- Location
- Ottawa
Actually I think the Primordial War is better if it lasted not "a single Exalted lifetime" but only a few years to a few month.
Zeus didn't spend a thousand years working his way up to Mount Olympus before spending a century bringing down Cronos.
Zeus didn't exist in a game system that has characters acquiring xp and growing stronger with age. He was about as tough when he took the throne as he was a thousand years later.
The Exalted, meanwhile, exist in a setting and system that expects them and their adventures to grow over time. Someone who's been Exalted for a few weeks will have their hands full dealing with mortal opposition. It takes time for Exalts to become ready to challenge a sapient world full of superhuman monsters and its dozens of beyond-divine semi-independent souls.
Suppose you were running a Primordial War game. Would you really have the whole story span a few in-game months?
The Primordials do not have to be a match for the Exalted, because their relative "power levels" are largely irrelevant to the modern setting.
Nonsense. The modern setting has a couple dozen living Primordials, a few hundred Third Circles, a couple thousand Second Circles, and countless First Circles. Small pieces of the Primordials have stats in the back of the Ex3 Core, and some of them are pretty damn tough. Some of them are clearly stronger than the sample Exalts in the same book, who've been empowered for longer than the duration you posit for the Primordial War.
There were probably more Third Circles in the Primordial War than there were Celestials. That gives a pretty high lower bound on how strong the Primordial side of the War was.
Starting characters in Ex3 have been Exalted maybe six months. And I don't think a bunch of chargen Exalts took down a thousand Third Circles, their armies, and their worlds.
And I don't think having the Exalted reach Essence 5 in secret before crushing the Primordials like overleveled JRPG characters taking out the final boss after doing all the sidequests is a good idea at all.