The correct way to fry an egg

  • Sunny side up

    Votes: 16 64.0%
  • Sunny side down

    Votes: 9 36.0%

  • Total voters
    25
  • Poll closed .
[x][Princess] Ask her to sit down, and ask Hitomi to bring a pot of tea, and prepare yourself for a long explanation of the state of affairs of the Star Empire and where grief potatoes come from, and why you think this is bad and why you don't like it. And then ask her for her thoughts on the matter, and then listen.
[X][Princess] Show her hospitality, and implore her aid
[X][Misc] Give Kyouko and hug, thank her for staying with us and apologize for making her worry in the first place

Adding objectives I guess.

[X][Objectives] Stop Governance from creating torture wheels and making Ryouko the embodiment of all of humanity.
[X][Objectives] Repair Godoka.
[X][Objectives] Ensure Sakura's magic to save the AIs/destroy the SE dystopia succeeds in achieving its objective
[X][Objectives] Aim to save the 2011 timeline and the Governance timeline.
[X][Objectives] Save Governance!Asami and Governance!Simona
 
Last edited:
I think we're going to need a Mokona
You know what? You can have a mokona, right after you've tamed a few rune gods.

Also, in the interest of facilitating reader sanity, your intertextual hint is that you ought not consider feather-Sakura to be much more than an outside observer who has blundered in and who considers the concept of soul gems unnatural and very wrong.
 
Hey look! Tomoyo has updated their location and made a new profile post. Tomoyo is currently in 'Clear Card Volume 1' and their new profile post was:

Hey, you know how to make feathers, right? you use the fix-everything magic on the soul gem and poof! magic wings! (fly safely ok?)

So if we contract we can go flying with Kyouko? Lets do that, nothing wrong with that.
 
I just read the quest, and it's combination of, "amazing story," and "I"m so confused..."

Is that normal for this quest?
*pats on back* Yes. *hangs head with a heavy sigh* Yes it is.

Hey look! Tomoyo has updated their location and made a new profile post. Tomoyo is currently in 'Clear Card Volume 1' and their new profile post was:

So if we contract we can go flying with Kyouko? Lets do that, nothing wrong with that.
That's just telling me we can do a thing by booping soul gems with our Tim Taylor approved Fix It Magictm​... maybe. Either that or we kill them and turn them into an Angel which... could actually help depending on what they can do and interact with when they are dead through that method actually.
 
Hey look! Tomoyo has updated their location and made a new profile post. Tomoyo is currently in 'Clear Card Volume 1'
why yes I am!

 
Well. I do favor mystery over confusion... so...
Is there anything in particular I can help you with?
Okay, I'll list the two "what?" moments I can remember at the top of my head. The first one is a little embarrassing because it was probably explained somewhere I just missed, but what's up with Tomoyo Shizuki? There was that who I said and You said back when Clarissa was in the SE universe, was she possessing Tomoyo Shizuki? Is Tomoyo Shizuki your avatar which is why you used You for Clarissa (the PoV character) and I for Tomoyo (plus it's your username)?

The second might fall under the category of spoilers because it's recent, but in case we were supposed to get it and I just missed it, the multiple universe thing. So previously Clarissa and co thought there was the past timeline they were in, the SE timeline, and the Governance timeline, but Gretchen corrected Clarissa and said that the past timeline was actually the SE timeline's past. Did we ever get any information on where the "Hell" universe fits into this? Is this confirmation that the Hell universe was the Governance universe and the strange things that Clarissa and co noticed before being abducted to the past were coincidences?

Oh, a couple other things. Were we supposed to know who Princess Sakura was? Just the SE timeline's Kyoko? And I was confused about whether we were supposed to know why Gretchen is around when Godoka has been paradoxed out of existence.
 
Is Tomoyo Shizuki your avatar which is why you used You for Clarissa (the PoV character) and I for Tomoyo (plus it's your username)?

Yep, our author is the Star Empire's Tomoyo.

the multiple universe thing. So previously Clarissa and co thought there was the past timeline they were in, the SE timeline, and the Governance timeline, but Gretchen corrected Clarissa and said that the past timeline was actually the SE timeline's past.

So, we origanally thought there were 3 universes, but Gretchen corrected us and explained there are 2. The 2011 timeline is the Star Empires future, not its past. That universe will eventually (was? Time travel is weird) be 'fixed' by someone (probably us or our Star Empire counterpart) using Sakura's powers.

Did we ever get any information on where the "Hell" universe fits into this?

The hell universe is the simulated world used to contain Simona's copy that Ryouko, Asami, Machina and us were dragged into.

Were we supposed to know who Princess Sakura was?

Not Princesses Sakura, but we knew a girl who went to school with papa and tomoyo who was named Kinomoto Sakura.

And I was confused about whether we were supposed to know why Gretchen is around when Godoka has been paradoxed out of existence.

Seems that since Gretchen exsists outside of time she can be both fixed and not fixed at the same time. That or we are time travelling more then I realise.
 
Yep, our author is the Star Empire's Tomoyo.
Buwah? Really? I was kind of joking. Like seriously though, what's her background? What is she doing in the SE? Was she also in the Governance universe?
The hell universe is the simulated world used to contain Simona's copy that Ryouko, Asami, Machina and us were dragged into.
Did we ever figure out whether Ryouko is actually Ryouko who was dragged into the Hell universe or if we're somehow copies of them and if we went back to the Governance universe we'd run into their Ryouko?
 
Oh, a couple other things. Were we supposed to know who Princess Sakura was? Just the SE timeline's Kyoko? And I was confused about whether we were supposed to know why Gretchen is around when Godoka has been paradoxed out of existence.

You should probably just treat her as (a) a parallel to a girl in the eighties in your current timeline, Kinomoto Sakura, no relation to Sakura Kyouko, and (b) an outsider who is confronting you with a perspective which suggests soul gems are badly wrong.

At least one person recognized it as a ripoff an overt homage, and was going slightly too far into speculah based on that; I've issued a reply in the current updoot's thread, but managing these expectations is an ongoing effort, and more can be done. Maybe a header or footer somewhere. That would probably do the job without being obtrusive! And I do get to purple text and commentary now that it's an appropriate timeline for that again...

That said, if you want to experience Tsubasa: Reservoir Chronicle (or its anime), I can say that I enjoyed it, but a visit to the regular Cardcaptor Sakura first is probably advisable — at least episode 2 — though if you want to see exactly what Puella Magi Madoka Madoka was ripping off in the first few episodes, and meet the OG Mysterious Transfer Student who our protagonist first met in a dream, or something, that's episode 8.

But if you don't do any of that, that should be fine too.


Is Tomoyo Shizuki your avatar which is why you used You for Clarissa (the PoV character) and I for Tomoyo (plus it's your username)?
Not quite! Clarissa is more of a Gothic novel protagonist, see Samuel Richardson's Clarissa (1748) — compare also Charles Brockden Brown's Edgar Huntly: Memoirs of a Sleepwalker (1799) which uses a Clarice, but not as a protagonist.
(don't worry, I don't remember much else from that class)
Our magical-girl story protagonist is neither of these. She is Clarisse, the Moon Princess. :)

Buwah? Really? I was kind of joking.
I'm not sure what to say? The story has a narrator? :p

Like seriously though, what's her background?
Well, in 2011, she's Hitomi's mom!

What is she doing in the SE?
Protecting the universe from external threats, scheming to make it less SE, telling bedtime stories to orphans, you know... stuff!

Was she also in the Governance universe?
Well, in 2011, she would have been Hitomi's mom, so, your great-something-grandmother!

Did we ever get any information on where the "Hell" universe fits into this? Is this confirmation that the Hell universe was the Governance universe and the strange things that Clarissa and co noticed before being abducted to the past were coincidences?
The idea here is that somewhere in Governance there are simulations which are equivalent to being some sort of sub-universe, bubble universe, or similar: you can put souls into them, but the universe operates under external control.

Did we ever figure out whether Ryouko is actually Ryouko who was dragged into the Hell universe or if we're somehow copies of them and if we went back to the Governance universe we'd run into their Ryouko?
Would you prefer memory transfers, like the one that turned shy little Homura into the cold-as-ice veteran of twelve years? You have a ribbon. Princess Ryouko might complicate things though...

I was confused about whether we were supposed to know why Gretchen is around when Godoka has been paradoxed out of existence.
Oh. You'll note that you haven't seen Gretchen as Gretchen within this timeline, only on the way back from others. In this case, you'd just tried to be Kyuubey when your soul was flung off somewhere extra-universal. Gretchen has helpfully compared this to Sakura's feathers being scattered, and notes that her access to these universes is more limited: this is partially on account of the absence of magical girls.
Do keep this risk in mind if you try to accomplish anything with feathers.
Slightly related to that: did you read the April Fools updoots? (I'll edit a note about that in to the main story, too).

Also if the april fools update is confusing, don't worry about it at all. It's an April Fools update for a reason. If you recognize the material and can find some good metaphor or suddenly understand where Gretchen got her perpetual motion machine speech from, that's all good Fun. If not, well, I put the soul/feather/egg/cage metaphor stuff in this-doot also because any external hints need redundant internal hints — and then maybe repetition of the hints a few times.
 
Last edited:
I am confused about what I am supposed to be confused about. Like things are making sense to me..so...um.

I am worried that I am not even seeing the questions to which the hints are hints to the answer of.
 
I am worried that I am not even seeing the questions to which the hints are hints to the answer of.
oh, right this moment it's soul-gem-and-magic topics mostly.

"why does kyuubey know all about these feathers?"
"exactly how interested is he in getting them back?"
"what precisely does he intend to do with them?"
"who entrusted feathers to kyuubey in the first place, and why?"
"why are we bringing up egg-cage-things in this metaphor, what does that imply?"
"does all this explain anything else that's happened or is anticipated in visions?"
"is there anything in TTS backing up the idea that soul gems are unnatural?" like the chapter 46 quote
et cetera, et cetera
"why are there so few magical girls with wings?"
 
Would you prefer memory transfers, like the one that turned shy little Homura into the cold-as-ice veteran of twelve years? You have a ribbon. Princess Ryouko might complicate things though...
Actually I'd prefer there being two Ryouko's. Delicious drama you see. Existential debate, who's the real Ryouko, etc. etc. :D Sometimes I'm a bit of a story sadist.
 
Actually I'd prefer there being two Ryouko's. Delicious drama you see. Existential debate, who's the real Ryouko, etc. etc. :D Sometimes I'm a bit of a story sadist.

Ryouko1: "No, really. Who is this girl, and why is she more suddenly more interesting than I am?"
Ryouko2: "Look, if you really want to deal with the alternate realities where we're a stuck-up, spoiled FA hyperclass princess, you are more than welcome. Be my guest."
Clarisse2: "Calm down, both of you."
Ryouko1: "Goddess, you get a real Clarisse, too?"
Clarisse1 (internally): "What do you mean, a real Clarisse?" :mad:
Ryouko2: "Anyway, the point is, I'm here to steal your girlfriend."
Ryouko1: <agog>
Clarisse2: "Clone. Clone her girlfriend."
Asami (quietly, blushing): "... You don't need to clone me, you're both welcome to stay for as long as you want..."
Clarisse2: "... hey, you know, maybe we can make Asami the moon princess. Asami, do you like ribbons?"
 
Ryouko1: "No, really. Who is this girl, and why is she more suddenly more interesting than I am?"
Ryouko2: "Look, if you really want to deal with the alternate realities where we're a stuck-up, spoiled FA hyperclass princess, you are more than welcome. Be my guest."
Clarisse2: "Calm down, both of you."
Ryouko1: "Goddess, you get a real Clarisse, too?"
Clarisse1 (internally): "What do you mean, a real Clarisse?" :mad:
Ryouko2: "Anyway, the point is, I'm here to steal your girlfriend."
Ryouko1: <agog>
Clarisse2: "Clone. Clone her girlfriend."
Asami (quietly, blushing): "... You don't need to clone me, you're both welcome to stay for as long as you want..."
Clarisse2: "... hey, you know, maybe we can make Asami the moon princess. Asami, do you like ribbons?"
Simona 1, 2, 3, 4, H, z, and *: "Notice Me Sempai!"
 
Oh no, Tomoyo is hiding text in their posts now. In part because BB codes. This might lead to more elaborate hiding spotshttp://like this one

Not quite! Clarissa is more of a Gothic novel protagonist, see Samuel Richardson's Clarissa (1748) — compare also Charles Brockden Brown's Edgar Huntly: Memoirs of a Sleepwalker (1799) which uses a Clarice, but not as a protagonist.
(don't worry, I don't remember much else from that class)
Our magical-girl story protagonist is neither of these. She is Clarisse, the Moon Princess. :)

Oh. You'll note that you haven't seen Gretchen as Gretchen within this timeline, only on the way back from others. In this case, you'd just tried to be Kyuubey when your soul was flung off somewhere extra-universal. Gretchen has helpfully compared this to Sakura's feathers being scattered, and notes that her access to these universes is more limited: this is partially on account of the absence of magical girls.
Do keep this risk in mind if you try to accomplish anything with feathers.

"why does kyuubey know all about these feathers?"
"exactly how interested is he in getting them back?"
"what precisely does he intend to do with them?"
"who entrusted feathers to kyuubey in the first place, and why?"
"why are we bringing up egg-cage-things in this metaphor, what does that imply?"
"does all this explain anything else that's happened or is anticipated in visions?"
"is there anything in TTS backing up the idea that soul gems are unnatural?"like the chapter 46 quote
et cetera, et cetera
"why are there so few magical girls with wings?"
 
I am the state.
> Give Kyouko and hug, thank her for staying with us and apologize for making her worry in the first place.

You do so, and send your words gratitude internally.

The Princess looks jealous.

> ask Hitomi to bring a pot of tea
> ask the princess to sit down
> prepare yourself for a long explanation of the state of affairs of the Star Empire and where grief potatoes come from
> … and why you think this is bad and why you don't like it.


"Hitomi?"

"Yes?" she asks.

"Might we impose upon you for some tea?

She looks a bit uncertain.

"It will take a while to ready the tea room—"

"There's need to be so formal," you say. "Just something everyday. Simpler is better."

"Ah," says Hitomi, uncertainty fading. "Of course," she smiles.

Ryouko narrows her eyes.

"Is this to be a ritual humiliation?" she asks, skeptically.

"We don't do that sort of imperial melodrama here," you say. "While I'm certain you've had much more rarefied tea experiences than we can possibly offer, I want to offer you our simple hospitality in a spirit of goodwill and sorority. If you truly wish to understand, you can start there. It will be idiomatic for the whole experience."

Ryouko inhales.

"If you say so," she says.

"… I'll be back in a few moments," says Hitomi.




Kirika has excused herself — or perhaps Hitomi has gotten her to excuse herself. Madoka was a little unsure about whether or not she should be here, but Shizuki Tomoyo insisted on sending her up with a tray of refreshments, and she's here now. This is a distraction, because Madoka wearing a black dress, with a white sash and white ribbons, and a little silver necklace with a heart. It's a good thing you have something very important to worry about, because a distractingly cute pink girl is not what you need after watching yourself make out with Gretchen.

You make introductions.

Madoka seems a little wowed by the idea of an actual princess, but you reassure her and the others that she's a person like everyone else.

"I take it from all this that you're a democracy, then," says the princess, as she sips the tea.

"Indeed," you say. "I am glad you are aware of the concept. I had wondered if it might be suppressed."

"I do have a bad habit of reading forbidden books," says the princess, slightly pleased with herself.

"We are in twenty-first century Japan," says Nanami. "We've got an emperor, for ceremonial purposes, but the government is representative. Ryouko and Clarisse come from a twenty-fifth century democracy, of a different sort."

The princess nods.

"Well, I hope that you prosper," she says, "though I fear I am skeptical. While democracy is a beautiful idea, it has always proved sadly transient in practice. To be ruled by the people, sooner or later, means leadership which is fickle, short-sighted, corrupt, and intemperate. In the end, stability, strength are more important than self-rule, and will deliver more prosperity to more people. Better to be ruled by a benevolent monarch with justice and measured liberty — at least, if one can be freed from the exigencies of succession."

"Your Empress, I suppose?" you remark.

"Indeed," says the princess. "The Star Empire has democratic neighbors, and they thrive, but it is under the umbrella of imperial protection that they do so. I have no doubt they would be quite different otherwise."

You look around to the others.

"… well now," you say. "These are somewhat tendentious assertions. Of Governance, though, I must say that our democratic processes are not hampered by the same prejudices against use of technology."

"Ah," says the princess. "I wouldn't know about that, I'm afraid."

"Speaking of which," you say, "I should probably warn you that you have an awful lot of technology inside you right now."

To her credit, she does a very good job of masking her sudden discomfort. You can only just barely tell.

"What sort of technology?" she asks.

"Military grade cybernetics," you say. "Communications, computing, memory, translation, enhancements to your senses, skeletal reinforcements…"

She places the teacup down on the table very carefully.

Madoka reaches out a hand. "It's a little scary at first," she says, "but it's okay. You're still you."

"Oh," she says, a little blankly. "Thank you, Gretchen."

Madoka gives her hand a squeeze, then lets go.

You blink a few times.

But of course, if the princess knew Madoka, it would be by that name. And Madoka must assume she's confused. She looks a little confused herself. Best not to say anything.

"Besides the cybernetic implants generally," you say, "there is, in particular, a tactical computer that is embedded on your spine. I would strongly appreciate if you were to avoid damaging it by rejecting it as incompatible with your self image."

"Ah," she says — worry on her voice. "Of course. It would be quite rude of me. My counterpart will no doubt have need of it."

"Also," you say, "the tactical computer is technically my original body.

"I have a Clarisse inside of me?" asks the princess, confused, looking down at herself.

"Yes," you say. " Moreover, I believe that you are interfering with my operation, so if you could figure out any way to stop, it would be very helpful."

Among other things, there ought to be data over there which you can access, Ryouko's memory data of the past couple of days — and any recordings from your own sensors that might help a little. And because you are getting better at understanding magic, you're pretty sure that it is a soul interference thing, her psyche walling you out of that space.

Ryouko looks to you, and takes a deep breath…

The interference fades.



Unfortunately, Ryouko's most recent memories don't seem to have been recorded in your absence. But you can see the princess's thoughts, now, and her thoughts about you. She has a mixed set of emotions running through her right now, and one of them still feels roughly as if she had suddenly found out there was a cephalapod living inside her. But a Clarisse inside of her is okay, in a way that a generic technology inside of her isn't. She is rationalizing it to herself like that, anyway. She appears to have made a habit of using you as an anchor, and much more strongly than you had expected.

Thank you, you say, internally, sharing a bit of gratitude.

The princess blinks.

"Oh my," she says.

Here. Relax, you say, allowing yourself discretionary access to her brain chemistry — just slightly more than you'd use with your Ryouko, you notice, with a tiny bit of sympathy for Machina.



"Are you better?" you ask.

Ryouko nods.

Kyouko munches a sandwich.

"The Empire's attitudes towards technology lie near to the root of its current crisis," you say. "Please understand, though, that if we are upset with the way things are, it need not follow that we are upset with you. Indeed, we hardly know you, at least not in this form. Our complaint is against your state."

Nanami nods.

You take a sip of your tea.

"I am the state," says the princess, unironically.

Your tea does something interesting and tries very hard to go out our nose. You only just manage to stop it.

"Well, obviously not all of it," adds Ryouko, as you start coughing.

"Oh, dear," says Hitomi, handing you a napkin.

"I thought that was Napoleon," says Kyouko, who vaguely recalls hearing a quote like that once.

"You're thinking of… um… King Louis," says Nanami, who's just looked it up internally.

"Thank you," you say to Hitomi.

"I am the white-hot tip of humanity's spear," says the princess. "I am the hope of our defenders, and I am the vehicle of annihilation, against those would stand against us."

She glares at Kyouko, who is finishing a sandwich.

"Huh?" says Kyouko.

Ryouko sighs. "You could try to be just a little impressed."

"I'm sure that your armies are very impressive," says Hitomi, "but you have arrived in a peaceful land. All we have is a small self-defense force."

"Well… okay," she says. "That's different."

She's frustrated. She wants to articulate, that she is legitimate, that she belongs where she is — because on some level, she's not entirely sure that it's true, and if it weren't true, that would be terrifying.

"It's not a bad thing, to protect people," you tell her. "But I hope that if we wage war, it is in pursuit of peace."

Madoka nods.

"I suppose I haven't had much time to contemplate peace," says the princess. "But I suppose that you have some ideas about changing the world. That new girl, Asami. She's your doing, is she not?"

You shake your head. "There are lots of things I would like to change about your empire," you say, "but I didn't hide Asami from Simona as a plot. I did it, firstly, because she was terrified, and second, because she's your counterpart's girlfriend."

"… oh," says Ryouko, adjusting an internal model. "I see. You were looking out for one of my Star Avengers. I guess it's not too surprising that your Ryouko would have one who's artificial."

"Well, she's not an artificial being in our universe," you say. "She's just an ordinary girl, and that speaks to just how narrow the distance is between us. We all have souls, after all. And there aren't any Star Avengers."

"Oh, of course," says Princess Ryouko. "That's an imperial name, you wouldn't call them that…"

"No, Ryouko has friends," you explain. "She doesn't lead a special task force like you do, and she only has one girlfriend."

"What?" asks the Princess. "Just the one?"

Kyouko looks confused. "You have more than one girlfriend?" she asks.

"We were aiming for a circle of twelve," says the princess. "With regular visitors, of course."

"Oi," says Nanami. "Not gonna lie, that's a little bit freaky."

"Well, I'm the star princess," says Ryouko, batting her eyelashes at Nanami a little. "It would be quite selfish of me to only have one girlfriend."

Nanami looks somewhat uncomfortable.

"Wow," says Kyouko, narrowing her eyes. "I mean, I got the impression your universe was messed up. But that's, like, seriously messed up. Jesus."

The princess looks back at her. She's still smiling, but has just shifted to a more defensive mindset.

"But I have so many worthy admirers," she says. "It would be terrible for me to disappoint them."

This fact seems, unfortunately, to be another anchor of her self-esteem, so it's hard to know exactly what to say about it here.

Kyouko tries to form words, and sort of fails for a moment. She shakes her head. "Depraved," she finally says.

"Kyouko!" you exclaim. "Please. You're insulting a guest."

"Well, someone needs to tell her that polygamy is wrong," says Kyouko.

"Kyouko, I would ask you to exercise caution as you judge someone who was raised in a very different culture from your own," you tell her.

Kyouko shakes her head. "Isn't the point of this to talk about the things that are wrong with her civilization?" she asks. "When did we drag in the moral relativism?"

"First," you say, "it's hardly moral relativism if I am less concerned about personal relationships than I am with civilization-scale atrocities. Second, there are complications to her situation, and whatever you think of it is probably inaccurate. And third, my dear, I will point out that my own Governance future has no qualms about polyamorous relationships, not for their own sake anyway. It's the power imbalances necessarily associated with a royal harem that concern me more."

You leave unsaid that there are lots of things that governance Kyouko has done that she would object to, if she knew about them, and that taking advantage of her position is one of them.

Kyouko's mouth hangs open, and Nanami looks a little bit disgusted at you.

Hitomi leans over to whisper something to Madoka.

"Are you a Christian?" asks the princess. "You sound like a Christian."

"Yeah?" asks Kyouko. "Got a problem with Christians?"

The princess shrugs. "I wasn't the one who eliminated your kind."

"You did what?" asks Kyouko.

"Ryouko!" you exclaim. "You're antagonizing my … my girlfriend!"

"Oh, I thought she said she was a Christian," says Ryouko. "You can't very well serve the lamb god and have two girls being together."

"Like you'd know the first thing about it, you genocidal maniac—"

"Both of you!" you exclaim, standing up. "Stop this!"

"Oh, great," says the princess, rolling her eyes. "This Clarisse thinks she's my mother, too."

This stings a bit — less on account of what she specifically said, and more because of the last time.

It's different when you can see inside like this, though. She's expecting an oddly specific type of response. Those words were an invocation of sorts, a ritual, a protocol — in a way, it is a plea for help. She's looking for a way to lose an argument, not because she really cares, but more as a way of not dealing with any of these challenges any more. More importantly, she expects this will lead to reassurances, and reminders of how much you love her. On some level she knows this is a very immature way of asking for them, but she wants a little to be babied, while also reminded of her importance. Implicit in all this is the idea that you will recognize this plea, and grant it.

But you are not inclined to spoil the girl any further.

"I'm not your mother," you begin. "And this is important. I'm not playing your little games."

Something turns cold inside of her.

"Be quiet, then," says Princess Ryouko, annoyed, waving a hand at you.

You prepare to chew her out— and you find yourself unable to speak.

You stand there a moment, your mouth open.

… The internal part isn't working either.

The princess smiles.

"Why don't you sit down?" she suggests with a smile, laced with a sliver of cruelty.

No. You won't. You won't let her do this to you. How can she make you do things? You're programmed for loyalty, not obedience, and this is definitely not in her best interest, let alone your own Ryouko's best interest.

You just stand there, fighting this, shaking.

It's not your programming. It's magic doing this, isn't it? Ryouko's soul, claiming your entire self as part of its dominion. You were grateful when that meant the two of you you would return from the dead together, but this is different.

Ryouko blinks and looks at you, earnestly surprised.

"How are you not sitting down?" she asks.

Madoka speaks up.

"Stop it!" she cries. "Look, you're hurting her."

The princess does look, suddenly uncertain, and the force that is trying to make you sit down becomes weaker — enough that you can muster the strength to speak to her internally.

Ryouko, you say to her. This isn't right. Please let me go.

You share your feeling of wrongness, a hint of the terror.

She is startled. When she does let you go, you almost fall, but Kyouko catches you.

"Are you all right?" asks Kyouko. "What was that? Are you hurt?"

You catch your breath for just a moment.

"That," you say bitterly. "That, since you ask, is exactly why I like the other Ryouko more."

And then you see it play back in her memory —

"What's wrong, Clarisse?" asked Princess Ryouko.

Clarisse smiled, but looked away.

The two of them had been dancing, a waltz, among the roses, under the stars. It was wonderful, and yet, the princess could tell, something was weighing on her handmaiden's mind.

"You can tell me," she proposed, but Clarisse just shook her head.

"Come come," she said. "How about a kiss?"

"No," said Clarisse, quietly, shaking her head.

"Clarisse? Come now, aren't I your favorite Ryouko?"

And her Clarisse just looked so sad, so heartbroken...



"I don't know what you just did," declares Kyouko, "but that was seriously messed up."

"… she shouldn't even be able to do that," says the princess, objecting, as if this fact were a robust defense.

You shake your head. "You may have freer use of your soul than I do, Princess, but you trespass where you have no right. I am not your minion, I am a person. And so is your Clarisse. So is Asami. So is every soul that has suffered so that you can be the Star Princess.

Ryouko looks over to Madoka.

"Okay, I get it," she whines. "Can I go home now?"

"Huh?" says Madoka.

Ryouko expects Madoka to send her home.

"Whenever you're ready," says the princess, turning away.

"No," you say. "We're not done yet. Because if you are not very, very careful when you go back, you are going to be responsible for even more souls. Trillions of trillions. It might be the most important thing in the world."


> explain where grief potatoes come from

You explain it to her.

"You don't like that, I guess," she says.

She has the idea that she's supposed to feel bad about this. She doesn't actually feel bad. It's too abstract, it's numbers, there's nothing there for her mind to really grasp, no sense of people.

"… You would have me tear down the Empire itself," she says.

"A trillion times over," you tell her.

"I can't do that," she whispers.

You shake your head.

"I think you can," you tell her.

She considers this.

"It makes you very sad," she concludes.

She takes a deep breath.

For you, then, she says. For the sake of Clarisse.

With determination, with intention, with a practiced skill, she reaches inside herself for that internal lever, for her self-concept, and she pulls on it with all her might, and she holds it there.

There is a light around her and a bit of a wind, and a magic that burns like a fire.

It fades.

"… Ryouko?" you ask.

She shakes her head.

"No," she says. "Still not your Ryouko."

"If it's really the same soul…" you begin.

"A moment ago," says Ryouko, "I half imagined I could pretend I was the good one. But of course, that doesn't work, does it?"

She's also a little annoyed with herself for cheating… or for having to cheat.

She turns to bow to the others.

"I thank you very much for your hospitality," she says. "I am sorry for abusing it so. I'm, um … trying to do better. I will do better …"

The room turns blue and everything freezes.

Now? you ask yourself.

The dark figure comes into the room from behind you.

"What are you doing?" asks Simona.

"I was speaking to the princess," you say, "about the problems of her empire—"

"Are you trying to cause a paradox?" interrupts Simona. "You've turned her against her fate. If she doesn't accept the role as a living goddess, you won't survive the cataclysm." She studies the room. "Why are we doing this in Mitakihara?" she continues. "Ryouko was supposed to be going to school in America!"

"… why America?" you ask her. "What happens there?"

"Nothing happens there!!" exclaims Simona. "It's quiet! Safe! She'd actually have a chance at a normal life! … relatively normal, anyway." She sighs. "Maybe we can steal a little bit of Homura, and rewind things."

"You wanted Ryouko to be happy in a place where nothing ever happened, where she didn't matter?" you ask. "Are we even talking about the same person? Have you actually met the girl?"

"Oh, spare me the lecture, Maggie," she snaps at you. "You are not the only one who cares about Ryouko, and she matters enough already."

And with that name, something clicks. You can see her soul gem — or what used to be her soul gem — and it swirls pitch black with corruption.

A message appears overlaid in your vision in the nomenclator system in a runic alphabet, though the meaning is clear.

Abraxas. The witch of paradox.

This must be a barrier. It's a lot like Homura's timestop. You think you've located the interference — you could wake the other half of your self, and Ryouko...

"If you won't cooperate," says the witch, with a sigh, "I guess we could just leave Governance Ryouko in the Star Empire to save everyone." She bites her lip. "What does that do to the Salem project, though…"



> If you're going to paradox everything, you should commit to it now

[] Fight the paradox witch
-[] wake Ryouko through your link to her
-[] wake Kyouko with handholding
-[] (write in tactics)
[] Attempt to reason with the witch
-[] (write in)

[] Ribbon Madoka and ask her to save the witch
[] Apply feathery restoration magic to Abraxas from within yourself

[] Avoid paradox: Redo this meeting with the Princess, sacrificing her character development
[] Avoid paradox: Sacrifice your Ryouko to be the one who saves the Star Empire
[] Avoid paradox: Go to the Empire to save everyone, yourself
[] Avoid paradox: (write in some other scheme)

POSTSCRIPT — Additional options to facilitate the use of the Star Staff against Abraxas.
[x] Paradox yourself a compatible feather
-[x] Implore aid in the 1980s
--[] Relay it via an Yukari / Hitomi ribbon-swap
--[] (write in some other vehicle for its delivery)
--[] Maybe you can just swap places with Kinomoto Sakura for a moment
--[] Rely on Simona's discretion
--[x] Rely on Tomoyo's discretion
(Remember, I am on your side.)
-[ ] Borrow it from the Star Empire, in accordance with your duties
--[] (propose a scheme for its delivery)
--[] Rely on Tomoyo's discretion
Remember that you need it there in the future under your current plans.

-[ ] Borrow it from the 2011 future
--[] (propose some scheme or vehicle for its acquisition and delivery)
--[] Trust in the future and believe
I am 100% confident that you will find a compatible feather in the 2011 future.

-[ ] From the Governance timeline
--[] Rely on some unknown party's discretion
--[] (propose some scheme)
The universes are pretty good at corresponding so far, so hopefully one exists, but lots of unknowns.
 
Last edited:
Negotiating with a witch is a waste of time and I don't think we have enough feathers to save her without risking death. We need to defeat her. She'll drop a grief seed and we can presumably turn it back into a soul gem later once we get a feather.

[X] Fight the paradox witch
-[X] wake Nanami with handholding
-[X] wake Kyouko with handholding
-[X] Contact Homura for help since she's immune to time stop

[X] Avoid paradox: Go to the Empire to destroy it yourself after defeating Abraxas and save G!Ryouko and Godoka
 
Last edited:
Abraxas. The witch of paradox.

Interesting that the witch didn't show up until after we speak with Ryouko, is this witch attracted to paradox's? She certainly didn't know where we were beforehand. Fighting could be extremely difficult, but I agree we should do so.

We are the ones breaking the rules, we should be the ones to fix things, we have access to the fix everything magic after all. I still think that the Star Empire can be redeemed and so I'm against destroying it. I think we should aim to keep both 2011 and SE alive, though some way of having both godoka and human madoka to exist in the 2011 timeline.

The biggest question is, how should we vote on this, do we choose to fight and avoid a paradox or just one or the other?
 
The biggest question is, how should we vote on this, do we choose to fight and avoid a paradox or just one or the other?
A good point. I had intended the "go to the Empire yourself" option to be an alternative to fighting. If you'd like to fight and then go to the Empire... hmm.
Might I ask you to add some form of "After you fight the witch" to your vote there, @AceJade ?
 
Back
Top