So what's the possibility space for doing beneficial things (or neutral things) with astrology, with or without Dark Arts?

Could you make someone lucky, or enhance their odds of success at some specific task or skill, or make two people likely to fall in love, or other things that are classically blamed on people's horoscopes?
There was also a suggestion to use dark astrology to create zombie animals and send them to the forbidden forest to collect ingredients.

Zombie squirrel will collect nuts, zombie moles will collect roots, zombie hares grass, zombie ants various seeds and mow down small animals, zombie eagles can hunt small game, zombie snakes will hide small objects in their stomachs, zombie birds can collect branches of magic trees, zombies-spiders, on which they will hunt small insects, zombie mosquitoes collect animal blood.
 
Last edited:
There was also a suggestion to use dark astrology to create zombie animals and send them to the forbidden forest to collect ingredients.

Zombie squirrel will collect nuts, zombie moles will collect roots, zombie hares grass, zombie ants various seeds and mow down small animals, zombie eagles can hunt small game, zombie snakes will hide small objects in their stomachs, zombie birds can collect branches of magic trees, zombies-spiders, on which they will hunt small insects, zombie mosquitoes collect animal blood.
That definitely could not possibly go wrong in any way. XD
 
Disco Elysium
Disco Elysium

The Christmas Feast had been a grandiose and familial affair, with the four House tables replaced by a single buffet of roast turkey, baked potatoes, and luscious chipolatas. It was surrounded on all sides by rows of tall Christmas trees, decorated lavishly and elegantly. Around a fifth of the student body was in attendance, alongside maybe a half of the teachers. It seemed like everyone was having lots of fun, sharing conversation, recalling the events of the year with something like early nostalgia, laughing at simple jokes, or simply basking in the open and affectionate atmosphere of the event and enjoying the presence of the other people around them.

Almost uncharacteristically, some of the Professors even consumed minor amounts of alcohol at the table, growing more jovial by the second. It all reached a feverish peak when Professor Flitwick challenged Professor Hagrid to a drinking contest, in earnest, which prompted more than a couple of worried looks in the former man's direction. Professor Flitwick's cheeks had noticeably reddened by his fifth cup, and he behaved in a distracted manner, as though someone had stuffed a warm pillow into his head. On the other hand, Hagrid kept going to his tenth cup as though chugging water from a jug, rather than boosted wine. By his seventh cup, Professor Flitwick had surrendered and allowed his head to rest sideways on the table, though Hagrid kept drinking for the both of them; ever-charitable, the giant decided to call the event 'a draw.'

At the conclusion of the companionable feast, Professor Pettigrew cast some kind of complex Charm or spell, and made the dishes and cutlery dance around the table while singing a jolly, high-pitched Christmas tune in the voices of children, to which everyone happily clapped along. Not the woman to ever be one-upped, Professor McGonagall pushed up her glasses with two fingers, and without even moving her wand, conjured an entire band of skeletal dancers, singers, and performers from the null ether. It prompted yet another contest, to see who might create better entertainment.

Naturally, the Assistant Professor ceded the contest to the Deputy Headmistress, when she opened up the sky to reveal a dazzling arrangement of constellations shaped like people, dancing with each other, overlaid with dancing and bobbing supernovae reflecting an ephemeral sound like soft, chiming instruments: the music of the spheres.

"Perhaps next year," Pettigrew had said to that.

"Perhaps," McGonagall agreed with faint, atypical smugness.

Harry, though, sat back and sulked at Professor Pettigrew's loss in the contest. He knew with a bone-deep certainty those weren't even real constellations, but simple glamour and illusions of stars. According to him, Professor McGonagall had cheated, even though he didn't word such a statement openly.

And then, Headmaster Dumbledore - having left the Great Hall to use the bathroom some ten minutes ago - suddenly Apparated in the middle of the table, wearing stylish Aviator Muggle sunglasses, a Hawaiian aloha shirt haphazardly placed over his robes, and bearing an entire crate of exotic fizzy drinks. As everyone observed with surprise and bafflement, he expertly cracked a single can of Hansen's Natural Soda open with his thumb, releasing a hiss of gas. He raised it up high like a victory torch, so everyone could see, and then clenched the can in his fist while aiming it down, contents shooting into his open mouth like a waterfall of sugary juices; then, he crushed the can with his fist, threw it down on the floor, picked another one out of the crate, and yelled, "PARTY!" Not a full minute later, the disco lights were up and there was a conga line happening.

As Harry looked around for a free spot to begin grooving, Sirius approached him from behind and tapped him on the shoulder. Harry turned.

"Harry, I'd like to give you the Christmas present I prepared for you!" Sirius yelled. "Before... the Christmas Feast becomes too crazy!"

Harry nodded in understanding and assent, showing a thumbs-up. Although he was barely able to hear Sirius' words over the nightclub remix of Lipps Inc's Funkytown playing in the Great Hall at near-deafening volumes from everywhere at once, he caught about enough words to fill the blanks out.

An earnest - though pained, by the cacophony surrounding them - smile on his face, Sirius smoothly reached into his coat and handed over a small gift wrapped in red paper. It was smaller than even a particularly thin book. Next to them, Professor Flitwick began tapping his foot to the beat, even though he was unconscious.

"Can I open it?" Harry asked.

"Maybe not here! Later! I only wanted to tell you-" Sirius was interrupted when a Slytherin girl accidentally bumped into him, apologizing then moving to dance elsewhere. "I only wanted to tell you, I know that I'm not the best guardian-"

All of a sudden, Flitwick rebooted from his drunken stupor, and, upon noticing his surroundings, breathed in sharply with his pupils widening like he was on a sudden, inexplicable sugar high. "A GLORIOUS DISCO PARTY?! OH. MY. MERLIN! I NEED TO RELIVE MY GLORY DAYS!" He started climbing the table with dangerously unstable steps.

"I'm not the godfather you might've wished for!" Sirius continued. "I fell apart after James and Lily died, and I never completely picked myself up, but my work as a teacher has been a good way to look to the future and away from that dark past. I know that I'm often absorbed in my work-"

With almost no warning, next to them, Flitwick gloriously leaped into the teeming masses of dancing students and teachers. "BANZAAAI!" He was caught, fortunately.

Sirius sighed. "I haven't been there as often as I would have liked to provide some help for you. I'm very sorry for all of this, Harry. I promise that I'll find time for you, and I promise to do better from now on! Merry Christmas!"

"I promise that I'll do better as well!" Harry decided, on a spur of the moment. "I haven't been spending as much time with you, either! Merry Christmas!"

"I LOVE DISCO PARTIES! CAN YOU DANCE LIKE A HIPPOGRIFF!? MA MA MA, MA MA MA, MA MA MA! FLYIN' OFF FROM A CLIFF!"

"THAT'S ROCK, NOT DISCO, PROFESSOR!" someone shouted.

"MA MA MA, MA MA MA, MA MA MA! YEAH, YEAH, YEAH!"

---

There are several days before January properly begins, and the Hogwarts Express isn't returning until then. As such, you've got several days and nights to explore the castle with almost no other students around, and almost no oversight from pesky and nosy teachers. You could get away with almost anything!

[ ] Experiment with Cloak of Invisibility - Harry can use this period to figure out what his mysterious Christmas gift does: namely, among other things, it turns you invisible (and makes you immortal, but he doesn't know that yet, so shhh.) If unpicked, Harry will assume it's a random cloth and figure its functions out at some later date.

[ ] Observe the Firmament - The protean resplendency of the sky is eternal, though we don't always see it, huddled in our castles of stone and magic. Harry will spend this peaceful time watching the sky.

[ ] Practice the Dark Arts - Let's be serious, you could hardly ask for a better time to do something illegal and secretive. Maybe get to brewing some of those interesting potions that Geist mentioned?

[ ] Build Network of Runes - Carve a network of personal runes over the castle halls. It's the only time where you can do this without reasonably getting caught by anyone. Although these runes won't do anything by themselves, you might be able to access them in the future, for spying or doing other things.

[ ] Explore the Castle - Its secret chambers, the places no one goes to because of Mr. Filch, the underground layers that you haven't been to yet! There's so many places in Hogwarts that you've heard of but haven't even entered.

[ ] Write-in
 
Last edited:
[X] Experiment with Cloak of Invisibility - Harry can use this period to figure out what his mysterious Christmas gift does: namely, among other things, it turns you invisible (and makes you immortal, but he doesn't know that yet, so shhh.) If unpicked, Harry will assume it's a random cloth and figure its functions out at some later date.

While everything is tempting, having the cloak will let us do sketchy things any time we want. It could also easily save our lives.

And then, Headmaster Dumbledore - having left the Great Hall to use the bathroom some ten minutes ago - suddenly Apparated on the middle of the table, wearing stylish Aviator Muggle sunglasses, a Hawaiian aloha shirt haphazardly placed over his robes, and bearing an entire crate of exotic fizzy drinks. As everyone observed with surprise and bafflement, he expertly cracked a single can of Hansen's Natural Soda open with his thumb, releasing a hiss of gas. He raised it up high like a victory torch, so everyone could see, and then clenched the can in his fist while aiming it down, contents shooting into his open mouth like a waterfall of sugary juices; then, he crushed the can with his fist, threw it down on the floor, picked another one out of the crate, and yelled, "PARTY!" Not a full minute later, the disco lights were up and there was a conga line happening.
Did someone slip something in my drink? XD
 
Last edited:
So currently I am thinking either cloak of invisibility or getting a reserve of potions/Rune network but I am now convinced by cloak for yeah getting it online would make doing other dark tasks far more doable

[X] Experiment with Cloak of Invisibility - Harry can use this period to figure out what his mysterious Christmas gift does: namely, among other things, it turns you invisible (and makes you immortal, but he doesn't know that yet, so shhh.) If unpicked, Harry will assume it's a random cloth and figure its functions out at some later date.
 
[X] Explore the Castle - Its secret chambers, the places no one goes to because of Mr. Filch, the underground layers that you haven't been to yet! There's so many places in Hogwarts that you've heard of but haven't even entered.
 
The vote aside, it would be nice if we could set up some regular time to spend privately with Sirius. Like having a private meal or going for a hike or something, at least once a week.

The two of them need a chance to talk about things. Even if it's just whatever Harry's learning, it would be good for them.
 
Last edited:
[] Build Network of Runes

Listening in the common room is exactly what is needed for our spy network. Because this is an important accumulation of information that rats cannot reach.


[X] Observe the Firmament
I'm changing my voice because with the invisibility cloak, we can apply runes at any moment. While the solstice is once a year.
 
Last edited:
No brainer. Mantle of Death needs to be studied. It is winter solstice though.. an important Astrological time. That we won't have access to until next year.

[X] Observe the Firmament

The Sun reaches its southernmost point every year in late December. This is called the Winter Solstice and it's been considered one of the most spiritually significant days of the year. Think of it as the birthday of the Sun, as it begins its journey north. This year the Solstice takes place on December 21 and will be particularly powerful because two planets, Jupiter and Saturn will be exactly conjunct to each other that day.

Even if we pick the other choices we should write in to dedicate 21st December to observing the solstice.

[X] Experiment with Cloak of Invisibility
-[X] But make time to stargaze at the winter solstice night.
 
Last edited:
[X] Experiment with Cloak of Invisibility - Harry can use this period to figure out what his mysterious Christmas gift does: namely, among other things, it turns you invisible (and makes you immortal, but he doesn't know that yet, so shhh.) If unpicked, Harry will assume it's a random cloth and figure its functions out at some later date.

For me it's a no-brainer. Cloak of Invisibility.
 
[X] Practice the Dark Arts - Let's be serious, you could hardly ask for a better time to do something illegal and secretive. Maybe get to brewing some of those interesting potions that Geist mentioned?
 
[X] Experiment with Cloak of Invisibility

We can do everything else on the list with the Cloak.
 
[X] Practice the Dark Arts - Let's be serious, you could hardly ask for a better time to do something illegal and secretive. Maybe get to brewing some of those interesting potions that Geist mentioned?
 
So what kind of immortality does the cloak grant? If that was in canon it's been too long for me to recall.
 
So what kind of immortality does the cloak grant? If that was in canon it's been too long for me to recall.
In the tale of death and three brothers. The younger brother asked Death for a mantle in which Death would not find him. And he hid from her until he became decrepit and old. After that, he voluntarily took off the mantle to die, giving it to his son.
In the discord, a proposal was put forward that it is impossible to die under the mantle, regardless of the condition of the wearer.
 
In the tale of death and three brothers. The younger brother asked Death for a mantle in which Death would not find him. And he hid from her until he became decrepit and old. After that, he voluntarily took off the mantle to die, giving it to his son.
In the discord, a proposal was put forward that it is impossible to die under the mantle, regardless of the condition of the wearer.
So you could age and be mortally wounded, but not die. Sounds like something to be used with care, but potentially useful.

I wonder if the mantle would completely defeat the effect of the killing curse. Of course Harry is already immune, so it's a bit academic unless we loan it out.

Edit: I just thought of an amazing potential use of it. Buying time for the wounded. If someone's been horribly injured, you could put it on them to keep them alive long enough to get them to the best possible medical care. Maybe even give them medical care while they were wearing it, if necessary. Like if they've bled out all their blood, maybe you could patch the holes and transfuse enough to keep them alive when you take it off. Or the wizard equivalent with potions, whatever.
 
Last edited:
So you could age and be mortally wounded, but not die. Sounds like something to be used with care, but potentially useful.

I wonder if the mantle would completely defeat the effect of the killing curse. Of course Harry is already immune, so it's a bit academic unless we loan it out.

Edit: I just thought of an amazing potential use of it. Buying time for the wounded. If someone's been horribly injured, you could put it on them to keep them alive long enough to get them to the best possible medical care. Maybe even give them medical care while they were wearing it, if necessary. Like if they've bled out all their blood, maybe you could patch the holes and transfuse enough to keep them alive when you take it off. Or the wizard equivalent with potions, whatever.
Most likely, avada simply won't "find" the invisibility cloak user because of how closely the death curse is connected with death.
 
Back
Top