but it quickly subsides in a short-lived burst of mental clarity even beyond what you already had
Well, that is certainly interesting. Flooding our head with madness, even in quantities that wouldn't cause a break, give us a small boost to SCIENCE! We really should become a Therapist, and feast on the natural madness of all our people.
Bit upset on how quickly we went to threatening. Oh sure, we COULD pry the answers from his mind, but that is a rather obviously evil approach, and would be rather likely to set him against us.
As for what we do now, I don't wana jump straight to Truth Serum. If answers are really needed, and nothing has developed in a day or two of normal interrogation, then maybe. Otherwise, nah.
[X] Pardon yourself for a moment and draw Gio aside to get the answers to the following conditions. Be sure to be out of the room, don't want the Paladin eaves-dropping
-[X] If the Trace spell doesn't require, or is aided by, having all 3 specimens, have the two currently unconscious intruders placed in the cells.
-[X] If the Trace Spell is liable to be detected from the other side, have some Civilian Mode Joes inconspicuously teleport into the general vicinity (like, within a few blocks) of the target and make their way there, and get satellite coverage of the location going.
-[X] If the Trace Spell isn't liable to be detected, hold off on any immediate action other than satellite coverage
-[X] After done talking with Gio, return to interrogating the Paladin.
--[X] "You seem to be either delusional, or TERRIBLY out of touch with current events. Maybe even not from this dimension, stranger things have happened. I will give you some basic information that you seem to be sorely lacking. One, we are not planning to take over the world, but to save it. Two, this base is meant to serve as the fore-front of the defense against Alien Threats. Three, we are supported and funded by the majority of the nations of the world, I highly doubt anyone would try to defend you if you tried to sabotage our efforts to protect humanity. Now, it seems fairly likely that you didn't intend to do evil, so I highly suggest you cooperate."
Any criticisms?