Most magic systems don't have 'put yourself in danger' as the default requirement for initiation, though! We didn't need a laboratory setting for Viscerality and we wouldn't need one for a Mortal Order or Maskcraft.The fact is, we're not going to get another ideal laboratory setting. With an expert such as this present, or with such a sizable store of Import. And it took a lot of omake and quality discussion by the players to reach this point.
First of all, why ever not? We're going to keep making masks, we're going to keep exploring things, the dreamland we're going to return to at some point is potentially made of identity (since our cohesiveness therein was identity-y)... There will be other options! Also, this isn't one of those options! I don't think Facelessness manipulation is Identity manipulation. If you can manipulate acid, you don't have control over paper. If you were proposing exposing Dorian to dangerous quantities of identity through a specialist Mask, I'd understand that, at least, but the evidence suggests Facelessness is a substance that harms identity, not a negative quantity identity in-itself (If it was the latter, it would deplete over time as it came in contact with Identity and mutually annihilated!)Identity mechanics repeatedly comes up in the lore. There never will be another moment quite like this to delve into it, to realise the start of our endgame vision of a Dorian with multiple fixated masks.
No, see, I genuinely think it's middling because I don't see reason to believe it would have any benefits beyond creating facelessness (Artificer's!), moving facelessness (probably possible with a vacuum-like artificer's without a generator!), and being a bit better at Masks due to the moving facelessness part. Which is Okay, but Middling.It's uncertain yes, but middling? It's not your preferred option but please don't intentionally downplay the potential of things.
It probably greater lets us employ war crimes imagine someone with faceless powers with an identity and the ability of logical thought. Given I doubt we'd spec into a route like that but its probably an avenue.Most magic systems don't have 'put yourself in danger' as the default requirement for initiation, though! We didn't need a laboratory setting for Viscerality and we wouldn't need one for a Mortal Order or Maskcraft.or lycantrophy.
Also, this is not an ideal laboratory setting. We've got like... 3 days, I think? For mentalism Maybe you could say it's ideal, but even then, we're not reinforced against it! This isn't a ideal laboratory, it's a mad scientist's shed.
First of all, why ever not? We're going to keep making masks, we're going to keep exploring things, the dreamland we're going to return to at some point is potentially made of identity (since our cohesiveness therein was identity-y)... There will be other options! Also, this isn't one of those options! I don't think Facelessness manipulation is Identity manipulation. If you can manipulate acid, you don't have control over paper. If you were proposing exposing Dorian to dangerous quantities of identity through a specialist Mask, I'd understand that, at least, but the evidence suggests Facelessness is a substance that harms identity, not a negative quantity identity in-itself (If it was the latter, it would deplete over time as it came in contact with Identity and mutually annihilated!)
No, see, I genuinely think it's middling because I don't see reason to believe it would have any benefits beyond creating facelessness (Artificer's!), moving facelessness (probably possible with a vacuum-like artificer's without a generator!), and being a bit better at Masks due to the moving facelessness part. Which is Okay, but Middling.
It probably greater lets us employ war crimes imagine someone with faceless powers with an identity and the ability of logical thought. Given I doubt we'd spec into a route like that but its probably an avenue.
But worse war crimes.We can already do war crimes but we don't want to because they're war crimes
Make a mask of our identity maybe as a worse case scenario. Not sure how viable this is though since we are already short on time and making them a mask.In case that we go into the fire, we should consider saving some of our memories in case we do lose them. Supernatural means would be preferred, a some kind of mask that can just give us back memories or skills(should we lose them) on touch, but in case we can't manage that a more mundane means of just writing important stuff down would be great. It would suck if we lost our understand of how Street works or memories of our family, etc.
We might consider creating a mask that would help us here. Now, in general the entire purposes of masks is to fight back Facelessness, however given our skill level it should be possible to create a somewhat faulty mask that barely does that, while still providing some kind of useful power. Ideally it would be something that would still protect us from secondary effects of getting blasted by Facelessness, however in a pinch a buff to Visceralism might be useful, as its abilities might flare up in the face of Facelessness.
We could lend Mooneater to someone and have them project images of our loved ones to act as an anchor while we are getting blasted.
Waiting for Musorov to finish first is a natural step here. If his own procedure goes well he can assist us in battling secondary effects of our own procedure, and if it is a complete fucking failure and he goes insane trying to kill everyone here, we might have bigger fish to fry. Likewise, copying Mentalism with Glass would allow us to copy mental defenses, although that goes back to issue of Masks being made to prevent this.
If there is a nearby subject i.e. some kind of captive werewolf, we might first do the procedure on them to see how the downsides manifest there, and afterwards we can copy their new powers to see how they work and maybe even use them for much more refined blasting instead of just cudgeling ourselves over the head with Artificer. Similarly we could start process with Artificer, see how it goes, and then make a specialized mask for the process so it does less damage.
In theory, we could consume the Marshwarden berry and go to the House while we are getting sandblasted, and use the House to center our identity while the process is happening
We can make masks relatively quickly with supplies, and this place should have them. That being said, Dorian 2.0 doesn't have a reason to put on identity mask of Dorian 1.0, so I don't view it as a viable strategy.Make a mask of our identity maybe as a worse case scenario. Not sure how viable this is though since we are already short on time and making them a mask.
eh Dorian 2.0 has plenty of reason too depending on the level of personality change the shift doesn't have to be significant.We can make masks relatively quickly with supplies, and this place should have them. That being said, Dorian 2.0 doesn't have a reason to put on identity mask of Dorian 1.0, so I don't view it as a viable strategy.
High levels of fixation might help us withstand the process though, and one of the benefits of the process might be loss of fixation. If that is the case we should pivot to either Fixating Artificer or some new mask that supports this power.
I think a mask of our own face would go a long way to preventing substantial differences in our mindset. We'll be subsumed by a caustic identity eating substance, one that has to fully flow through us for an extended period of time. Having what essentially amounts to a snapshot copy, should be a big help for recovering from any damage.
We know that lack of mask on Drethir leads to decay of personality, which ultimately turns one into a Faceless, a mask consuming horror. Now, it stands to a reason that Drethir has a constant level of Facelessness which people are exposed to and after some time succumb to, except for some reason it is fine to remove mask when the other people are not around. This means that Facelessness is not doing that much on its own, at least not at those levels, but is somewhat amplified by the presence of others.[ ] Masked - On Drethir, identity's not unlike a fleeting mist. Those who bare their face in public suffer existential decay, which if allowed to progress culminates in them becoming Faceless: shifting horrors that consume masks to regain some semblance of identity - ever ravenous, never sated. All sapient beings therefore have at least one mask, which has magical properties defined by its form, materials, and wearer; even intelligent animals have evolved carapaces or osseous structures on their heads to act as natural masks. Not unlike a cork in a tub, a mask seals its wearer's identity off and prevents its incremental leakage. It's safe to remove a mask when alone, and should be done with regularity, for the other side of a mask is Fixation: mask and man becoming one, distinct entity.
As a Masked, you're an exceptional individual; a carver and designer, as well as a revolutionary. When the Drethiri Empire began a culture of monopolization and replacement of tribal masks with ones that promoted prosocial behavior, you chose to oppose them and decided to become a rebel. Now, mortally wounded after an assassination gone wrong, the Street is your rescuer.
Thematically making a mask of our own face would go so hard. It's would a huge opportunity loss not to at this juncture. With Viscerality, it would be easier now too. Just peel off Dorian's face and keep it alive and self sustaining to keep his features pristine for the mask.
...An interesting theory! Birdsie has referred to it as Anti-Identity, but I suppose that could be part of the trick. The quote 'Even Satan thinks generating more Facelessness is distasteful', though, seems a bit less kayfabe-y.I believe that my conjecture is correct. "Facelessness", as we called it, is actually just raw identity energy and not some kind of antagonistic force.
Ah yeah, that would imply otherwise then....An interesting theory! Birdsie has referred to it as Anti-Identity, but I suppose that could be part of the trick. The quote 'Even Satan thinks generating more Facelessness is distasteful', though, seems a bit less kayfabe-y.
They wouldn't, they would just have close to zero identity, being an amorphous blob of hunger. The distinction here is between "identity energy" and "identity" where the later is formed out of the former but too much of the former can cause later to crumble. So horrors would be just raw identity energy to the point where any attempt at developing a semblance of identity is immediately eroded, which is why they seek out powerful enough established identity in form of a mask.Also, if it's raw identity, how would Faceless beings have 'negative' rather than 'zero' identity? Once their identity fell to 0, wouldn't the raw stuff of identity be more likely to stick to the identityless being or saturate it or something, rather than somehow invert it further?