresden potions to "make yourself fall in love with someone" are possible and are within Dresden's repertoire. We could probably kitbash a potion to make someone feel temporary despair with Bob's help, and/or with a Crown's question. Whether this would be Alchemy 2 or 3 is a question, but definitely not higher. I would argue that this is alchemy 2. Perfect hangover cure is alchemy 1, so some sort of addiction remover is probably alchemy 1/2. So we could, in principle, engineer something where we give a volunteer with a lot of life force (ourselves?) a potion to feel despair with no lasting consequences, and let the girl feed on them. That would be at least an AP worth of action, however, I feel. Might still be worth it - we are kinda obligated to do it, as per taking her into our service.

Alternatively, we need to work out how to string her along until we get both the Kingdom and MMP for synergy, or at least MMP. So at least a month, likely 3 (until christmas). Occult research could be utilized for this, probably. As in "research occult elder lore, and we'll do a grand ritual with you later" something like this. We'll need to keep her occupied, at least.
 
Its small, its barebones, its driver safety measures are pretty minimal, with a used car rater putting it at 2/5 in the event of an accident. Its associated with Molly, so people may well target it thinking Molly is inside it.
What is the justification for handing this down?

Its not that we lack the money to pay for something modern.
Its not that we value a low profile over personal or family safety.
Its not even that we are trying to lord shit over him.

So why?
Usual procedure.

First-time drivers get an older/cheaper car, because they are more likely to damage it.
Not necessarily in serious accidents, but often enough in minor stuff like parking in and out or some other miscalculation.

I don't think I know anybody who didn't scratch up their car in the first few years at least once or twice.

So you drive something unspectacular until you actually have a few years worth of experience on the road.
 
Usual procedure.
First-time drivers get an older/cheaper car, because they are more likely to damage it.
Not necessarily in serious accidents, but often enough in minor stuff like parking in and out or some other miscalculation.

I don't think I know anybody who didn't scratch up their car in the first few years at least once or twice.
So you drive something unspectacular until you actually have a few years worth of experience on the road.
Thank you for the reply.However, that isnt accurate for the US.
Chicago has better public transport options than most of the US, and regardless of that, cars arent a luxury here like in much of Europe, but a necessity.

Teenagers customarily start out driving with their parents vehicles, regardless of how expensive they are, and get older/cheaper cars only because their families/their finances generally cant afford anything better. Those teenagers and young adults who can get new cars typically some of the most car-proud people around.

This is also true for first-time drivers; nobody buys an older/cheaper car as a daily driver to get experience.
Not here.

===
If he manages to scratch it up even with a cyberdevil giving him driver assist, he saves his allowance and gets it fixed. Or drives it as is. Its a learning opportunity. Or we make a sibling bonding occasion of it and both of us work to fix it at home with Tool Constructs.
Money at this level is not a concern for Molly any more.

I dont know if Rosie can even drive yet, and she certainly hasnt been doing it recently. And yet we certainly arent going to stick her and her newborn in an old, cheap car because she might scratch it. Thats what car insurance is for. Shit, if that was a major concern of ours, we'd be looking for a used car to rebuild if our time wasnt literally worth more than the money right now.

If we do replace the beetle for harry we should melt down the old one to make parts for his new vehicle, it's bound to have picked up some sort of mythic narrative from everything he's put it through.
Nah.
You buy a mid-high end, reliable car in the 60-70k range off the shelf and enchant it; with any luck it and its electronics will last him ten to twenty years before the electronics become so outdated that we have to convince him to get a replacement.

Its going to be difficult enough to convince him to take it; convincing him to melt down his old car is just adding extra steps of difficulty to the process.
Thank you.
 
Last edited:
So, let's actually brainstorm what we can do about it with our toolset.
My idea is to have her feed on Molly while Molly is in a vat of Bleach.

This would heal Molly and provide her with power. The mental effect would be taken care of via IPM.

Ofc feeding on an Infernal is dicy at best. Feeding on one while while it is plugged into a spiritual center of the cosmos is....yeah.

Especially since Molly's Essence is a mix of Nuclear Hate Fire and Spitefully Cursed Ice.
 
Last edited:
Actually @DragonParadox what damage does a WVamp do when feeding? Bashing or lethal? Would being submerged help heal faster than she can eat?

Also would the plan work? Can they feed on Infernal Essence? Would IPM stop her from feeding?

There are two ways described in the books.

Hungry Dead.
Infernals: Each point of stolen Infernal Essence
grants one point of Yin Chi and one point of Yang Chi, but this Chi is poisonous and defiled, and inflicts intense misery and considerable injury upon any vampire foolish enough to consume it, save for certain akuma or follow￾ers of the Scorpion Eater Dharma. For the mechanical consequences of imbibing defiled Chi, see p. page 383.
Vampires
With one terribly severe exception, vampires find
the blood of the Chosen exceptionally nourishing. For each health level of lethal damage inflicted by a vam￾pire's Kiss, the vampire gains three blood points when feeding on Dragon-Blooded, Lunars, Sidereals, Abys￾sals, Infernals, Liminals, and Alchemicals. Not only that, but a vampire who kills a Terrestrial Exalt through exsanguination absorbs the barest shadow of the power of Exaltation, lowering their Generation by one for a number of nights equal to his victim's Essence rating.

The Solar Exalted form the major exception to this trend. The power of the sun hums in their veins, and any vampire drinking a Solar's blood suffers one level of aggravated damage for each blood point they try to consume. This is considered damage from sunlight, for the purpose of Fortitude and the Setite clan weakness.
 
My idea is to have her feed on Molly while Molly is in a vat of Bleach.

This would heal Molly and provide her with power. The mental effect would be taken care of via IPM.

Ofc feeding on an Infernal is dicy at best. Feeding on one while while it is plugged into a spiritual center of the cosmos is....yeah.

Especially since Molly's Essence is a mix of Nuclear Hate Fire and Spitefully Cursed Ice.
It was established that she can't feed on Molly:
Instead of answering you grab the girl's arm, wrenching her off the table, leaving her reeling whether by the violence of the act or the sound of the glass coffee table shattering she finally breaks eye contact with her victim. Alas for her she then makes eye contact with you and tries to pull power from the well of your soul.

"Had you not warded your mind she might well be convulsing at the touch of chi too harsh for her palette," Usum notes clinically, really not what you need right now.
Our chi is too harsh for her. Whether this is because of infernal flavor, or because she's a lowly demonblood trying to feed on the celestial exalted grade essence is a separate issue. Lydia, as a terrestrial-grade exalt and conceptually aligned with despair (because death is connected to despair) might be swingable, but I certainly won't even ask her to subject herself to soul-crushing despair for some random girl. Molly would probably need to create some sort of filtering and dilluting ritual to be able to feed the girl. If we collaborate with Harry we could probably make something.
 
Actually @DragonParadox what damage does a WVamp do when feeding? Bashing or lethal? Would being submerged help heal faster than she can eat?

Also would the plan work? Can they feed on Infernal Essence? Would IPM stop her from feeding?

There are two ways described in the books.

Hungry Dead.

Vampires

They do temp willpower damage at first, then once they really get going they start doing permanent willpower damage and when that hits zero you are dead. They also cannot feed from Molly because her Essence is made of endless darkness and radioactive hate. Not in the least compatible with the phage. It would be like a human trying to eat a radioactive core for the energy inside.
 
Forgot we had that. Would need liquid despair + Life energy but that would be blowing it on her.

Then again, we are not using it for anything.....
 
Back
Top