all fictions
I hate you! (it's not against the rules!)
- Location
- Mons Regius
- Pronouns
- He/Him
That's one weird way of reading what I said and what I linked. I said many people missed what that scene meant watching it, and then I referenced another scene of internal monologue from the VN that maybe should have been kept for viewers to make sense of that earlier scene and Shirou's psychology.Then @all fictions says that Nasu demanded nothing to be replaced,
That Nasu was satisfied with it is one completely separate thing from the argument I was making since I did not say the scene in itself was bad, only that viewers got confused.
Maybe try not to reduct posts to the most uncharitable reading? Or at least not cut up a whole argument to just one of its point? You fear being dogpiled but then you do this like you are trying to bait people.
Nasu literally explains in depth what he means, and seeing as you played the VN, you should get why (hint: PTSD).Also, let me just be baffled by that. "Shirou should never smile"? That is probably the chuuniest thing I've ever heard, even after playing the source material.
Last edited: