Status
Not open for further replies.
You can argue about the nuances of Many Worlds Interpretation all you want, but please keep in mind that in this story My Little Pony is a real place where magical ponies frolic and learn about the magic of friendship, and you can go there, if you want.

Now I'm not a scientist, but I'm pretty sure Many Worlds Interpretation can't explain pony magic.
"So how does magic work, Twilight?"

"Oh, magic doesn't actually exist."

"What."

"The universe is constantly dividing into innumerable quantum universes, and there are always a tiny percentage of those universes where by sheer chance events that look like magic occur. By sheer coincidence we have always been in the universes where those pseudo-magic events happen. We are simply a very low-probability timeline."

"What."

"Of course, in the vast majority of divergent universes those pseudo-magical events stop happening and pony civilization collapses because our 'magic' no longer works."
 
The way I see it, time and causality act much like lightning and photosynthesis- at first, every possible route is explored, but at the end, the most efficient routes (or the only ones that make it to the end) retroactively become the only routes taken. IMO, what most people perceive as free will is simply the result of ignorance, as all outcomes have a reason for such, even if that reason doesn't make any sense. Your decisions are based on your own criteria and circumstances, and you will change it depending on certain variables and changes. That does not necessarily mean that our wills are irrelevant; on the contrary, it means that our wills are predetermined not by outside forces, but by our own values and beliefs. Destiny is determined by our own wills, even if it is inevitable. Or at least that is what I believe.
 
Last edited:
Multiple Worlds theory could be the reason, but by that logic our current reality could be the 0.000000... 000001 percent chance that no one has jumped at just the right angle to achieve levitation.

Not really the best analogy, since originally in DC comics Black Condor could fly just because he was raised by birds, and the Top gained psychic powers, enhanced intelligence, and superhuman speed by just spinning.

As bad as they are, this seems to be a bit too specific to be the Guardians;
I'm betting on the Controllers; cue Massive disapointment for Paul

If the controllers thought that humanity was a problem they'd send a suneater to destroy the entire solar system, they broke off from the Guardians because they thought the Guardians are too nice. Let me repeat, the Guardians are too nice in the Controllers opinion.
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
I am beginning to suspect that OL being Outside Fate has had a larger impact on his ability to mass produce tech than we thought. Think about it, in this universe great scientists are Fated to be un-appreciated, denied research grants, shunned and ignored by big business. OL, being Outside Fate, is ignored by the normal mediating effects that keep the status quo. Grayven on the other hand, is not. If I'm right, this means that there is a practical upper limit to what the universe will allow Grayven to achieve without intervening while for Paul there is not.

I'm gonna avoid making jokes about Nabu for a minute and ask why you think OL is outside of fate?

Even if you wanna make the argument that he is because he isn't a native of universe 16, he's been taking in stuff from said universe(notably food and the orange light) and has a major league cosmic entity lending out a vital organ to act as his soul.
 
OL's name is, from what I recall, not written in the Book of Destiny. Zatanna tried looking it up earlier in the story.
Here:

"Probably not, but I am rather tired of this whole situation. Do you know a spell for revealing the name of a person by looking at them?"

"I.. could.. probably... Ekat-."

"Wait, wait!" I lie fully on the floor. Sure, my environmental shield would probably stay active if I blacked out again, but no sense taking unnecessary risks. "Okay, go."

"Ekat sih eman morf eht Koob fo Ynitsed!"

I wait for something to happen. I don't think I've moved...

"Paul?"

"Still with you. Get anything?"

"No. I don't think I can have done it right."
 
Even if you wanna make the argument that he is because he isn't a native of universe 16, he's been taking in stuff from said universe(notably food and the orange light) and has a major league cosmic entity lending out a vital organ to act as his soul.
There's people native to that universe which aren't in the book either, there's no reason this would happen unless you go full "copy someone else soul" à la Grayven. Also isn't the Ophidian more of an attachment rather than his soul?
 
There's also the fact that Time Travellers remembered a universe without him, indicating that he might not be completely hooked into earth 16's causality (Truggs, Kadabra). If causality itself can't get a complete hold on him then he should be immune to prophesy. The book of Destiny makes perfect sense if this is true.

That Lord of Chaos who has no death written in the book of destiny can die by his hand because all of that prophesy depends on a causal universe. Ragnarok would be the same deal. If the effect is strong enough to throw off physical-temoporal reactions then magic-temporal reactions don't stand a chance.
 
There's also the fact that Time Travellers remembered a universe without him, indicating that he might not be completely hooked into earth 16's causality (Truggs, Kadabra). If causality itself can't get a complete hold on him then he should be immune to prophesy. The book of Destiny makes perfect sense if this is true.
Time travel (backward) probably just create a new divergent timeline.
 
But as we've learned anyone on Earth 16 who insists on proper scientific procedure is likely under the control of a Starro, so it's probably for the best.
Can this be harnessed to create Starro tech from people who try to apply scientific principles? If the Star Hunters had got away, would they have taken one of the scientists with them to gradually produce infinite amounts of Starro tech? Maybe this is how they amassed so much in the first place, because OL did mention that there was a lot more than he would have thought should have been left after the Light used it.
 
Time travel (backward) probably just create a new divergent timeline.
What you are suggesting would be reverse causality. He did not exist in the timeline they came from. If there wasn't something going on, causality should ensure that time travellers in the world he arrived in should not remember a world where he does not exist. Causality flows one way, except for backwards time travel and the changes that are caused by Paul's existence should propagate instantly through all of future time unless there is something actively preventing that.

It is confusing because we are talking about three distinct means of reality manipulation. OL's appearance should create a world or set of worlds where from a future observer's point of view he always showed up, making him and every change he makes part of all future spacetime for every part of earth 16 unless you have alternate earth 16s where he did not show up, in which case you would have time travellers unaware of OL show up in the world where he does not exist. Unless something very very weird is going on with time, destiny, and prophesy. Either OL has this effect or something is imposing it around him.
 
Family Day (part 10)
25th April
09:35 GMT -6


"I already heard part of that story from Magnificus."

Venus nods. "I didn't.. know about the test subjects.. at the time. Thaddeus had a lot of data on fetal development and.. I believed him when he said his techniques would ensure that our children had the best start in life they could get."

Beautia leans forward and pats her mother on the left arm with her right hand. "Mom, I started work in a hospital as a fully qualified MD at seventeen. I'd say it worked."

"There's.. more to life than how quickly you can start work. Your social skills may be better than your father's, but I still had to drag you out of your laboratory to go and make friends. And Paul's the first boyfriend you've ever brought home to meet the family."

"Mom."

I reach back with my left arm, putting it around her shoulder. "Do you know exactly what he did?"

"Thaddeus… He thought normal zygote selection techniques were wasteful. You have to fertilise a lot of eggs and then test them… So he did a full genetic work up of both of us and used that to calculate the optimal-" Mmmmmmmmmm! "-combination of genetic characteristics and womb conditions." She leans forward slightly. "And -let me tell you- I wasn't exactly flattered by that. Making a child is a very chemically complicated business, but Thaddeus was on top of it. I must have taken more dietary supplements during those nine months than the rest of my life put together."

"That sounds a bit…"

"He was.. trying to help. To do something good. And if anyone had actually been prepared to invest in the technology he developed we could have eliminated congenital deformity worldwide by now."

"And.. the Beresfords?"

"He never exactly said he was going to give our children super powers, just that they'd be as fit and healthy as humanly possible. I suppose he.. just had higher standards for Humans."

"I've certainly never had a problem with my strength."

Venus looks less certain. "You didn't have to breast feed two-" Beautia and I both cringe. "-super strong children." She notices our reaction and smiles. "Thaddeus ended up developing a sort of super resilient rubber nipple cover-" We cringe more as she mimes. "-which seemed to do the trick, but it still wasn't exactly comfortable. Fortunately, you both learned a degree of self control and spatial awareness before you did too much damage to our home. I don't know how the… How Missus Beresford managed with that."

"Breast pump and putting them on formula early. Please don't ask me how I know that." She was perfectly happy to talk, but her alcohol-lubricated ramblings were somewhat disjointed. Still, her children's rehabilitation is.. if not going well, then at least going. Magnificus has actually phoned them a few times, and his sheer condescension has spurred Tuppence into paying attention in class. "Their father used to take them out to an abandoned quarry where they could cut loose with their full strength." Which is almost certainly where the positive association with smashing comes from.

Beautia shrugs. "I never really cared about being strong. Dad.. emphasised intellectual development. I suppose I always thought that I was as strong as I'd ever need to be so I may as well focus on things that actually interested me."

"And.. Magnificus? I'd have thought.. at school…"

"We were always the youngest in our year. It wasn't such a big deal for me, but for him being shorter than the other guys.. did give him a few problems. And then he was.. too strong. If he got into a fight-"

Venus nods. "And that happened a few times."

"-he wouldn't just win, he'd mop the floor with them. He found it pretty hard to make friends."

"He was too clever for other children his age and too young for the other children in his classes." Two nods. "I suppose that.. in a way, Hugo Danner was luckier. He only outclassed the people around him physically."

Beautia rests her head on my arm. "I suppose that's why -despite everything- we've stayed so close as a family."

"Despite half of the family being supervillains?"

"Would you rather I leave Georgia and Thaddeus Junior with only their father for guidance? I'm not happy about the path they've chosen… But at least this way I can make sure that they're not doing anything too crazy."

"We're the only other people we all know who can understand what we're working on. Who can keep up with us when we start working on something beyond cutting edge."

"I've got the shade of Thomas Morrow on call. He's the only expert on thaumorobotics on the planet."

"I didn't say there weren't other people, just that we're the ones we know best. And there aren't many."

I nod. "Okay. Your father clearly had no illusions about his own physical attractiveness if he selected genes for appearance mostly from-" I indicate Venus with my right hand. "-you. Then why-?"

Venus raises her eyebrows. "Why do Thaddeus Junior and Georgia look like him with hair and him in drag respectively?"

"I wasn't going to put it quite that harshly, but… Yes, basically."

"That.. was.. when Thaddeus started to go more and more… Off. Our first children had the best of everything. With them… He said that if he compromised on some characteristics he could enhance certain others. Genes don't code for characteristics, they code for chemicals, so it seemed reasonable." Venus looks a little down, then perks up slightly. "Of course, since they didn't have super strength it was a lot easier on my-."

"Mom!"

"Thaddeus said that since intellectual ability was more useful for influencing the world than physical appearance he needed to do everything he could to maximise their intellectual development. Including discouraging them to have anything much to do with other children." She sighs again. "They both have better social awareness than he does, but otherwise… They have the same relentless, ruthless intellect that he has. Has now."

I frown. "But the Danner Formula wouldn't have made them less intelligent. It doesn't.. affect that at all. Unless he had some other alchemical formula for augmenting their brains."

"He said… And this wasn't until after the divorce. Because if he'd told me beforehand it would have caused the divorce. He said that that by denying them the ability to rely on their physical abilities, he was forcing them to rely on their intellect for everything. They weren't designed to be all that much more intelligent than Beautia and Magnificus, they were designed to be better motivated."

It makes a creepy kind of sense. "No one would give them anything, so they'd have to learn to take it." I frown. "That's-."

She nods. "Supervillain thinking. I've tried to encourage them to do other things… But.. it.. hasn't really worked. Particularly after the divorce. Thaddeus wanted to keep contact and.. he could help them with their projects more than I could. And then by the time he went full supervillain they were closer to him than ever." She looks pensive. "They sent me a message after Thaddeus disappeared to let me know they were alright, but this will be the first time I've seen them since then."

"Are they going to be alright with me being here?"

"I don't… They probably won't resent you more than they would resent anyone else." She takes a deep breath and then slowly exhales. "Okay, that's enough about my family. Why don't you tell me about yours?"
 
Last edited:
25th April
09:35 GMT -6


"I already heard part of that story from Magnificus."

Venus nods. "I didn't.. know about the test subjects.. at the time. Thaddeus had a lot of data on fetal development and.. I believed him when he said his techniques would ensure that our children had the best start in life they could get."

Beautia leans forward and pats her mother on the left arm with her right hand. "Mom, I started work in a hospital as a fully qualified MD at seventeen. I'd say it worked."

"There's.. more to life than how quickly you can start work. Your social skills may be better than your fathers, but I still had to drag you out of your laboratory to go and make friends. And Paul's the first boyfriend you've ever brought home to meet the family."

"Mom."

I reach back with my left arm, putting it around her shoulder. "Do you know exactly what he did?"

"Thaddeus… He though normal zygote selection techniques were wasteful. You have to fertilise a lot of eggs and then test them… So he did a full genetic work up of both of us and used that to calculate the optimal-" Mmmmmmmmmm! "-combination of genetic characteristics and womb conditions." She leans forward slightly. "And -let me tell you- I wasn't exactly flattered by that. Making a child is a very chemically complicated business, but Thaddeus was on top of it. I must have taken more dietary supplements during those nine months than the rest of my life put together."

"That sounds a bit…"

"He was.. trying to help. To do something good. And if anyone had actually been prepared to invest in the technology he developed we could have eliminated congenital deformity worldwide by now."

"And.. the Beresfords?"

"He never exactly said he was going to give our children super powers, just that they'd be as fit and healthy as humanly possible. I suppose he.. just had higher standards for Humans."

"I've certainly never had a problem with my strength."

Venus looks less certain. "You didn't have to breast feed two-" Beautia and I both cringe. "-super strong children." She notices our reaction and smiles. "Thaddeus ended up developing a sort of super resilient rubber nipple cover-" We cringe more as she mimes. "-which seemed to do the trick, but it still wasn't exactly comfortable. Fortunately, you both learned a degree of self control and spatial awareness before you did too much damage to our home. I don't know how the… How Missus Beresford managed with that."

"Breast pump and putting them on formula early. Please don't ask me how I know that." She was perfectly happy to talk, but her alcohol-lubricated ramblings were somewhat disjointed. Still, her children's rehabilitation is.. if not going well, then at least going. Magnificus has actually phoned them a few times, and his sheer condescension has spurred Tuppence into paying attention in class. "Their father used to take them out to an abandoned quarry where they could cut lose with their full strength." Which is almost certainly where the positive association with smashing comes from.

Beautia shrugs. "I never really cared about being strong. Dad.. emphasised intellectual development. I suppose I always thought that I was as strong as I'd ever need to be so I may as well focus on things that actually interested me."

"And.. Magnificus? I'd have thought.. at school…"

"We were always the youngest in our year. It wasn't such a big deal for me, but for him being shorter than the other guys.. did give him a few problems. And then he was.. too strong. If he got into a fight-"

Venus nods. "And that happened a few times."

"-he wouldn't just win, he'd mop the floor with them. He found it pretty hard to make friends."

"He was too clever for other children his age and too young for the other children in his classes." Two nods. "I suppose that.. in a way, Hugo Danner was luckier. He only outclassed the people around him physically."

Beautia rests her head on my arm. "I suppose that's why -despite everything- we've stayed so close as a family."

"Despite half of the family being supervillains?"

"Would you rather I leave Georgia and Thaddeus Junior with only their father for guidance? I'm not happy about the path they've chosen… But at least this way I can make sure that they're not doing anything too crazy."

"We're the only other people we all know who can understand what we're working on. Who can keep up with us when we start working on something beyond cutting edge."

"I've got the shade of Thomas Morrow on call. He's the only expert on thaumorobotics on the planet."

"I didn't say there weren't other people, just that we're the ones we know best. And there aren't many."

I nod. "Okay. Your father clearly had no illusions about his own physical attractiveness if he selecting genes for appearance mostly from-" I indicate Venus with my right hand. "-you. Then why-?"

Venus raises her eyebrows. "Why do Thaddeus Junior and Georgia look like him with hair and him in drag respectively?"

"I wasn't going to put it quite that harshly, but… Yes, basically."

"That.. was.. when Thaddeus started to go more and more… Off. Our first children had the best of everything. With them… He said that if he compromised on some characteristics he could enhance certain others. Genes don't code for characteristics, they code for chemicals, so it seemed reasonable." Venus looks a little down, then perks up slightly. "Of course, since they didn't have super strength it was a lot easier on my-."

"Mom!"

"Thaddeus said that since intellectual ability was more useful for influencing the world than physical appearance he needed to do everything he could to maximise their intellectual development. Including discouraging them to have anything much to do with other children." She sighs again. "They both have better social awareness than he does, but otherwise… They have the same relentless, ruthless intellect that he has. Has now."

I frown. "But the Danner Formula wouldn't have made them less intelligent. It doesn't.. affect that at all. Unless he had some other alchemical formula for augmenting their brains."

"He said… And this wasn't until after the divorce. Because if he'd told me beforehand it would have caused the divorce. He said that that by denying them the ability to rely on their physical abilities, he was forcing them to rely on their intellect for everything. They weren't designed to be all that much more intelligent than Beautia and Magnificus, they were designed to be better motivated."

It makes a creepy kind of sense. "No one would given them anything, so they'd have to learn to take it." I frown. "That's-."

She nods. "Supervillain thinking. I've tried to encourage them to do other things… But.. it.. hasn't really worked. Particularly after the divorce. Thaddeus wanted to keep contact and.. he could help them with their projects more than I could. And then by the time he went full supervillain they were closer to him than ever." She looks pensive. "They sent me a message after Thaddeus disappeared to let me know they were alright, but this will be the first time I've seen them since then."

"Are they going to be alright with me being here?"

"I don't… They probably won't resent you more than they would resent anyone else." She takes a deep breath and then slowly exhales. "Okay, that's enough about my family. Why don't you tell me about yours?"
I wonder how they will react when they find out that he can give them the Danner powers.
 
physical attractiveness if he selecting genes for appearance
if he selected genes for
"No one would given them anything, so they'd have
would have given them

Seems easier to go mechanical womb for creating babies with super-strength, but perhaps the concept wasn't thought up at the time? Would also be easier to maintain a desired level of chemicals and environmental conditions, come to think of it.
 
if he selected genes for
would have given them
Thank you, corrected.
Seems easier to go mechanical womb for creating babies with super-strength, but perhaps the concept wasn't thought up at the time? Would also be easier to maintain a desired level of chemicals and environmental conditions, come to think of it.
He was concerned that the Danner Formula needed a living mother due to magic.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top