Status
Not open for further replies.
I could also give thought that we could use our own willingness to accept failure and point out that a defeat is an opportunity to learn and grow. Give some legitimate advice.
 
I could also give thought that we could use our own willingness to accept failure and point out that a defeat is an opportunity to learn and grow. Give some legitimate advice.
Exactly.
Either as genuine advise, or to make sure they keep growing and being worthy opponents.
If they get up and get better there will be fame in defeating them again. There is no fame in kicking a downed puppy.
 
wasn't one of the gimmiks with our character meant to be that the show never addresses that Presto is a puppet until he gets taken off and it's treated like it's a big reveal?
It seems you're absolutely right. I got that twisted around. While turning other people into puppets is funny and on-the nose, it seems to be the will of the original plan creator that everyone take Presto seriously and not acknowledge that he himself is a hand puppet.
[x] plan: we can't have Jeri we already have Jeri at home, Jeri at home:

If The Puppeteer wins, any chance we could have "The Puppeteer" be our dog puppet while Johana can act like their assistant (or even try to act like she's innocent and always blame it on the puppet if she gets caught)? Like, if The Puppeteer does any monologing or makes any announcements to the city, the camera is always fixed on the puppet while Johana is trying to hide offscreen and the eventual discovery that "Puppeteer" is just a hand puppet is treated like some kind of big reveal?



You'll have to ask the original plan maker about that, but I'd allow it with a minor bonus for the idea. Just the idea of a kid-friendly Ventriloquist/Scarface tickles me pink.

I imagine one way for the Paw Patrol to defeat Johanna/Presto (or whichever puppet we use) could be to get the puppet off her hand and replace it with a "heroic" one. Simply removing the evil puppet means she could use her allays to grab the puppet back but if they put a good puppet on her hand she would be "forced" to use the new puppet instead. The would at least last until the episode ends or her janitor puppet or whatever forces her to clean up the mess she made. (Heh, imagine her being a "reformed" by the good guys taking away her bad-guy puppet and replace it with a good-guy one. Until her next criminal comeback starts when she either retrieves her old puppet, makes a new bad guy puppet, or one of the other villains decides to do a team-up by returning Presto to the Puppeteer so they can all work together).

I'm going to retract the last part of my vote and replace it with another option.

@gale, @Night_stalker, If you're willing to go along with the change, could you change your posts to vote solely by plan name? Like this?

[] Plan: Master of Puppets

That'll allow your votes to update along with mine.
 
I feel like we should encourage our nemeses here. We need proper foes to compete against if we are to truly shine. Shame I can't write dialogue for shit.
 
Transforming the main characters into cloth puppets will also let the show runners sell stuffed animal versions of everyone, so if you think about it we're ensuring the survival of the Paw Patrol universe.
"Oh no don't turn me into a marketable plushie!"
"While others see Paw Patrol Pups, All I see are Small Controllable Plushes! Abra Kadabra! Alakazam!"
 
A funny thing I just imagined... Imagine if Pestro was live-action... Like whenever it zooms into just him in frame he's an actual live-action sock puppet for no reason. Or it could be like that one skit in Gravity falls that whenever the credits finish rolling on an episode with Pestro and The Puppeteer it shows a skit with a live-action puppet version of Pestro.
 
[X] Plan: Master of Puppets + added slip up
-[X] Humdinger : Yes
-[X] *Presto's Wand of Puppetification* : Presto's mainstay wand, now endowed with a sinister gleam. When the magic words are chanted ("Abra Kadabra! Alakazam!"), a beam of purple sparks jets out to transform his victim into a humble hand puppet. The magic gives out after a few hours, but can be reversed earlier by chanting the magic words in reverse ("Alakazam! Kadabra Abra!").
-[X] What to Say: say "I am not that bad come on" before quickly changing to "she was not that bad I meant" then changing topic quickly and asking what they think is up with her magical powers, anyways. She looked like a stage magician, but she had little fairies and a dragon; isn't that kind of really weird?
 
Last edited:
A funny thing I just imagined... Imagine if Pestro was live-action... Like whenever it zooms into just him in frame he's an actual live-action sock puppet for no reason. Or it could be like that one skit in Gravity falls that whenever the credits finish rolling on an episode with Pestro and The Puppeteer it shows a skit with a live-action puppet version of Pestro.
You read my mind. I was imagining every time it went to him it was a single-character live-action closeup -- kind of like that Pirate from Spongebob? A live action puppet.

(Maybe with a little wooden counter in front of him to hide the arm so that he can be in the center of the screen. And then, when Presto is hit with the de-puppeting spell, he can have realistic dog paws grab the frame of the set and, like, physically tear them apart to put himself into the rest of the animation with everyone. That would go incredibly hard.)

(That's mostly just a joke, though.)
[X] Plan: Master of Puppets + added slip up
-[X] Humdinger : Yes
-[X] *Presto's Wand of Puppetification* : Presto's mainstay wand, now endowed with a sinister gleam. When the magic words are chanted ("Abra Kadabra! Alakazam!"), a beam of purple sparks jets out to transform his victim into a humble hand puppet. The magic gives out after a few hours, but can be reversed earlier by chanting the magic words in reverse ("Alakazam! Kadabra Abra!").
-[X] What to Say: say "I am not that bad come on" before quickly changing to "she was not that bad I meant" then changing topic quickly and joking that it looks like it couldn't have been easy, driving with a puppet on her hand. Ask what they think is up with that, anyways; it didn't seem like it was just normal ventriloquism going on there, especially with all the other magic tricks she was doing.
The slipup is a matter of personal taste, but the original plan was changed because it's a gimmick that we're not acknowledging that Presto is a puppet.
 
@gale, @Night_stalker, If you're willing to go along with the change, could you change your posts to vote solely by plan name? Like this?
Done

You read my mind. I was imagining every time it went to him it was a single-character live-action closeup -- kind of like that Pirate from Spongebob? A live action puppet.

(Maybe with a little wooden counter in front of him to hide the arm so that he can be in the center of the screen. And then, when Presto is hit with the de-puppeting spell, he can have realistic dog paws grab the frame of the set and, like, physically tear them apart to put himself into the rest of the animation with everyone. That would go incredibly hard.)
Honestly, it'd be unique enough to make us memorable.

Plus imagine the jokes.
 
I'm curious what Johanna's parents or other family members might be like? Clearly some neglectfulness might be involved but there could be more to it.



I'm imagining something like our parents are rich with shady connections and are very distant to their daughter. When Johanna ran away they barely cared, thinking someone kidnapped her and they'd just post a ransom note soon enough.

But then the ransom note didn't come so figured they'd have to hire an investigator to track her down. Cue several months later when said investigator comes up with a picture of the Puppeteer and Presto. Johanna's disguise does a good job hiding her identity, but Presto is the same puppet she had when she went out to her talent show months ago, so the investigator puts the pieces together pretty quickly.

Said parents say it makes sense and order them to retrieve Johanna, but do it discreetly because they don't want the public hearing of their crazy daughter acting out like this. "She's always talking 'magic', and her imaginary friends. We don't know where she got those drones or that fake dragon, but they should be harmless unless she's working with someone else."

So they're more embarrassed she's acting up than concerned about her safety and might provide an extra threat to us. Either sending hired help to retrieve Johanna, providing the Paw Patrol with help, etc.

Bonus points if our parent's business mostly employs dogs because they're cheaper and nobody complains. Why employ expensive human workers when you can have dogs trained to dig in the iron mines or make clothes in a sweatshop? (with the help of machines and vehicles of course).

Edit: Extra if it's shown our parents have a pet dog they like to fawn over pamper more than their daughter. Or its just her mother ("Oh, I'd love to go to your Talent show, but Floofsy's modeling for one of the new Canine Crunchy ads and you know how she gets stage fright without me?") while the father is more all business and likes how are more obedient and less of a hassle to work with. The investigator(s) sent to track Johanna down might be dog themselves or at least have dogs on their team.

Or it could be a team of dogs with a token human who handles all the official paperwork or meeting with officials like Mayor Goodway or Ryder, but during interactions with Father they default to him giving orders to the leader of the dog team.
 
Last edited:
If we bring in another whole team just to handle us, I feel like it might take the focus away from the main protagonists.

I liked the idea of having to go up against the dog we lost to at the talent show, though. We'd have an emotional connection set against that one, and it'd be easier for the audience to understand our back-and-forth.
 
Last edited:
Thank You All
I've just checked, and the quest has reached the 100 watcher landmark. So, um... wow.

Thank you all for being the reason why I'm making this quest. This had initially been a dumb idea my muse had bashed me over the head to make, and I wasn't expecting this much positive feedback. So thank you for indulging me with this idea and for breathing life into it. :D

And as such, I'd like to ask you all: how has your experience in this quest been, and how do you feel about how I write this quest? I'd love to know all your opinions on this.

Also, voting will end in about an hour since one of the plans is already leading by a mile, but I want to give a chance for anyone else to pitch their own plans. :)
 
I just had a sad idea... what if the dog that beat our girl in the talent show is her mother's purse dog that she clearly favors...


If you want more tearjerking that dog genuinely loves Johannha and blames herself for the girl running away so she sneaks to adventure bay to try and bring her home.
 
just to throw some variety into this vote

[X] Plan Cloak of Illusions and finding out the hero's plan
-[X] Humdinger : Yes
-[X]The Cloak of Illusions is a light blue sparkling masterpiece that can make the wearer invisible (Transparent) while the hood of the cloak is over their head and when the cape is thrown open wide three illusionary clones of the wearer appear and hide the wearer true location.
-[X] Ask the Pups if they or Ryder have any plan on how they are going catch The Great and Mighty Presto and his lovely assistant The Puppeteer Master next time they make an appearance.
 
Last edited:
I've just checked, and the quest has reached the 100 watcher landmark. So, um... wow.

Thank you all for being the reason why I'm making this quest. This had initially been a dumb idea my muse had bashed me over the head to make, and I wasn't expecting this much positive feedback. So thank you for indulging me with this idea and for breathing life into it. :D

And as such, I'd like to ask you all: how has your experience in this quest been, and how do you feel about how I write this quest? I'd love to know all your opinions on this.

Also, voting will end in about an hour since one of the plans is already leading by a mile, but I want to give a chance for anyone else to pitch their own plans. :)
A dumb idea, but a fun one. All i know about Paw Patrol is that it exists and sometimes shops have merch aimed at little kids with that name and little dogs on it, but the quest is fun.

If you want more tearjerking that dog genuinely loves Johannha and blames herself for the girl running away so she sneaks to adventure bay to try and bring her home.
And joins the Paw Patrol to protect her from this new villian terrorizing the town. Taking the role of dealing with magic, ofcourse.
 
[X] Plan: Master of Puppets

This is probably gonna win, Though The only thing about this that I would Change is for some parts of what to say would be more uplifting and helpful like previously stated. Like "It's like when Mrs. Pearson is training me self-defense. She may knock me down a bunch of times but if I keep getting back up I can continue to learn and grow!"
 
[X] Plan: Master of Puppets + uplifting
-[X] Humdinger : Yes
-[X] *Presto's Wand of Puppetification* : Presto's mainstay wand, now endowed with a sinister gleam. When the magic words are chanted ("Abra Kadabra! Alakazam!"), a beam of purple sparks jets out to transform his victim into a humble hand puppet. The magic gives out after a few hours, but can be reversed earlier by chanting the magic words in reverse ("Alakazam! Kadabra Abra!").
-[X] What to Say: "It's like when Mrs. Pearson is training me self-defense. She may knock me down a bunch of times but if I keep getting back up I can continue to learn and grow!". Also ask what they think is up with her magical powers, anyways. She looked like a stage magician, but she had little fairies and a dragon; isn't that kind of really weird?

Hey @AUnderSave.
Is this good.
 
2,134 more messages…
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top